3.5 stars.
I have mixed emotions here. On the one hand, I'm really glad this book touched on specific notions our society has due to rape culture. On the other hand, I feel like this is already something we saw in the first book of this series. While I appreciate the story here, it very much felt like a recycled plot so it was harder to be interested in, especially when I guessed the plot was going to go the way it did so early on.
I found Casey to be really frustrating here. I don't like the way she shut down her friends when they were trying to help her, and I really didn't like the way she treated Lexi when Lexi was the only one saying anything that made any sort of sense. I've never been in Casey's shoes, so I can't pretend to know how I would react, but her reaction bothered me. Autumn and Lexi are trying to give their take on what happened between Casey and Justin, and instead of hearing them out, Casey's main thought is "I'm nobody's victim," and "if I had been raped, I'd remember it," the latter of which was the most annoying thing I have ever read, because she had said multiple times that she didn't remember what happened that night. If she couldn't remember, how could she know that she had been raped or if she hadn't? If she couldn't remember saying yes, then she couldn't remember saying no either, and her stubbornness against that notion, and her determination to just believe she had cheated on Cole was aggravating. Maybe it's because I can't relate to the situation, or maybe it's because I've spoken out about rape culture so often that the way Casey was unintentionally perpetuating it upon herself, but I just really didn't the way she was acting.