What do you think?
Rate this book
And Then He Pressed Play: Track One
Sixteen-year-old A.J. Walker is openly gay, painfully Canadian, and very much out of his depth. He’s wanted to do his school’s exchange program for years, but now that he’s landed at an all-boys school in Glenbridge Ireland, he’s starting to question his decisions. Armed with nothing more than his trusty Discman and an accent that makes him stand out, A.J. has one get through the Irish school year.
Born and raised in Glenbridge, Bren O’Shea has never known how to sit still or keep quiet. He’s also never known a day without laughter. Even when things get bad, Bren always knows how to get a smile out of someone, whether they asked him or not. His mam always says he needs to think before he acts, but as long as his heart’s in the right place, what’s the harm in a bit of impulse?
Glenbridge is the sort of town where everyone knows everyone—and unfortunately for A.J. once someone thinks they know you, it’s hard to change their mind.
After a rocky start that ends in disaster, Bren and A.J. need to decide if it’s worth reaching out to someone who’s so different from you—especially when one of you has to leave in June.
Born and raised in Glenbridge, Bren O’Shea has never known how to sit still or keep quiet. He’s also never known a day without laughter. Even when things get bad, Bren always knows how to get a smile out of someone, whether they asked him or not. His mam always says he needs to think before he acts, but as long as his heart’s in the right place, what’s the harm in a bit of impulse?
Glenbridge is the sort of town where everyone knows everyone—and unfortunately for A.J. once someone thinks they know you, it’s hard to change their mind.
After a rocky start that ends in disaster, Bren and A.J. need to decide if it’s worth reaching out to someone who’s so different from you—especially when one of you has to leave in June.
339 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 23, 2026
20 people are currently reading
204 people want to read
About the author
Robert J. Halliwell
2 books16 followersJust a gay indie author trying to tell stories that make readers feel things.
Currently working on "And Then He Pressed Play: Track Two"
Currently working on "And Then He Pressed Play: Track Two"
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews
February 7, 2026
4.5 ⭐️New to me author, 2nd book, YA - I had super low expectations but damn this FAR SURPASSED THEM! I loved it! Never have I ever read a more authentic feeling YA. Their relationship progresses so organically and doesn’t feel superficial at all. I’m impressed how much these guys act like actual teenagers but without it being cringey. I loved Bren’s mam and all the friends. The storyline is not all roses (TW homophobia) but their understated braveness melted my cynical heart.
16yr old Canadian, A.J spends a year on student exchange in Ireland trying to overcome his awkwardness and fit in, meeting Bren who is pasty, ginger and loud. I was as enamoured by the Irish accents as he was, not sure why I find “feckin, so” as appealing as I do, but it really does things for me.
This is not at all spicy but what they have is really genuine and innocent, feels authentic for their age and not like some creepy teen fetish. I never, at any point, wished that it had more explicit sex scenes.
Who needs sex scenes when you have these charmers?
“Still feel like I should make it up to you...Wanna see me arse again?”
The ending was very fitting for a teen romance. It’s not realistic for these guys to be getting married or have a solid HEA but of course, I need more!! Is there going to be more in this world?? I want it!
The plot resolution felt realistic, as much as in a perfect world I would hope for something different. Justice is served in its own way, via the community, which would hopefully make enough of an impact for change.
❤️ ”He’s my lad.” ❤️
Thankyou to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC and to Anita for BR this with me.
16yr old Canadian, A.J spends a year on student exchange in Ireland trying to overcome his awkwardness and fit in, meeting Bren who is pasty, ginger and loud. I was as enamoured by the Irish accents as he was, not sure why I find “feckin, so” as appealing as I do, but it really does things for me.
This is not at all spicy but what they have is really genuine and innocent, feels authentic for their age and not like some creepy teen fetish. I never, at any point, wished that it had more explicit sex scenes.
Who needs sex scenes when you have these charmers?
“Still feel like I should make it up to you...Wanna see me arse again?”
The ending was very fitting for a teen romance. It’s not realistic for these guys to be getting married or have a solid HEA but of course, I need more!! Is there going to be more in this world?? I want it!
The plot resolution felt realistic, as much as in a perfect world I would hope for something different. Justice is served in its own way, via the community, which would hopefully make enough of an impact for change.
❤️ ”He’s my lad.” ❤️
Thankyou to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC and to Anita for BR this with me.
February 18, 2026
Thanks to the author for sending me this ARC. And thanks to my dear friend Sarah, who reminded me to read it.
I absolutely loved this book. This is the kind of love teenagers dream of having. It was cute and funny, and it felt realistic in a way books with teens don’t usually get right. The Irish setting felt so atmospheric, and the cultural differences that AJ encounters were super funny. I really liked how we overcame his distrust and, little by little, stopped resisting Bren's friendship advances and eventually incorporated their friend group. Even the Robolad nickname was cute!
"He thought he'd learned everything there was to know about kissing Bren, but now, as warmth spread from both his lips and the talisman balanced in his hand, he realized how foolish that had been. He could kiss this boy for a thousand lifetimes, and there would always be something new to learn."
It has some heavy moments, because homophobia is real, but I do believe the story was brighter than anything, and it ends up on a hopeful note, not a HEA because these boys are 16 and it wouldn't be attainable, but in a very nice HFN, and I want to believe future for more. I would love to know if this will be the first book in a series or if there is a possibility of seeing these characters again in the future.
Just to finish, I’ll say that one of the things I love most about reading is learning new things. After it was mentioned in the book and I found out that hurling is an ancient Irish sport with roots extending over 3,000 years, I just had to go and watch a highlights video on YouTube, and let me just say that was wild, and their shorts are very short!
I absolutely loved this book. This is the kind of love teenagers dream of having. It was cute and funny, and it felt realistic in a way books with teens don’t usually get right. The Irish setting felt so atmospheric, and the cultural differences that AJ encounters were super funny. I really liked how we overcame his distrust and, little by little, stopped resisting Bren's friendship advances and eventually incorporated their friend group. Even the Robolad nickname was cute!
"He thought he'd learned everything there was to know about kissing Bren, but now, as warmth spread from both his lips and the talisman balanced in his hand, he realized how foolish that had been. He could kiss this boy for a thousand lifetimes, and there would always be something new to learn."
It has some heavy moments, because homophobia is real, but I do believe the story was brighter than anything, and it ends up on a hopeful note, not a HEA because these boys are 16 and it wouldn't be attainable, but in a very nice HFN, and I want to believe future for more. I would love to know if this will be the first book in a series or if there is a possibility of seeing these characters again in the future.
Just to finish, I’ll say that one of the things I love most about reading is learning new things. After it was mentioned in the book and I found out that hurling is an ancient Irish sport with roots extending over 3,000 years, I just had to go and watch a highlights video on YouTube, and let me just say that was wild, and their shorts are very short!
February 25, 2026
4.5 ⭐️
And Then He Pressed Play: Track One by Robert J. Halliwell is a YA gay romance set in 2006, Ireland. It follows exchange student A.J. Walker from Canada, who's openly gay, rather quiet and shy, and listens to a lot of music. Irish Bren O'Shea is the exact opossite; he's loud and confident, and not out yet.
I really really enjoyed this book. The relationship development between A.J. and Bren felt very natural and earned. It starts a bit messy and awkward and slowly turns into a cute first love story. The pacing was steady, nothing felt rushed nor too slow.
The 2006 setting worked so well. The Discman. The musicals (A.J. is a Wicked fan!!). But also the darker parts of that time—the internalized homophobia, and therefore the violence. The way being openly gay in a small town could genuinely put you at risk. It didn’t feel exaggerated, but it also didn’t sugarcoat things. There’s queer joy here, yes, but it exists alongside fear and harm. It feel authentic. We're still not at a point where queer people live safely in every country. Homophobia is still a thing, everywhere and always. But still, things looked different only twenty years ago.
I also really appreciated the Irish setting. Glenbridge added more depth to A.J.’s experience as an outsider. I loved the side characters. Not only the friend group, but Bren’s mam especially.
And the ending… I loved that it was a realistic HFN, and still satisfying. Well, they're sixteen. It hurt a little, but in the good way.
Overall, I enjoyed reading this book. First love, self-discovery, lots of pressure. I’m so glad I picked it up.
(Also: It seems like the author is working on a second book (Track Two) about them. I am excited and curious how their story will continue.)
This books comes out on February 23rd, 2026.
Thanks to the author and NetGalley for providing the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
And Then He Pressed Play: Track One by Robert J. Halliwell is a YA gay romance set in 2006, Ireland. It follows exchange student A.J. Walker from Canada, who's openly gay, rather quiet and shy, and listens to a lot of music. Irish Bren O'Shea is the exact opossite; he's loud and confident, and not out yet.
I really really enjoyed this book. The relationship development between A.J. and Bren felt very natural and earned. It starts a bit messy and awkward and slowly turns into a cute first love story. The pacing was steady, nothing felt rushed nor too slow.
The 2006 setting worked so well. The Discman. The musicals (A.J. is a Wicked fan!!). But also the darker parts of that time—the internalized homophobia, and therefore the violence. The way being openly gay in a small town could genuinely put you at risk. It didn’t feel exaggerated, but it also didn’t sugarcoat things. There’s queer joy here, yes, but it exists alongside fear and harm. It feel authentic. We're still not at a point where queer people live safely in every country. Homophobia is still a thing, everywhere and always. But still, things looked different only twenty years ago.
I also really appreciated the Irish setting. Glenbridge added more depth to A.J.’s experience as an outsider. I loved the side characters. Not only the friend group, but Bren’s mam especially.
And the ending… I loved that it was a realistic HFN, and still satisfying. Well, they're sixteen. It hurt a little, but in the good way.
Overall, I enjoyed reading this book. First love, self-discovery, lots of pressure. I’m so glad I picked it up.
(Also: It seems like the author is working on a second book (Track Two) about them. I am excited and curious how their story will continue.)
This books comes out on February 23rd, 2026.
Thanks to the author and NetGalley for providing the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
February 6, 2026
• YA m/m romance • ARC •
This was such a great YA read! I am genuinely surprised by how well the author wrote authentic, non-cringe teenaged characters and a very appropriate teen romance 👏
It’s 2006 Ireland, and 16yo A.J. is on a school exchange from Canada. He is a quiet, awkwardly self-aware, out gay teen, taking part in an exchange experience in another country where he doesn’t know a single soul. A.J. has a lot of classes with a loud and outgoing ginger boy, Bren. Their relationship builds from awkward misunderstandings, to a tentative and then a genuine friendship, and eventually deeper feels are caught. Bren has a really good circle of friends and most accept A.J. in to their fold with no issues. The interactions and the progression of all the relationships were so entertaining to read, if I had the time I could probably have read this in one sitting!
Also, I have to admit that I’m a huge sucker for the Irish brogue on-page, and all the lads, Mams, Das, shites and fecks brought me so much joy! 🤭😅
CW - homophobia and related violence… I suppose though, that it is regrettably realistic for the time in which the story takes place. But is definitely not the focus of the book, and the way in which A.J. was supported was written really well here I thought.
Overall, I loved this. It just warmed my soul. The pacing, the characters, the dialogue, the story… I literally have no complaints and 100% recommend for YA romance fans.
5⭐️ Ty Sarah for suggesting we read this!
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.
This was such a great YA read! I am genuinely surprised by how well the author wrote authentic, non-cringe teenaged characters and a very appropriate teen romance 👏
It’s 2006 Ireland, and 16yo A.J. is on a school exchange from Canada. He is a quiet, awkwardly self-aware, out gay teen, taking part in an exchange experience in another country where he doesn’t know a single soul. A.J. has a lot of classes with a loud and outgoing ginger boy, Bren. Their relationship builds from awkward misunderstandings, to a tentative and then a genuine friendship, and eventually deeper feels are caught. Bren has a really good circle of friends and most accept A.J. in to their fold with no issues. The interactions and the progression of all the relationships were so entertaining to read, if I had the time I could probably have read this in one sitting!
Also, I have to admit that I’m a huge sucker for the Irish brogue on-page, and all the lads, Mams, Das, shites and fecks brought me so much joy! 🤭😅
CW - homophobia and related violence… I suppose though, that it is regrettably realistic for the time in which the story takes place. But is definitely not the focus of the book, and the way in which A.J. was supported was written really well here I thought.
Overall, I loved this. It just warmed my soul. The pacing, the characters, the dialogue, the story… I literally have no complaints and 100% recommend for YA romance fans.
5⭐️ Ty Sarah for suggesting we read this!
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.
February 27, 2026
This book was such a lovely surprise! It made me feel safe while reading it, and that is priceless in the times we’re living in.
It was sweet and funny and gentle, but never stupid or silly. It let the characters be awkward, confused, scared, and kind without turning any of that into a lesson or a bad joke.
A.J. goes to Ireland feeling completely out of place, and Bren comes into his life trying to be nice and accidentally doing everything wrong at first. Watching their friendship grow, slowly and clumsily, because: teenagers, and then turn into something more felt honest and safe. I trusted the story with them, which doesn’t always happen. I love these boys, so much!
There is so much goodness in here but not in a fake way. There are dark moments (homophobia, fear, violence) but they don’t define the story. The book doesn’t deny that the world can be cruel, but it refuses to let cruelty be the loudest voice.
The music, the 2000s vibes, Ireland as the setting. All of it was chef’s kiss.
I think this is a book every teenager, hell, every human, deserves to read. One that fills you up with gooey goodness and courage.
I finished it with a full heart and I can’t wait to see where the story goes from here.
Thank you to NetGalley and Victory Editing for the ARC. I wanted to love this book, and I truly did ♥️
It was sweet and funny and gentle, but never stupid or silly. It let the characters be awkward, confused, scared, and kind without turning any of that into a lesson or a bad joke.
A.J. goes to Ireland feeling completely out of place, and Bren comes into his life trying to be nice and accidentally doing everything wrong at first. Watching their friendship grow, slowly and clumsily, because: teenagers, and then turn into something more felt honest and safe. I trusted the story with them, which doesn’t always happen. I love these boys, so much!
There is so much goodness in here but not in a fake way. There are dark moments (homophobia, fear, violence) but they don’t define the story. The book doesn’t deny that the world can be cruel, but it refuses to let cruelty be the loudest voice.
The music, the 2000s vibes, Ireland as the setting. All of it was chef’s kiss.
I think this is a book every teenager, hell, every human, deserves to read. One that fills you up with gooey goodness and courage.
I finished it with a full heart and I can’t wait to see where the story goes from here.
Thank you to NetGalley and Victory Editing for the ARC. I wanted to love this book, and I truly did ♥️
Review of advance copy received from Author
Review of ARC from the author
The plot follows A.J., an openly gay, sixteen year old, foreign exchange student from Canada who decides to spend a year in Ireland. There, he meets Bren and they become quick friends and then something more.
Trigger warnings: homophobia and mild violence
Overall, I thought it was a super cute book. I couldn't put it down and read it in 2 days! I loved the dynamic between AJ and Bren. Though, I wish the author explored the relationships between AJ and the other characters more (the book was shorter than I expected.) I don't know much about Ireland but I think the author did a good job describing Glenbridge; it was really immersive and atmospheric. I also liked how the author didn't sugar coat the blatant homophobia AJ faced which was unfortunately very common in the early 2000s. It's an important theme to explore.
Now, one thing I didn't like was how, sometimes, there was a lack of flow between some scenes and chapters. It felt a bit jarring and I think the book could've benefited for a larger page count to really flesh out some scenes and explore themes with more depth.
Lastly, I wouldn't consider it a full happily ever after (though AJ and Bren are still together when AJ goes back to Canada) but more of a hopeful ending. I hope there's a sequel where Bren ends up spending a year of university (?) in Canada or maybe even a summer!
(I'll definitely buy a physical copy when the book comes out!!)
The plot follows A.J., an openly gay, sixteen year old, foreign exchange student from Canada who decides to spend a year in Ireland. There, he meets Bren and they become quick friends and then something more.
Trigger warnings: homophobia and mild violence
Overall, I thought it was a super cute book. I couldn't put it down and read it in 2 days! I loved the dynamic between AJ and Bren. Though, I wish the author explored the relationships between AJ and the other characters more (the book was shorter than I expected.) I don't know much about Ireland but I think the author did a good job describing Glenbridge; it was really immersive and atmospheric. I also liked how the author didn't sugar coat the blatant homophobia AJ faced which was unfortunately very common in the early 2000s. It's an important theme to explore.
Now, one thing I didn't like was how, sometimes, there was a lack of flow between some scenes and chapters. It felt a bit jarring and I think the book could've benefited for a larger page count to really flesh out some scenes and explore themes with more depth.
Lastly, I wouldn't consider it a full happily ever after (though AJ and Bren are still together when AJ goes back to Canada) but more of a hopeful ending. I hope there's a sequel where Bren ends up spending a year of university (?) in Canada or maybe even a summer!
(I'll definitely buy a physical copy when the book comes out!!)
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Wholeheartedly, this was such a good book.
Within the first few chapters,
I immediately appreciated the self-confidence that A.J. possessed already, being sure of his sexuality and not willing to lie nor compromise himself to "fit in". Bren's energy was infectious and I loved reading through his character development, allowing himself to be emotional and affectionate.
I found myself becoming fond of all the characters in this novel. I especially like how the women in Bren and A.J.'s lives were written. It is no mystery that Bren's unwavering strength and kindness was passed down from his mother.
I like that Orlaith and Aoife did not share the same cruelty as Cian and his lackeys. Niamh is a good woman, and it made me happy that she spoke with Aoife out of concern, helping to push her away from Cian.
Rory's genuine connection with A.J. through reading and music was really sweet. Brick's well-intentioned brashness and Mickie's change of heart (realizing his friend's happiness was more important than taught bigotry) made great additions to their cast of friends.
I also wanted to mention that the pacing of this novel was very good! I never felt like something dragged on for too long, or wrapped up too soon. The events following A.J.'s assault made sense, and Bren helping him through a panic attack upon returning to school (and seeing Cian) was a true testament of his patience and love.
A.J. using music as a coping mechanism throughout the whole novel felt like a realistic portrayal of an
anxious, gay, neurodivergent teenager trying to find himself in a foreign country.
This was an awesome first ARC for me! I loved all of the Canadian references (Nanaimo bars for the win!).
Within the first few chapters,
I immediately appreciated the self-confidence that A.J. possessed already, being sure of his sexuality and not willing to lie nor compromise himself to "fit in". Bren's energy was infectious and I loved reading through his character development, allowing himself to be emotional and affectionate.
I found myself becoming fond of all the characters in this novel. I especially like how the women in Bren and A.J.'s lives were written. It is no mystery that Bren's unwavering strength and kindness was passed down from his mother.
I like that Orlaith and Aoife did not share the same cruelty as Cian and his lackeys. Niamh is a good woman, and it made me happy that she spoke with Aoife out of concern, helping to push her away from Cian.
Rory's genuine connection with A.J. through reading and music was really sweet. Brick's well-intentioned brashness and Mickie's change of heart (realizing his friend's happiness was more important than taught bigotry) made great additions to their cast of friends.
I also wanted to mention that the pacing of this novel was very good! I never felt like something dragged on for too long, or wrapped up too soon. The events following A.J.'s assault made sense, and Bren helping him through a panic attack upon returning to school (and seeing Cian) was a true testament of his patience and love.
A.J. using music as a coping mechanism throughout the whole novel felt like a realistic portrayal of an
anxious, gay, neurodivergent teenager trying to find himself in a foreign country.
This was an awesome first ARC for me! I loved all of the Canadian references (Nanaimo bars for the win!).
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 10, 2026
I received this book as an ARC in return for a review, so here goes nothing!
This was a cute, cozy, quick read. The characters felt very realistic and accurate for teens of that era (loved the instant message conversations on the family desktop!) My only complaint is that I wish we got to spend a bit more nice, easy time with AJ and Bren to combat the difficulties they faced. But overall I loved getting to experience their relationship develop, it was so genuine and sweet.
“He’s my lad” 🥺❤️
This was a cute, cozy, quick read. The characters felt very realistic and accurate for teens of that era (loved the instant message conversations on the family desktop!) My only complaint is that I wish we got to spend a bit more nice, easy time with AJ and Bren to combat the difficulties they faced. But overall I loved getting to experience their relationship develop, it was so genuine and sweet.
“He’s my lad” 🥺❤️
February 27, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley for giving me a digital ARC of this book to read!
3.5 stars. I started this book knowing next to nothing, so it was really fun to follow Canadian exchange student A.J. go to Ireland for the school year and go back home with a found family and a boyfriend!
I liked how the author handled bringing up new words that A.J. and the reader might not know, it was effortless and didn't take us out of the scene to be a dramatic teaching moment. Also, most of the time, you could used good ol' context clues to figure it out. I also really liked the friend group, and how A.J. connected to them each in a unique way. It really gives our main character some multidimensionality. I also really liked that although the proper authorities gave no consequences to Cian and his little group, the town got together to do alienate them after being bigots.
The biggest thing that threw me off was the writing at times? There was an over explanation of actions that I'm not really a fan of, and it could have been left up to the reader to interpret what those actions meant. It just makes for a more fulfilling reading experience when the reader can pick up what the writer is subtly putting down!
3.5 stars. I started this book knowing next to nothing, so it was really fun to follow Canadian exchange student A.J. go to Ireland for the school year and go back home with a found family and a boyfriend!
I liked how the author handled bringing up new words that A.J. and the reader might not know, it was effortless and didn't take us out of the scene to be a dramatic teaching moment. Also, most of the time, you could used good ol' context clues to figure it out. I also really liked the friend group, and how A.J. connected to them each in a unique way. It really gives our main character some multidimensionality. I also really liked that although the proper authorities gave no consequences to Cian and his little group, the town got together to do alienate them after being bigots.
The biggest thing that threw me off was the writing at times? There was an over explanation of actions that I'm not really a fan of, and it could have been left up to the reader to interpret what those actions meant. It just makes for a more fulfilling reading experience when the reader can pick up what the writer is subtly putting down!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 14, 2026
Really enjoyed this one. Canadian exchange student A.J. [16, and who just happens to be gay] discovers his own found family in Ireland, in the small town of Glenbridge, with Bren, Rory and a few of their friends. Sadly, the original group was torn down the middle as some of them accepted A.J. for who he was, the others? Not so much ☹️. Although not shown on page, a heads-up that bullying and violence does unfortunately feature in the story.
We can only hope for a well-deserved happy ending in book 2. Loved Bren's mam, and some of the more enlightened adults in the town, set in Ireland in 2006. 4.5 stars rounded up.
We can only hope for a well-deserved happy ending in book 2. Loved Bren's mam, and some of the more enlightened adults in the town, set in Ireland in 2006. 4.5 stars rounded up.
March 11, 2026
My god I LOVED THIS!! I will be back to review!!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
*3.75 rounded up
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me an ARC in exchange for a review.
CW: homophobia, underage drinking, physical assault
The strongest element of And Then He Pressed Play is the characters; right from the beginning, they feel like real people, real teenagers. I could very clearly see Bren and his friends mucking about before school starts, and A.J. lurking in the background, too shy to join in. I loved the platonic relationships depicted with their banter and their moments of seriousness too. I loved the familial relationship between Bren and his mother, how they so evidently love each other. And I, of course, loved the relationship between A.J. and Bren; the awkwardness and misunderstandings, and the build up of friendship to romance. However, for my personal taste, the move from friendship to romance was a bit too quick. I'm a huge sucker for slow burn (the slower the better), and while I understand that this is no way meant to be a 500-page book of yearning, I would've liked to see the characters steep in their feelings a bit more.
On the topic of pacing, and I'm repeating myself, I think it could've been slower generally. Some of my favourite moments within this book are when A.J. has the chance to take a breath to take in the Irish landscape, and this is, in part, due to how wonderfully they are written, but also because the reader can breathe with him too. A.J. is on exchange for a year, though we only really see half of that as weeks, sometimes months, are skipped over. I want to see more of the struggle of living in a new place, in a new country, of missing home. I want to see these new relationships develop (yes, Bren's and A.J.'s, but also A.J.'s and Rory's), and A.J. learning more about Ireland and Irish culture. In short, I want more.
(I'm sorry, but I do have to mention that one of the scenes near the end was a little to corny for me. I love romance as a genre, but that is where I draw the corniness line)
Overall, this is an extremely solid YA novel and I'd be very keen to read more from this author!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me an ARC in exchange for a review.
CW: homophobia, underage drinking, physical assault
The strongest element of And Then He Pressed Play is the characters; right from the beginning, they feel like real people, real teenagers. I could very clearly see Bren and his friends mucking about before school starts, and A.J. lurking in the background, too shy to join in. I loved the platonic relationships depicted with their banter and their moments of seriousness too. I loved the familial relationship between Bren and his mother, how they so evidently love each other. And I, of course, loved the relationship between A.J. and Bren; the awkwardness and misunderstandings, and the build up of friendship to romance. However, for my personal taste, the move from friendship to romance was a bit too quick. I'm a huge sucker for slow burn (the slower the better), and while I understand that this is no way meant to be a 500-page book of yearning, I would've liked to see the characters steep in their feelings a bit more.
On the topic of pacing, and I'm repeating myself, I think it could've been slower generally. Some of my favourite moments within this book are when A.J. has the chance to take a breath to take in the Irish landscape, and this is, in part, due to how wonderfully they are written, but also because the reader can breathe with him too. A.J. is on exchange for a year, though we only really see half of that as weeks, sometimes months, are skipped over. I want to see more of the struggle of living in a new place, in a new country, of missing home. I want to see these new relationships develop (yes, Bren's and A.J.'s, but also A.J.'s and Rory's), and A.J. learning more about Ireland and Irish culture. In short, I want more.
(I'm sorry, but I do have to mention that one of the scenes near the end was a little to corny for me. I love romance as a genre, but that is where I draw the corniness line)
Overall, this is an extremely solid YA novel and I'd be very keen to read more from this author!
February 25, 2026
ARC read (recently completed), thank you to the author
I genuinely enjoyed this book more than I expected, it was incredibly cute and fluffy. It had little pieces of Saskatchewan and Moose Jaw that I really appreciated (eg bunnyhug and Moose Jaw's crescent park). It's nice to see Saskatchewan featured (even if it's a small reference) in queer literature, and makes the story feel more local and closer to home. I am looking forward to Robert's future works.
I genuinely enjoyed this book more than I expected, it was incredibly cute and fluffy. It had little pieces of Saskatchewan and Moose Jaw that I really appreciated (eg bunnyhug and Moose Jaw's crescent park). It's nice to see Saskatchewan featured (even if it's a small reference) in queer literature, and makes the story feel more local and closer to home. I am looking forward to Robert's future works.
March 1, 2026
thank you to the author for the ARC!
queer YA romances with cute covers can be very hit or miss, but i'm happy to report this was a hit 🙂↕️ i truly became so fond of AJ and Bren, and loved seeing their relationship develop over the course of the story. adored all of the niche cultural references, and all of the characters' little quirks. also really appreciated the emphasis on emotional closeness/connection here over gratuitous spice!
my teensy tiny little qualms were 1) i wish there was a liiiittle bit more of a slow burn or build up before any confession of attraction, and 2) some of the conflict-resolutions felt a little too quick and simple imo.
but overall, such a feel-good story that was just what i needed. hope there's a sequel :)
queer YA romances with cute covers can be very hit or miss, but i'm happy to report this was a hit 🙂↕️ i truly became so fond of AJ and Bren, and loved seeing their relationship develop over the course of the story. adored all of the niche cultural references, and all of the characters' little quirks. also really appreciated the emphasis on emotional closeness/connection here over gratuitous spice!
my teensy tiny little qualms were 1) i wish there was a liiiittle bit more of a slow burn or build up before any confession of attraction, and 2) some of the conflict-resolutions felt a little too quick and simple imo.
but overall, such a feel-good story that was just what i needed. hope there's a sequel :)
Review of advance copy received from Author
I really enjoyed this book. AJ and Bren’s friendship turned relationship felt authentic and realistic. Robert did a wonderful job of painting a picture of their teen lives in the early 2000s (as an elder millennial, it brought me back haha) with the pop culture references, music choices and technology usage. The Ireland setting was perfection – the descriptions helped me imagine myself walking along with them. No part of the plot felt rushed or forced, but was an organic progression as both characters learned about each other and themselves. Bren’s friend group welcomed Aj because Bren did and I loved their dynamic. I am very much looking forward to Track 2.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I found this book while browsing NetGalley and, as an artist, I found myself immediately drawn to the cover. It is a lovely, fitting style with a great texture to it, and after reading I can confidently state that it perfectly matches the personalities of Bren and A.J. - Bren's over-the-top Nature and A.J.'s initial reluctance and quiet nature - and just matches the whole vibe of the story.
C.W.: homophobia, assault
Plot:
A.J. is a Canadian teenager who has arrived in Ireland as an exchange student. He is anxious and overthinking everything on his way to his first day at the Irish secondary school. He is listening to music with his beloved Discman sitting on the ground before class, when the loud and extroverted (and yoghurt-covered) Bren approaches him. A.J. believes he is being made fun of, and is pretty reluctant to communicate with Bren, but soon bites the bullet, talks with him, and realises it was all just banter and befriends with Bren and his group. The pair grow closer and feelings begin to develop and they become pretty much inseparable, doing everything together. However, A.J. is due to fly back to Canada in the Summer. They have to make the most of the time they will have together in person this school year.
Thoughts:
It took me a few pages to get into this book, but became hooked soon after. I must say, the descriptions of absolutely nobody wearing their uniforms right stood out to me so much because it is just so true. These teenagers feel so painfully real. It doesn't feel like the typical "kids written by an out of touch old person": they all feel like real kids I could have had driving me mad in my classes a few years ago. I enjoyed all the Ireland-specific things mentioned throughout.
The panic A.J. felt was so real. Although I have never moved to an entirely different country with nobody I know, I have always had pretty bad anxiety and found his overthinking and paranoia so, so unbelievably relatable. His reaction to the class introductions was just so me, and his introduction was a very funny call back to what Bren said when they met not long before that "My name's A.J. Walker, I'm from Canada and... And I don't fight polar bears", even if saying it ended up embarrassing him. I feel like you can detect their, I suppose, fascination with one another right away. They just keep thinking about each other. Bren keeps trying to connect with and befriend A.J., thinking he was maybe just shy and introverted. When A.J. said hi to Bren first the next day and tried to make conversation it made me smile as it was such a contrast to the previous day, but the next bit was unfortunate. A.J. was trying to hard to "be normal", but one accident caused by Bren and he just totally broke with the emotions all bursting out at once. I was so so so glad that the author chose not to go for the route of making the characters frustratingly miscommunicate for half the book and instead went for confrontation and apologies early-on, not just with this incident, but throughout the whole book the communication between all the characters was very refreshing. I was a bit shocked when A.J. said he was gay (especially with the way he said it haha) to Bren so soon considering it's set in 2006 and casual homophobia seemed rife in that school environment, but I think it was a good thing for the story and that whole interaction in the greenhouse did really just make A.J. feel more comfortable and himself. Plus it definitely made Bren want to be around him even more.
The book is full of little moments which made me giggle, such as A.J., hesitating, saying "what's the craic?" to fit in and it just not sounding right. And it is also full of moments I just felt I had to reread multiple times like the first kiss which I had to slowly repeat because it just felt like such a good scene. Total chef's kiss that. And Nat's reaction being told about it was fabulous. The progression all felt super natural. It is by no means a slow burn, but it didn't feel too fast for me. Not that I have personal experience, but it felt realistic for a school romance not to have it drag out for months and months, especially with A.J. only being in Ireland for the one school year.
I love Bren's mam.
A nice quote from A.J.'s thoughts: 'Every moment, as long as you're mine'
Of course, the incident closer to the end was horrible, but it was (in this case) unfortunately realistic. It was scary and anxiety-inducing. It did, however, cause some positives and really brought everyone closer together and made for a very emotional section. It was very sad reading about how it affected everyone after, but they all tried hard to not let it affect them.
I swear this book made me feel every possible emotion. The ending brought tears to my eyes (and I swear it was not because of the eye drops I had just used) and I am incredibly desperate for a sequel, which I hope will become a reality as hinted by the 'Track One' in the title. I am not ready to let the lads go!!
Totally a must-read for fans of YA Romance.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for providing the ARC for me to review.
C.W.: homophobia, assault
Plot:
A.J. is a Canadian teenager who has arrived in Ireland as an exchange student. He is anxious and overthinking everything on his way to his first day at the Irish secondary school. He is listening to music with his beloved Discman sitting on the ground before class, when the loud and extroverted (and yoghurt-covered) Bren approaches him. A.J. believes he is being made fun of, and is pretty reluctant to communicate with Bren, but soon bites the bullet, talks with him, and realises it was all just banter and befriends with Bren and his group. The pair grow closer and feelings begin to develop and they become pretty much inseparable, doing everything together. However, A.J. is due to fly back to Canada in the Summer. They have to make the most of the time they will have together in person this school year.
Thoughts:
It took me a few pages to get into this book, but became hooked soon after. I must say, the descriptions of absolutely nobody wearing their uniforms right stood out to me so much because it is just so true. These teenagers feel so painfully real. It doesn't feel like the typical "kids written by an out of touch old person": they all feel like real kids I could have had driving me mad in my classes a few years ago. I enjoyed all the Ireland-specific things mentioned throughout.
The panic A.J. felt was so real. Although I have never moved to an entirely different country with nobody I know, I have always had pretty bad anxiety and found his overthinking and paranoia so, so unbelievably relatable. His reaction to the class introductions was just so me, and his introduction was a very funny call back to what Bren said when they met not long before that "My name's A.J. Walker, I'm from Canada and... And I don't fight polar bears", even if saying it ended up embarrassing him. I feel like you can detect their, I suppose, fascination with one another right away. They just keep thinking about each other. Bren keeps trying to connect with and befriend A.J., thinking he was maybe just shy and introverted. When A.J. said hi to Bren first the next day and tried to make conversation it made me smile as it was such a contrast to the previous day, but the next bit was unfortunate. A.J. was trying to hard to "be normal", but one accident caused by Bren and he just totally broke with the emotions all bursting out at once. I was so so so glad that the author chose not to go for the route of making the characters frustratingly miscommunicate for half the book and instead went for confrontation and apologies early-on, not just with this incident, but throughout the whole book the communication between all the characters was very refreshing. I was a bit shocked when A.J. said he was gay (especially with the way he said it haha) to Bren so soon considering it's set in 2006 and casual homophobia seemed rife in that school environment, but I think it was a good thing for the story and that whole interaction in the greenhouse did really just make A.J. feel more comfortable and himself. Plus it definitely made Bren want to be around him even more.
The book is full of little moments which made me giggle, such as A.J., hesitating, saying "what's the craic?" to fit in and it just not sounding right. And it is also full of moments I just felt I had to reread multiple times like the first kiss which I had to slowly repeat because it just felt like such a good scene. Total chef's kiss that. And Nat's reaction being told about it was fabulous. The progression all felt super natural. It is by no means a slow burn, but it didn't feel too fast for me. Not that I have personal experience, but it felt realistic for a school romance not to have it drag out for months and months, especially with A.J. only being in Ireland for the one school year.
I love Bren's mam.
A nice quote from A.J.'s thoughts: 'Every moment, as long as you're mine'
Of course, the incident closer to the end was horrible, but it was (in this case) unfortunately realistic. It was scary and anxiety-inducing. It did, however, cause some positives and really brought everyone closer together and made for a very emotional section. It was very sad reading about how it affected everyone after, but they all tried hard to not let it affect them.
I swear this book made me feel every possible emotion. The ending brought tears to my eyes (and I swear it was not because of the eye drops I had just used) and I am incredibly desperate for a sequel, which I hope will become a reality as hinted by the 'Track One' in the title. I am not ready to let the lads go!!
Totally a must-read for fans of YA Romance.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for providing the ARC for me to review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I adore these characters and the story so much!
A.J. is an exchange student who meets Bren but doesn’t start on the right foot. A.J. wants to fit in, but he feels like an outcast and thinks people are talking behind his back. Once the misunderstanding is cleared, A.J. and Bren become close friends, and feelings begin to develop between them.
The way Ireland is described and how much of a culture shock it is for A.J. make it easy to put myself in his shoes. As a fellow introvert, I can understand how scary this might be. For him, though, it’s much tougher because he’s a queer boy in an all-boys school, and if the students found out about his sexuality, they might think he’s hitting on them. A.J. is open about his sexuality, kind of. He doesn’t say it out loud, but if someone asks, he won’t deny it. On the other hand, Bren is having a bi awakening. He’s experiencing feelings he’s never had with any other person he’s been interested in, and he’s having them with A.J.
A.J. and Bren are complete opposites. They’re the opposites-attract, friends-to-lovers trope. A.J. is mostly calm but can get stressed easily and is a people-pleaser. He has his trusty Walkman that helps ground him. On the other hand, Bren is like a chaotic golden retriever. He says what’s on his mind and likes teasing people. Nothing seems to faze him unless someone messes with A.J. Watching them fall in love had me kicking my feet. They were so adorable and funny with each other. I’m jealous of how romantic these two were. The message Bren left A.J. on his mixtape! A.J.’s song he composed for Bren! Like, come on. So sweet 🥰
There’s an incident that had me tearing up and angry. I don’t want to spoil it, but I just want to say homophobes are the worst, and the fact that there were barely any repercussions was frustrating, though unfortunately seen so many times. Let people live their lives for goodness’ sake, especially when they’re minding their business and not hurting anyone. I hated what A.J. goes through, but I was so happy he had people who loved him and had his back.
It has a bittersweet ending, but it’s realistic in this situation. If you enjoy characters navigating life with humor, friendship, music, love, and a heartwarming queer romance, I recommend trying this one out.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.
A.J. is an exchange student who meets Bren but doesn’t start on the right foot. A.J. wants to fit in, but he feels like an outcast and thinks people are talking behind his back. Once the misunderstanding is cleared, A.J. and Bren become close friends, and feelings begin to develop between them.
The way Ireland is described and how much of a culture shock it is for A.J. make it easy to put myself in his shoes. As a fellow introvert, I can understand how scary this might be. For him, though, it’s much tougher because he’s a queer boy in an all-boys school, and if the students found out about his sexuality, they might think he’s hitting on them. A.J. is open about his sexuality, kind of. He doesn’t say it out loud, but if someone asks, he won’t deny it. On the other hand, Bren is having a bi awakening. He’s experiencing feelings he’s never had with any other person he’s been interested in, and he’s having them with A.J.
A.J. and Bren are complete opposites. They’re the opposites-attract, friends-to-lovers trope. A.J. is mostly calm but can get stressed easily and is a people-pleaser. He has his trusty Walkman that helps ground him. On the other hand, Bren is like a chaotic golden retriever. He says what’s on his mind and likes teasing people. Nothing seems to faze him unless someone messes with A.J. Watching them fall in love had me kicking my feet. They were so adorable and funny with each other. I’m jealous of how romantic these two were. The message Bren left A.J. on his mixtape! A.J.’s song he composed for Bren! Like, come on. So sweet 🥰
There’s an incident that had me tearing up and angry. I don’t want to spoil it, but I just want to say homophobes are the worst, and the fact that there were barely any repercussions was frustrating, though unfortunately seen so many times. Let people live their lives for goodness’ sake, especially when they’re minding their business and not hurting anyone. I hated what A.J. goes through, but I was so happy he had people who loved him and had his back.
It has a bittersweet ending, but it’s realistic in this situation. If you enjoy characters navigating life with humor, friendship, music, love, and a heartwarming queer romance, I recommend trying this one out.
Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
4.75 ⭐️🤩
I had a great time reading this book! Adored the setting (2006 Ireland), the characters and the story. A heartwarming queer romance that leaves you feeling good.
It’s very entertaining. We get cute moments, funny scenes, sad stuff, and guaranteed fun, sweet, teenage first love. These two had me “giggling kicking my feet” with their funny and cutesy scenes.
It all just felt real. The pacing their friendship developed, their feelings - natural and sometimes clumsy, how they talked - not only the main characters, but also the other characters, their friends/classmates, and the adults. Bren’s scenes with his friends were hilarious.
Speaking of adults, MAM! Bren’s mom is funny and kind. Also the small glimpses we got of A.J’s parents, so caring and also funny. Ok, basically everyone’s funny HAHAHA.
Special highlight: “He’s my lad” STOP 😭😭💗❤️🩹
Of course, can’t leave out the trigger - homophobia. The fear of being called names, and how people will react. Sad, but real. An important part of the story to make it accurate for what two boys in love would go through at that time, but don’t let it put off reading this book. It doesn’t take away all the amazing scenes. It makes it more real. And despite it all, love should always win.
The ending let me wanting more. If a sequel is coming “Track One”, count me in to read it! I want to know what happens next. Please!! Hahaha
✨
If you enjoy stories the following tropes, go ahead! Give this a read.
🌍 Exchange Student 🇨🇦 A.J meets 🇮🇪 Bren
🩵 Young Adult Romance
🤣 Funny teen banter
🤝 Friendship group
🎃 Halloween party
📚 Classes together
🥺 First Love
🎶 Mixtapes
Set in 2006, Canadian 16-year-old A.J goes to Ireland for an exchange program. Openly gay (if anyone asks), usually quiet, sometimes awkward and yet to make friends at his new all-boys school. Then he meets Bren, very much his opposite, extrovert, loud, outgoing, and now his new friend.
They get past a misunderstanding and soon develop a friendship. And that friendship soon gets to be….. more than just friends. Now Bren is having his bisexual awakening. He’s never felt this way for a guy before. But A.J is leaving soon, back to Canada. How will they deal with this? They can’t date, can they? 👀
Thank you so much to NetGalley, Victory Editing and Robert J. Halliwell for the ARC!
I had a great time reading this book! Adored the setting (2006 Ireland), the characters and the story. A heartwarming queer romance that leaves you feeling good.
It’s very entertaining. We get cute moments, funny scenes, sad stuff, and guaranteed fun, sweet, teenage first love. These two had me “giggling kicking my feet” with their funny and cutesy scenes.
It all just felt real. The pacing their friendship developed, their feelings - natural and sometimes clumsy, how they talked - not only the main characters, but also the other characters, their friends/classmates, and the adults. Bren’s scenes with his friends were hilarious.
Speaking of adults, MAM! Bren’s mom is funny and kind. Also the small glimpses we got of A.J’s parents, so caring and also funny. Ok, basically everyone’s funny HAHAHA.
Special highlight: “He’s my lad” STOP 😭😭💗❤️🩹
Of course, can’t leave out the trigger - homophobia. The fear of being called names, and how people will react. Sad, but real. An important part of the story to make it accurate for what two boys in love would go through at that time, but don’t let it put off reading this book. It doesn’t take away all the amazing scenes. It makes it more real. And despite it all, love should always win.
The ending let me wanting more. If a sequel is coming “Track One”, count me in to read it! I want to know what happens next. Please!! Hahaha
✨
If you enjoy stories the following tropes, go ahead! Give this a read.
🌍 Exchange Student 🇨🇦 A.J meets 🇮🇪 Bren
🩵 Young Adult Romance
🤣 Funny teen banter
🤝 Friendship group
🎃 Halloween party
📚 Classes together
🥺 First Love
🎶 Mixtapes
Set in 2006, Canadian 16-year-old A.J goes to Ireland for an exchange program. Openly gay (if anyone asks), usually quiet, sometimes awkward and yet to make friends at his new all-boys school. Then he meets Bren, very much his opposite, extrovert, loud, outgoing, and now his new friend.
They get past a misunderstanding and soon develop a friendship. And that friendship soon gets to be….. more than just friends. Now Bren is having his bisexual awakening. He’s never felt this way for a guy before. But A.J is leaving soon, back to Canada. How will they deal with this? They can’t date, can they? 👀
Thank you so much to NetGalley, Victory Editing and Robert J. Halliwell for the ARC!
March 1, 2026
Review as an ARC
"If you want something badly enough, you have to fight for it. Step up your game."
Review as an ARC
"If you want something badly enough, you have to fight for it. Step up your game."
Reseña como ARC
"Si deseas algo con todas tus fuerzas, tienes que luchar por ello. Dale un paso al frente."
- Scott Pilgrim vs The World
Arriving in a new country isn't always easy, but with the right company, it can feel like home.
AJ is a 16-year-old Canadian boy who is openly gay, always using his Discman, and decides to apply for an exchange program. He ends up in the mountains of Ireland with a foster family, at an all-boys school, and encounters a group of boys who initially seem like troublemakers, but sooner than he expects, they "adopt" him and nickname him Robolad.
Bren, 16 years old. A mischievous Irish boy (when no one's looking) and a very loyal friend. He quickly becomes curious about the new boy, but soon begins to develop more than a few confusing feelings toward him and even tries to protect what he considers a friendship. He realizes that Bren is as different as he is charming.
Between musicals, hurling, and home economics classes; Love arrives and surprises us more than once.
I'm continuing my reading in English (and perhaps I'm faster at it), and this time I discovered this book by accident on Instagram and decided I absolutely had to read it.
In this case, we travel back 20 years (2006) in a story that portrays the teenage reality of those years and highlights how fun, but also how sad and melancholic it all feels. It deals with themes like self-identity, neurodivergence, school bullying, and acceptance in a way that is both painful and beautiful.
There are diverse characters in the book; Bren's friends are part of that typical group that wants to be socially accepted but is a disaster.
Some of my favorite characters are Nat, that long-distance friend you tell everything to, Maura, the mother who has a very fun and beautiful relationship with her son, and of course AJ with his music and Bren with his exotic baking.
I loved this book and I hope you can read it too.
"If you want something badly enough, you have to fight for it. Step up your game."
Review as an ARC
"If you want something badly enough, you have to fight for it. Step up your game."
Reseña como ARC
"Si deseas algo con todas tus fuerzas, tienes que luchar por ello. Dale un paso al frente."
- Scott Pilgrim vs The World
Arriving in a new country isn't always easy, but with the right company, it can feel like home.
AJ is a 16-year-old Canadian boy who is openly gay, always using his Discman, and decides to apply for an exchange program. He ends up in the mountains of Ireland with a foster family, at an all-boys school, and encounters a group of boys who initially seem like troublemakers, but sooner than he expects, they "adopt" him and nickname him Robolad.
Bren, 16 years old. A mischievous Irish boy (when no one's looking) and a very loyal friend. He quickly becomes curious about the new boy, but soon begins to develop more than a few confusing feelings toward him and even tries to protect what he considers a friendship. He realizes that Bren is as different as he is charming.
Between musicals, hurling, and home economics classes; Love arrives and surprises us more than once.
I'm continuing my reading in English (and perhaps I'm faster at it), and this time I discovered this book by accident on Instagram and decided I absolutely had to read it.
In this case, we travel back 20 years (2006) in a story that portrays the teenage reality of those years and highlights how fun, but also how sad and melancholic it all feels. It deals with themes like self-identity, neurodivergence, school bullying, and acceptance in a way that is both painful and beautiful.
There are diverse characters in the book; Bren's friends are part of that typical group that wants to be socially accepted but is a disaster.
Some of my favorite characters are Nat, that long-distance friend you tell everything to, Maura, the mother who has a very fun and beautiful relationship with her son, and of course AJ with his music and Bren with his exotic baking.
I loved this book and I hope you can read it too.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
5 Stars
And Then He Pressed Play: Track One is a beautifully heartwarming coming-of-age tale, set in 2006, all about self-growth, friendship, and first love for one Canadian exchange student and the Irish lad who at first befriends him and then steals his heart during a semester abroad.
This book is a prime example of why (at forty) I still read (good) YA fiction. I was drawn in by the synopsis and I went in thinking “this should be nice,” but before long I was a human-pendulum swinging between giddy feet-kicking and clutching my chest in an emotional chokehold with how much I was invested in the lives of these two teenage boys and their butterfly inducing love story.
I related a lot to shy, anxious, music-loving A.J. and I was absolutely smitten with spirited ginger and all-around Irish sweetheart Bren. They were fantastically endearing characters individually, but together they were next-level adorable, etching a pretty permanent smile on my face over their countless cute and delightful interactions as they fell in love.
Being squarely a YA story, the romance between A.J. and Bren was all things age-appropriate and non-explicit. There were plenty of heartfelt moments of self-discovery (for Bren, at least) and lots of first kisses and intimate emotional moments shared between the boys that were perfectly innocent but deeply moving.
As a bit of a warning, there is some on-page bullying and even a pretty harrowing on-page assault that raises the stakes and (sadly) cements this story in a very authentic reality, BUT it never veers too far from the giddy, sweet, soul-warming tone that made (almost) every second of this story an absolute delight to read.
Something else that made this story a delight to read were the secondary characters who surrounded A.J. and Bren with so much love and support, and plenty of playful ribbing by their friends and peers, that the story felt fuller and richer for every one of the faces that helped make this a more joyful and rewarding story. Bren’s mam specifically needs a shout-out here—the woman is an absolute champion and I delighted in every scene she graced the page.
The story itself ends on a very melancholic note, leaving me a bit of a sobbing, heartsick mess by the time I turned the final page, if I’m being completely transparent. BUT it was also a super hopeful and sweet ending, that felt entirely fitting, considering the youthful age of the boys and their circumstances at the time of the story.
However, seeing “Track One” tacked on to the title above makes me desperately hopeful for a “Track Two” in the lives of A.J. and Bren. These boys and their love story were at once deeply emotional and intensely joy-inspiring, that I can’t help but pray to the book gods (and directly to the author) that we are blessed with more of their story in the not-too-distant future…
…but even if that never transpires, and this is firmly meant to read as a standalone, I relished in every moment of my reading experience. It was such a wonderful coming-of-age LGBT love story to add to my coveted favourites shelf, and I eagerly look forward to reading more from this author going forward.
***A special thanks to the author and the publishers (via Netgalley) for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
And Then He Pressed Play: Track One is a beautifully heartwarming coming-of-age tale, set in 2006, all about self-growth, friendship, and first love for one Canadian exchange student and the Irish lad who at first befriends him and then steals his heart during a semester abroad.
This book is a prime example of why (at forty) I still read (good) YA fiction. I was drawn in by the synopsis and I went in thinking “this should be nice,” but before long I was a human-pendulum swinging between giddy feet-kicking and clutching my chest in an emotional chokehold with how much I was invested in the lives of these two teenage boys and their butterfly inducing love story.
I related a lot to shy, anxious, music-loving A.J. and I was absolutely smitten with spirited ginger and all-around Irish sweetheart Bren. They were fantastically endearing characters individually, but together they were next-level adorable, etching a pretty permanent smile on my face over their countless cute and delightful interactions as they fell in love.
Being squarely a YA story, the romance between A.J. and Bren was all things age-appropriate and non-explicit. There were plenty of heartfelt moments of self-discovery (for Bren, at least) and lots of first kisses and intimate emotional moments shared between the boys that were perfectly innocent but deeply moving.
As a bit of a warning, there is some on-page bullying and even a pretty harrowing on-page assault that raises the stakes and (sadly) cements this story in a very authentic reality, BUT it never veers too far from the giddy, sweet, soul-warming tone that made (almost) every second of this story an absolute delight to read.
Something else that made this story a delight to read were the secondary characters who surrounded A.J. and Bren with so much love and support, and plenty of playful ribbing by their friends and peers, that the story felt fuller and richer for every one of the faces that helped make this a more joyful and rewarding story. Bren’s mam specifically needs a shout-out here—the woman is an absolute champion and I delighted in every scene she graced the page.
The story itself ends on a very melancholic note, leaving me a bit of a sobbing, heartsick mess by the time I turned the final page, if I’m being completely transparent. BUT it was also a super hopeful and sweet ending, that felt entirely fitting, considering the youthful age of the boys and their circumstances at the time of the story.
However, seeing “Track One” tacked on to the title above makes me desperately hopeful for a “Track Two” in the lives of A.J. and Bren. These boys and their love story were at once deeply emotional and intensely joy-inspiring, that I can’t help but pray to the book gods (and directly to the author) that we are blessed with more of their story in the not-too-distant future…
…but even if that never transpires, and this is firmly meant to read as a standalone, I relished in every moment of my reading experience. It was such a wonderful coming-of-age LGBT love story to add to my coveted favourites shelf, and I eagerly look forward to reading more from this author going forward.
***A special thanks to the author and the publishers (via Netgalley) for providing an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Arc Reader review
I first heard about the author through my social media and couldn’t be any happier! Lucky to have been selected as an ARC reader.
Firstly, one of the strongest aspects of the story is the relationship between Bren and A.J. Their connection and developing relationship felt organic and relatable. Their last moments had me bawling my eyes out, because despite everything, their love felt real and tangible. Here’s hoping to a sequel (or more) where we can see further development for both of them.
The theme of moving to a new place was especially impactful for me on a personal level. As someone who has moved to Ireland to live, the sensations of displacement, uncertainty, and gradual belonging felt incredibly grounded and relatable. These moments added another layer of realism to the story that made it resonate even more strongly. I still remember my own struggles with the many different accents I found around Ireland!
I’ll admit, the few moments of homophobia were difficult to read at times, but intentionally so. They felt sharp and unfortunately reflective of what many people still experience today. To this day, I still want Cian behind bars ASAP.
Ultimately, “And Then He Pressed Play” is a story about finding connection in unfamiliar places, about the quiet bravery it takes to let yourself be seen, and about the heartbreak of loving someone when you know time is against you. I would wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone looking for a queer story that feels honest, intimate, and emotionally true. A story that doesn’t shy away from pain, but still leaves you holding onto something warm and hopeful once it’s over.
Overall, I couldn’t have started 2026 with any other book.
#TeamMaura
I first heard about the author through my social media and couldn’t be any happier! Lucky to have been selected as an ARC reader.
Firstly, one of the strongest aspects of the story is the relationship between Bren and A.J. Their connection and developing relationship felt organic and relatable. Their last moments had me bawling my eyes out, because despite everything, their love felt real and tangible. Here’s hoping to a sequel (or more) where we can see further development for both of them.
The theme of moving to a new place was especially impactful for me on a personal level. As someone who has moved to Ireland to live, the sensations of displacement, uncertainty, and gradual belonging felt incredibly grounded and relatable. These moments added another layer of realism to the story that made it resonate even more strongly. I still remember my own struggles with the many different accents I found around Ireland!
I’ll admit, the few moments of homophobia were difficult to read at times, but intentionally so. They felt sharp and unfortunately reflective of what many people still experience today. To this day, I still want Cian behind bars ASAP.
Ultimately, “And Then He Pressed Play” is a story about finding connection in unfamiliar places, about the quiet bravery it takes to let yourself be seen, and about the heartbreak of loving someone when you know time is against you. I would wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone looking for a queer story that feels honest, intimate, and emotionally true. A story that doesn’t shy away from pain, but still leaves you holding onto something warm and hopeful once it’s over.
Overall, I couldn’t have started 2026 with any other book.
#TeamMaura
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
the characters, the growth, the love, the confidence, and the support shown in the book of what made it a 5 star read. it was beautiful and sweet and real and I can't wait to read another by the new to me author
such a sweet book! an exchange student comes from Canada to Ireland for a year. difficult to make friends at first, when your new and different and don't know the local slang. after a bit of a rough start A.J. finally finds a group of friends and starts to get settled.
Bren wanted to be friends from the start, but culture differences and insecurities stalled that. after they find their footing, they form a friendship and a bond that was delightful to read.
I don't want to accidentally spoil anything so I'll list some of the top qualities of this book:
each of the lads in the friend group has their own distinct personalities and it was fun to get to know them as AJ did. I had never heard of Hurling before, so that was also fun to get to know. the level of care shown by Bren had me smiling like a book hasn't in a long time. I love love loved Bren's relationship with his mom.
everything was so realistic and believable. forgetting you had to work after a long night with friends? been there. having friendly feelings turn into something so much more? been there too. being the odd man out trying to find your place to belong? yup. a single mom that worked a lot so I had a lot of freedom but still a healthy level of respect and love for? yes, actually. being thousands of miles away from your bestie, only able to communicate thru the Internet? yes to that too!
the reality of being bullied for who you are and who you love was heartbreaking, but written with such care and love that it was bearable to read. and it was important.
such a sweet book! an exchange student comes from Canada to Ireland for a year. difficult to make friends at first, when your new and different and don't know the local slang. after a bit of a rough start A.J. finally finds a group of friends and starts to get settled.
Bren wanted to be friends from the start, but culture differences and insecurities stalled that. after they find their footing, they form a friendship and a bond that was delightful to read.
I don't want to accidentally spoil anything so I'll list some of the top qualities of this book:
each of the lads in the friend group has their own distinct personalities and it was fun to get to know them as AJ did. I had never heard of Hurling before, so that was also fun to get to know. the level of care shown by Bren had me smiling like a book hasn't in a long time. I love love loved Bren's relationship with his mom.
everything was so realistic and believable. forgetting you had to work after a long night with friends? been there. having friendly feelings turn into something so much more? been there too. being the odd man out trying to find your place to belong? yup. a single mom that worked a lot so I had a lot of freedom but still a healthy level of respect and love for? yes, actually. being thousands of miles away from your bestie, only able to communicate thru the Internet? yes to that too!
the reality of being bullied for who you are and who you love was heartbreaking, but written with such care and love that it was bearable to read. and it was important.
Review of advance copy
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review :-) Thank you!
And Then He Pressed Play is a sweet book, I would say most suitable for a young teen audience - I have, alas, outgrown this, but I can acknowledge that a tween me would appreciate a story like this.
A.J. and Bren have an endearingly awkward relationship. They move very fast and they're quite juvenile at times, but it didn't bother me since A.J.'s stay was so short. They had to make the most of their time! I get that!
I would have liked to see more interactions with the whole crew. A.J. and Bren are obviously the main characters of the book, but they have interesting dynamics with their friends that I feel were a little underexplored. It's clear that the group is very tight-knit, I just wish this was shown in the book rather than just implied. More interactions with A.J.'s friends from Canada would be welcome too, even if only second-hand via texts with Nat.
The references to Ireland and Irish culture fell flat for me, as an Irish reader. Bren isn't a common nickname and Finley is an even less common name, so I honestly expected Bren to have some sort of American twist to him. I would say "shite" and "arse" are a little overused, and I felt a little fatigued seeing the same slang over and over again. In one instance, a character refers to being in "class six" of primary school, which is not phrasing that I've ever heard used. I'm sure this would all be novel for a non-Irish reader, but a little more accuracy wouldn't hurt! A valiant effort, it just missed the mark.
I can definitely see the potential in this book, and I wish the author much luck for the next one!
And Then He Pressed Play is a sweet book, I would say most suitable for a young teen audience - I have, alas, outgrown this, but I can acknowledge that a tween me would appreciate a story like this.
A.J. and Bren have an endearingly awkward relationship. They move very fast and they're quite juvenile at times, but it didn't bother me since A.J.'s stay was so short. They had to make the most of their time! I get that!
I would have liked to see more interactions with the whole crew. A.J. and Bren are obviously the main characters of the book, but they have interesting dynamics with their friends that I feel were a little underexplored. It's clear that the group is very tight-knit, I just wish this was shown in the book rather than just implied. More interactions with A.J.'s friends from Canada would be welcome too, even if only second-hand via texts with Nat.
The references to Ireland and Irish culture fell flat for me, as an Irish reader. Bren isn't a common nickname and Finley is an even less common name, so I honestly expected Bren to have some sort of American twist to him. I would say "shite" and "arse" are a little overused, and I felt a little fatigued seeing the same slang over and over again. In one instance, a character refers to being in "class six" of primary school, which is not phrasing that I've ever heard used. I'm sure this would all be novel for a non-Irish reader, but a little more accuracy wouldn't hurt! A valiant effort, it just missed the mark.
I can definitely see the potential in this book, and I wish the author much luck for the next one!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I requested an ARC from the author for this book and am so happy I received one. I LOVED this book! A.J. and Bren are such great characters. A.J.: social anxiety, love of music, being Canadian (like me) and out gay teen. Bren: gregarious, sensitive about his house, lots of friends. Totally opposites that just mesh well, after A.J. realizes Bren is actually trying to be friendly and not bullying him anyway. As someone with anxiety I thought the way the author dealt with A.J.'s insecurities and worries was believable and realistic. Same goes for Bren coming to realize he doesn't just like A.J. as a friend. I don't know if the book will come with content warnings but it should. Homophobia, bullying, and assault are the big ones; underage drinking, vomiting and on-page descriptions of someone after an assault if those matter to you. I also loved the side characters and how they weren't one dimensional: Bren's mom, Bren's friends and A.J.'s best friend Nat. I have no idea how accurate the portrayal of Ireland, the accents, vocabulary and culture was but I enjoyed it. The book did lose half a star for me though because there were so many Irish words and phrases that I didn't understand and weren't explained. There were also quite a few grammatical issues that disrupted the flow. Overall, I loved the relationship between the boys, how sweet they were to each other, how close A.J. got to so many people in the town, the ways they showed their love, Bren being the only one to use A.J.'s real name, and even the realistic way the assault was handled. I can see this being one of my favorite books of the year.
February 25, 2026
I read “And Then He Pressed Play” as an ARC, and it was an absolute joy from the very first page to the last. I immediately fell in love with the quirky characters. They were written with such authenticity and heart and by the end, I just wanted to protect them at all costs.
I especially loved the way the relationship between AJ and Bren slowly builds and grows. The development feels natural and earned, and the chemistry between them is undeniable. It’s tender, awkward in the best way, and full of those small, meaningful moments that make you root for them so deeply. Watching them navigate their feelings felt honest and heartfelt.
I read this book while being in Ireland, where the weather has been absolutely dreadful and we haven’t seen the sun in what feels like forever and this book was my vitamin D. Reading it here made the experience even more special.
The book also transported me straight back to the 2000s, with all the small details, it felt like stepping into a time capsule.
There are some darker topics in this book, like homophobia (which was to be expected, given that it is set in the 2000s), but these themes are handled with care and respect.
This was an absolute comfort read for me. I really wish we had books like this ten years ago. Stories like this matter so much, and I’m incredibly happy that the next generation gets to grow up with them.
If you loved Heartstopper by Alice Oseman, you will definitely enjoy this book too.
I will absolutely be rereading this one.
I especially loved the way the relationship between AJ and Bren slowly builds and grows. The development feels natural and earned, and the chemistry between them is undeniable. It’s tender, awkward in the best way, and full of those small, meaningful moments that make you root for them so deeply. Watching them navigate their feelings felt honest and heartfelt.
I read this book while being in Ireland, where the weather has been absolutely dreadful and we haven’t seen the sun in what feels like forever and this book was my vitamin D. Reading it here made the experience even more special.
The book also transported me straight back to the 2000s, with all the small details, it felt like stepping into a time capsule.
There are some darker topics in this book, like homophobia (which was to be expected, given that it is set in the 2000s), but these themes are handled with care and respect.
This was an absolute comfort read for me. I really wish we had books like this ten years ago. Stories like this matter so much, and I’m incredibly happy that the next generation gets to grow up with them.
If you loved Heartstopper by Alice Oseman, you will definitely enjoy this book too.
I will absolutely be rereading this one.
March 12, 2026
AJ is on an exchange year in Ireland when he meets and falls for Bren, his first friend at an all boys school. A very simple summary of the book because I don't like to put anything that may spoil it. This is a good YA book, it deals with important and difficult themes that I think it's important to read for anyone. It's generally a very sweet book, obviously meant for a teen audience, you watch two young men fall for each other even though their time together is limited, you get to see how they are together and the difference in how they show themselves to other people around them. There is of course the big theme of homophobia which is definitely encountered here and is some of what happens is hard to read even as an adult because you hate to think about the fact that their are people who endure this every day, and you want to just wrap these boys in a hug. It's well written, it's not difficult or complex to read. For its intended audience I think it's just right. I enjoyed it. Though i'll be honest and say I think the latter part of the book felt rushed, there was a lot of building the relationship, which is important and was night, but when the tougher stuff happened, it felt hurried from then until the end and I personally would have liked to see it dealt with more in depth. Important themes could have been looked at more, and I think it would have been good to see it more. That definitely pulled my rating down a bit. Overall though, a good read.
Thank you netgalley for the ARC.
Thank you netgalley for the ARC.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This book was beyond cute, and also probably some of the realest representation of being queer as a young adult I've seen. A.J. is coded as being autistic as well but it's also never stated it's just how he is. It's the same with the characters queerness as well. It never feels like anything needs to be named but just is.
A.J's thought process contrasting with Bren's is one of the highlights of the book in my opinion. You go from A.J. who is high strung and anxious and a little suspicious socially at first, to Bren who is jus5 trying to make friends and have some fun while making sure everyone else is having fun. And the changes in these mentalities as the characters grow with each other and rub off on one another is immaculate
The book also starts with a pronunciation guide for some of the harder to pronounce Irish character names, which is a great accessibility addition and saves you from having to google it every time and get hung up and take more time reading as you try to find a way to pronounce the names.
The supporting characters are also equally as well written and make the world that much more vibrant. I'd say if you enjoy a romance story that's very grounded in reality but still somehow whimsical and magical anyways. Or are seeking a story that gives representation for queer or autistic characters this book would be a very good pick.
A.J's thought process contrasting with Bren's is one of the highlights of the book in my opinion. You go from A.J. who is high strung and anxious and a little suspicious socially at first, to Bren who is jus5 trying to make friends and have some fun while making sure everyone else is having fun. And the changes in these mentalities as the characters grow with each other and rub off on one another is immaculate
The book also starts with a pronunciation guide for some of the harder to pronounce Irish character names, which is a great accessibility addition and saves you from having to google it every time and get hung up and take more time reading as you try to find a way to pronounce the names.
The supporting characters are also equally as well written and make the world that much more vibrant. I'd say if you enjoy a romance story that's very grounded in reality but still somehow whimsical and magical anyways. Or are seeking a story that gives representation for queer or autistic characters this book would be a very good pick.
March 3, 2026
In the year 2006, A.J. is a Canadian who finally gets accepted into the foreign exchange program to Ireland. There is a bit of a language or accent barrier and he doesn't seem to get along with his host family too much.
However on his first day of school, he meets Bren and his friends. They don’t start on the greatest terms but over time they overcome their misunderstandings and become friends. And maybe something more.
I think if you are a fan of Heartstopper, you will enjoy this book. It gave me Heartstopper vibes throughout the novel.
The author took this in a direction I was not expecting. The middle of the book just had my heart pounding for A. J.
I forgot that this was set in 2006, because it kept mentioning Discman, which he used to play music to help with his anxiety but gradually started using it less.
It was nice that A.J. still talked to his friends back home and even told them things to keep them up to date with his new life in Ireland.
I was not a fan of the ending, cause I felt a character should have been more punished. However, this is a reality for a lot of people. Not everyone gets the justice they deserve.
I was so invested, I was reading this novel during the Three Days Grace concert.
I do hope we get a sequel to this. The last line I still think about and it has been a few days since I finished.
However on his first day of school, he meets Bren and his friends. They don’t start on the greatest terms but over time they overcome their misunderstandings and become friends. And maybe something more.
I think if you are a fan of Heartstopper, you will enjoy this book. It gave me Heartstopper vibes throughout the novel.
The author took this in a direction I was not expecting. The middle of the book just had my heart pounding for A. J.
I forgot that this was set in 2006, because it kept mentioning Discman, which he used to play music to help with his anxiety but gradually started using it less.
It was nice that A.J. still talked to his friends back home and even told them things to keep them up to date with his new life in Ireland.
I was not a fan of the ending, cause I felt a character should have been more punished. However, this is a reality for a lot of people. Not everyone gets the justice they deserve.
I was so invested, I was reading this novel during the Three Days Grace concert.
I do hope we get a sequel to this. The last line I still think about and it has been a few days since I finished.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
In, “And Then He Pressed Play,” author Robert J. Halliwell has written a sweet LGBTQ+ romance, with a cozy Irish setting, and dipped in so much mid-2000’s nostalgia that I could hardly put it down, and I read in just 2 sittings.
A.J. and Bren couldn’t have been more different from each other, but watching them fall in love was beautiful, and they make a truly adorable couple.
As the story takes place in 2006/2007, there is some period-typical homophobia from various characters (in words, attitudes and actions) but it was handled with exceptional care, and as a gay man who came of age during the time that this story is set, I really appreciated that the author didn’t gloss over how difficult it could be, especially in a school setting. It made me feel incredibly seen.
We’re not even a month into 2026, yet I can safely say that this will be one of my favourite books of the entire year!
“And Then He Pressed Play,” is scheduled for release on February 23, 2026, and if you’re a reader of LGBTQ+ romance, you definitely will want to pre-order this one as soon as possible!
Thank you to Robert J. Halliwell and BookFunnel for allowing me the honour of reading this one early!
A.J. and Bren couldn’t have been more different from each other, but watching them fall in love was beautiful, and they make a truly adorable couple.
As the story takes place in 2006/2007, there is some period-typical homophobia from various characters (in words, attitudes and actions) but it was handled with exceptional care, and as a gay man who came of age during the time that this story is set, I really appreciated that the author didn’t gloss over how difficult it could be, especially in a school setting. It made me feel incredibly seen.
We’re not even a month into 2026, yet I can safely say that this will be one of my favourite books of the entire year!
“And Then He Pressed Play,” is scheduled for release on February 23, 2026, and if you’re a reader of LGBTQ+ romance, you definitely will want to pre-order this one as soon as possible!
Thank you to Robert J. Halliwell and BookFunnel for allowing me the honour of reading this one early!
Review of advance copy received from Author
4.5/5
I could not but this book down. The vibes of this book were so cozy and heartfelt. The plot itself was very character driven but the story was extremely captivating and addictive. The growth and acceptance was very realistic and sweet. I was smiling almost the whole time.
The characters were all so well-written and easy to like. I loved AJ, he was portrayed so well. The growth and slow rise in self-confidence made this story feel realistic and very relatable. Then there is sweet, sweet Bren, who had my heart melting! He was so seet and so considerate and so incredibly lovable. AJ and Bren’s love story was so addictive and heart-warming. I loved everything about their relationship.
I also really liked the dynamics within their friend group. I loved how, after getting to know him, they just accepted AJ into their group and included him in their shenanigans. I like all of them, but my favourite is definitely Rory. I’ll admit, I am a sucker for a quiet, supportive friend with a savage side. Plus all his conversations with AJ were all very……heart-warming.
My only complaint: I want more. More of the friend group and, especially more of AJ and Bren!
I could not but this book down. The vibes of this book were so cozy and heartfelt. The plot itself was very character driven but the story was extremely captivating and addictive. The growth and acceptance was very realistic and sweet. I was smiling almost the whole time.
The characters were all so well-written and easy to like. I loved AJ, he was portrayed so well. The growth and slow rise in self-confidence made this story feel realistic and very relatable. Then there is sweet, sweet Bren, who had my heart melting! He was so seet and so considerate and so incredibly lovable. AJ and Bren’s love story was so addictive and heart-warming. I loved everything about their relationship.
I also really liked the dynamics within their friend group. I loved how, after getting to know him, they just accepted AJ into their group and included him in their shenanigans. I like all of them, but my favourite is definitely Rory. I’ll admit, I am a sucker for a quiet, supportive friend with a savage side. Plus all his conversations with AJ were all very……heart-warming.
My only complaint: I want more. More of the friend group and, especially more of AJ and Bren!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews