Fox News anchor and #1 NYT bestselling author Bret Baier makes the case for America, in this celebration of the nation’s virtues timed to America’s 250th anniversary
William Bret Baier is an American journalist and the host of Special Report with Bret Baier on the Fox News Channel and the chief political anchor for Fox. He previously worked as the network's Chief White House Correspondent and Pentagon correspondent.
There are many people who will refuse to read this book because Bret Baier is an anchor on Fox News. Funnily enough, you are kind of making his point!
Here is what everyone needs to know about The Case for America. Baier has not written some sort of jingoistic defense of America as the end-all, be-all of statecraft. He immediately tells the reader he knows there are people upset with where we are as a country. He recognizes that there are good reasons to feel this way.
What follows is a book that says, "Let's just for a moment look at the good this country has done over the past 250 years." Let's also celebrate the fact that we are a young country comparatively who probably never should have survived this long. This book is not about dismissing viewpoints. In fact, Republicans and Democrats are cited throughout the book as proof that we can be divided and still function. (Fun fact: Two of my West Point classmates are interviewed for the book. One is a Republican and one is a Democrat.)
In the end, this book is great for what it is. A little history, a little politics, but a celebration throughout. Because even if you refuse to read this book because you can't bear to think of America positively right now, or because of the name on the front, then that is entirely your right. You can proclaim it loudly wherever you want. And that's the point.
(This book was provided as a review copy by Mariner Books.)
So, I went into this one expecting a lot of political talking points, but it was actually much more informative than I anticipated and not as biased as I worried it would be. Bret Baier does a great job walking through American history and making the case for why our country is unique without it feeling like a nonstop partisan lecture. Especially because he talked to people from both sides.
I learned quite a bit. You don’t have to agree with every point to appreciate the message. Overall, a worthwhile read that left me feeling more informed and more appreciative of America, especially going into our 250th anniversary.
This is a reminder of things we already know, but have all slightly forgotten over the past decade or so, in my opinion. Our forefathers debated and argued, but ultimately used that push and pull to work together in creating the Constitution of the United States. As we celebrate 250 years of our country's existence, this book serves as an inspiration to do our part to continue moving forward.
A beautiful, simple, bipartisan case for why America is great! Baier invites people from each political party to explain why they love America and why they fight for it the way that they do. Would definitely recommend
I read this, reluctantly, as my book club decided on it. I wasn't thrilled to read a book by "the chief political anchor" for Fox News, as I'm sure others wouldn't be happy if I suggested a Rachel Maddow book, but there it is. I was assured the book wasn't political. Indeed, there was nothing overtly political about the book and Baier makes some good points about the "messiness" of democracy as he commemorates the 250th anniversary of our country. But he also completely fails to acknowledge that Jan 6, 2021 was NOT a "peaceful transfer of power" and makes no mention of the current president's continuous lies about the 2020 election, or the pardoning of those convicted Jan 6 felons or the recent "slush fund" to compensate them. Similar thoughts about other subjects - immigration, bipartisanship, etc - where Baier ignores current reality especially in speaking about treating all with dignity. He makes some good points, including that "Presidents are elected to serve all Americans, not just those who vote for him" but disregards the complete disrespect shown by the current occupant for the American voter, the American people, and the American Constitution.
The Case for America: An Argument on Behalf of Our Nation
By Bret Baier with Catherine Whitney
All of our politicians and media should read this book. As intended, it is timely, just before the celebration of America’s 250th birthday. Mr. Baier makes the case that Americans can, and have, disagreed vociferously without being enemies and that we should again. He provided many examples. He also makes the case, God bless him, that we can admit America’s faults in her history without demonizing her… recognizing her greatness. He utilized many of my favorite quotes from presidents and other notables, which I thoroughly enjoyed. Definitely worth your time. If you do not have time to sit down and read it, buy the audiobook, which the author narrated in his easy-going style.
In Shakespeare’s “The Tempest” a character (Antonio) rationalizes a conspiracy to commit murder as the fated result of all that has transpired before, saying “what’s past is prologue.” The phrase has come to be less deterministic and more prognostic of what might be if the context of the past is relevant to future circumstances.
And that’s the key in Fox News anchor Bret Baier’s very interesting book, “The Case for America”, an apologetic on the occasion of the 250th anniversary of the key founding document, the Declaration of Independence, for America’s future based on our past resilience and perseverance. Baier makes his case in courtroom-style fashion and argues that America will thrive and remain a beacon of liberty in the future because that is the American character and spirit, which has pulled us through circumstances far more daunting and divisive than present. His case is effective and strong and well worth the refresher in a time where knowledge of our past seems to be waning, Baier himself pointing to the lapse of emphasis on civics in our schools this century. Truly, America has persevered and emerged stronger through wars, slavery, economic depression, divisiveness, and even bad leadership. That is a comforting reality and the result of both the traditional American spirit and extraordinarily farsighted leadership. It’s why we’ve made it for the first 250 years and well worth remembering.
What’s missing somewhat from Baier’s optimistic defense is the prosecution’s case. Is our past context relevant to present trends and future circumstances, particularly the embrace of the traditional American spirit? Or have we become so divisive or complacent that the spirit is less a part of our national character? Do we still have unifying leadership to awaken and invigorate the American spirit? Or is our leadership too ideological in departures from that spirit? Is the past still prologue?
Baier’s book is well worth reading, but its hopefulness falls a bit short of a needed debate.
The Case for America is a thoughtful, timely, and deeply patriotic reflection on what the United States means as it approaches its 250th anniversary. Bret Baier does not present America as perfect, and that is what makes the book more convincing.
Instead, he looks at the country through its founding ideals, struggles, divisions, resilience, freedom, civic values, and continuing promise.
I appreciated the courtroom-like structure of the book, where America’s history becomes evidence in a larger argument about national character. The strongest parts for me were the discussions of unity despite disagreement, the importance of civic education, and the idea that patriotism should include honesty, not blind praise.
At times, the tone is more hopeful than critical, so readers looking for a harsher historical reckoning may want more depth on America’s failures. Still, as a readable and reflective defense of American ideals, this is a meaningful book.
A worthwhile read for anyone interested in American history, democracy, civics, leadership, and the future of the American Dream.
Can the Founders’ ideals still inspire and unite the nation 250th years after the Declaration of Independence? The impossible dream of the United States of America began with a declaration. Years before the Revolution was won, long before the Constitution was created, we were a nation because of our decision to be free. Though the universal hunger for freedom that endures, these days our country often seems at cross purposes. Our very history is divisive. On one side, there are the unrelenting complaints about all the things we’re getting wrong. Such critics seem intent on focusing on the darker chapters of our story. On the other side is a sanitized version of history that leaves little room for self-reflection. It’s as if any admission of frailty or failure is an unpatriotic act. “In The Case for America” Bret Baier argues that neither of these pictures reflects our reality. To make the case for the nation’s enduring value, he underscores our fundamental character: unity, freedom, resilience. Baier shares his own reflections alongside those of numerous historians, commentators, and business leaders in a moving ode to a nation.
Bret Baier is a gifted writer as well as a top broadcast journalist/anchor. Because he works for Fox News, some may not consider reading this timely book prepared for the 250th birthday of our country. That would be a shame. This is a non-political reflection on America as a country. with balanced and fair discussion over the things American has done right and areas where the country has fallen short.
Baier uses a variety of sources in developing a concise and very readable narrative. The Case for America can easily be completed in just a few days, but allow some time for reflection and introspection. The book begins with a review of the Declaration of Independence, and what it means at the time of its first reading and today. After going through several other key points, such as the search for freedom, Baier offers his own assessment about the case for America.
The book is a vibrant mix of history and politics. I enjoyed it, and came away hopeful for out country at a time it is facing divisions on multiple fronts. I rate it 5/5 starts.
My thanks to the author, Mariner Books, and NetGalley for an opportunity to review an ARC of this book.
I approached this book with an open mind. I was initially skeptical, partly because it’s written by a Fox News reporter, a network I often associate with sensationalism and a lack of objectivity. Still, I knew nothing about Bret Baier personally, so I wanted to give the book a fair chance.
To my surprise, there isn’t much to dispute in the way the material is presented. The book largely recounts stories of past presidents and how they shaped, protected, and carried forward the American experiment. I appreciated its generally nonpartisan tone and the uplifting stories rooted in American values and civic ideals.
That said, it was striking how briefly January 6th was addressed, only a few sentences, and how little criticism was offered, especially given how strongly the book emphasizes civic education, trust in institutions, and the preservation of the Union. The event seems to contradict many of the principles the book celebrates, making its minimal treatment feel like a noticeable omission.
Overall, though, it’s a light and engaging read, and a fitting reflection as the nation approaches 250 years since the Declaration of Independence.
I received this book courtesy of NetGalley for the purpose of a fair and honest review.
Overview: Since the 2016 election season, the United States has seemed to become hyperpartisan. Is this true? Are we doomed to lose our country because of a hyperpartisanship that has infected our nation? One side of the divide sees the United States as a perfect nation and the other side doesn't seem to see anything but our flaws. How do we find a way to bridge this gap? Mr. Baier seems to have an answer. Will it help? Let's find out.
Dislikes: Mr. Baier seemed to look for any answer to our problems except from a higher power. Even when he quoted the Founders, references to God are cut out. Perhaps he was seeking to avoid giving offense?
Likes: It was great to hear how many people were trying to find common ground.
We also hear some great news about congressmembers working together. Hearing that such friendships can cross the political lines in this time is a breath of hope.
Conclusion: This is a fascinating book. If you are seeking to find peace in the United States today, then this book is for you. Enjoy the read.
A Case for America by Bret Baier is an excellent read. Mr. Baier provides a compelling argument for America in advance of our 250th Anniversary. If you are interested in our Nation’s history or not the insight into how our Country came to be and how so many have shaped this into the greatest Country in the world is well presented. Mr. Baier quotes Washington and many of our Founding Fathers. He also interviews several contemporaries on the foundations of our Democracy and what makes America unique among nations 250 years after her birth. “The best case for America is the fact that our Constitution still stands after 250 years, along with our ideals.” Who among them would have guessed that as we prepare to celebrate our Anniversary, America would be the world’s most admired and strongest nation. The American dream is alive and well.
Another fabulous book by Mr. Baier. Well done! I can’t wait to see what you have in store for us next.
I just finished this new book by Bret Baier & highly recommend it. It is a comprehensive history of our 250 years and so appropriate for release this year. Bret is an excellent historian and this book covers all the important periods of our history, both good and bad. He spends a lot of time interviewing many knowledgable people to include their insight and comments. Even though I took Civics and American history, I learned a lot from this book.
My personal observation of the current climate in our political arena is alarming. Both parties must LISTEN to each other and reach across the aisle for reasonable partisan discussions and get important legislation passed. All the hateful and ugly dialog is embarrassing and does not accomplish anything.
RECOMMENDATION - ALL ELECTED OFFICIALS, FEDERAL,STATE AND LOCAL SHOULD READ THIS BOOK.
I wasn’t sure what to expect with this book, but I was grateful for the optimism expressed and for the thought-provoking snippets of American history and Brett’s analysis. The same optimism of recognizing our country’s greatness and of our citizens resonated with me, but I’m sensing less optimism in present times. The majority of US citizens are good, resilient and giving as he describes. Legal immigrants share that same goodness. Somewhere along the way, a generation of young people and weak-minded adults seem to be on a destructive trajectory that will eventually result in a civil uprising. These people are consumed by such deep-rooted hatred of one man that it has affected their everyday lives. I may be less optimistic of some people’s ability to save themselves or the country, but I will remain as hopeful as possible for our future generations.
Brett Baier shares stories past and present to support The Case for America. The book is not a rose-colored glasses collection of stories, Baier discusses the not so rosy history of our country and how resilient the country has been to get through difficult and dark times.
Baier has included discussions and interviews he’s had on his podcast with both Republicans and Democrats giving support to his Case For America bipartisanship within the congress and senate.
The book is an enjoyable read, you’ll learn a little bit of history, and it’s great for celebrating the 250th birthday of our country!
A Case for America provides a compelling argument for America’s inspiring history in advance of our 250th anniversary. Baier quotes Washington and our Founding Fathers, as well as contemporaries on the foundations of our democracy and what makes America unique among nations 250 years after her birth. “The best case for America is the fact that our constitution still stands after 250 years, along with our ideals.” Who among them would have guessed that as we prepare to celebrate our anniversary, America would be the world’s most admired and strongest nation. The American dream is alive and well. “There is still no place on earth like America.”
Nothing special here ... just a summary of various events that have happened to the USA and how we were able to overcome, recover and thrive after each of them. There are a few quotes from current leaders and thinkers about why our country will continue to survive (but not how).
I had hoped there would be some thought about why we are where we are in the USA and how we might work our way past the serious issues that we currently face. There was none of that. There was the assurance that, since we have rebounded before, we will do it again. I believe that's true. How we do it, I am no closer to that knowledge than when I started this book.
In the year of our country’s 250th birthday, Brett Baier has written “The Case for America: An Argument on Behalf of our Nation.” The Fox News commentator through history and modern testimonies describes the characteristics of our great nation: Unity in diversity, Freedom, Resilience, Opportunity, Civic virtue, and the reality of the American Dream. While admitting that there were many times when the United States did not live up to these lofty standards, he made the case that there was no place with a better opportunity to achieve these goals. I would not say that this was a great book, but it was informative, although there were times when it seemed to be simply a collage of the personal stories of different personalities. He truly writes like a journalist. (252 pages)
Bret Baier’s case for America is one that I agree with. We will still have our challenges going forward. Bret touched on the well-intentioned Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965, also known as the Hart-Cellar Act. However, I believe we are living with the consequences of allowing people to enter our country who have no intention of assimilating into our culture.
Another of my personal beliefs is that God inspired the founding fathers to create this country and continues to protect us.
This is an incredible work and should be read by both sides of the aisle and those in between. Bret has a way of articulating what made this country what it is today and what everyone needs to do to remain the best country this world has ever seen. There were times in the book that I misted up with patriotism hearing what so many men and women have done for this nation. Please read with a mind focused on keeping America great and getting even better.
You will have a deeper appreciation and understanding of our founders’ words evoking our unalienable rights to “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” after reading Brett Baier’s “The Case for America”. Through Brett’s collection of experiences, investigations and conversations, he provides us with a reminder of why we should be so proud to be American and why the ideals of the American experiment are worth fighting to preserve. A wonderful read as we approach our 250th Anniversary!
In a time of great division, the US needs more books like this. Sadly, it seems today everyone is so party first. Washington warned of this very mentality. Rather than focus on the negative, the nation needs to focus on the things that unite. A nation united is stronger and can solve almost any problem. That is the message that resonates so well in this book. I think everyone needs to hear this, especially today.
In the Apostle Paul's letter to the Church in Galatia, he warned, "If you bite and devour each other, watch out or you will be destroyed by each other." (Galatians 5:15, NIV) That seems to be where our nation is at the time of America's 250th birthday, so it is easy for the average citizen to feel discouraged. Brett Baier's timely argument lifts the reader's spirit and devour and success against all odds.
America is in such a bad place these days… or is it? Bret takes the reader through our history and interviews some Americans who have an opinion on where we are today and are we going to see a future. Great, fast read and a good one to read as we celebrate the 250th birthday of the United States of America.
“Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same, or one day we will spend our sunset years telling our children and our children’s children what it was once like in the United States where men were free.”
A very positive look at what made and makes America great. We all see things that are wrong, be we the people can change those things. We often don't appreciate what we have because we concentrate on the bad, take a look at the good we find in these pages.
This is a book that I will read again. I listened to it on audible and love that Bret Baier narrated it. His writing is straight forward, practical, and common sense. I appreciate how he makes clear that our country has and will continue to improve by examining our past objectively. Thank you Bret Baier. I will be sending a copy of this to my children and grandchildren.