Sung in the Shadows

The Art of Love and Danger #2

by Crystal Caudill

When past darkness prowls, will stepping into the light lead to a brighter future?

In nineteenth-century Cincinnati, fear keeps Nora Davis caged with secrets and lies. Her true identity as the daughter of a famous opera singer is too dangerous to reveal with her former captors still on the loose. But weekly singing lessons at Longview Asylum—her paranoid mother's permanent residence—light a flame in Nora, and it's one she can avoid fanning for only so long.
 
With his suicidal ma in the asylum, Ezekiel Beaumont's soul is weary, but Nora's presence at the asylum intrigues him. As a Pike's Opera House employee, Ezekiel thinks Nora might be cut out for the stage. He also begins to wonder if Nora's ma is really the famed Constanza Brisbane, who went missing mid-performance. He's determined to find out.
 
Though Ezekiel brings the performance world a little too close for comfort, Nora is drawn to his warm personality all the same. The two of them steadily grow closer, but then Nora begins to fear she's being watched, and her own paranoia blooms.
 
As the line between what's real and false grows fainter, will Ezekiel's and Nora's faith and love overcome?
 
"From the haunting halls of Longview Asylum to the dangerous secrets of Nora's past, Sung in the Shadows delivers a riveting blend of romance, mystery, and redemption." —Misty M. Beller, USA TODAY best-selling author of the Sisters of the Rockies series

Genres: Historical Fiction, Mystery, Suspense, Christian Fiction, Christian Romance, Christian

314 pages, Kindle Edition

Published March 17, 2026

About the author

Crystal Caudill is the author of “dangerously good historical romance,” with her work garnering awards from Romance Writers of America and ACFW. She is a stay-at-home mom and caregiver, and when she isn’t writing, Crystal can be found playing board games with her family, drinking hot tea, or reading other great books at her home outside Cincinnati, Ohio. Find out more at crystalcaudill.com.

Reviews

[Paula Shreckhise · Rating 5 out of 5]

"We can do everything right and it still not be enough. Only God is enough, even though sometimes it doesn't feel like He is."
A meet cute in an insane asylum? All thanks to a cantankerous cat who brings comic relief to a dark subject.
This well-written book gives hope among despair. It is infused with intrigue, mystery, danger and romance in an unlikely situation.
In this second in the series , The Art of Love and Danger, Nora sees her past catch up to her. Fellow Guardians from book one are there to help her as well as hero Ezekiel. Ezekiel and Nora meet at Longview Asylum where each of their mothers is a ward of the state. Ezekiel proves his integrity as he shows his faith in God and loyalty to Nora. Nora battles seen and unseen enemies and questions her own sanity but takes comfort in scripture and her faith.
This was an interesting look into not only asylums of 1869 bur of the opera world too.
Lovers of Christian Historical Fiction will want to put this one on their list.
*A complimentary copy of this book was provided by Kregel on behalf of the author via NetGalley. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are mine alone.*

[Andrea Cox]

FTC Disclosure: I copyedited this book. These are my honest thoughts.

This story was wonderful! I especially loved how complex and beautiful the plot was. It featured characters trapped in an asylum, a near-feral housecat, a forbidden romance, a friendship club that constantly got into scrapes, and a lovely faith thread. What more could a reader ask for?

[Melissa (christianbooksandcoffee) · Rating 5 out of 5]

Wow! I seriously could not put this book down once I started. The opening just sucks you right in. This is the second book in the series but it works as a standalone. This story centers around Nora, Ezekiel, and a third pov of Nora’s mother. Nora and her parents have to change their identity after Nora was kidnapped briefly as a child. There are two villains after Nora and her mother, because of her mother’s past association with them. Nora’s mom is in an asylum and she claims to have her other identities so they think she is crazy. I felt so bad for the treatment she goes through there. Ezekiel’s mom is also at the asylum so that’s how Nora and him meet. There is a lot going on in this story and I’m trying my best not to spoil anything. The suspense is so good, I was on the edge of my seat for Nora. I loved Ezekiel and Nora a lot and loved their relationship and watching it progress. I also loved the cat Tristan, he was a fun addition to the story. The Christian content was very strong. If you are looking for a book with suspense, romance, a touch of mystery and great Christian content, then this a book for you! I highly recommend!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Content: there is some disturbing treatment in the asylum.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author and netgalley. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.

[Melmo2610 · Rating 4 out of 5]

Wowza, what a fantastic story! It's a hard read to be sure as it deals with mental illness and the way patients were abused at asylums in the name of treatment, but this is a story that is hard to put down. Crystal did a wonderful job at weaving hope within the pages even when hopeless seems the better bet. I really loved Ezekiel and how he didn't give up on Nora even when that would have been the easy thing to do. The villains in this story are some of the most evil villains I have ever came across which definitely impressed me. This is not an easy read but it was a phenomenal story.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher and was not required to post a positive review. All thoughts are my own.

[Charity · Rating 5 out of 5]

What do I say about this book? This book is one that will grab hold of you from the very first chapter and not let you go until that last word. It will make you squirm with discomfort and keep you on the very edge of your seat.

But you will also fall more in love with each of the characters-well, not ALL the characters, but the regulars here. The Guardians is my favorite friend group, and I can't get enough of them.

I will also say that hopefully, I wasn't ill-named.

Read the book. You'll figure it out.

~I was given a complimentary copy of this book. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.~

[Courtney Pityer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Sung in the Shadows is an excellent installment to the The Art of Love and Danger series! I will say there was enough mystery and drama that had me hooked on the story from start to finish. Not only was I facinated by the drama and mystery elements I found myself drawn to the mental health aspects as well. It saddens me about some of the methods that were used back then on those who were suffering and many of these people's voices went unheard.

We are introduced to Nora who as a child was kidnapped by some people from her mother's past. After she was found her parents that it would be safer to take on new identities and forget the magnificent experiences they had at the Opera house. But years later Nora's mother finds herself in the Asylum unable to let go of the past life she once led and Nora herself wonders if she might inherit what ails her mother.

Despite her woes she manages to make a friend in Ezekiel whose mother also suffers at the Asylum. However, despite this happiness danger still lurks. There is still bad blood from Nora's kidnapping years ago and escaping revenge isn't always an easy task.

[Teri · Rating 5 out of 5]

I don’t think it’s possible for me to give this book enough stars. It’s no secret that I adore historical fiction, but when you blend it with a “he falls first” romance between Nora and Ezekiel, intrigue, music, secret identities, an underlying sense of danger, the precious “Guardians“ sisterhood (with familiar faces if you’ve read Crystal Caudill’s other books), the most sensitive depiction of mental illnesses that I’ve ever seen, and a sense of hope in all of that unbelievable mess, it’s an unparalleled masterpiece. If any of those things appeal to you, or if you just like your romance with a dash of danger, this one is for you! I received an advanced copy of this book from the author/publisher and was under no obligation to provide a positive review.

[Deena Peterson · Rating 4 out of 5]

What a powerful story! Crystal Caudill masterfully captures the impact of mental illness and has created the perfect characters to help tell the tale.

A traumatic event sets the tone for the story, and Nora’s subsequent struggles with panic and anxiety. Unfortunately her family has decided to keep those events secret, ultimately leading to her mother being kept in an insane asylum.

The story takes place in the 1880’s, so the conditions and stigma are abysmal. But it’s there that Nora encounters Ezekiel, the crazy cat Tristan, and Ezekiel’s mother, also a patient at the asylum.

What follows is an intricate story of truth vs lies, darkness vs light, and hope vs despair. Caudill tackles a sensitive topic with grace and compassion, wrapping everything into a puzzling mystery that isn’t solved until the final chapters.

I received an advance copy from the publisher. I’m under no obligation and my review has not been solicited. Highly recommend!

[Carolyn Bryant · Rating 5 out of 5]

Sung in the Shadows is a captivating, entertaining addition to The Art of Love and Danger series. From the dazzling beauty of the Gilded Age opera to the unsettling corridors of Longview Asylum, this powerful, emotionally charged tale lingered in my heart and mind long after I finished reading and moved on to other things. The complex plot expertly combines compelling characters, riveting suspense, well-researched history, atmospheric settings, challenging romance, and inspiring faith. The darkness of Longview Asylum is tempered by humorous moments, the antics of a certain "beastly" cat, and witty banter between Nora and Ezekiel. I appreciate the inspiring faith thread with themes of redemption, freedom from fear, bearing one another's burdens, and trusting God. I also value the thoughtful treatment of sensitive mental health issues. I highly recommend this book and can't wait to read the next book in the series.
I received a copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley with no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Leslie · Rating 5 out of 5]

Crystal Caudill continues her magnificent The Art of Love and Danger series with the second installment, Sung in the Shadows! Ms. Caudill takes Readers on a wild ride of psychological proportions to Cincinnati in the 1880s by telling the story of Nora, a young woman who has been hiding in the city with her Parents after getting kidnapped as a child. Nora loved the opera lifestyle her Opera Singer Mother raised her in until Nora was kidnapped during a performance. Though Nora escaped, her Captors were never found. Escaping to Cincinnati to protect Nora, Nora and her Parents assume new identities, while constantly looking over their shoulders. This proves to be too much for Nora’s mother, who goes by Constanza Brisbane and causes Constanza to be committed to Longview Asylum. During weekly visits to Longview Asylum, Nora gets singing lessons from her Mother. Meanwhile, Ezekiel also visits his Mother at Longview Asylum and is mesmerized by the singing he hears as he passes by on the way to visit his mom. During one visit, both Mothers are in the same room when Nora and Ezekiel arrive. Instantly attracted, Ezekiel wants to strike up a friendship with Nora, but because of Nora’s past, she refuses to let Ezekiel close. But Ezekiel doesn’t give up. As Ezekiel tears down Nora’s walls, they see they have much in common—from their shared experiences with having a mother at Longview Asylum to both having a history with the opera world, and most importantly their Faith. As Nora lets her guard down, she senses someone is following her, seeing and hearing things from the past. Deciding to let Ezekiel fully into her world, Nora allows skeletons to be rattled while walking down a long, dark road that she hopes will lead to Freedom.

I love Sung in the Shadows by Crystal Caudill! I love how Ms. Caudill swept me into Sung in the Shadows! The storyline of Sung in the Shadows reminded me of Miss Blaire in Blackwell’s Island by Grace Hitchcock and The Purple Nightgown by A. D. Lawrence, which I loved! I loved meeting Ezekiel and getting to know Nora better—and seeing Nora’s Guardian Friends was a hoot! I love how Ezekiel and Nora were opposites, but were a perfect fit on things that matter. I love how Nora was equal parts spit-fire to Ezekiel’s spice in their relationship. I love the Faith that both Nora and Ezekiel had in Jesus, but that they both approached it differently—causing them to learn from one another. I love how Ms. Caudill wrote Ezekiel to look at mental health through the Eyes of Jesus! What Ezekiel said about mental health made sense to me and I love how he backed it up with Scripture! I loved the theme of being yoked that became a major thread in the plot due to what Ezekiel spoke over Nora. (Make sure to read Sung in the Shadows!) I love how, through the character of Ezekiel, that Nora, Constanza, as well as Ezekiel’s Mom, were able to see that Jesus is in the midst of their struggles with mental health, reminding them regardless, that they do have a sound mind. I especially love how Ezekiel stood by Nora and his Mother, regardless of how things turned out. I love how realistically and historically accurate Ms. Caudill wrote some of the scenes that included mental health issues. I felt what Constanza and Ezekiel’s Mom went through at Longview Asylum and what Nora went through with her anxiety and panic attacks. I love the suspenseful ride that Sung in the Shadows took me on, showing that even through the dark roads of the story, Hope and True Freedom shined through, exemplifying that Jesus can meet us right where we’re at! I highly recommend Sung in the Shadows by Crystal Caudill! I can’t wait to see where Ms. Caudill takes The Art of Love and Danger series next!

Have you read Sung in the Shadows? What did you think of the book?

Thank you to NetGalley, the Publisher, and Karen from Book Lovers and Launchers for the opportunity to read Sung in the Shadows and for letting me be on the Launch Team. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Becky Lewis · Rating 5 out of 5]

“FEAR WAS A CAGE, AND it had Nora Davis’s family trapped and hidden beneath a canvas of secrets and lies.”

Crystal Caudill takes us back to the Gilded Age in 1869 New York , then 1881 in Cincinnati. Just as the cities as separated by vast miles and differences, the plight of the Davis family has changed from one extreme to another. In New York, Constanza Brisbane, famed soprano opera singer, is at the height of her career. Suddenly, following the kidnapping of her 11-year-old daughter Eleanora, the little family moves halfway across the country, assumes aliases, and embark on totally different lives. Music, once an integral part of their lives, is forbidden, as is the opera. As we see the little family 11 years later, it is now very dysfunctional. “Mr. Davis” is distant emotionally and often gone, “Mrs. Davis” has been placed in a mental asylum suffering from paranoias and dementia, and “Nora” has tired of her father’s restrictive rules.

Nora meets Ezekiel Beaumont, a composer and opera stage manager, in her visits to her mother at the asylum. Ezekiel’s mother suffers from her own severe mental health issues, and Ezekiel is at wits’ end how to help her. Surprisingly, Mrs. Beaumont takes well to both Nora and Nora’s mother. She even tries to encourage Nora’s mother’s floundering faith, and her need for forgiveness. But God… can use anybody. He not only uses Mrs. Beaumont in her weaknesses, but He uses the mind of a so-called crazy patient to challenge Mrs. Beaumont! “So God can abandon you, but He cannot abandon me? Are you the exception? Because if you’re the exception to His promise not to abandon, then maybe I’m the exception to forgiveness.” “There are no exceptions to His promises-”

As Nora and Ezekiel begin to form a bond and work together, of course the protective and rather hilarious Guardians group tries to help along the romance ( read: interfere) When spectres from Nora and Mrs. Davis’s past threaten to obliterate all their hopes for a return to normalcy, will God intervene?

I absolutely loved the tension of the story, as it builds throughout. I loved the tender love both Nora and Ezekiel hold for their mothers who are struggling. And their realizations help me in my real-life situations, too. “If there is one thing I’ve learned through Mum’s illness, it’s that her choices are hers alone. We can do everything in the world to protect our loved ones—put rules in place, hide them from the dangers posed, shield them from pain—but we were never meant to bear the burden of saving them from themselves. We cannot even save ourselves.” Thank goodness, Nora and Ezekiel begin to realize, as I am, that the burdens we bear for others are never meant to be a strangle-hold of responsibility, but an opportunity to turn that burden over to the One Who truly holds our our loved one in His hands.

Mrs. Jensen and Tristan are my fave secondary characters. They make me smile. Mrs. Jensen for her soft, witty, reasonable ways. Tristan, because he is sooooo bad and still a comfort to many!

Sung in the Shadows will dwell in the recesses of my mind for a long time, as a particularly great marriage of historical fiction, true tragic events of our pasts, great storytelling, romance, and inescapable Truth! Thank you, Ms. Caudill!!

I received a copy of the book from the author and publisher via NetGalley. I also ordered my own ebook, plus a pb for the trophy shelf! No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.

Notable Quotables:

“My souls needs to sing. Music is as much a part of me as it is Mum.”- Nora

“Keeping secrets from those who loved her wasn’t a protective shield. It was an isolating cage that cast a debilitating shadow of fear, shame, guilt, and distrust over the relationships that mattered most.” ( Nora)

“We can do everything right and it still not be enough. Only God is enough, even though sometimes it doesn’t feel like He is. I don’t understand why He is allowing this. It feels wrong and unjust. I’m angry with Him, and I’m scared of what the future holds. I don’t want this burden He’s given us, but I know it’s not our fault. I know it’s not our job to save them.”- Nora

“Hiding your pain and thoughts doesn’t
make you a stronger person. It makes life lonelier to walk through. “- Ezekiel

[DevotedToHope · Rating 5 out of 5]

There are places in a life where shadows gather quietly. Some come from what has been done and what has been spoken until truth feels uncertain. A voice can be silenced there. Memory can feel unsteady. A heart can begin to question what it once knew with clarity.

This story steps into those places and does not rush past them. The cruelty carried within these pages is deliberate and self-serving. It leaves wounds that do not disappear when the moment has passed. Confusion settles in. Fear takes root. The mind wrestles to hold onto what is true.

I felt the power of that. Not only the danger … but the disorientation. The slow erosion of confidence that comes when truth is hidden behind a fog-filled mirror.

This story holds heartfelt, crushing suffering with a gentleness that is beautifully careful … and deeply seen.

Mental and emotional anguish are treated with dignity and thoughtful care. The heaviness carried by each person is honored. The pain is real. The confusion is real and it is met with compassion.

The darkness here has a source. It is found in deception. In manipulation. In sin that distorts what is good and presses heavily on those who have already been wounded.

It is not left unanswered. There is a steady truth moving beneath every shadow. Nothing is hidden from Christ. Not what has been done. Not what has been buried. Not what feels impossible to untangle. Not what we repeat to ourselves over and over and over again.

Our Heavenly Father sees clearly. May we always pray for eyes that see as He sees and discern as He discerns. Because when everything feels uncertain, the soul does not need more opinions. It needs God’s absolute, never-changing truth.

God Almighty does not turn away. Where shame presses heavily, grace begins its work. Where guilt settles, forgiveness speaks with authority. Truth stands firm even when it has been hidden or pushed into the shadows.

There are moments when forgiveness feels out of reach. The cost feels too high. The wounds feel too deep. The story allows that even more weight to remain … and then gently brings it before Christ.

Jesus holds those who choose Him securely in His powerful and loving hands even when everything feels uncertain. That is where something begins to shift. Not suddenly. Not all at once. But the transformation begins.

The shadows do not vanish in an instant. The wounds remain part of the story. Yet light presses forward with quiet strength. Truth steadies what has been shaken. Grace reaches into places that have long been closed.

Something the darkness nearly destroyed begins to live again as the light of Jesus shines through and gently restores.

This story settles in the heart and gently reaches with lasting impact. The writing is careful and intentional. Each layer is handled with sensitivity and purpose. The realities of mental and emotional suffering are approached with compassion and respect.

Sung in the Shadows carries truth that does not bend.

Grace does not remain distant. It enters the darkest places and does its work there.

And what remains is this:
The darkness does not win.
Truth stands.
Christ sees.
And Jesus holds, with both tenderness and authority, what the world tried to break.

I received a copy of this book from the author, publisher, and NetGalley. I am not required to write a positive review in any way or for any reason. My honest and unbiased opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on the writing style, the pacing, and the story’s content, ensuring transparency and reliability.

[Kristi W - Book Love By Kristi · Rating 5 out of 5]

“I can’t live my entire life in this forced silence. Marriage is forever, and I don’t want to be in a prison of hiding who I am, who I love, and what I love.” “Is that what you think? That I’m forcing you into a prison?” “No, but if you keep a songbird hidden in a covered cage forever, eventually their music dies . . . and so do they.”

This amazing forbidden love story has a strong faith theme (but it’s not preach-y), danger, suspense, friendship, and romance. The author gently and respectfully deals with mental illnesses and asylum residents. There is darkness but it is driven away by hope and faith!

Nora is brave, devoted, and scared. I loved that Nora was willing to do just about anything to help her Mum. Nora’s love of music was amazing and the connection she was able to have with her Mum and Ezekiel because of that love, fantastic. Her struggles were heartbreaking at times but I LOVED that she leaned into her faith (Thank you, Ezekiel!). I loved her bravery and her ability to keep her head in dangerous and difficult situations was amazing. Oh, do I love the “Guardians”! What a wonderful group of ladies that care for, protect, and truly support one another. Ezekiel is protective, kind, and talented. I loved his gentleness and support of Nora. His patience with her, his determination to win her heart, and his complete acceptance of her were beautiful! I loved his protectiveness of Nora even when he didn’t know the truth or even what the danger was. Their connection through music was fantastic and led to some amazing conversations and swoony moments. I loved his devotion to his Ma. I loved his faith and how he encouraged both his Ma and Nora in their faith. Ezekiel and Nora face many trials and dangers but come through them stronger together. Their devotion to each other and God is such a bright part of their story.

A few more quotes:
“Are you still attempting to charm me?” “No. You told me to discard the tactic, even if I did mean every compliment.”

“Mum always said music is the soul’s heartbeat.”

“I’m so glad you’re home.” “Home. I like the sound of that. It’s cozy here, and with all those instruments, I’m sure there is plenty of music.” “Why do I get the feeling you just want me for my music?” She playfully elbowed him. “You’re more than music to me, although it doesn’t hurt that you can sing and play.

Notes: This is book 2 in the series. It can be read as a standalone, the characters of book 1 have multiple appearances and there are a few small spoilers. Also, a secondary character has attempted suicide and has suicidal thoughts.

This ARC was provided by the author and publisher @kregelbooks via NetGalley. I was not required to give a positive review, rating and opinions are my own.

[Melissa’s Bookshelf · Rating 5 out of 5]

Wow! Crystal Caudill knocks it out of the park with Sung in the Shadows. Full of danger, heartfelt romance, conniving villains, & faith, this story grabbed hold & didn’t let go. My heart went out to Nora, who still carries the scars & anxiety from her harrowing past, & to her mother, whose understandable paranoia landed her in an asylum. I adored Ezekiel, the protective hero who falls hard & fast for Nora & is determined to win her heart. His own mother resides in the same asylum after struggling with depression & suicide attempts. It’s a fast-paced story of revenge, suspense, irresistible romance, & finding peace amid unfathomable circumstances.

Once music filled their home, but now Nora Davis must stifle her talents & live under a cloud of secrets. Kidnapped as a child by ruthless thieves seeking revenge on her opera diva mother, who turned them in to Scotland Yard before fleeing to America, Nora was forced to change her name & start over. Her mother claims three identities, but is she telling the truth? When the man who kidnapped her years ago suddenly appears, Nora fears she may be suffering the same delusions as her mother. Her only bright spots are Ezekiel whose musical talents & opera connections make a relationship with him forbidden, & his mischievous cat, Tristan. Determined to uncover the truth, Nora soon finds her life in danger as the past resurfaces.

I loved this story! The author portrays mental illness & the horrors of asylum life with both accuracy & compassion, & I was struck by the barbaric treatments once used to “cure” patients. The he-falls-first romance between Nora & Ezekiel sparkles with chemistry, playful banter, & a shared love of music. I especially loved Ezekiel’s protectiveness, strong faith, & the gentle care he shows his mother. Nora is brave, resilient, & determined even in the face of terror, gaslighting, & danger. I also enjoyed “the Guardians” sisterhood who watch out for one another.

The suspense is off the charts. The spooky, gothic asylum setting & the villains’ attempts to gaslight Nora create nonstop tension. I loved unraveling the mystery of Constanza’s past, while Tristan the cat nearly stole the show. The deep hope & faith woven through difficult trials added a beautiful layer, & I loved how opera & music were interwoven throughout the story.

Highly recommend! Though this is part of a series, it’s easily read as a standalone, & now I can’t wait to read more. I received an advanced copy from the publisher with no expectation of a positive review. All opinions are completely my own & provided voluntarily.

[Alyssa Amey Madjeski · Rating 5 out of 5]

"We have God's spirit of power, love, and a sound mind.
There is no room for fear. We’ll get through this together."

How to write a review that does this story justice? Sung in the Shadows takes such a good look at trusting God with our fears, our mental health, and our future. Nora and Ezekiel face a lot of hard things in this book. But it's a beautiful reminder that God's got this when we don't.

I absolutely loved Ezekiel. I love how he pursued Nora but also gave her space. I love how he supported her when she feels like she’s falling apart. I love how he stands up for her. I loved how he turned to God when he couldn’t do those things for her directly.

Nora wouldn’t say she’s strong. But she is. She’s resilient. Childhood trauma, enduring a loving but sometimes irrational father, trying to love and support her mother. Learning to defend herself. Building friendships and learning when to stand up for herself. All the while terrified of what lurks in the shadows- real or imagined.

I loved Ezekiel and Nora’s relationship- how it developed and how they learned to share each other’s burdens and joys and sorrows. It was so sweet. I loved being reunited with the other Guardians. Fewer crazy antics this time, but I guess that comes from one of them being engaged to a detective, haha! I just love Caudill’s blend of history, suspense, romance, and even humor. All my favorite things.

The historical look at Longview Asylum broke my heart. That’s one thing that our modern world has gotten right, because loving care and support for mental illness- real or perceived- was practically non-existent in the 1800s. Even good doctors had no real ideas for treatments. Caudill does such a good job bringing the experience to life- heartbreaking, frustrating, upsetting, with traces of hope.

I do recommend reading Written in Secret first, but you don’t have to in order to still fully enjoy this story. I had to remind myself Counterfeit Love (Theresa’s story) takes place after this series is done, as I read that one in between Written in Secret and Sung in the Shadows. Flossie’s book is next!

I received a complementary copy of this book from Kregel Publishing. I was not asked to leave a positive review. My opinions are my own.

[Erin Laramore · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was an excellent historical romance! Though it is book 2 in the Art of Love and Danger series, the story itself could stand on its own. But I would recommend reading in order as there are some potential spoilers in this book of the first book. But I believe they could be enjoyed out of order still. This series focuses on "The Guardians", a group of 4 friends who look out for each other and others in need of defending. This book focused on Nora, whose mysterious past comes to light in the beginning chapters of the book. When we meet up with the family 12 years later, the events of the past have caused Nora's mother to be paranoid to the point of finding herself in an asylum. It is on a regular Tuesday visit that Nora finally gets a formal introduction to Ezekiel Beaumont, the handsome gentleman who has been visiting his own mother at the same time. I enjoyed their meet-cute, including a finicky feline (Tristan was for sure the star of this story!), as well as the circumstances that continued to push them together.

This story had a solid suspense thread, a "fun" romance with some witty banter and opposites attract, and a grace-filled focus on mental health concerns. With a setting of an asylum, a mental health focus could go different ways, but the author addressed the struggles of Nora, Ezekiel and their respective mothers with grace. I also enjoyed the musical focus and the faith thread that included scriptures that encouraged the characters in their difficult days. I enjoyed a behind-the-scenes look at the opera and how it was managed in the 19th century, as well as the growth and development of the characters. I enjoyed the themes of loyalty and sharing one another's burdens and turning to Christ for light in the darkest hours. This was a thoroughly enjoyable read and one I can easily recommend to fans of historical romantic suspense (and any of those elements separately), readers who struggle with mental health or readers who love someone who does. Special thanks to the author and publisher for an advance e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to provide a review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.

[Jenny x Carolena · Rating 5 out of 5]

Sung in the Shadows by Crystal Caudill pulled me in fast with an opening that’s genuinely unsettling, then kept tightening the tension as the story jumps ahead into the fallout years later. Set in the late 1800s, it follows Eleonora (Nora), who’s spent most of her life under a cloud of secrecy and assumed identities. And honestly, her frustration makes total sense. She’s tired of being careful, tired of being scared, and tired of living like danger is still right outside the door. Enter Ezekiel Beaumont, an opera house employee with a weary heart and a lot on his shoulders, especially with his mother living at the same asylum as Nora’s. He’s sly in a quietly funny way, unexpectedly warm, and the kind of person who keeps showing up when Nora would rather stay guarded. Intrigued by her from the start, he’s persistent without being overbearing, and he’s determined to understand the woman behind the walls she’s built.

As the story goes on, the danger doesn’t show up in obvious ways, it creeps. It manipulates. It makes Nora question herself, which is a special kind of terrifying with her mother’s situation hanging over everything. By the time I hit the final stretch, I was fully locked in. The ending plays out like a movie in your head, and I had to force myself to slow down because I didn’t want to miss a beat.

By the time I finished, my biggest takeaway was this: even when things get ugly and unfair, the book keeps pointing back to hope and faith as something steady when everything else is shaky. It’s intense, emotional, and hard to put down.

TRIGGER WARNING: This book does highlight the treatment of mental illness in that era and how absolutely heartbreaking it is. The asylum scenes are bleak in a way that never feels like background scenery. They show how easily someone could be labeled, controlled, and dismissed, and how “treatment” could turn into punishment the moment a person didn’t fit the rules. Watching characters be analyzed, doubted, and handled like problems instead of people was infuriating. The fear of being seen as “unstable,” the power imbalance, and the cruel consequences for stepping out of line create this constant helplessness that’s hard to shake. This isn’t just a story about avoiding bad people. It’s about surviving systems that can crush you when you’re already vulnerable.

QUOTES:

Guilt was an apparition that endlessly haunted one with the clinking chains of shame, fear, disgust, and isolation.

I don't understand you. You don't flirt with my friends, but you insist upon doing so with me. You are obviously of a more gregarious nature than myself and must find me boring, yet you choose to single me out. Is it because you see my disinterest as a challenge to conquer? Or are you not quite right in the head?

We can do everything right and it still not be enough. Only God is enough, even though sometimes it doesn't feel like He is. I don't understand why He is allowing this. It feels wrong and unjust. I'm angry with Him, and I'm scared of what the future holds. I don't want this burden He's given us, but I know it's not our fault. I know it's not our job to save them.

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

[Winnie · Rating 5 out of 5]

“Hiding your pain and thoughts doesn’t make you a stronger person. It makes life lonelier to walk through.”

Sung in the Shadows by talented author Crystal Caudill is a heart-tugging story filled with engaging main characters, despicable villains, and an assortment of other people ranging from cruel to kind and everywhere in between. Also included is Tristan, a demon of a cat with an attitude. The plot of the tale is very creative and attention-grabbing, and it kept me turning the pages.

Nora was the victim of a kidnapping as a child, and her parents changed their names and hid their identities to try to keep themselves safe from the villains. Nora’s mother is a renowned singer, Constanza Brisbane, and her paranoia has caused her to be confined to the Longview Asylum. As Nora visits her mother there, she meets Ezekiel Beaumont whose mother also resides at asylum. He works at an opera house, which is a forbidden place for Nora, so she intends to avoid him. I loved Ezekiel’s compassionate and caring personality, and his persistence in trying to help Nora.

“Maybe Jesus has paired us under the same yoke so we can share each other’s burdens as He guides us through this mess of life.”

As past collides with the present and Nora’s family is once again in danger, the intrigue, mystery, and intensity ramp up. The author does a wonderful job of interjecting some humor and lighter moments into the rather gritty and heart-wrenching subject matter. Themes of family, faith, and hope among the darkness give an inspirational tone to the story. The author handled the subject of mental illness realistically and compassionately.

This book is part of Caudill’s Art of Love and Danger series but can be read as a stand-alone book. I enjoyed seeing Nora’s friends, The Guardians, show up in this book and be a support for her.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy from Kregel Publications. All opinions are my own.

[Emily · Rating 4 out of 5]

Sung in the Shadows is book two in the Art of Love and Danger series, though it can be read as a standalone without feeling like you missed something. Crystal Caudill has done a remarkable job creating a historical story with mystery, suspense, and even some humor sprinkled in. This was quite the page turner.

Nora’s mom is a former opera singer who now resides in an asylum. She was put there after Nora was kidnapped as a child, and now seems to have worried herself into such a panic that she has anxiety over the whereabouts of Nora. Though they are over a decade removed from the incident, the kidnappers were former acquaintances, and they seem to be out for payback.  Though nothing has happened until now.

Ezekiel’s mom suffers from ‘melancholy’ (depression) and resides at the Asylum with Nora’s mom. When Ezekiel is visiting his mom, he overhears Nora and her mom singing. And that is when he must know more about Nora.  When Nora shows up with her friends at the Opera house, he shows her around. Little does Nora and Ezekiel know, this one misstep has set off a powder keg of events. Nora and Ezekiel grow closer and begin spending more time together, and things begin to unravel. Nora feels like maybe she is starting to lose her mind, like her mother.  

With faith elements throughout the story, Crystal Caudill has written a beautiful story.  


Quote that made me laugh:
“Surely Father hadn’t brought home another suitor after their discussion yesterday, especially one so….fowl-ish. The narrow-faced man had a beak nose, an abnormally large Adam’s apple, and legs impossibly scrawny compared to the wide girth they carried. Hopefully, the man wasn’t a hunter, because if he wore the wrong clothes, Thanksgiving would be a very dangerous season for him indeed.”   

*I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, which I received from the author. A positive review was not required. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.

[Megan · Rating 5 out of 5]

Since the first book in this series, I have really enjoyed the characters and the world the author created for them. Getting to revisit the Guardians was so fun, I really love this group of women and the hijinks they often get into, as well as how they so wonderfully support and help one another. The romance between Ezekiel and Nora was top notch. And I really loved Tristan the cat as well. He added some much needed levity to the story.
This story was a difficult one to read at times. Not because of any fault of the author, but due to the subject matter of mental health. Reading how people in asylums were treated at the time in history, the things they had to endure to be "healed" was truly heart wrenching to read at times. The author did a phenomenal job in handling the subject matter with grace and compassion. I think everyone can relate to something in this book as we all struggle with one thing or another at times in our lives.
The message of hope woven throughout the story, how God never leaves or forsakes us, was such a wonderful counter-measure to the difficulties Nora's mother faces in the asylum. I think this is a message we all need, but especially those that fight the dragons of anxiety and depression. There is always hope to be had, and the world needs your unique self in it.
Getting a peak into the Opera world was really fun as well. I could just imagine the fabulous operas mentioned in this story. So much so, it almost makes me want to go see an opera for myself.
If you're looking for a romance with true depth, one that features characters with real life struggles, you won't go wrong with a Crystal Caudill book. Her stories are immersive, thought-provoking, and destined to make you want to lock out the world until you turn the last page.
*I read an early ARC from the author/publisher. All opinions expressed are entirely my own.

[Valerie T · Rating 5 out of 5]

I hadn’t read a book quite like this before. I thought I had the plot pretty well figured out early on. I was wrong. Slow building tension, a shadowy villain who may or may not be imaginary, and a dark asylum weave together a surprising story of hope and God’s providence against all odds. There is no flippancy or sugar coating in how this book deals with its heavy themes, but neither is there any hesitancy to point to the light of Christ even when - especially when - the pain in this world seems all encompassing.

When I read “Counterfeit Love,” the first book in Crystal Caudill’s “Hidden Hearts of the Gilded Age” series, I remember thinking how well researched it was. “Sung in the Shadows” made me feel the same way. While I have no preexisting passion for late 19th century opera, the author’s descriptions of it helped me feel both at home in the world and curious about its unique setting. The characters fit naturally into this world, and the points of view helped me understand both the physical setting and also aspects of mental health struggles that can easily be forgotten.

I appreciated the humor scattered throughout the story. The clever dialogue (and antics of an unruly cat!) helped keep the book from feeling too heavy. The romance, also, was a sweet blend of playful and serious. The way it unfolded seemed uniquely right for the characters.

The Christian message isn’t an afterthought in this book. It felt honest, and at the same time it felt truly hopeful. Not that everything works out perfectly in this world, but that in Christ, all of the wrongs in the outside world and inside ourselves will be made right in the end.

Something I consider when recommending or reviewing is “Did this book make me think, both while I was reading it and once I finished it?” The answer in this case - as with all of Crystal Caudill’s books - is yes.

[Lisa · Rating 5 out of 5]

Nora Davis and her family are forced into hiding after she escapes a harrowing kidnapping and threat of harm to her mother, a famous opera star. Nora’s mother finds herself in Longview Asylum due to her paranoia and erratic behavior after the event. Nora never gives up hope that her mother will one day be released and visits her weekly. Ezekiel Beaumont also sees his mother at Longview who is suffering from extreme melancholia. My heart went out to both Nora and Ezekiel as they must witness the sad conditions of the patients and the living quarters of their mothers.

While the aspect of the asylum is sad, there is also hope as Nora’s mother realizes that she is not the same woman she once was and there is forgiveness and redemption. I loved the faith that is shown throughout the story and the hope that God can forgive and help you to overcome fear.

I love the stedfast character of Ezekiel. He never gives up on his mother, and he believes in Nora when others don’t. Filled with vile villains, danger, and suspense, readers will enjoy this rich historical novel.

While this is the second book in the Art of Love and Danger, it can certainly be read as a standalone. I love the women who comprise of the members of the Guardians, and I can’t wait to read the next book!

I received a copy of this book from Kregel and NetGalley with no obligation to write a positive review.

[Lakeisha Heeringa · Rating 5 out of 5]

As a young child, Eleanora was kidnapped from an opera house while her mother, the famous Constanza Brisbane, sang on stage. Despite her miraculous escape, the traumatic event has haunted her and her parents ever since. Now an adult, Eleanora lives under an assumed name and is forbidden to have anything to do with music. Her mother has succumbed to the mental strain and now lives in an insane asylum. But are Constanza’s fears about the kidnapper’s return just the hallucinations of a crazed woman? Or is Eleanora still very much in danger?

Pros: This was a great story! Plenty of tragic backstory to keep me intrigued, lots of music (my favorite) and enough ratcheting tension to turn this historical romance into a psychological thriller. But as much as I loved the mystery, the sweet romance, and the doses of witty banter, I also really appreciated the compassionate yet unflinching Biblical approach to mental health. It takes courage to write about hard subjects and I hope this book is part of a greater trend among Christian authors to shine the light of Christ onto weighty issues like this one.

Cons: A few anachronistic words and phrases, but I’m a nerd about that kind of stuff.

The Bottom Line: Gaslight, but with elements of The Phantom of the Opera, make this Christian Historical Romance novel a slow-build psychological thriller!

I received an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.

[Katie · Rating 5 out of 5]

Trigger warning for suicide attempt
"We can do everything right and it still not be enough. Only God is enough, even though sometimes it doesn't feel like He is."
From the open stage of the opera theaters to the hidden cells of the asylum, this is a story that kept me guessing. Nora and Ezekiel are wonderful multi-dimensional characters with a supporting cast that is very well thought out, in a setting that is unique while still very believable. I loved getting a glimpse of opera life during the 19th century, while the scenes in the asylum are absolutely heartbreaking. The gaslighting of a character throughout the book was so well done I thought I was the one losing my mind. Mental illness and suicide was handled in a very realistic, sensitive, and Biblical way. The inclusion of scripture was also appreciated and necessary to a story like this. It is made clear that God alone can calm our fears and renew our minds.
Although this is the second installment in this series, Sung in the Shadows can stand alone. I did not read the first one, and the only thing that confused me was the continual references to the Guardians, but a search of the author’s website provided all the background information I needed.
Fans of Christian historical fiction, the Guilded age/Victorian era, and romance mixed with mystery and deep spiritual truths will enjoy this book. This was my first Crystal Caudill novel, and she is now on my must-read list.
*I received a complimentary copy of this e-book from the author through NetGalley. I am not required to leave a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

[Jorie · Rating 4 out of 5]

Phew. This was quite the ride! I have never read this author before and goodness, she is talented!

There’s danger, darkness, intrigue, suspense, kidnapping, an asylum, and yet SO much hope & light through the Gospel of Christ.

This book kept me hooked from start to finish and that ending 🥹. There is the absolute sweetest, swoon-worthy, (very clean/kisses only) romance in this as well. Oh my word it’s so sweet. 🥹

This does delve into 19th century asylums and the “treatments” that were given ~ it is handled in a sensitive way but if you are sensitive to topics pertaining to mental health/suicide then just know that that is featured. Again, it is handled very sensitively and through out it all the Hope & Light of the Gospel is present in such beautiful ways. I really appreciated how such a hard topic was handled!

If you like historical fiction that has mystery, intrigue & suspense, as well as the clear Gospel message, then this would be right up your alley!

Thank you so much to Kregel Books & NetGalley for the advance copy. All opinions are my own and have not been influenced in any way.

*This is Book 2 in a series, and I would suggest reading Book 1 first. I haven’t read 1 and this 2nd book does have spoilers in it from the first.* (I plan to check out book 1 at some point because I want to know the backstory to the secondary characters!)

[Angela · Rating 5 out of 5]

Crystal Caudill is a newer author to me. I recently met her at an author event and an opportunity came up to be on the launch team for this book and I applied and was accepted. I received the ebook form of this book from NetGalley for an honest review.

Nora is a fiery redhead who keeps herself guarded for what happened to her as a child. Her mom used to be an opera singer, and while singing at a performance Nora was kidnapped. To keep the family safe Nora's dad moved the family and they took on a new identity. Nora's mom has been placed in an asylum and while visiting her mom Nora meets Ezekiel. Ezekiel's mom is also a patient at the asylum and the two bond over this similar situation. Nora is not used to Ezekiel's bold flirting, but as the two start to lean on each other for support a deep friendship starts to grow.

But the past is now starting to catch up with Nora and her family and Nora wants to keep her family and Ezekiel safe. Can she trust Ezekiel enough to share her true story and can they rescue her mom from the awful events happening to her mom there?

This book kept my interest. This will not be the only book by Crystal. If you like historical romance and mystery than you will truly enjoy this book.

[Rebecca · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 stars
"Be gentle with her but don't give up. She's a hard one to get to know, but I think it's because she fears being known. She had a harrowing childhood."

Nora Davis had experienced quite a harrowing childhood, to the extent that her parents relocated, changed their names, and kept Nora as far away from the music performance world as possible. In some ways they were successful, with her mother tucked away in an asylum and her father working as an accountant, they never imagined that a besotted man would unknowingly turn the clock back towards danger.

Visiting his mother once a week at Longview Asylum, stage manager Ezekiel Beaumont had the unique pleasure of listening to Nora Davis sing under her mother's careful tutelage. When he was finally able to gain her attention (albeit with the help of a maniacal cat!) she expressed no interest in friendly conversation, much less his flirtatious antics. To his credit, Ezekiel could demonstrate unadulterated persistence and quickly realized that the lovely young woman carried the sort of heavy burdens that she was never meant to bear.

This story wields a worthy sword; cutting through pleasantries with deft precision, exposing raw wounds and deep fears, maneuvering steadily through the darkness of hopelessness and into the brilliant arena of truth. Nora and Ezekiel painstakingly learn how to transfer their burdens to the only One who promises rest for their souls, but in the interim . . . . . there is an amazing story to be told!

[Jo|Ruth Reads · Rating 5 out of 5]

This story pulled me in right away and I had to see how it would end.

Nora is living a life that's not her own. Growing up her family lived for the performance world. But when their lives are threatened they are left hiding who they are to save their lives. When Nora meets Ezekiel, a man who shares her love of opera, she begins to wonder if she could ever return to the world she once loved.

Ezekiel is drawn to Nora right away, but he knows she is hiding something. As their feelings begin to grow, a threat from Nora’s past reappears. Leading Ezekial to quickly realize that if they want any future together, he has to find out who is after her and what she's been hiding!

I enjoyed the way Nora and Ezekiel interact and how their relationship grows over time.The banter was super entertaining and I loved the strong thread of faith throughout. The mystery and suspense kept me turning the pages, and the romance kept me invested and rooting for these two!

I gave this 4.5 stars rounded up to 5.

I received a complimentary copy. This review is my honest opinion.

TW:abuse in a mental institution, attempted suicide, kidnapping, mental health struggles, attempted murder.

[Julie · Rating 4 out of 5]

The premise of this story drew me right in!! When Nora was a child, she was kidnapped while her famous opera singer mother, Constanza Brisbane, was on stage. Nora narrowly escapes her captors, but the family decides to go into hiding & mysteriously drop out of the spotlight in order to keep their daughter safe. However the weight of Constanza’s past haunts her & the belief that those who seek to harm her family are still plotting their revenge becomes too heavy to bear & severe paranoia grips her … resulting in a committal to Longview Asylum.

Nora visits her mother at Longview weekly for singing lessons & there enters Ezekiel … the son of another patient of the asylum. As threats & dangers draw close, so do Ezekiel & Nora … and armed with love & their faith, they will face what lurks in the shadows together.

I absolutely love books set in this time era … the late-ish 1800’s is so fascinating to me!! The dark drama of the opera scene, the horrifying treatment of mental health & the backdrop of Cincinnati during the Gilded Age create the perfect atmosphere for this eerie mystery. The characters are on point & played well, the banter is charming & witty, the romance is sweet, the mystery is suspenseful, the villains are perfectly villain-y & the subject matter of mental health is handled respectfully through the lens of faith. This is just one of those stories that you want to sit with long after turning that last page & bask in its light-filled message of hope, redemption, forgiveness & love!

Thank you to Kregel Publications for the arc!

[Betti · Rating 5 out of 5]

NYC Opera House, March 1869. Eleonora Brisbane, 11, is waiting for her mother, famous opera singer Constanta Brisbane to be finished with her performance, when out of nowhere she is kidnapped by a couple from her mother’s past. Equally suddenly, she, and her parents have left everything behind.

The invisible and lonely burden of loving someone who suffered any mental illness. Mum, with no music left in her life, becomes a shell of herself, and finds herself in the Longview Insane Asylum - a horrid place where no one believes her. For Nora, the weight of her mother’s situation becomes an almost impossible burden to bear. Will she finally believe that God has not given her the spirit of fear, but rather of power, love and a sound mind?

An early copy of The Art of Love & Danger Book Two was received through Kregel Publications and NetGalley. These impressions are my own and were in no way solicited.