The Promise of Forever
Spoilers below.
It was a heartwarming story overall. But if readers are looking for a slow buildup between the MCs, there's none of that here. Jesse (32) and Hallie (27) have known each other for years; I think since she was 10. She is essentially the adopted daughter of his family and is also best friends with Jesse's sister, Wren.
So, like I mentioned, we kind of missed the whole buildup of whatever went down between them. We just jumped right into the scene where they had already kissed 10 months ago, but then they started avoiding each other after that, for reasons, of course.
Anyway, for one week, Hallie became Jesse's babysitter since his sister went on a trip with her boyfriend. Then, the house next to his, which was supposedly meant for his brother, was offered to Hallie by his parents. Even though babysitting is over, they still find themselves close by since they’re neighbors now. Plus, she’s working for his family, specifically with his brother.
Since they want to avoid any awkwardness, they talked about why she has been avoiding him. Back to the moment they kissed, the morning after, Jesse thought that Hallie wanted to be with his brother. Hallie, on the other hand, believed it was a mistake.
Have I mentioned that she has an abandonment issue? Her mom walked out when she was just 10, and by the time she hit 18, her dad couldn't move fast enough to live his life again, and now she only has her brother.
So, you see, she thinks that she's not really worth sticking around for. Jesse's family is the only one she's ever known, and she doesn't want to lose them. As someone who always expects the worst, she fears that starting a relationship might end in heartbreak and being left alone, thinking they would probably side with him instead of her. Hence the avoidance tactic while still being polite and civil.
There's a lot of pushing away from Hallie, as you might expect from someone dealing with her kind of issues. But Jesse, being the all-in guy that he is, chose to go with her pace and has been patient ever since. He stayed steady and kept showing her what life could be like with him, letting her know he’d be there for as long as she wanted. This is why it's heartwarming because it's not just Jesse, but his family and daughter also showed appreciation and love to Hallie.
It took her some time to really get that he's genuine and he's here to stay. But when she finally jumped in (even though she still had some worries), she went all in completely. She didn't hold back and just trusted he’d always have her back, and he’d come through with his words.
I love the romance and the found family aspect. But I feel like the father-daughter screen time between Jesse and Emma didn't get enough attention. We only see them have fights and eat dinner, and when they go on dates, most of these are done off-page, and we don't know what they actually did or even talked about.
When her bitch mom disappoints and never follows through on her promises, I wish we could've seen Jesse helping Emma navigate her emotions. For them to have a serious conversation because these letdowns affect the both of them.
While Hallie and his family always make up for the clusterfuck after the egg donor bails, it still would have been nice to know how Emma feels about these things. We only got a few lines from her (almost at the end) appreciating Hallie and her dad's effort to make her feel better. But like I said, we didn't get these moments.
Anyway, moving past that, I really enjoyed this book, but I still liked the first one a bit more. 🤭
Book info:
— Bff’s brother
— Forced proximity
— Single dad
— Grumpy x Sunshine
— Mutual pining
— Abandonment Issues
— Absentee parent
— Found family
— No cheating, real OM/OW, separation*
— No V (h - no info, H - celibate for years)
— HEA (2 yrs later, married, and just had their son)
Notes:
— There's no separation in the sense that they were not together. But they would go for days, even for weeks, without talking because Hallie got stuck in her head.
— No V. Hallie mentioned that she had boyfriends, but she didn't specify when her most recent relationship was. But Jesse has been celibate for the last 8 years, and I think his ex was the last woman he had been with.
— OM. Not really. After they slept together for the first time, they both agreed it's a one-time thing. Wren (H's sister) asked Hallie to go on a blind date with her colleague. Then she asked Jesse what she should do about it, and he told her to go for it (even though he really didn't want to). She went on two dates with this guy; nothing happened between them, and Jesse crashed the second date but immediately left after he finally said his piece.
— The egg donor. It was a ONS that resulted in pregnancy, and Jesse was raised a better man, so he decided to stay with the OW to raise their kid. They were together for a few years until their daughter was 3 (I think???) but the woman decided that the small town was not for her and she wanted more in her life, then giving him full custody.
— She showed up almost at the end when she found out that Jesse's daughter is having a party and a famous band is the guest. The egg donor wanted to be a singer, so she made a scene to get inside the event, hoping she could score a demo with the band. But she got kicked out after making a fool of herself.