this is a fave. for creatives, there are so many opinions flying around and it could feel very confrontational. and sometimes it makes being a beginners (and probably seasoned artists) hard, and develop imposter syndrome. but this author really makes it a point that, sure we can take opinions into consideration, but at the end of it all, each creative should generate their own opinions and derive validation from within (sounds cheesy ik, but the way the author wrote ab it is not cheesy and is inspiring, trust). and that takes a lot of pressure off of being a noob (who has a dying need to be perfect at everything i start). i’ve always felt like art (and most things) are not black and white, with a lot of grey area, where it does AND doesnt follow rules, and i guess it’s just nice that another person is validating that two things can be true at once as well. this book was also just so fun to read (topic-wise and visually). i borrowed this from my mentor and i need to get a copy of my own now to bookmark + annotate. bc i def will be referring back to it!
I thought it might be somewhat helpful, and teach me something about my major, but it just went over the same lessons I've heard over and over from professors and advisors. Ward makes a simple point, and then goes on and on about it, basically saying the same thing 5 times over.
Besides the not-stellar writing, the design actually bothered me, which I was surprised about considering this is a book about graphic design... There is a very odd mix of page designs, making me feel like he made this book just to show off his InDesign skills. In the middle of the book, there is a very startling introduction of color, to signal the beginning of a section of designer-contributed 'popular lies abt graphic design'. This section really caught be off-guard, due to the fact that there was zero introduction, and suddenly some of the text was horizontal for no reason??? There were many sections of this book where the text was just not legible or easily-readable. While I want this book to look cool, it should also be readable, because, well, it's a book!
This book might be enjoyable for someone who isn't very well versed in graphic design, and is just getting into it, but as someone who is majoring in graphic design, I found it very repetitive and boring. I'M ANNOYED!
An OK read imo. Too bad the quality of the opinions aren't consistent. Some opinions are too obvious to be really interesting, while other aren't discussed thoroughly enough.
Major downside is the layout of the book. Quite a few opinion titles are totally unreadable, which is quite contradictory for a book about graphic design. Especially because the author explicitly discusses how GD can/should be about making messages more readable to people, and that you shouldn't just 'break the rules' unless you have a really good reason to do so. Maybe I'm missing the point here, but making you go back to the table of contents to learn which opinion you're reading is pretty lame.
Disclaimer: I'm not a graphic designer, so maybe some subjects aren't as appealing to me as they could be for someone who works in the field.
I had a hard time believing what the designer was saying when I disliked the design of the book so much. First, the cover literally fell off the book (cmon Actar?) Every new topic / title page, i found myself going "wow, thats hideous / unreadable / totally corny" - and then yes, person who made that totally hideous / unreadable / totally corny thing, tell me your opinions on design ...? Useless. I read it just to get through it, but couldnt believe a word he said after making such an ugly boring-looking dysfunctional mid-90's-bad-styled book.
Pretty decient read if you alrady have a pretty good knowledge base of graphic design to begin with. There's not a lot that's new here as one might expect, given the fact the book is about popular misconceptions about graphic design. Most of the topics are ones that most designers would have stumbled across at one point or another.
This being said it was a fairly interesting read that was specifically from the writers point of view. The layout made the reading that much more enjoyable which I would most likely contribute to the fact the writer is a designer. I'd like to note that the book is a pretty quick read and is pretty small (it would fit pretty well in a pocket). I enjoyed the dark color theme it seemed to keep through out the book.
Overall I would say if you can get this book for pretty cheap, go ahead. It's always nice seeing alternative perspectives on graphic design, especially a lot of the popular ones this book touches on.
A good book about graphic design, It told me thirty-five phenomenon the industry often happens, let me knew the case of graphic design works. And the book design was very interesting, in the middle part of the book with a fluorescent orange to made the book design, it's very attracted to me, while the lies about graphic design and image performance together, it's so the article was very interesting.
It’s a great way to remind you why you’re doing what you’re doing if you’re not in your dream design job currently, and it reinforced my passion for the job and my hunger to learn more and achieve my ambitions. Basically, it made me want to be a better designer and gave me advice on how to do that.
Very quick but interesting read! I was delighted to realize I don't agree with all that is said in this book, because I think that was the point in the first place. I think the value of this book is the fact that you have to consider all the premises (or lies) in the book and, as a designer, have (or formulate on the spot) your own opinion on each of them. I always embrace debate about design and I think this book offers plenty of views on aspects of design to debate about.
Great read. Very straight forward and insightful opinions of things taught and accepted throughout the design industry. Designed very thoughtfully as well where the end of the book ends on the Print is Dead- lie chapter. Found Ward to be very clever, encouraging and truthful from personal and professional experiences. I would definitely recommend this to any designer/student at any point in their career.
A really fun refresher. It was laid out in similarity to rambling with a colleague over coffee. I would recommend this for designers that have the blues, or anyone curious about a career in Graphic Design.
A very good book on design, by an author that has strong opinions but a very quiet, simple style. He discusses many of the sacred cows of graphic design and presents a balanced view. This is all theory, with little technical discussion, and is all the better for it. Highly recommended.
My favorite thing about this book is how the author makes some very bold remarks about the profession without professing that any of his claims are absolute truth. He is able to humbly give some great advice without compromising his arguments.