This book comes with a bunch of little blurbs on the cover where hockey industry insiders say things like “this book is great for new fans and old!” and “helpful if you watch 82 or 2 games a season!” Those reviewers are flatly wrong. This book will be next to useless for newcomers to the game. The author uses copious examples of players and teams to illustrate the concepts he’s discussing, but he doesn’t talk about them in enough detail to fully establish what he’s trying to convey. You need preexisting familiarity with hockey history, famous players, and the early-to-mid 2010s NHL landscape to understand it fully. I have that familiarity, more or less, which is good because I would have been lost without it.
The gameplay explanations skip over basics in favor of more complicated stuff. The author expects his readers to already know a lot about the game. He definitely expects a baseline level of familiarity with other sports as well, as he loves to discuss concepts via football and basketball analogies. He is a sports columnist, and he writes like one.
The vocabulary is similarly aimed at veteran fans. Hockey commentary is rife with terminology and thick slang, and even if you watch a lot of hockey, there are terms that are hard to pick up. For example, you know how I know what a toe drag is? I went to a hockey clinic and did a stickhandling drill that involved doing one. I wouldn’t have caught that definition from a game broadcast.
Once I got past the mismatch of expectations that I had from judging the book by its cover, I got more out of it. “Not for newbies” isn’t a flaw here—the blurbs are false advertising, but the author makes no promises to be beginner-friendly. Unfortunately, there are some problems that stem from what the book does rather than what it doesn’t do.
Organization of information on the page is terrible. Just awful. There are numerous insets and charts that cover a variety of topics, which are usually only tangentially related to the primary focus of any given section. They are placed quite poorly, and nearly all of them interrupt passages so that the reader has to either pause in the middle of a section to read them or go back for them upon reaching a new section header.
The tone here is very snarky and humorous. This would be fine if it didn’t actively impede my comprehension of the information the book holds. Man, this is a guidebook. It isn’t a good thing that it prioritizes comedy over clarity. Hard to tell sometimes where a joke stops and a fact begins. Hard to tell sometimes where the author’s opinion stops and widely held industry views about the game begin. The pop culture references are aging fast, too—we are ten years on from publication, and it shows. I’m sure Greg Wyshynski has his fans, but I only ever see his name in screenshots of other teams’ twitter drama, so he didn’t manage to establish much credibility with me. He knows a lot about hockey, but I’m not sold on his ability to convey that information to others.
The book falls into a pattern I’ve noticed before with YouTube videos I’ve watched for gameplay explanations and skating skills. My theory is that people who make these explanations tend to have known hockey for so long that they no longer have perspective on what newer fans will and won’t easily understand. This leads to explanations that are very simple or pretty advanced, with a tendency to skip over the in-between. It’s either “let’s talk about the difference between major and minor penalties!” or “anyone can see that the deke to the backhand through the triangle would have been a better shot here.” Makes it challenging to pick up intermediate information. For gameplay and strategy explanations, this book falls on the advanced side of intermediate, where you really have to already know a decent amount about hockey to understand what the author is saying.
That said, there are a few chapters at the end of the book that cover things like front offices and the draft, and those are very entry-level and easy to understand. I found those chapters accessible and informative, if not very detailed. Unlike most of the book, those chapters would be useful for new fans…not that any new fan is likely to get to them, since they follow several chapters that focus on gameplay.
One thing that I absolutely am sold on is Wyshynski’s love for the game. He talks frequently about the joys of watching hockey—about anticipating hits, seeing replays of cool moments, knowing that Ovechkin is going to do the same thing on the power play and goalies simply won’t be able to stop it. The book isn’t dry—it really covers what it’s like to watch, and Wyshynski is completely correct about a lot of it.
This book is unfortunately mid-tier. I picked it up hoping for some of those intermediate-level explanations to help me understand more game strategy, and for that, I found it mildly helpful. The presentation of information is muddy, the diagrams and charts are poorly labeled, and the author’s voice is definitely better suited to short sports opinion columns than to a full-length book. Some good points, some flaws; not a waste of time, but not a book I’d recommend. I’ll keep my copy around, because I suspect it will be more useful as a future reference now that I know what’s in it.