On a switchback ride through the USA, riding pillion with America's founding fathers, Jonathan Freedland searches out the qualities that made America the land at the end of his childhood rainbow, the place his grandfather and he conspired to run off to because of its open promise and unbounded potential. Noisy, crass, greedy, riddled with crime, riven by race, obsessed by money: America, exporter of junk to the UK. Or is it?
From Lesbianville in New Hampshire to Tent City in Arizona, from the high kitsch celebration of Liberace to the Bible Belt austerity of Iowa, from the paranoid militia of rural Montana to Florida's Condo Canyon, this is a journey to the heart of modern America-to Normal, Illinois. On his travels Freedland reveals how Americans control of their own lives, shape their own communities and vibrantly assert their rights. And there's even a twist: the spirit that inspires the American secret is actually our own-a British revolutionary fervour mislaid across the Atlantic. This what has made America the diverse, freedom-loving, self-sufficient, independent icon to the world: the place where socialism never took hold because it is inherent in the founding vision, where capitalism at the same time has reached its apogee; where many cultures contribute to the national fabric and yet the sense of belonging to the nation and reverence for its symbols is unmatched across the globe. It's time Britain shared the vitality: time to reclaim the revolution and bring it home.
A good book but a little dated now, it was written in 1998 though that's to be expected. His predictions for the future were a little off, but who could have guessed the current mess occurring was going to happen?
This is the perfect manifesto for a Great Britain I could be proud of. One where the politicians serve the people, rather than the reverse. One where success is based on merit, not birthright. One which is inclusive, truly democratic and where citizens (rather than subjects) are fully engaged in politics.
Originally written in the late 1990s, before the attacks on the World Trade Centre, the financial crash. the implosion of the Labour Party and before Donald Trump, it is nonetheless fascinating. I'd love to read an updated version (I think there was one in 2008 but a lot has happened since then.)
A number of the changes Freedland recommends the UK take from the US system have now been adopted, such as a Freedom of Information Act, Bill of Rights (in the form of the European Convention) and directly elected Mayors and Police Commissioners. Not with complete success. But that doesn't take away from the potential for a different type of politics and culture.
The book is, perhaps, guilty of wearing rose tinted glasses when looking at US politics and society. Freedland does address the downsides of his arguments but it's certainly not a balanced book. The penultimate chapter, however, with his Ten Steps to a Revolution, is very powerful and still stands up as a manifesto for change that many in this country yearn for.
Well written, easy to read and strongly argued, this is a book worth giving some time to. Out of date but still strongly relevant.
This is a good polemic against the established interests of the UK's political institutions and structure. Freedland exhorts the American way as being a natural progression of British progressivism and individualism, hence the old adage 'An American is an Englishman with freedom.'
It does seem that this book has had some effect on the ruling political classes in this country (the London Mayor, elected police commissioners and a move towards devolution for Wales and Scotland) or at least may have dovetailed with modern British political thinking.
His train of thought is of one from the libertarian wing and that must be taken into account when reading this book.
Overall he makes a pretty good case for republicanism in the UK but I think somewhat glosses over, to an extent, the less salubrious issues in American politics and ignores some of the better aspects of the Parliamentary system in Britain.
This book is also worth a read if you are studying American politics at a FE or HE institution, he pretty much gives everything you would find in a textbook but in a more readable manner
The title of this book is a complete misnomer. I picked it up expecting an essay on the pros and cons of turning Britain into a Republic and possibly some suggestions as to how that would happen and what it would look like.
Instead I got chapter after chapter of in depth examination of what makes America great, and one chapter on "things the UK should think about". It's not a "case for a British Republic" at all, in fact it should be titled "Look how great America is".