Skywater

by Melinda Worth Popham

This spare and affecting novel has the precision and the stinging sweetness of a fable... a wonderful book.Thomas McGuane Evoking a rich sense of place and animal behavior, (Popham) lets us see through very different eyes.The Seattle Times A parable of making the best of a world short of everything. The people and the creatures of Pophams fable are right, they belong, and they mean.Wallace Stegner Refreshing... life-affirming... the first book Ive read in a long time that left me with teary eyes at the end.The San Diego Tribune

Genres: Fiction, Nature, Animals, Environment, Westerns

256 pages, Mass Market Paperback

First published January 1, 1990

Reviews

[Hollie Ruthless · Rating 5 out of 5]

I picked this book up from a free shelf, never intending to read it myself, but rather obtaining it for my husband who has taken a recent interest in the desert. After reading it, he insisted I read it as well. In all honestly, I didn't have high expectations of it, so I was surprised when I ended up enjoying it immensely! Writing a book from the perspective of animals is a tricky task, but I've never seen it done so well. The author has a great understanding of coyotes and it really shows through the writing. She describes the way the animals perceive the world and communicate so well, I'm convinced this is the closest we will ever be reading the thoughts of animals. The author also has a unique way of switching narrators without the story coming to a full-stop, yet also without leading to confusion. I don't know if I've ever come across that writing style before. Although the majority of the story follows the coyotes, there are little dips into humanity that filled me with rage, disgust, pity, love, horror, fear, sadness and heartbreak. Not that the coyotes' story was lacking any of those emotions. Despite the fact that the entire novel is in a desert setting, the descriptions of the landscape and surroundings never get dull or redundant. It is inadvertently educational about the land and the animals without feeling like a lesson at all. Even over 15 years later, it is still relevant and I wish it would get more attention, particularly in my corner of the United States. For what I would consider a short book, it has left quite the impact on me and has opened my eyes to a whole new world. This is definitely not in my usual genre and I am glad that I ventured out and read it anyway. I would love to read more by this author, but I appreciate the fact that she wrote a novel on something she fully understood and then stopped there. Her writing style is beautiful, though; I can only hope that she eventually decides to write another novel about something she cares about.

[Joyce · Rating 5 out of 5]

I rarely read novels. This was a beautiful novel, given to me by my Grandmother Evelyn, after she read it. She was close to 90 at the time!

[Kaz · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is an elite book. I’ve never read something that had me so attached to animal characters. The way she fleshed them out, made them so realistic yet still so easy to connect to. It was a really sad book with a beautiful ending and I can’t believe how little known it is. Can’t recommend enough.

[Dan · Rating 5 out of 5]

Gorgeous writing and beautiful story.
Several EXTREME depictions of animal cruelty, but they are integral to the story.

[Derrick R. · Rating 5 out of 5]

While I find it hard to accept that anything in life is truly "destined to be", finding a copy of Skywater on the free book shelf of a local library was quite the perfect happenstance. Having lapsed in recent years on reading (and other subsequent creative endeavors) in favor of buckling down to work and take care of my children, I had recently relocated to Southern California and, inspired by the inviting weather, started to venture outside. I became a regular at local parks and enthralled by my new surroundings, started to hike the surrounding hills and canyons. It's amazing how ones mindset can change with the absence of mosquitos and added benefit of dry shoes. I had begun to learn and appreciate both the delicate balance and resilience of nature. It was my newfound summation that more incredible things were happening outside the computer screen than within it.

Enter Skywater by Melinda Worth Popham. Skywater was as informative to me as it was a poignant and beautiful tale of a reluctant pack of coyotes and their incredible will to survive. It seamlessly bridges the commonality between our species and puts you in the shoes of the coyotes as they venture toward the mythological "skywater". Equally as compelling, it tells the story of an adorable older couple whose admiration for the coyotes gives hope for our ability to co-exist. "Every year approximately 400,000 coyotes are exterminated in the United States", and while the book never treads into lecture territory, it very clearly paints the picture of a species deemed "dispensable" by the human race. The narrative is mighty in its mere 206 pages. I truly enjoyed this book for its ability to help me see the beauty of the desert landscape and the unwavering courage of the coyote. It was the perfect re-entry point for getting back to reading for enjoyment and I wholeheartedly recommend it.

[Elle Thornton · Rating 5 out of 5]

Finding Love in the Desert Places
Skywater unfolds a spellbinding journey with a small band of coyotes, whose distinct natures and ultimate fates are as deeply moving as characters in a Shakespearean play. After their well is poisoned in the Sonoran desert, the coyotes follow their leader to find what is believed to be the promised ancestral place of endless life-giving water. The coyotes face many dangers in the merciless worlds they navigate on their quest to reach Skywater: sharpshooter riflemen at a military proving ground; rivers; deadly highways; baited traps. The power of this story goes far beyond the perils the hunted and weary coyotes face: it comes from Melinda Worth Popham’s ability to see something wonderful in the unloved suffering outcast, in the rejected, and to convey its worthiness and wonder to the reader. The writing is extraordinary. On every level, Skywater is a transformative story.

[Jessica · Rating 2 out of 5]

I had reservations about a novel told from the perspective of coyotes, but I trusted my co-worker's recommendation on the strength of our mutual appreciation for Wallace Stegner. For a fable, this was done well. But I guess I don't like fables. The author anthropomorphizes the animals to an absurd degree. The coyote's actions seemed realistic (most of the time) and could have stood alone without the narrative of their human-like thoughts. I know I shouldn't have been expecting realism, but I couldn't help it and so spent most of the book annoyed.

[Dizzy · Rating 1 out of 5]

Giving this book 1 star because I can't give it less on this site. So poorly written it's laughable. The author writes using her Stanford degree and handy dictionary writing companion but the story is predictable and flat out boring. I power read it in one day and glad to be done with it. The premise of evil humans (except for a couple) vs. innocent coyotes and their interactions. I love nature and enjoy seeing animals in nature but this story is just so full of itself, it's painful. Seriously hard to believe that it made it to publication.

[Jim · Rating 5 out of 5]

I live in Tucson, Arizona. This story starts in my neighborhood and ends in a good place. If you love animals, especially dogs and similar critters, this book will tear your heart out. I cried several times while I read it and had to put it aside for a while when I was in the middle of it. If it gets to be too much for you, go to the last couple of chapters and see how it ends. Then you can read the second half.

[Wendy L · Rating 4 out of 5]

I loved it! The old couple parallels the coyotes' life, loneliness, death, life's struggles and I liked the Fiction with truth of how eradication took place against the coyotes. A tender heartwarming story.

[Linda · Rating 5 out of 5]

One of the all-time great books. Wonderful perspective all humans should try to see. One book I will never be without.

[Amy · Rating 4 out of 5]

Sad and heartwarming little story about those tricky little coyotes. In the end people should be shot for some of the terrible things they do to animals.

[Lauren · Rating 4 out of 5]

How much is it possible to anthropomorphize creatures before becomes too much like a Disney story? In the case of this book, pretty far. Or perhaps I am able to give the author the benefit of the doubt more because I can relate so much to the emotional intelligence of my own pets. Surely they must think like we do. Or not. I would say that this is probably the biggest drawback to this book, though it did not get in the way of it's enjoyment for me. Let's just say that towards the end it was a stretch to imagine a coyote using a kind of logic to decide whether or not to chance risky behavior. For the most part this story is spellbinding, captivating, and tragic. I did not know the extent of the devastation visited upon the coyote population in the first half of the 20th century, and it is useful to have a book like this to remind us how much our human decisions impact the life around us.

[Barb Fay · Rating 5 out of 5]

A beautifully written novel that parallels the love stories of a husband and wife and 2 coyotes in the desert. Both couples live in close proximity to each other and respect each others' spaces and lifestyles, but who are forced out of their habitats by the diminishing supply of clean water, caused by overly mined copper. "The desert was land no longer true to itself."
The spiritual aspect of the story is the most poignant. Each couple must leave their peaceful habitats in search of life-sustaining water. To the coyotes, that means finding 'skywater' which turns out to be a place only for the spirits of the dead, not for desert beings. "A worthy novel whose spirit of place is seldom marred by the obvious trap of sentimentality--and whose eloquent vision of humanism is ecological rather than materialistic." Kirkus Review.

[Azuki · Rating 5 out of 5]

I enjoyed it more than I expected. So beautifully written.

The story is about a group of wandering coyotes. It is hard to read at moments, for an animal lover who hate senseless cruelties. But I guess I was prepared for worse so I was happy enough with the ending. : D

There is some anthropomorphization, but I think it's done well, the coyotes aren't "talking" to each other. In fact, I suspect they could communicate in more detail than what the book implies, and the behavioral description sounds like I was watching Animal Planet.

[Trish White · Rating 5 out of 5]

Fabulous story, so very well executed, will enchant any reader. Imaginative character development.

Fabulous story, so very well executed, will enchant almost any reader. Imaginative character development, smooth poetic prose, stars an Everyman hero on a great adventure. Will undoubtedly read this again and then, perhaps again!

[Rosemary · Rating 4 out of 5]

Beautifully written fable. Loved the main characters, both human and coyote.

[Jennifer Ley · Rating 5 out of 5]

One of the first books I read as a virtual member of Kip's Book Club in Joshua Tree. Beautiful done.

[J · Rating 5 out of 5]

This has been one of my all-time favorites since I came upon it at a library in Ottawa (KS) and took the time to read it. The book follows along in the fashion of "Black Beauty" and Felix Salten's "Bambi" but unlike those two books it has a refreshing depth all of its own.

The story is a glorious masterpiece that weaves together two separate stories - the viewpoint of a spirit-thirsting coyote and his companions plus the story of a grieving couple who upon packing up for the Pacific ended up in the desert of the Kofa Mountains. Living together as neighbors it is only the sad consequences of human action plus love that drives them apart.

The characters were strongly created - their personalities a perfect blend that gave the story its strength. And it is a story that is full of emotional beauty, philosophical musings and the nature of survival that drives each species that lives side by side.

Definitely a timeless classic for generations to come.....

P.S. With this book I have to say the cover art is very important for passing it off. This is the one that I came upon first and this is definitely the best cover art that can be found for the book itself. I am fortunate that even though my sister gave me one copy without it that I was able to find a hardcover with this exact beautiful artwork without it costing me an arm and leg. Definitely gorgeous!

[Sal · Rating 5 out of 5]

It was a really amazing book. It showed the story from a coyote's view especially, and showed how it's mostly humans who make the mistakes; not coyotes. The characters, all of them, are just so amazing. It's just a really great book. I love it so much. I think the main reason I love it so much is because I love animals. I've created an attachment with coyotes. It's a really really really good book. I would've never have doubted that anyone else would not like it if they love animals. But if they think coyotes are to blame, like the book says, for everything but the weather, I think if you read this book you'll create an attachment with coyotes like I did. It was my father who introduced this to me, and I really pay respect to him. Enjoy the book. --KB, age 9

[Becky Loader · Rating 4 out of 5]

I will never feel the same about coyotes after meeting Brand X and his compatriots.

An old couple who live in the desert purposely foul their well when they find out that a defunct copper mine is poisoning their groundwater. This forces the local wildlife to find a new water supply and saves them from a nasty death. The story, told from the coyote perspective, documents their search for "Skywater." The Native Americans call the coyote, "God's Dog," and I think it fits.

[Julia · Rating 5 out of 5]

Really unusual and wonderful to read a story told mostly from a wild animal's POV.

[Jennifer Ley · Rating 5 out of 5]

Truly remarkable use of language and metaphor. The world from a coyote's point of view. Chilling, and sad.

[John Ulferts · Rating 5 out of 5]

Simply a wonderful, heartwarming book that humanizes one of our keystone species - voyotes. we need to treat them and their brothers, wolves, so much better.