The original title of this book was supposed to be "The Frontier Wife," and was rejected by Grey's overzealous and officious editors. (They also chopped this to shreds, before the publishers came to their senses and re-released the full version later. Thank goodness I read this full version.) While the original title doesn't really captivate the direction of the book, it is a little closer than "30,000 on the Hoof."
This is a tale of a single family, told mostly from the point of view of the woman who left comfort to move west and marry her sweetheart. It is also a very nice lens by which we can see the growth and change in this country. Through the Huetts' eyes we see the world grow and change, while the patriarch, Logan, clings to his dream of 30,000 cattle. For being a "western," I thought this book was very deep and moving.
Perhaps it is the similarity between Huett and my own father (heck, even Zane Grey and Dad) that resonates within. Dogged determination, resolve, strength—things that built this country. These are traits that Logan Huett never lets go of.
And yet the world moves and grows, while the Huetts cling to their existence in a (once) remote canyon.
I’d never really read Michener or stories like this, so forgive my reactions. As far as westerns go, I’ve only read two Grey novels now, and had previously only known shoot-‘em-ups in L’Amour. So to see a western writer tackle the personal aspect of the American West, the changes that the land and history make upon people, was quite striking. It moved me in ways that this genre has not. Through Grey’s gorgeous prose, I felt Logan’s emotions as automobiles appeared, when his sons described flying planes, and submarines. Here was a man who had lived off the land, built a cabin with his hands (something else Dad did...), and stuck to his dream of raising cattle. Though my reaction was borne from my generation, it still should make sense: I felt as if I were playing the game Civilization, cultivating fields, building warriors; only to have two units of French mechanized artillery storm my gates.
Even if you’re not into chronological/historical stories like this, I still recommend this book. It is very personal and quite deep.