What do you think?
Rate this book
How to Write a Love Story
One writer, one editor, one hot summer... A romance for the books?
Ciara Sheridan's father has left her with three things: a sprawling and distinctly ramshackle estate on the Irish coast, the outline for the finale to his bestselling epic fantasy series that he wanted her to finish - and writer's block.
Enter Sam Avery: Frank-Sheridan-fanboy and hotshot editor, sent from the New York publishing house direct to her doorstep - against Ciara's wishes and red pen at the ready.
With the deadline looming, Ciara and Sam have just a few weeks to stop bickering, write this novel and secure Frank's legacy.
But as the summer heats up, so too does the tension between them. Will their own love story be the plot twist neither of them see coming?
Book Lovers meets Leap Year in this dual-POV, forced-proximity, bookish romantic comedy with a VERY HOT twist - the brand-new book from bestselling Kindle chart sensation and Irish author, Catherine Walsh.
Ciara Sheridan's father has left her with three things: a sprawling and distinctly ramshackle estate on the Irish coast, the outline for the finale to his bestselling epic fantasy series that he wanted her to finish - and writer's block.
Enter Sam Avery: Frank-Sheridan-fanboy and hotshot editor, sent from the New York publishing house direct to her doorstep - against Ciara's wishes and red pen at the ready.
With the deadline looming, Ciara and Sam have just a few weeks to stop bickering, write this novel and secure Frank's legacy.
But as the summer heats up, so too does the tension between them. Will their own love story be the plot twist neither of them see coming?
Book Lovers meets Leap Year in this dual-POV, forced-proximity, bookish romantic comedy with a VERY HOT twist - the brand-new book from bestselling Kindle chart sensation and Irish author, Catherine Walsh.
352 pages, Paperback
First published March 10, 2026
1486 people are currently reading
52810 people want to read
About the author
Catherine Walsh
8 books3,341 followersI'm not on here anymore!
You can find me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/catwalshwri...
You can find me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/catwalshwri...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,382 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
How To Write A Love Story written by Catherine Walsh was beautiful, powerful, inspiring, heart warming, emotional, heart breaking, and pure. I have come to know and love Catherine Walsh because of her Holiday Romance series, but this time she wrote a whole new book with no tinsel in sight, but instead a new group of characters that better get their own books because I fell in love with every single one of them. Let me just say that How To Write A Love Story is going to be THEEEE book of spring/summer. I had such a fun time reading this book, I will say it wasn't perfect, it definitely had it's flaws, but I believe that many people will have this brand new romance book in their beach bags this summer. If you know Catherine Walsh, all of her books take place in Ireland and this one was no exception, every time I read one of her books Catherine makes me want to pack my bags and take a months long vacation to Ireland because my goodness she makes it sound so beautiful minus the disgusting humidity in the summer time. I need everyone and their mother to add this beautiful book to their want to read list, like right now, go, RUN. I can't recommend this book enough, if you love banter, slow burns, and lovable characters, you better have your calendars marked for March 10th, 2026 because you won't want to miss out on this newly anticipated release by the one and only Catherine Walsh. If I don't see my friends adding this book, you best believe I will bully you.
THANK YOU TO NETGALLEY AND DUTTON FOR AN ARC OF THIS BOOK IN EXCHANGE FOR AN HONEST REVIEW!!!!!!
"🇮🇪🌞My father used to say that nowhere is more beautiful than Ireland in the sunshine🇮🇪🌞".
"💔😭You don't think about your memories of people until they are gone💔😭".
"💗✨You ever feel like you are completely free and yet utterly stuck at the same time💗✨?"
Ciara pronounced Keer-ah Sheridan is the daughter of famous author Frank Sheridan. Frank is the author of the Ravian series which is a nine volume epic fantasy series, it was supposed to be ten books but Frank unexpectedly passed away leaving this beloved series unfinished, but luckily he left behind notebooks filled with hundreds of notes. Frank wanted someone to finish this series for him, so who best to finish this series none other than Ciara Sheridan because she lived her whole life in the shadow of the Ravian series. Ciara is writing the promised and final book- "The Last Mountain", there's only one problem- Ciara has never written a love story before. But she definitely knows how to write books because she is a crime author with three novels written under a pseudonym. Ciara's mom died from cancer when Ciara was too young, but her dad Frank stepped up as a single father despite being a teacher by day and an author by night. Ciara was just seven years old when the Ravian series came to life, so of course she should be the one to write the last and final book. I absolutely loved Ciara, she was such a relatable character, she has her imperfections, but her biggest insecurity is that she's worried about what people truly think about her. I also loved her best friend Maddie, she was so blunt yet so supportive towards Ciara (we better get Maddie's book next). Halfway through college, Ciara made a rule- don't make friends with people who read. Lmao, this woman was so funny.
Sam Avery is an editor at Richardson Books and has dreams to own Richardson Books when the owner Casey Richardson retires, but Sam has to prove that he's a worthy candidate for this huge position. Richardson Books is dedicated to bringing the best sci-fi and fantasy fiction to shelves around the world. Sam was hired as an editorial assistant ten years ago and is slowly making his way to the top. Sam's boss Casey Richardson sends Sam to Ireland to help Ciara edit and write the final book in the Ravian series which also happens to be Sam's favorite series ever, Sam read the first Ravian book when he was thirteen years old, and he also has the exact same tattoo as one of the characters from this beloved series. As an editor, Sam is passionate about helping authors reach their fullest potential. When Sam hears that Ciara needs help, he takes a mini trip to Ireland to help Ciara Sheridan write the most beautiful love story. Sam got into publishing because Ciara's dad Frank inspired him to do so. Sam has never been afraid to tell the truth, he's not rude about it, he's honestly super sweet, but he just doesn't sugar coat things. Sam is secretly a giant nerd and a workaholic, he's such a lovable character. I absolutely adored Sam, he wasn't in it for the money, he just wanted to help Ciara write the final book for the series he has loved so much. Ugh, Sam's heart was just so pure and beautiful, he might have gotten frustrated with Ciara at times, but my goodness he had so much patience. We also love an honest man, but I truly think Sam and Ciara just wanted the closure for The Last Mountain.
THANK YOU TO NETGALLEY AND DUTTON FOR AN ARC OF THIS BOOK IN EXCHANGE FOR AN HONEST REVIEW!!!!!!
"🇮🇪🌞My father used to say that nowhere is more beautiful than Ireland in the sunshine🇮🇪🌞".
"💔😭You don't think about your memories of people until they are gone💔😭".
"💗✨You ever feel like you are completely free and yet utterly stuck at the same time💗✨?"
Ciara pronounced Keer-ah Sheridan is the daughter of famous author Frank Sheridan. Frank is the author of the Ravian series which is a nine volume epic fantasy series, it was supposed to be ten books but Frank unexpectedly passed away leaving this beloved series unfinished, but luckily he left behind notebooks filled with hundreds of notes. Frank wanted someone to finish this series for him, so who best to finish this series none other than Ciara Sheridan because she lived her whole life in the shadow of the Ravian series. Ciara is writing the promised and final book- "The Last Mountain", there's only one problem- Ciara has never written a love story before. But she definitely knows how to write books because she is a crime author with three novels written under a pseudonym. Ciara's mom died from cancer when Ciara was too young, but her dad Frank stepped up as a single father despite being a teacher by day and an author by night. Ciara was just seven years old when the Ravian series came to life, so of course she should be the one to write the last and final book. I absolutely loved Ciara, she was such a relatable character, she has her imperfections, but her biggest insecurity is that she's worried about what people truly think about her. I also loved her best friend Maddie, she was so blunt yet so supportive towards Ciara (we better get Maddie's book next). Halfway through college, Ciara made a rule- don't make friends with people who read. Lmao, this woman was so funny.
Sam Avery is an editor at Richardson Books and has dreams to own Richardson Books when the owner Casey Richardson retires, but Sam has to prove that he's a worthy candidate for this huge position. Richardson Books is dedicated to bringing the best sci-fi and fantasy fiction to shelves around the world. Sam was hired as an editorial assistant ten years ago and is slowly making his way to the top. Sam's boss Casey Richardson sends Sam to Ireland to help Ciara edit and write the final book in the Ravian series which also happens to be Sam's favorite series ever, Sam read the first Ravian book when he was thirteen years old, and he also has the exact same tattoo as one of the characters from this beloved series. As an editor, Sam is passionate about helping authors reach their fullest potential. When Sam hears that Ciara needs help, he takes a mini trip to Ireland to help Ciara Sheridan write the most beautiful love story. Sam got into publishing because Ciara's dad Frank inspired him to do so. Sam has never been afraid to tell the truth, he's not rude about it, he's honestly super sweet, but he just doesn't sugar coat things. Sam is secretly a giant nerd and a workaholic, he's such a lovable character. I absolutely adored Sam, he wasn't in it for the money, he just wanted to help Ciara write the final book for the series he has loved so much. Ugh, Sam's heart was just so pure and beautiful, he might have gotten frustrated with Ciara at times, but my goodness he had so much patience. We also love an honest man, but I truly think Sam and Ciara just wanted the closure for The Last Mountain.
March 26, 2026
4.25 ⭐️
˚ ༘♡ ⋆｡˚ ꕥ After the death of her father, Ciara Sheridan is left with his estate that is falling apart, the outline for the last book to his bestselling fantasy series, and writer’s block, which makes the other two items harder to deal with. And this is where Sam Avery, a hotshot editor from New York, enters the scene. Sam is not only good at his job, but he’s a Frank Sheridan fanboy and knows everything about the series, which prompts his boss to send him to the Irish coast to help Ciara finish the book. It should be easy enough. Until he arrives on her doorstep, and they can’t seem to get along very well. But with the deadline approaching, Sam and Ciara put their differences and bickering aside, and try to get the novel written, all the while trying to survive the heat wave and the simmering tension between them that is undeniably there.
︵‿︵‿୨♡୧‿︵‿︵
ᴺᴼᵂ ᴾᴸᴬᵞᴵᴺᴳ: One for the Books by Ben Dunnill
0:22 ───ㅇ───── 2:57
˚ ༘♡ ⋆｡˚ ꕥ I had a grand time reading this! 😍 Not only did it make me laugh because I loved the bickering between Ciara and Sam, but it also made me smile because of how sweet it was. And it was set in Ireland. What more could I want? 🤭❤
I loved both Ciara and Sam. They felt like real people trying to write a novel while ignoring the growing attraction they felt for each other. It was a blast whenever they were together because I love me some good sarcasm and banter. 😏 And I’m glad that the third-act conflict wasn’t stupid, like it usually is when characters run away instead of dealing with the situation at hand. The situation itself made me cringe out of second-hand embarrassment (I have issues–it’s a me problem), but I’m so happy that the characters decided to be adults and try to figure things out as people should. Winner, winner, chicken dinner! They get the “Being Able Not to Piss Me Off” award. (It’s a real thing now. 😂)
And the side characters! Ronan, Maddie, and Sam’s coworkers and boss were all amazing. I have no complaints there.
The pacing was also great. It didn’t feel too long or too short. The plot kept me interested the entire time. The writing was fun and engaging, which only made this book so much easier to read. I could have read this in one sitting if I didn’t have a disgustingly short attention span. 😅 And the slow burn romance is Sarah-approved because, well, you know me. I don’t even want the characters glancing longingly at each other until we reach the 50% mark or past that. Make the romance worth it. Make them yearn. That’s all I’m asking for at this point. 😭 Did the romance make me swoon? No, but it was still sweet, and I’ll take it.
Anyways, I am SO happy that the first book I’ve read by Catherine Walsh was a success! I will definitely read more of her books in the future. If you love books about books with a sweet romance and are set in one of the most beautiful places on earth, then I totally recommend this novel! 🧡
ꨄ︎ Thank you to Dutton and NetGalley for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review! All opinions and statements are my own. ꨄ︎
❗Content Warnings❗
Mentions the death of a parent.
Swearing: Yes
Spice: Open-Door/Steamy (🌶🌶🌶/5)
˚ ༘♡ ⋆｡˚ ꕥ After the death of her father, Ciara Sheridan is left with his estate that is falling apart, the outline for the last book to his bestselling fantasy series, and writer’s block, which makes the other two items harder to deal with. And this is where Sam Avery, a hotshot editor from New York, enters the scene. Sam is not only good at his job, but he’s a Frank Sheridan fanboy and knows everything about the series, which prompts his boss to send him to the Irish coast to help Ciara finish the book. It should be easy enough. Until he arrives on her doorstep, and they can’t seem to get along very well. But with the deadline approaching, Sam and Ciara put their differences and bickering aside, and try to get the novel written, all the while trying to survive the heat wave and the simmering tension between them that is undeniably there.
︵‿︵‿୨♡୧‿︵‿︵
ᴺᴼᵂ ᴾᴸᴬᵞᴵᴺᴳ: One for the Books by Ben Dunnill
0:22 ───ㅇ───── 2:57
˚ ༘♡ ⋆｡˚ ꕥ I had a grand time reading this! 😍 Not only did it make me laugh because I loved the bickering between Ciara and Sam, but it also made me smile because of how sweet it was. And it was set in Ireland. What more could I want? 🤭❤
I loved both Ciara and Sam. They felt like real people trying to write a novel while ignoring the growing attraction they felt for each other. It was a blast whenever they were together because I love me some good sarcasm and banter. 😏 And I’m glad that the third-act conflict wasn’t stupid, like it usually is when characters run away instead of dealing with the situation at hand. The situation itself made me cringe out of second-hand embarrassment (I have issues–it’s a me problem), but I’m so happy that the characters decided to be adults and try to figure things out as people should. Winner, winner, chicken dinner! They get the “Being Able Not to Piss Me Off” award. (It’s a real thing now. 😂)
And the side characters! Ronan, Maddie, and Sam’s coworkers and boss were all amazing. I have no complaints there.
The pacing was also great. It didn’t feel too long or too short. The plot kept me interested the entire time. The writing was fun and engaging, which only made this book so much easier to read. I could have read this in one sitting if I didn’t have a disgustingly short attention span. 😅 And the slow burn romance is Sarah-approved because, well, you know me. I don’t even want the characters glancing longingly at each other until we reach the 50% mark or past that. Make the romance worth it. Make them yearn. That’s all I’m asking for at this point. 😭 Did the romance make me swoon? No, but it was still sweet, and I’ll take it.
Anyways, I am SO happy that the first book I’ve read by Catherine Walsh was a success! I will definitely read more of her books in the future. If you love books about books with a sweet romance and are set in one of the most beautiful places on earth, then I totally recommend this novel! 🧡
ꨄ︎ Thank you to Dutton and NetGalley for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review! All opinions and statements are my own. ꨄ︎
❗Content Warnings❗
Mentions the death of a parent.
Swearing: Yes
Spice: Open-Door/Steamy (🌶🌶🌶/5)
March 1, 2026
I truly can’t put into words how much I love this book and I’m envious of everyone who gets to read it for the first time.
‘how to write a love story’ is a slow burn romance that follows sam avery and ciara sheridan in the first pov.
I don’t think I can articulate how much I enjoyed this book, and how even though it’s a romance, it felt so much more than that.
the romance isn’t at the forefront of the plot—which made for a good story because it’s not integral to it and felt like an added extra. I loved that sam and ciara got to know each other as friends before exploring anything romantic.
I loved the instant chemistry where it felt like—despite knowing each other less than 24 hours—they had known each other for years.
there’s a good mix of banter, moments of sincerity, and the right amount of spice that it doesn’t take away from the plot.
there was some solid side characters that felt important to the story and how it progressed. I’m very excited for what felt like the potential second book for maddie!
“I think I need to be clear, that given the choice, I would choose you every time.”
this is and forever will be one of my favourite books and I can’t recommend it more!
thank you little brown for the advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review!
update (22/02/26) – just finished my reread and I truly love this book so much. I will forever mourn the version of me that got to read this for the first time
‘how to write a love story’ is a slow burn romance that follows sam avery and ciara sheridan in the first pov.
I don’t think I can articulate how much I enjoyed this book, and how even though it’s a romance, it felt so much more than that.
the romance isn’t at the forefront of the plot—which made for a good story because it’s not integral to it and felt like an added extra. I loved that sam and ciara got to know each other as friends before exploring anything romantic.
I loved the instant chemistry where it felt like—despite knowing each other less than 24 hours—they had known each other for years.
there’s a good mix of banter, moments of sincerity, and the right amount of spice that it doesn’t take away from the plot.
there was some solid side characters that felt important to the story and how it progressed. I’m very excited for what felt like the potential second book for maddie!
“I think I need to be clear, that given the choice, I would choose you every time.”
this is and forever will be one of my favourite books and I can’t recommend it more!
thank you little brown for the advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review!
update (22/02/26) – just finished my reread and I truly love this book so much. I will forever mourn the version of me that got to read this for the first time
March 21, 2026
In a word: Cute!
Catherine Walsh never fails to put a smile on my face and her newest How to Write a Love Story is no exception to that. She’s so well-loved because she understands the rom-com formula and she sticks to it. No need to reinvent the wheel when the current one works!
Ciara Sheridan is the daughter of beloved Irish author Frank Sheridan who recently passed away leaving his wildly popular fantasy series Ravian unfinished. An author herself of crime novels, Frank’s wish was that Ciara would finish his series-ending book The Last Mountain using an outline that he’d left behind. The problem is she doesn’t write fantasy and has anxiety-inducing levels of writer’s block every time she tries to write it. Oh, and his fans will throw an absolute fit if they find out she’s the one writing it!
Enter Sam Avery, a New York editor. Sam’s boss Casey Richardson owns the publishing house that will publish the final book, and he’s known Ciara since she was a child. He thinks Sam, who just happens to be a diehard fan of the series, will be the perfect one to steer the book to completion and books a summer trip for him to Ireland to do just that.
I’m sure it doesn’t take much imagination to see where this is going. When Sam arrives the sparks immediately fly … just not THOSE sparks. Nope, the only heat between them at first is their tempers! Can these two get a working relationship off the ground and get Frank’s final vision to the world? I’ll give you three guesses, but you’ll only need one.
Expect all the typical bumps along the way, but also know that you’re going to get two very likeable leads, a whole lot of fun banter, some excellent side characters including Ronan the bartender/amateur microbrewing disaster, Ciara’s no-nonsense bestie Maddie, Sam’s sister Lizzie and his NYC office mates.
I really liked the chemistry between Sam and Ciara. It was believable to me without being over the top. The issues in front of them were relatable, and despite the requisite third act hiccup, it didn’t resort to the emotional histrionics some rom-coms do. They dealt with it like adults, and I always appreciate that.
This is sweet, good fun. Sam and Ciara are hilarious together. There’s some spice, but it stays relatively clean. I did an immersion read, listening to the audio from my library along with the digital ARC. I thought the narration by Jonathan Aarons and Roisin Rankin was excellent!
If you enjoy a summer romance with sarcastic, funny banter set in a charming Irish village, this is a quick, feel good read that may hit the spot!
★★★★
Thanks to Dutton Books, NetGalley and author Catherine Walsh for this digital ARC to honestly review. It’s out now.
Catherine Walsh never fails to put a smile on my face and her newest How to Write a Love Story is no exception to that. She’s so well-loved because she understands the rom-com formula and she sticks to it. No need to reinvent the wheel when the current one works!
Ciara Sheridan is the daughter of beloved Irish author Frank Sheridan who recently passed away leaving his wildly popular fantasy series Ravian unfinished. An author herself of crime novels, Frank’s wish was that Ciara would finish his series-ending book The Last Mountain using an outline that he’d left behind. The problem is she doesn’t write fantasy and has anxiety-inducing levels of writer’s block every time she tries to write it. Oh, and his fans will throw an absolute fit if they find out she’s the one writing it!
Enter Sam Avery, a New York editor. Sam’s boss Casey Richardson owns the publishing house that will publish the final book, and he’s known Ciara since she was a child. He thinks Sam, who just happens to be a diehard fan of the series, will be the perfect one to steer the book to completion and books a summer trip for him to Ireland to do just that.
I’m sure it doesn’t take much imagination to see where this is going. When Sam arrives the sparks immediately fly … just not THOSE sparks. Nope, the only heat between them at first is their tempers! Can these two get a working relationship off the ground and get Frank’s final vision to the world? I’ll give you three guesses, but you’ll only need one.
Expect all the typical bumps along the way, but also know that you’re going to get two very likeable leads, a whole lot of fun banter, some excellent side characters including Ronan the bartender/amateur microbrewing disaster, Ciara’s no-nonsense bestie Maddie, Sam’s sister Lizzie and his NYC office mates.
I really liked the chemistry between Sam and Ciara. It was believable to me without being over the top. The issues in front of them were relatable, and despite the requisite third act hiccup, it didn’t resort to the emotional histrionics some rom-coms do. They dealt with it like adults, and I always appreciate that.
This is sweet, good fun. Sam and Ciara are hilarious together. There’s some spice, but it stays relatively clean. I did an immersion read, listening to the audio from my library along with the digital ARC. I thought the narration by Jonathan Aarons and Roisin Rankin was excellent!
If you enjoy a summer romance with sarcastic, funny banter set in a charming Irish village, this is a quick, feel good read that may hit the spot!
★★★★
Thanks to Dutton Books, NetGalley and author Catherine Walsh for this digital ARC to honestly review. It’s out now.
February 20, 2026
4.5💫
talk about a SLOW. BURN.
guys. let's be real for a second. this was so good and i need everyone to add this to their tbr. this will be THE book of the spring/summer and i'm so excited for everyone to get the opportunity to read this book.
sam is an editor at a big fantasy publishing group and he has been assigned to go to ireland to help ciara finish the last book of her diseased fathers' widely popular fantasy series. sam is also a mega fan of the series, which makes this job for him extra special and important.
ciara and sams relationship is so slow burn but it's absolutely the perfect timing for them. i loved watching how they relationship developed and got stronger overtime. their humor together and banter was also so fun to read and their relationship just felt so sweet and wholesome to me. I loved the small town setting and i think maddie was the perfect side character. she was so funny too and i just loved her as a character. hopefully we get her story next with hamburger man??
i need everyone to get so excited for this release and add it to their anticipated reads list because WOW this was SO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!
thank you to dutton books, catherine walsh, and natgalley for the arc!!! out 3/10 :)))
talk about a SLOW. BURN.
guys. let's be real for a second. this was so good and i need everyone to add this to their tbr. this will be THE book of the spring/summer and i'm so excited for everyone to get the opportunity to read this book.
sam is an editor at a big fantasy publishing group and he has been assigned to go to ireland to help ciara finish the last book of her diseased fathers' widely popular fantasy series. sam is also a mega fan of the series, which makes this job for him extra special and important.
ciara and sams relationship is so slow burn but it's absolutely the perfect timing for them. i loved watching how they relationship developed and got stronger overtime. their humor together and banter was also so fun to read and their relationship just felt so sweet and wholesome to me. I loved the small town setting and i think maddie was the perfect side character. she was so funny too and i just loved her as a character. hopefully we get her story next with hamburger man??
i need everyone to get so excited for this release and add it to their anticipated reads list because WOW this was SO GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!
thank you to dutton books, catherine walsh, and natgalley for the arc!!! out 3/10 :)))
March 14, 2026
3.5⭐️
If there's one thing that Catherine Walsh does really well, it would be her romances. This book was absolutely adorable! While I wasn't really obsessed with it, I found it to be super cute and fun and enjoyable.
When I first started this book, I will be completely honest and say that it was a bit of a drag. I know, not the best way to start a review but let me explain.
The book throws you right in within the first chapter. I think it started really well and had a good setup for how the rest of the book would go. I enjoyed getting to know Sam and Ciara and I thought they had a lot of potential, but the execution of their personalities really fell flat for me. It didn't feel like there was a whole lot to them and their characters left a bit to be desired.
HOWEVER, once they started getting to know each other and you start to see their chemistry blooming I think it came together really well. I liked the fact that their personalities didn't clash and actually ended up complimenting each other. Whether that be their banter or their heart-to-heart conversations, it was really sweet. So many cute little moments that made your heart feel so full and the next thing you know, you have a massive smile on your face.
In terms of the actual plot of the book, THAT is something I think was done really well. The love and dedication that Ciara had to continue her father's legacy and just an entire book on the struggle of grieving someone who left too soon was heartbreaking yet beautiful. There are so many battles going on in Ciara's mind of whether she's doing the right thing and trying to find the best way to honor her father was so in detail and handled with a lot of care. Not only that, but this was a journey of self-discovery and self-acceptance.
This book is just another reason as to why I love Catherine Walsh's books; they're so easy to read and fun to consume and you could probably finish it within a day or two. The writing is simplistic and very easy to follow and understand. I think this would be a perfect book to read by the beach or on vacation just because of how light it is and the setting of the book. If you decide to pick this up, read it by the pool or while you're lounging on the beach! I definitely think it'd be worth it. 🩷
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
𝓟𝓻𝓮-𝓡𝓮𝓪𝓭: 📚🌅
When I saw that Catherine Walsh came out with a new book, I got sooo excited caused I loved her Christmas books (both were 5 stars for me)!! I'm looking forward to seeing how her other books are, starting with this 🩷
If there's one thing that Catherine Walsh does really well, it would be her romances. This book was absolutely adorable! While I wasn't really obsessed with it, I found it to be super cute and fun and enjoyable.
When I first started this book, I will be completely honest and say that it was a bit of a drag. I know, not the best way to start a review but let me explain.
The book throws you right in within the first chapter. I think it started really well and had a good setup for how the rest of the book would go. I enjoyed getting to know Sam and Ciara and I thought they had a lot of potential, but the execution of their personalities really fell flat for me. It didn't feel like there was a whole lot to them and their characters left a bit to be desired.
HOWEVER, once they started getting to know each other and you start to see their chemistry blooming I think it came together really well. I liked the fact that their personalities didn't clash and actually ended up complimenting each other. Whether that be their banter or their heart-to-heart conversations, it was really sweet. So many cute little moments that made your heart feel so full and the next thing you know, you have a massive smile on your face.
In terms of the actual plot of the book, THAT is something I think was done really well. The love and dedication that Ciara had to continue her father's legacy and just an entire book on the struggle of grieving someone who left too soon was heartbreaking yet beautiful. There are so many battles going on in Ciara's mind of whether she's doing the right thing and trying to find the best way to honor her father was so in detail and handled with a lot of care. Not only that, but this was a journey of self-discovery and self-acceptance.
This book is just another reason as to why I love Catherine Walsh's books; they're so easy to read and fun to consume and you could probably finish it within a day or two. The writing is simplistic and very easy to follow and understand. I think this would be a perfect book to read by the beach or on vacation just because of how light it is and the setting of the book. If you decide to pick this up, read it by the pool or while you're lounging on the beach! I definitely think it'd be worth it. 🩷
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
𝓟𝓻𝓮-𝓡𝓮𝓪𝓭: 📚🌅
When I saw that Catherine Walsh came out with a new book, I got sooo excited caused I loved her Christmas books (both were 5 stars for me)!! I'm looking forward to seeing how her other books are, starting with this 🩷
March 16, 2026
4⭐️! if you like catherine walsh’s holiday rom coms, i feel like this is a really great summer version with that same charm 🌞📖 it’s bantery, swoony, and very bingeable! catherine walsh really knows how to write romance that feels sharp & swoony without tipping over into cringey.
i did think the dual pov was interesting because even though ciara is obviously central to the story, starting with sam’s perspective made him feel more like the main character to me. i didn’t mind that though because i found him really easy to connect with & it definitely made the book feel more fast paced! it’s also just hard to write a male main character that i actually enjoy reading from, and sam is really great (and respectful) to spend time with 💛
i also really liked the themes around ciara’s grief, imposter syndrome, and confidence as a writer. but because i ended up feeling more emotionally connected to sam’s perspective, when ciara is the one working through most of the deeper emotional stuff, i didn’t always feel as invested in that arc as i wanted to. sam ends up being more of the supportive character in her journey, which works for the romance, but it made the emotional balance feel slightly uneven for me..?
i also felt like the maddie side plot (ciara’s friend!) started taking up a little more space than i wanted. it definitely felt like it was setting up for another book, which is fine, but i wish it had been teased a little more lightly because it pulled some focus for me!
overall though, this was just a really cute, really solid romance! humorous & heartfelt & if you’re a sucker for bookish books this one is gonna HIT!!! p.s. i read every single one of ciara’s chapters in a maura higgins accent in my head & i highly recommend 🫶🇮🇪 thank you to netgalley & dutton for the ARC copy! all thoughts are my own!
i did think the dual pov was interesting because even though ciara is obviously central to the story, starting with sam’s perspective made him feel more like the main character to me. i didn’t mind that though because i found him really easy to connect with & it definitely made the book feel more fast paced! it’s also just hard to write a male main character that i actually enjoy reading from, and sam is really great (and respectful) to spend time with 💛
i also really liked the themes around ciara’s grief, imposter syndrome, and confidence as a writer. but because i ended up feeling more emotionally connected to sam’s perspective, when ciara is the one working through most of the deeper emotional stuff, i didn’t always feel as invested in that arc as i wanted to. sam ends up being more of the supportive character in her journey, which works for the romance, but it made the emotional balance feel slightly uneven for me..?
i also felt like the maddie side plot (ciara’s friend!) started taking up a little more space than i wanted. it definitely felt like it was setting up for another book, which is fine, but i wish it had been teased a little more lightly because it pulled some focus for me!
overall though, this was just a really cute, really solid romance! humorous & heartfelt & if you’re a sucker for bookish books this one is gonna HIT!!! p.s. i read every single one of ciara’s chapters in a maura higgins accent in my head & i highly recommend 🫶🇮🇪 thank you to netgalley & dutton for the ARC copy! all thoughts are my own!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I liked it. Kind of want to put the shrugging woman emoji behind that statement and call it a day because I don’t have much else to say about it.
It’s just that this book didn’t really make me feel anything. It was fine, but I never really warmed to the story. Which might be because 1) it’s a book about writing a book. And I think I found out through this story that I’m not into that. And 2) while I really liked Ciara, I did not like Sam. He was mostly okay, but there was something about him that rubbed me the wrong way. And he is the hero, so with me not liking him this was doomed from the start.
I’d have appreciated the slow burn of their romance if the romance had worked for me but be warned that it is actually a slow burn. It takes them a good while to get things going. I found Ciara to be very cute and fun and charming. I liked the setting. I really liked her friendship with Maddie.
But in the end, I still just liked it and I want more from the stories I read. So I guess this wasn’t for me.
Might be for you though.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc in exchange for an honest review.
It’s just that this book didn’t really make me feel anything. It was fine, but I never really warmed to the story. Which might be because 1) it’s a book about writing a book. And I think I found out through this story that I’m not into that. And 2) while I really liked Ciara, I did not like Sam. He was mostly okay, but there was something about him that rubbed me the wrong way. And he is the hero, so with me not liking him this was doomed from the start.
I’d have appreciated the slow burn of their romance if the romance had worked for me but be warned that it is actually a slow burn. It takes them a good while to get things going. I found Ciara to be very cute and fun and charming. I liked the setting. I really liked her friendship with Maddie.
But in the end, I still just liked it and I want more from the stories I read. So I guess this wasn’t for me.
Might be for you though.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc in exchange for an honest review.
March 16, 2026
An enjoyable read, but it didn't give me the feels like some other books I've read from this author.
I liked Sam's character, but I'm very neutral when it comes to Ciara. She is quirky at times, in a way that I didn't find cute. Instead of empathizing with her grief, I just found everything about her living situation miserable. The fandom situation was creepy.
The romance felt a bit bland. For most of the story their relationship is professional. They got attracted to each other, which ok, but I wasn’t sold on their connection. I feel that there was more chemistry between the two side characters, Maddie and Shane, than between the main characters.
There is some third act drama that didn't feel very believable to me. I think that Sam was too professional to make such mistakes. The way their problems were solved was very convenient and rushed.
I liked the Irish setting, but why go for the heat wave? Can there be a heat wave in Ireland that lasts for almost three months? I don't think so. They were sweating so much, you'd think the story was set in Florida.
To end on a positive note, it's a nice, easy read. There's some witty banter and likable side characters. I liked how supportive everyone is in their little community. The friendship between Ciara and Maddie is really sweet.
I liked Sam's character, but I'm very neutral when it comes to Ciara. She is quirky at times, in a way that I didn't find cute. Instead of empathizing with her grief, I just found everything about her living situation miserable. The fandom situation was creepy.
The romance felt a bit bland. For most of the story their relationship is professional. They got attracted to each other, which ok, but I wasn’t sold on their connection. I feel that there was more chemistry between the two side characters, Maddie and Shane, than between the main characters.
There is some third act drama that didn't feel very believable to me. I think that Sam was too professional to make such mistakes. The way their problems were solved was very convenient and rushed.
I liked the Irish setting, but why go for the heat wave? Can there be a heat wave in Ireland that lasts for almost three months? I don't think so. They were sweating so much, you'd think the story was set in Florida.
To end on a positive note, it's a nice, easy read. There's some witty banter and likable side characters. I liked how supportive everyone is in their little community. The friendship between Ciara and Maddie is really sweet.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 18, 2026
Ciara Sheridan's father, Frank, was the author of a very famous fantasy book series. After his death he has asked that Ciara write the final installment. The problem is, she can't. She has struggled and struggled to no avail. Casey, Frank's publisher, decides to send one of his top editor's, Sam, to Ireland to help assist Ciara. Sam is also a die hard fan of her father and the book series so this is a dream come true for him.
Will these two be able to finish this book together all while falling in love?
I'd say you'll have to read this to find out but I think we all know the answer to that question.
I hate to be a party pooper but this one didn't really do it for me. Don't get me wrong it had it's cute moments and the characters were all pretty likable but it was definitely lacking in the chemistry department. There was no spark, no witty banter, and no real laughs for me. The pacing was so slow that I had to start skimming here and there just to move the story along. Also, I am not a fan of fantasy books so all the talk about the series along with the book they were writing together did nothing to help hold my attention.
So, unlike the main characters, this was not a love match for me. 2 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and Dutton for my complimentary copy.
Will these two be able to finish this book together all while falling in love?
I'd say you'll have to read this to find out but I think we all know the answer to that question.
I hate to be a party pooper but this one didn't really do it for me. Don't get me wrong it had it's cute moments and the characters were all pretty likable but it was definitely lacking in the chemistry department. There was no spark, no witty banter, and no real laughs for me. The pacing was so slow that I had to start skimming here and there just to move the story along. Also, I am not a fan of fantasy books so all the talk about the series along with the book they were writing together did nothing to help hold my attention.
So, unlike the main characters, this was not a love match for me. 2 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and Dutton for my complimentary copy.
March 11, 2026
I love a Catherine Walsh book and How to Write a Love Story is one of my favorite romances of 2025.
This book was everything I could have hoped for, and everything I love about romance novels. It has a wonderfully ideal Irish coast setting, a cast of quaint secondary characters, and a romance with easy chemistry but not without the tension or angst.
When our main character is tasked with finishing her deceased father's final book in his world famous fantasy series, she finds that her writers block is more than she can bear. Enter charming literary agent Sam Frank, who is this series biggest fan -- sent to Ireland to help her find her way again.
This beautiful slow burn romance swept me off my feet from the very first few chapters. The house that the book is set in is almost a charming character in and of itself. This book has all the right amounts of depth, healing, banter and sincerity. I found the romance to feel authentic in tone to reality. The conflict was also realistic as all the pressures of legacy, history, failure and love come together in a tangled heap.
I was enchanted and so glad I was able to snag this one early. If this is how 2026 is starting off with romance reads, I am already in the best of company.
This book was everything I could have hoped for, and everything I love about romance novels. It has a wonderfully ideal Irish coast setting, a cast of quaint secondary characters, and a romance with easy chemistry but not without the tension or angst.
When our main character is tasked with finishing her deceased father's final book in his world famous fantasy series, she finds that her writers block is more than she can bear. Enter charming literary agent Sam Frank, who is this series biggest fan -- sent to Ireland to help her find her way again.
This beautiful slow burn romance swept me off my feet from the very first few chapters. The house that the book is set in is almost a charming character in and of itself. This book has all the right amounts of depth, healing, banter and sincerity. I found the romance to feel authentic in tone to reality. The conflict was also realistic as all the pressures of legacy, history, failure and love come together in a tangled heap.
I was enchanted and so glad I was able to snag this one early. If this is how 2026 is starting off with romance reads, I am already in the best of company.
March 10, 2026
Happy release day to one of my faves of the year so far 🩷 my arc review:
4.5 ★ I LOVED this. From the very first page I was absolutely hooked and obsessed with this story. This book was so fast paced and easy to binge that I almost wish I had slowed down a little to savor it. I couldn't get enough. I love books about books, writers, and the publishing world and I think this book did that so well. I loved the premise of Ciara writing the last book in her father's series, and Sam being a fan of Ciara's father's books but also her editor. The tension that resulted between these two was INSANE. The banter was also top tier, and the yearning I felt from Sam was TOOOO good! I really enjoyed Ciara and Sam both together and individually, and I think they had excellent character growth both together and apart. Catherine's writing has always been a favorite of mine, with how fast paced, humorous, and heartfelt it is. I loved that this book had so many parts to it along with the romance. There was healing, friendship, a little side character rivalry, and the sweetest small town Ireland summer setting. I think every aspect of this book added so much to the story and kept me so entertained. I truly couldn't put this book down and read it in less than 24 hours. This book has everything I'd hope for in a summery romance and I'd recommend it to anyone that asked! My words truly don't do this book justice! Thank you to the publisher for the arc in exchange for my honest review! This is one everyone needs on their spring and summer tbrs!!
4.5 ★ I LOVED this. From the very first page I was absolutely hooked and obsessed with this story. This book was so fast paced and easy to binge that I almost wish I had slowed down a little to savor it. I couldn't get enough. I love books about books, writers, and the publishing world and I think this book did that so well. I loved the premise of Ciara writing the last book in her father's series, and Sam being a fan of Ciara's father's books but also her editor. The tension that resulted between these two was INSANE. The banter was also top tier, and the yearning I felt from Sam was TOOOO good! I really enjoyed Ciara and Sam both together and individually, and I think they had excellent character growth both together and apart. Catherine's writing has always been a favorite of mine, with how fast paced, humorous, and heartfelt it is. I loved that this book had so many parts to it along with the romance. There was healing, friendship, a little side character rivalry, and the sweetest small town Ireland summer setting. I think every aspect of this book added so much to the story and kept me so entertained. I truly couldn't put this book down and read it in less than 24 hours. This book has everything I'd hope for in a summery romance and I'd recommend it to anyone that asked! My words truly don't do this book justice! Thank you to the publisher for the arc in exchange for my honest review! This is one everyone needs on their spring and summer tbrs!!
March 17, 2026
The story follows an editor who gets the opportunity of a lifetime and the daughter of a famous writer. They both need to navigate their wants, their work, and their relationships.
It was well written, cozy, and comforting.
I think as long as you don't come in with too high expectations and understand this is not really a deep or fast-paced book, you'll enjoy it.
--------
I have it 🤩
--------
I'm going to need this. In my hands. ASAP.
It was well written, cozy, and comforting.
I think as long as you don't come in with too high expectations and understand this is not really a deep or fast-paced book, you'll enjoy it.
--------
I have it 🤩
--------
I'm going to need this. In my hands. ASAP.
March 26, 2026
Myślałam, że mi się bardziej spodoba, bo mamy tu pisanie książek, radzenie sobie ze stratą - w sumie zbliżona tematyka do "Poważny i nieromantyczna", ale jakoś w ogóle mnie to nie poruszyło, a momentami nawet nudziło i było to dla mnie trochę za płaskie. Takie ok, nie będę o nim myśleć, nie jest to "mój" romans, chociaż na początku myślałam, że będzie inaczej.
December 25, 2025
Catherine Walsh delivers yet again - probably one of the best romance novels I've ever read. One that sticks with you and I'd recommend to everyone. Enjoy! & thanks to NetGalley, the author and publisher for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
November 15, 2025
CAN YOU ALL HEAR ME SCREAMING FOR YOU TO ADD THIS TO YOUR TBR ??!!!!!!
I had absolute fun reading this book till 5 in the morning.
This is a story of Ciara an author whose talent was overshadowed by her father her whole life, who was a legendary author but some circumstances made her face it all.
And she had her editor Sam, who made her face it all with as much comfort and ease as he could provide.
Carrigwest is a small community where everyone looks after each other in their own crazy wayyy.
It's an amazing feeling well you apply for a random ARC and it turns out to be one of the best, you ever readddd.
This was my first book by Catherine and what a way to begin !! It clicked instantly for me, and I practically inhaled the whole thing.
This book has such a perfect balance of humour and sentiment, sarcasm and heartfelt moments. When I first started it, I expected a typical rom-com full of laughs, but it surprised me with its emotional depth. It has overwhelming emotions, but never overshadowing the light parts, just the right touch. This was my first EditorXAuthor trope read and I honestly couldn’t have asked for a better introduction. Every character was hilarious not only the main characters but side characters too, it was so much fun to read.
It was genuinely refreshing to see the behind-the-scenes reality of what both editors and authors deal with. The struggles, the meltdowns, the writer’s block, and the nerves. Seeing the pressure they face, and how reader expectations aren’t always only exciting but can be overwhelming, made the story feel so real. And how the editor’s honesty and steady support, is important in shaping the story so readers get the best version possible. It gave me a whole new appreciation for the process.
I’m counting down the days for Maddie and Shane’s book! Every character was such a delight to read—no dull moments, no cheesy filler. From Mary’s gossip, to Ronan brewing whiskey in the bathtub, to Casey being an unexpected father figure. I adored all of them. They were hilarious and endlessly fun.
All I'm saying is BE READY TO GET OBSESSED WITH IT IN COMING SUMMER !! ⛱️🏝️
thank you netgally and little, brown book for the ARC.
I had absolute fun reading this book till 5 in the morning.
This is a story of Ciara an author whose talent was overshadowed by her father her whole life, who was a legendary author but some circumstances made her face it all.
And she had her editor Sam, who made her face it all with as much comfort and ease as he could provide.
Carrigwest is a small community where everyone looks after each other in their own crazy wayyy.
It's an amazing feeling well you apply for a random ARC and it turns out to be one of the best, you ever readddd.
This was my first book by Catherine and what a way to begin !! It clicked instantly for me, and I practically inhaled the whole thing.
This book has such a perfect balance of humour and sentiment, sarcasm and heartfelt moments. When I first started it, I expected a typical rom-com full of laughs, but it surprised me with its emotional depth. It has overwhelming emotions, but never overshadowing the light parts, just the right touch. This was my first EditorXAuthor trope read and I honestly couldn’t have asked for a better introduction. Every character was hilarious not only the main characters but side characters too, it was so much fun to read.
It was genuinely refreshing to see the behind-the-scenes reality of what both editors and authors deal with. The struggles, the meltdowns, the writer’s block, and the nerves. Seeing the pressure they face, and how reader expectations aren’t always only exciting but can be overwhelming, made the story feel so real. And how the editor’s honesty and steady support, is important in shaping the story so readers get the best version possible. It gave me a whole new appreciation for the process.
I’m counting down the days for Maddie and Shane’s book! Every character was such a delight to read—no dull moments, no cheesy filler. From Mary’s gossip, to Ronan brewing whiskey in the bathtub, to Casey being an unexpected father figure. I adored all of them. They were hilarious and endlessly fun.
All I'm saying is BE READY TO GET OBSESSED WITH IT IN COMING SUMMER !! ⛱️🏝️
thank you netgally and little, brown book for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Thank you NetGalley and Dutton for this arc in exchange for an honest review!
2.5 stars
I really great setting with a loveable FMC with extremely underwhelming MMC.
The MMC single handedly ruined this book for me. He started off as a dick, which is fine, but that didn't go away. And I don't mean that he just had a rough exterior that we tend to love in a male lead. He was mostly a kind person that had a good sense of humor, but he did not have the right reactions to specific situations, and always at the FMC's expense.
He never had the respect for her as a human being. And in the middle of the work he just decides he is attracted to her and then I guess that's that.
There was also one of those things where 2 weeks of time goes by at the very beginning where really crucial development should have been but got glossed over and all of a sudden they're somewhat more comfortable with each other.
Not to mention a sequel is clearly being set up and those two characters had WAY more chemistry in their short interactions than the main characters here.
Sorry to say this was a definite disappointment 💔
2.5 stars
I really great setting with a loveable FMC with extremely underwhelming MMC.
The MMC single handedly ruined this book for me. He started off as a dick, which is fine, but that didn't go away. And I don't mean that he just had a rough exterior that we tend to love in a male lead. He was mostly a kind person that had a good sense of humor, but he did not have the right reactions to specific situations, and always at the FMC's expense.
He never had the respect for her as a human being. And in the middle of the work he just decides he is attracted to her and then I guess that's that.
There was also one of those things where 2 weeks of time goes by at the very beginning where really crucial development should have been but got glossed over and all of a sudden they're somewhat more comfortable with each other.
Not to mention a sequel is clearly being set up and those two characters had WAY more chemistry in their short interactions than the main characters here.
Sorry to say this was a definite disappointment 💔
March 26, 2026
Love a cute, quick romance. Very enjoyable on audio!
🌶️🌶️ — easy to skip the spice!
🌶️🌶️ — easy to skip the spice!
March 16, 2026
Meh, it was just okay.
March 9, 2026
Another great rom-com with heart from Catherine Walsh! It’s a romance about writing books so, of course.
As with her other books, the FMC is someone special. Ciara, with her dry sense of humor and a touching life story, grabs your attention and has you caring and cheering for her throughout. She struggles with the loss of her famous author father while trying to finish the last book in his series and find her own identity away from his shadow. Her grief and isolation are anchored in the house she grew up in which her father left to her. Her story as well as the gentle kindness from her dear friends are tenderly written.
When her ability to deliver the final book is questionable, her no-nonsense editor from New York, Sam, arrives to ensure it gets done. We get to see their relationship grow along with Ciara’s confidence and output for the book. There is a lot of angst in the first two thirds of the book that builds good tension! I would have liked a little more personality for Sam to add to their chemistry and relationship-build but their connection and dialogue felt real and natural.
Walsh’s FMC’s all combine strength and perseverance in challenging moments with sensitivity, introspection and selflessness, like many other authors do. But something about her FMC’s just feels different - more genuine in their struggles and character? I’m not sure what it is but it sure works.
We also get to watch the journey through the writing and editing experience with the added challenges of a cultish world of book devotees. A charming Irish village for a setting and a funny cast of supporting characters brings it all together! I really enjoy her books and this one is another winner.
Thank you to NetGalley, Dutton Publishing and Catherine Walsh for the opportunity to read an advance copy and share my thoughts.
As with her other books, the FMC is someone special. Ciara, with her dry sense of humor and a touching life story, grabs your attention and has you caring and cheering for her throughout. She struggles with the loss of her famous author father while trying to finish the last book in his series and find her own identity away from his shadow. Her grief and isolation are anchored in the house she grew up in which her father left to her. Her story as well as the gentle kindness from her dear friends are tenderly written.
When her ability to deliver the final book is questionable, her no-nonsense editor from New York, Sam, arrives to ensure it gets done. We get to see their relationship grow along with Ciara’s confidence and output for the book. There is a lot of angst in the first two thirds of the book that builds good tension! I would have liked a little more personality for Sam to add to their chemistry and relationship-build but their connection and dialogue felt real and natural.
Walsh’s FMC’s all combine strength and perseverance in challenging moments with sensitivity, introspection and selflessness, like many other authors do. But something about her FMC’s just feels different - more genuine in their struggles and character? I’m not sure what it is but it sure works.
We also get to watch the journey through the writing and editing experience with the added challenges of a cultish world of book devotees. A charming Irish village for a setting and a funny cast of supporting characters brings it all together! I really enjoy her books and this one is another winner.
Thank you to NetGalley, Dutton Publishing and Catherine Walsh for the opportunity to read an advance copy and share my thoughts.
March 14, 2026
How to Write a Love Story is a new contemporary romance from Catherine Walsh. I’ve read the previous 2 holiday romances from this author and really enjoyed them so I was definitely excited for a new release. This is set in rural Ireland and is very much a slow burn set in the bookish industry.
Sam is an ambitious editor from the U.S. and the story kicks off with him traveling to Ireland to assist Ciara. Ciara’s late father was a bestselling fantasy author and she is planning to finish her father’s last manuscript, the final installment in his epic bestselling fantasy series. Sam is kind of everything that Ciara is frustrated with. He’s a super fan of her late father, even has multiple tattoos for the fantasy series. Ciara has complicated feelings with her late father’s books and his fans. She was raised by her single father and felt like his books and career took her dad away from her growing up. The super fans also go too hard and make things uncomfortable for her.
This was an emotional journey for Ciara, as she is still grieving the loss of her father and trying to figure out how his books play in her life, while actively trying to write the final book installment. The slow burn romance between her and Sam while he’s in Ireland to help her with the book didn’t quite feel like it made sense to me, I wasn’t sold on their connection. I sadly just didn’t love this one quite as much as I did the author’s two previous books (Holiday Romance and Snowed In).
I received an ARC from the publisher, all thoughts in this review are my own.
Sam is an ambitious editor from the U.S. and the story kicks off with him traveling to Ireland to assist Ciara. Ciara’s late father was a bestselling fantasy author and she is planning to finish her father’s last manuscript, the final installment in his epic bestselling fantasy series. Sam is kind of everything that Ciara is frustrated with. He’s a super fan of her late father, even has multiple tattoos for the fantasy series. Ciara has complicated feelings with her late father’s books and his fans. She was raised by her single father and felt like his books and career took her dad away from her growing up. The super fans also go too hard and make things uncomfortable for her.
This was an emotional journey for Ciara, as she is still grieving the loss of her father and trying to figure out how his books play in her life, while actively trying to write the final book installment. The slow burn romance between her and Sam while he’s in Ireland to help her with the book didn’t quite feel like it made sense to me, I wasn’t sold on their connection. I sadly just didn’t love this one quite as much as I did the author’s two previous books (Holiday Romance and Snowed In).
I received an ARC from the publisher, all thoughts in this review are my own.
March 19, 2026
'how to write a love story' is the first book i've read from catherine walsh and no doubt i'll be reading more from her! she's got a great skill for writing banter and hilarious characters that still strongly resemble reality. i loved the premise of an editor and an author falling in love as they aim to piece together a really daunting, legacy novel.
my main issue with this story boils down to "why were they in love?" and i don't think walsh has fully satisfied me with the answer. ciara and sam find each other in critical moments of change in their lives. they're unwillingly brought together by this one goal of completing ciara's famous father's long beloved final book in the series (akin to george r.r. martin's a song of ice and fire series). what starts of as annoyance and distrust between the two leads soon turns into friendship. you can see ciara slowly bloom and rely on sam. she's attracted to him and what he brings to her life. i can see why she starts to fall for him.
on the other hand, it's hard to tell why sam falls for ciara. there are gaps in the timeline where their everyday discussions and hangouts get a glossed, passive mention. i assume he was falling in love during those moments. otherwise, it kind of just feels like he was sexually attracted to her and then her feelings took over and perhaps convinced him? then the subsequent drama and it's lack of real reckoning especially from sam's end made it hard for me to root for them.
i wish there was more simmering with their feelings and after they get together. it goes from 0 to 100 in a way that is a disservice to what could have been a really wonderful romantic build up. while this wasn't my favourite romance, i did quite enjoy catherine walsh's prose and will definitely be checking out her other works.
thank you for the opportunity to dutton books for the opportunity to read and review!
[2.75 overall]
my main issue with this story boils down to "why were they in love?" and i don't think walsh has fully satisfied me with the answer. ciara and sam find each other in critical moments of change in their lives. they're unwillingly brought together by this one goal of completing ciara's famous father's long beloved final book in the series (akin to george r.r. martin's a song of ice and fire series). what starts of as annoyance and distrust between the two leads soon turns into friendship. you can see ciara slowly bloom and rely on sam. she's attracted to him and what he brings to her life. i can see why she starts to fall for him.
on the other hand, it's hard to tell why sam falls for ciara. there are gaps in the timeline where their everyday discussions and hangouts get a glossed, passive mention. i assume he was falling in love during those moments. otherwise, it kind of just feels like he was sexually attracted to her and then her feelings took over and perhaps convinced him? then the subsequent drama and it's lack of real reckoning especially from sam's end made it hard for me to root for them.
i wish there was more simmering with their feelings and after they get together. it goes from 0 to 100 in a way that is a disservice to what could have been a really wonderful romantic build up. while this wasn't my favourite romance, i did quite enjoy catherine walsh's prose and will definitely be checking out her other works.
thank you for the opportunity to dutton books for the opportunity to read and review!
[2.75 overall]
March 10, 2026
4.5 stars. I adored so many things about this. The small town setting, Ciera + Sam’s doubly-lovable characters, their banter, hilarious.. their chemistry, so sweet. And I really loved the smart premise of a romance evolving around a book.
This had me smiling from ear-to-ear. So darn fun!! ❥ Pub. 3/10/26
Many thanks to NetGalley and Dutton. All opinions are my own.
This had me smiling from ear-to-ear. So darn fun!! ❥ Pub. 3/10/26
Many thanks to NetGalley and Dutton. All opinions are my own.
March 20, 2026
I absolutely adored this story. The Irish coastal setting, the SLOW BURN romance! 🔥 this book has the perfect balance of humour, sarcasm, sentiment and heartfelt moments. The perfect spring/summer read.
March 21, 2026
4, 5 stars🌟🌟🌟🌟I wanted something heartfelt and light, and I got it!🤗🌸
The romance was cute, tender and sweet, but what really elevated the book for me was the heroine. She goes through a lot, tends to procrastinate, cracks jokes that take you off guard, and is genuine in her insecurities. Her life journey after a loss managed to resonate with me.
The romance was cute, tender and sweet, but what really elevated the book for me was the heroine. She goes through a lot, tends to procrastinate, cracks jokes that take you off guard, and is genuine in her insecurities. Her life journey after a loss managed to resonate with me.
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
How to Write a Love Story is signature Walsh: relatable characters, excellent banter laced with humor à la Catherine Walsh, and a story that will grab your attention and play like a movie in your mind.
I loved both Ciara and Sam. Ciara's mind is a marvel - her tendency towards darker thoughts with a humorous undertone never failed to delight me. I could picture Sam just looking at her, going "hmm you're kind of scary, I dig it". Sam is such a loveable character too - a good guy, the kind that you want by your side. Both Ciara and Sam stay true to themselves, and while their partnership at first is not easy - this kind of relationship demands trust and some level of ease and comfort - seeing Ciara and Sam work towards their happiness was such a treat.
The Ireland setting is always a pleasure too.
The dual pov is fantastic - making you know the characters more intimately.
Everything feels very well balanced in this story. Walsh knows how to write well-rounded and layered characters - who are more than just two people being in love.
Catherine Walsh is one of my favorite authors, and I absolutely trust her to deliver stories that I know I will love. And if like me you are a Walsh fan, you will definitely love Sam and Ciara!
Thank you Dutton for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
---------
Who's ready for a new Catherine Walsh?! (Me, always me)
I loved both Ciara and Sam. Ciara's mind is a marvel - her tendency towards darker thoughts with a humorous undertone never failed to delight me. I could picture Sam just looking at her, going "hmm you're kind of scary, I dig it". Sam is such a loveable character too - a good guy, the kind that you want by your side. Both Ciara and Sam stay true to themselves, and while their partnership at first is not easy - this kind of relationship demands trust and some level of ease and comfort - seeing Ciara and Sam work towards their happiness was such a treat.
The Ireland setting is always a pleasure too.
The dual pov is fantastic - making you know the characters more intimately.
Everything feels very well balanced in this story. Walsh knows how to write well-rounded and layered characters - who are more than just two people being in love.
Catherine Walsh is one of my favorite authors, and I absolutely trust her to deliver stories that I know I will love. And if like me you are a Walsh fan, you will definitely love Sam and Ciara!
Thank you Dutton for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
---------
Who's ready for a new Catherine Walsh?! (Me, always me)
Currently reading
September 28, 2025catherine walsh just automatically saved 2026 with this announcement
November 10, 2025
4.5
I adored this book. It is such a cozy uplifting romance.
Ciara Sheridan's father is a famous writer. She is left heartbroken when he passes and overwhelmed with the sprawling infamous estate, located in Ireland. He wanted Ciara to finish the last book in his very famous and loved series. But it proves to be a very challenging task. So, the publisher sends their hot shot editor, Sam, to help her get through the writing process.
Sam and Ciara captured my heart. So did the town and the side characters. Every character was so lovable. It is such a delightful and beautiful love story that kept me flipping the pages.
The love story is a slow burn with excellent genuine build up and tension. Some of their time is spent off page so I can see why people may feel like the romance was rushed, but I think it was executed perfectly. This is a rom-com with emotional depth and great character development. There was a bit of a third-act-breakup that had me rolling my eyes and made me slow my reading with apprehension. Thankfully, the end redeemed that discomfort for me.
This is more than a romance. It's also about writing, publishing, editing, fandom, grief, and healing. It was highly fascinating and engaging.
Read this if you like:
Forced proximity
Witty banter
Ireland setting
Dual pov
I would recommend this charming and heartfelt book.
Thank you Dutton Publishing and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.
I adored this book. It is such a cozy uplifting romance.
Ciara Sheridan's father is a famous writer. She is left heartbroken when he passes and overwhelmed with the sprawling infamous estate, located in Ireland. He wanted Ciara to finish the last book in his very famous and loved series. But it proves to be a very challenging task. So, the publisher sends their hot shot editor, Sam, to help her get through the writing process.
Sam and Ciara captured my heart. So did the town and the side characters. Every character was so lovable. It is such a delightful and beautiful love story that kept me flipping the pages.
The love story is a slow burn with excellent genuine build up and tension. Some of their time is spent off page so I can see why people may feel like the romance was rushed, but I think it was executed perfectly. This is a rom-com with emotional depth and great character development. There was a bit of a third-act-breakup that had me rolling my eyes and made me slow my reading with apprehension. Thankfully, the end redeemed that discomfort for me.
This is more than a romance. It's also about writing, publishing, editing, fandom, grief, and healing. It was highly fascinating and engaging.
Read this if you like:
Forced proximity
Witty banter
Ireland setting
Dual pov
I would recommend this charming and heartfelt book.
Thank you Dutton Publishing and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.
February 28, 2026
Perfect in every way! I love Catherine Walsh’s books and this one is for sure my favorite! Love Ciara. Love Sam. Love it all!
I read this in about 12 hours and truly couldn’t put it down. If you’re an Emily Henry fan I highly recommend! The banter was so fun and the tension was DELICIOUS.
Thank you so much to NetGalley for the arc!
I read this in about 12 hours and truly couldn’t put it down. If you’re an Emily Henry fan I highly recommend! The banter was so fun and the tension was DELICIOUS.
Thank you so much to NetGalley for the arc!
Read
September 16, 2025I have very complicated feelings about this book but i will say that obsession that non-american authors have with appealing to the american idea of a HEA for marketing purposes being an engagement and/or baby drives me up the wall.
Received a digital arc from the publisher.
Received a digital arc from the publisher.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,382 reviews