This was a mixed bag in every sense. There was a lot going on in this volume, and for juggling it all I do applaud Bendis. However, it was a bit too scattered and unfocused as a result. I enjoyed how so many plot threads were woven together here: the New Avengers still dealing with the fallout of Civil War as well as the new threat of a Skrull invasion and the mistrust it has sewn, Spider-Woman switching sides, and on top of that having to deal with both the Venom Bomb (from the Mighty Avengers' second arc) and also having to deal with the Hood and his super-team of villains. It was a very packed arc, for better or for worse.
On one hand I do appreciate how well this volume ties Civil War to Secret Invasion; on the other hand I think there were quite a lot of missteps. First of all, I think the sudden bout of mistrust, especially on Luke Cage's part, was a bit too forced. I could see how he'd act like that with a baby to protect and all, but it just felt too out of character to me. I think Bendis should've eased into it instead of just bombarding us with sudden drama. Another Bendis misstep was spending almost an entire issue recycling writing from his Mighty Avengers Venom Bomb arc. I was reading both volumes interchangeably and the one crossover issue was just a flat-out lazy retelling of the events of Mighty Avengers. There was also another issue where all the villains were just talking without much happening, which would be fine and all if these villains were to stick around a bit longer, but with Secret Invasion coming in after this, I doubt they will. And how many times has Doctor Strange died in the past couple arcs? Twice now? C'monnnnn. Despite all my complaints, there were some decent bits of good writing here and there though.
The art was also a mixed bag. I like Leinil Yu most of the time, and this is no different. He did a pretty good job through most of this, but it did get messy at times. Coloring by Dave McCaig is quite the treat, and really helps Yu's pencils stand out. Also a huge kudos to the artist for the annual (Pagulayan); that huge brawl must have been a pain in the ass to draw, but he really knocked it out of the park.
Overall a good arc, all things considered. Still enjoying New Avengers over Mighty Avengers by a long shot.