The Covered Wagon

by Emerson Hough

Molly Wingate, middle-aged, portly, dark browed and strong, stood at the door of the rude tent which for the time made her home. She was pointing down the road which lay like an écru ribbon thrown down across the prairie grass, bordered beyond by the timber-grown bluffs of the Missouri.

Genres: Fiction, Westerns, Historical Fiction, Classics

258 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1922

About the author

Emerson Hough was an American author best known for writing western stories and historical novels.

He married Charlotte Chesebro of Chicago in 1897 and made that city his home. During World War I, he served as a Captain with the Intelligence Service. He died in Evanston, Illinois, on April 30, 1923, a week after seeing the Chicago premiere of the movie The Covered Wagon, based on his 1922 book. Covered Wagon was his biggest best-selling novel since Mississippi Bubble in 1902. "North of 36", another Hough novel, later became a popular silent film as well, "making him one of the first Western authors to enter into the motion picture industry." He is buried in Galesburg, Illinois.

Asked in 1918 to provide some details of his own life, he replied in the context of World War I: "This is no time for autobiography of men of letters. This is the day of biography for men who have been privileged to act in the great scenes of today. It is the time for boys of 23. At least we can bless them and back them the best we know. I will not tell about myself. It is of no consequence."

Hough's hometown, Newton, Iowa, has honored him in several ways. A school named for him opened in 1926. Emerson Hough Elementary School was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2002. His boyhood home bears a marker provided by the Daughters of the American Revolution. The school grounds include a playground with a western theme called Fort Emerson Hough. The local chapter of the Izaak Walton League also bears his name, as does a street, Emerson Hough Avenue in Lambs Grove, Iowa, a suburb of Newton.

In March 2010, the school board voted to close Emerson Hough School.Efforts to prevent its closure have included a fund raising and a Facebook page.

Reviews

[Debbie Zapata · Rating 1 out of 5]

I wanted to like this book. I saw it mentioned in a book I read in 2016, and I had also read another title by the same author, the delightful The Lady And The Pirate: Being The Plain Tale Of A Diligent Pirate And A Fair Captive. So I had high hopes for this one, especially since the author was best known for his Westerns.

But I simply could not get interested in this story of a wagon train heading for Oregon in 1848. It read as though the author could not forget (and wanted his readers to be sure and remember too) that he was telling us about A Big Event In History.

I want to finish the year with a fun book, not a pompous and predictable one. But I want to give Mr. Hough another try before I erase him completely from my Someday List, so I will go browse his author page at Gutenberg and see if he has anything else that might be more appealing.

DNF after 4 chapters.

[J.R. · Rating 3 out of 5]

I read and enjoyed this story as a boy. And I can say now it’s still enjoyable, despite a few quirks of dialogue and other uses we now consider old-fashioned.

Hough knew the people and land whereof he wrote, having living the pioneer life himself in New Mexico and as an avid outdoorsman throughout the west. Set in the late 1840s just before the California gold rush (which actually plays a vital role in the plot), the book tells of two wagon caravans bound for Oregon and the conflict which divides them because of a love triangle. Indian fights, buffalo hunts, dangerous river crossings and other dangers of the trail add to a gripping and entertaining read.

[Lizzie · Rating 4 out of 5]

It was overall a very good book.
Some of it was slow going and too much descriptions(maybe I'm too impatient?...) but overall the story was a good one. I'd definitely recommend.

[Barb in Maryland · Rating 4 out of 5]

4 stars for nostalgia's sake.
This was a favorite from my teen years. And I enjoyed just as much this time, even as I wondered how it would fare with someone coming to it cold. Read for the 2024 Retro Reads Book Pool.

Though first published in 1922, this book reads like an adventure novel from the late 19th century.
This is grand storytelling, old-fashioned 3rd person omniscient POV. The prose is exuberant, giving the reader a real sense of the enormous undertaking involved in getting the wagon trains across the western US during the 1840s. Our particular story takes place in 1848. The author's descriptions of the flora and fauna along the route are almost rapturous. The physical dangers aren't glossed over. The length of the journey, in miles (2100+) and time (5-6 months), is not downplayed.
But you can get a lot of that information from history books.
Hough gives us a good group of characters to personalize the historical facts. We have Jesse Wingate and his wife Molly, headed out from Illinois to Oregon. And their beautiful young daughter, also named Molly, and the two men who are courting young Molly--Sam Woodhull and Will Banion. (The author drops enough hints quite early on to let us know which man we should cheer for in this love triangle.) The author even mixes in a few historical people, Jim Bridger and Kit Carson, and gives them important parts in the story.
By modern standards there aren't too many cringe-worthy moments. The Native American tribesmen are treated in a fairly even-handed way, even though Hough is rather over-fond of the word 'savage' (which he also uses to describe some of the behavior of the wagon train's men). The word 'squaw' is almost always used re: the tribal women. I cringed the most over his portrayal of Jim Bridger, whose role in the story is often for supposed comic relief. Not funny to me.
The author manages to work the discovery of gold in California into the plot, as well as a buffalo hunt and an attack on the wagon train by at least one Indian tribe. The hunt and attack scenes are very exciting.
The book was an big hit when it was released and quickly turned into a movie, released in 1923. I've not ever seen the film. However, my hardback copy has photos from the movies interspersed throughout.
Note: Emerson Hough, born 1857, died 1923, wrote 20 or so novels. This was the last of his books to be published in his lifetime.

[CindySR]

DNF

The old western/mountain man-type patois made it unreadable.
Annoying female MC.

[David Mann · Rating 3 out of 5]

Epic in scope, at times poignant, but ultimately lacking in direction. This offering by Hough will hold your attention, but there are too few themes to explore beyond the author’s shopworn message that Oregon pioneers were doing big, important things.

Hough’s earlier novel “Heart’s Desire” might be regarded as one of the finest Western literary novels of the early twentieth century. What makes that novel so great is that Hough never takes his subject or his characters too seriously. It reads like a series of comical, poignant vignettes taken from ordinary life. It feels authentic and true. His characters are memorable and lovable. In contrast, with “The Covered Wagon”, Hough comes across burdened by the grandeur of his subject. Hough’s drama becomes melodramatic as he bludgeons us with scenes of glory and tragedy. In no uncertain terms he reminds us chapter after chapter that his characters are toiling across the country carrying the banner of freedom. It’s all a bit too cliche and too solemn.

Derivative theme aside, ‘The Covered Wagon’ is not without charm. The feud between the two male protagonists is well devised. Certain scenes of toil along the trail are masterfully described and ring authentic. The ending is satisfying.

Unless you’re a die-hard Hough fan, I’d stick to “Heart’s Desire”, “The Girl at the Halfway House”, and “North of 36” as Hough’s top 3 novels for fans of Western literature and early Twentieth Century Americana alike.

[Patricia J Lipinski · Rating 5 out of 5]

Great read

It gave the true flavor of events in the winning of the west and even included the probable words of great mountain men. I loved it.

[Katherine Jones · Rating 3 out of 5]

OK, this was entertaining enough. Only just. It's probably historically accurate from the perspective of the white characters living in their time. Don't expect more. There's a fantasy love story involving the gold rush, horses, the Snake River, characters you've heard of if you've watched any western movies or TV. but it is completely fictional. In fact I think this was made into a movie long ago. I might watch it sometime, but I'm not sure why.

Well, some of my ancestors traveled West in wagon trains, that's why. I'm aware of the political implications that are rarely covered by such art, but it's still interesting to imagine how these travels were done.

[Janis · Rating 3 out of 5]

Decent story. With the mountain man accents written into the story and most of the dialogue carried on between mountain men, I found this very hard to follow. Took me forever to read the thing, because I had to puzzle over each of those sentences trying to figure out what on earth they were saying. I only figured it out about half the time. I wish I’d been able to find an audio version. That would have been much better.

There’s a silent movie for this book, with the same title. My library had the movie. I give the movie 5 stars. Maybe watch it first. I think that’s the only reason I could follow the book, although the book is far more complex than the movie.

[Flowergarden24 · Rating 4 out of 5]

I have this book given to my Aunt from her Mother in 1926. It was old fashioned and dated of course but it was nice to read something straight forward and obvious. Yes it was predictable regarding the two men wanting the same girl but still nice to read during this time, April 2020. It was fun to read about historical figures included in the story and also find photos of the stops along the way of the wagon trains. Right now, old fashioned works for me.

[Pamela · Rating 4 out of 5]

I found this book in my school library. Someone had written in it: “This is a boring book and I couldn’t even find the climax.” So I decided to read it. There were a lot of exciting events in the book but I only gave it 4 stars because there were also pages of just telling about the times or something. I would scan those parts and get back to the wagon train, the Wingates and other people.

[Rodney · Rating 1 out of 5]

This writing style is just too antiquated for me. It is like the book Last of the Mohicans which I have never been able to read but love many of the movie and tv shows based upon it. The plot of a wagon train traveling across the Oregon Train in 1848 sounds interesting but this author managed to make it very boring.

[zuzu]

maybe gonna have to come back to this. much better than the (silent 🥸) movie

[Kim · Rating 3 out of 5]

I finished this book a few days ago and already I'm forgetting it, so it only gets three stars even though I remember having fun reading it. The title says it all though. Only there isn't one covered wagon there are a whole bunch of them, and they all gather together, and they all head west together, and they all fight and argue and eventually split up or die or kill someone. That's most of the story. I read it because I came across the 1923 silent movie based on the book. The big mystery is how I came across a 1923 silent movie, I just can't remember. But realizing it was from a book I went on a search, found the book and read it before I watched the movie. I always read a book before I watch the movie if I can. It wasn't a bad movie and it wasn't a bad book, although if these people want my advise they would have a much better trip if they would stop fighting each other over every thing, big or little. How they managed to fight the Indians and win is beyond me. I also read this about the author:

His other notable works included Story of the Cowboy, "which received a high recommendation from President Theodore Roosevelt," Way of the West, Singing Mouse Stories, and The Passing of the Frontier. Among his historical novels, The Magnificent Adventure in 1916 was set at the time of the Louisiana Purchase and the Lewis and Clark Expedition and told, said one reviewer, "a good stirring tale."

I never heard of any of them. But I never heard of this either until the movie entered my life. Then there is this:

Reviewers noted the political nature of Hough's Western fiction. One reviewer wrote that Hough's work is "not a novel at all; it is an arraignment; it is propaganda" for progressive Republicans or the Democrats. Hough "makes his point, and hammers it hard. He leaves nothing for the reader to guess....He goes at it all with bludgeon and battle-ax....He has, as a fighter, a strong style. His book is well worth reading. But it is not art."

I hate to break it to the reviewers but I never noticed the political propaganda, considering what we've been going through these last few months I never would have read the book if I had read the reviewers comments first. But if it was political it went over my head and I'm glad it did. That's all I can think of to say about it. It was easy to read, it was fun to read, and I'm glad I read it. I won't read it again though, now that the political stuff is in my head I know I'd be looking for it, and I really don't want to. Happy reading. :-)

[Paul · Rating 2 out of 5]

Can't believe I read the whole thing. But have to admit, it wasn't all bad, just a little bit old fashioned. This thing goes back to 1922 or so, and is done in what I would call an archaic writing style. Steeds for horses, anyone? The Indians are savages, the white race superior, the hero seems to be of southern origin, all the old attitudes. But like the covered wagon, it just keeps plugging along. We even get some real people like Kit Carson and Jim Bridge. Lots of "hold on thars." And of course a pretty white girl. You can learn a lot reading old books, and have some fun too. Plus, the description of the land are great.

pp

[Marlee Friesen · Rating 2 out of 5]

Picked up this faded old book hoping for a historically accurate picture of the first wagon train of families headed west to Oregon. Giving it two stars because, although I loved sections of this book for the descriptions of life and hardship along the Oregon trail, the main story was carried along by the feuding love interest of two wagon masters and the violent scenes that ensued in the lawless West, along with even more violent scenes of Indian massacre along the trail. Not a fan, however historically accurate or inaccurate it may be. Not a book I'll be keeping around for my children to read.

[Shawn Jarrell · Rating 3 out of 5]

An ok book

This was hard reading to follow but overall a good book. It seemed to be somewhat factual for historical purposes

[Samantha Glasser]

Read this book online for free through Project Gutenberg: http://www.gutenberg.org/files/13384/...