What do you think?
Rate this book
A Shore Thing
The BRAND NEW gorgeously funny romantic comedy from MULTI-MILLION COPY bestseller Portia MacIntosh, perfect for fans of Love Island, Christina Lauren and Tessa Bailey! 🏝️🌞💖 🏝️ Workplace romance 🏝️ Enemies to lovers 🏝️ Fake dating 🏝️ Forced proximity 🏝️ Reality TV show 🏝️ Caribbean island setting
Lights. Camera...Showmance!
From the moment Cleo met Lockie, her infuriatingly charming co-casting producer on hit reality show Welcome to Singledom, he’s been getting under her skin. Their job? Casting singles for the ultimate island romance. Their problem? They can’t agree on anything.
Now, the cameras are ready to roll, and the contestants—well, most of them—are en route. But when the threat of a tropical storm delays half the cast, launch night turns into a total disaster. With no Plan B, Cleo and Lockie are forced to step in as contestants. Just for 24 hours until the real stars arrive.
Simple, right? Except tensions are sky-high and sparks are flying for all the wrong reasons! All they have to do is couple-up and get voted off - but there’s a storm coming, so leaving the island might not be so easy. Cleo’s used to pulling strings behind the scenes, not falling headfirst into the drama.
But when the cameras stop rolling, will their fake fling fade with the credits—or could it be Cleo’s most unexpected plot twist yet?
Escape to paradise with a laugh-out-loud, gorgeous forced proximity with your rival romance from MILLION-COPY bestseller Portia MacIntosh
💖 Praise for Portia 💖
'Smart, funny and always brilliantly entertaining, every book from Portia becomes my new favourite rom com.' Shari Low
'I laughed, I cried - I loved it.’ Holly Martin
'The queen of rom com!' Rebecca Raisin
‘This is one of the easiest 5 stars I have given’ Reader Review
‘Portia Macintosh knows how to add the perfect amount of humor, current pop culture reference, and setting to make every rom-com an absolute joy to read!’ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Reader Review
‘If you're looking for a feel-good read that will make you laugh, swoon, and maybe even shed a tear, "Wish You Weren't Here" is a must-read. Highly recommend!’ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Reader Review
Lights. Camera...Showmance!
From the moment Cleo met Lockie, her infuriatingly charming co-casting producer on hit reality show Welcome to Singledom, he’s been getting under her skin. Their job? Casting singles for the ultimate island romance. Their problem? They can’t agree on anything.
Now, the cameras are ready to roll, and the contestants—well, most of them—are en route. But when the threat of a tropical storm delays half the cast, launch night turns into a total disaster. With no Plan B, Cleo and Lockie are forced to step in as contestants. Just for 24 hours until the real stars arrive.
Simple, right? Except tensions are sky-high and sparks are flying for all the wrong reasons! All they have to do is couple-up and get voted off - but there’s a storm coming, so leaving the island might not be so easy. Cleo’s used to pulling strings behind the scenes, not falling headfirst into the drama.
But when the cameras stop rolling, will their fake fling fade with the credits—or could it be Cleo’s most unexpected plot twist yet?
Escape to paradise with a laugh-out-loud, gorgeous forced proximity with your rival romance from MILLION-COPY bestseller Portia MacIntosh
💖 Praise for Portia 💖
'Smart, funny and always brilliantly entertaining, every book from Portia becomes my new favourite rom com.' Shari Low
'I laughed, I cried - I loved it.’ Holly Martin
'The queen of rom com!' Rebecca Raisin
‘This is one of the easiest 5 stars I have given’ Reader Review
‘Portia Macintosh knows how to add the perfect amount of humor, current pop culture reference, and setting to make every rom-com an absolute joy to read!’ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Reader Review
‘If you're looking for a feel-good read that will make you laugh, swoon, and maybe even shed a tear, "Wish You Weren't Here" is a must-read. Highly recommend!’ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Reader Review
260 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 26, 2026
205 people are currently reading
248 people want to read
About the author
Portia MacIntosh
55 books2,124 followersPortia MacIntosh is the bestselling author of over 30 romantic comedy novels.
From disastrous dates to destination weddings, Portia’s romcoms are the perfect way to escape from day to day life, visiting sunny beaches in the summer and snowy villages at Christmas time. Whether it’s southern Italy or the Yorkshire coast, Portia’s stories are the holiday you’re craving, conveniently packed in between the pages.
Formerly a journalist, Portia has left the city, swapping the music biz for the moors, to live the (not so) quiet life with her husband and her dog in Yorkshire.
Find out more at www.portiamacintosh.com
From disastrous dates to destination weddings, Portia’s romcoms are the perfect way to escape from day to day life, visiting sunny beaches in the summer and snowy villages at Christmas time. Whether it’s southern Italy or the Yorkshire coast, Portia’s stories are the holiday you’re craving, conveniently packed in between the pages.
Formerly a journalist, Portia has left the city, swapping the music biz for the moors, to live the (not so) quiet life with her husband and her dog in Yorkshire.
Find out more at www.portiamacintosh.com
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 158 reviews
February 6, 2026
3.5 stars
Portia Macintosh is an auto buy author for me, simply because whenever I pick up one of her books, I know I'm in for an enjoyable, light hearted, fun, easy read and yet again she delivered.
I enjoyed this right from the start and I was immediately drawn in by the familiar, easy writing style.
This was definitely a book where I liked all the characters. I really did like both our MC's Cleo and Lockie. I liked their banter and connection and I enjoyed watching their relationship develop.
One thing that I really liked about this book was the reality TV aspect. I don't read a lot of books based around that, so this felt like a pleasant change for me.
I felt the pacing was great, the plot and the characters relationship developed at just the right pace.
One very slight thing I wasn't that big a fan of was the ending. To me it did feel slightly rushed after all the build up, so that was a little disappointing.
However, if you are looking for a fun, light hearted, quick, easy to read book, that you can read in one sitting, you should definitely pick this up.
This definitely lived up to my high opinion of Portia Macintosh and I will definitely read from her again.
Thanks to Boldwood Books for the ARC I received in exchange for an honest review
Portia Macintosh is an auto buy author for me, simply because whenever I pick up one of her books, I know I'm in for an enjoyable, light hearted, fun, easy read and yet again she delivered.
I enjoyed this right from the start and I was immediately drawn in by the familiar, easy writing style.
This was definitely a book where I liked all the characters. I really did like both our MC's Cleo and Lockie. I liked their banter and connection and I enjoyed watching their relationship develop.
One thing that I really liked about this book was the reality TV aspect. I don't read a lot of books based around that, so this felt like a pleasant change for me.
I felt the pacing was great, the plot and the characters relationship developed at just the right pace.
One very slight thing I wasn't that big a fan of was the ending. To me it did feel slightly rushed after all the build up, so that was a little disappointing.
However, if you are looking for a fun, light hearted, quick, easy to read book, that you can read in one sitting, you should definitely pick this up.
This definitely lived up to my high opinion of Portia Macintosh and I will definitely read from her again.
Thanks to Boldwood Books for the ARC I received in exchange for an honest review
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
I LOVE Portias writing, and this has her signature style.
This was the perfect Caribbean adventure to escape the gloomy January weather.
I really enjoyed the reality show side of the story. I felt asthough I was there on the island. I loved the dynamic between all the islanders and the way each character bought their own strengths. Cleo and Lockie had great chemistry, although Lockies decisions made me a bit mad. I'm glad they found a way past it.
Closed door with intimacy implied
This was the perfect Caribbean adventure to escape the gloomy January weather.
I really enjoyed the reality show side of the story. I felt asthough I was there on the island. I loved the dynamic between all the islanders and the way each character bought their own strengths. Cleo and Lockie had great chemistry, although Lockies decisions made me a bit mad. I'm glad they found a way past it.
Closed door with intimacy implied
did-not-finish
February 1, 2026The beginning of this book was substantially better than the middle and the middle dragged in such a weird way because they get on the island and I’m realizing it’s gonna be very difficult for an author to portray a reality TV set properly in a romcom style and I don’t know how many times I’ve seen that done properly before.
I am realizing that there is a bit of a lack of conflict in this book and really the only conflict that we’re seeing is internal with the protagonist not wanting to be doing anything. She just just reluctant protagonist. We get it.
And then we have a guy that’s pretty cute, but we’re not supposed to like him so there’s tension. Got it.
i’m not sure if it’s because the characters weren’t brought to life enough yet or if it’s a me thing but I’m not finding myself wanting to pick this back up and reading it so I’m gonna give it one more chapter or two more chapters. See if it gets any better and that I might be enough this book around 60% because life is too short but also a 60% DNF just feels icky for some reason
If I made it more than halfway through the book, it usually try to just get through the last half but every time that I find that I do that the book doesn’t really get better so just hitting the progress bar might not be worth it
I think a big part of this is the lack of description of the island beyond very vague things, but we aren’t getting the full picture of what this island looks like.
I think it could’ve been really brought to life with a more lush description of what it feels and smells like because all I’m getting is that she doesn’t wanna sleep on her back and I understand like the survival shows technically what they look like, but I don’t feel like I’m putting a “helmet” on?
OK, I’m realizing what it is now there were like 15+ jokes thrown into the first three chapters and then right now we’re just in the protagonist internal conflict which I get it. She’s on an island and she doesn’t wanna be there and that point has been made clear, but it feels like that point is being nailed into a wall so hard that I was a reader. I’m getting tired of the book.
this is a DNF at 66% because I’m seeing that a lot of this book is kinda fluff and there’s just something about it that feels like there wasn’t a lot of love poured into the story and it’s just kind of being put on the shelves if I’m being totally honest? i do not mean that in a harsh way, just my perception
I might pick this book back up at some point, but I’m just not connecting with this one which is weird because I literally love trashy reality TV so much
I think it’s just because there’s like zero jokes thrown in. It’s not engaging or intriguing to me unfortunately
February 5, 2026
Turns out reading a fictionalised Love Island-esque novel is far more entertaining than watching the real thing!
January 30, 2026
Didn't enjoy this one. The story seemed a little silly and predictable to me. The characters weren't likeable either. My thanks to netgalley and the publishers for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
January 30, 2026
I wasn't sure how I was going to feel about reading about a reality TV show, but Portia always creates the best characters and cute happy endings.
Portia, you are my comfort read.
Portia, you are my comfort read.
December 24, 2025
Ehhhh this one wasn’t for me.
I’m a huge fan of reality tv shows, but not particularly Love Island. I thought this sounded like that blended with Survivor and would be fun, but I pretty much hated every character.
Lockie is a terrible MMC. Honestly. I was hoping this would be one of those books where the FMC Cleo decides she is too good for him and forges her own path. Nope. He literally makes the worst decisions and betrays Cleo more times than I can count. The man gives me the ick.
Cleo needed to grow a back bone. Girl, your boss can’t force you to put on a skimpy bikini and try to survive on a deserted island. You could have said no. She’s a pushover and not someone I wanted to cheer for.
If you like Love Island and some simple characters with stupid men, you may like this one. I just couldn’t make it work and click on my head.
*An ARC was received in exchange for an honest review.
I’m a huge fan of reality tv shows, but not particularly Love Island. I thought this sounded like that blended with Survivor and would be fun, but I pretty much hated every character.
Lockie is a terrible MMC. Honestly. I was hoping this would be one of those books where the FMC Cleo decides she is too good for him and forges her own path. Nope. He literally makes the worst decisions and betrays Cleo more times than I can count. The man gives me the ick.
Cleo needed to grow a back bone. Girl, your boss can’t force you to put on a skimpy bikini and try to survive on a deserted island. You could have said no. She’s a pushover and not someone I wanted to cheer for.
If you like Love Island and some simple characters with stupid men, you may like this one. I just couldn’t make it work and click on my head.
*An ARC was received in exchange for an honest review.
January 7, 2026
This is an ARC review. I want to thank Portia MacIntosh and Boldwood Books for allowing me the chance to read this book ahead of release day!
Cleo & Lockie’s love story is so unconventional but I love it! Talk about Survivor meets Love Island at its wildest. While the book didn’t pick up until the show started, once it did…it was hard not to be hooked. The found family dynamic that was created on the island became a huge draw to continue reading. Without their Island Daddy, they would not have made it! He was instrumental on ensuring they enacted the life skills he taught them as well as just did for them.
This was a sweet slow burn romance that has one of my favorite tropes, forced proximity. Nothing is more forced than going into work being told your job duties are now completely different and you’ll be stranded on an island.
This book reminded me that not everyone is who they display to the world. We all have hidden depth to us no matter how shallow or self-centered we act. This is a very sweet romance with some pretty funny moments especially on the island!
Cleo & Lockie’s love story is so unconventional but I love it! Talk about Survivor meets Love Island at its wildest. While the book didn’t pick up until the show started, once it did…it was hard not to be hooked. The found family dynamic that was created on the island became a huge draw to continue reading. Without their Island Daddy, they would not have made it! He was instrumental on ensuring they enacted the life skills he taught them as well as just did for them.
This was a sweet slow burn romance that has one of my favorite tropes, forced proximity. Nothing is more forced than going into work being told your job duties are now completely different and you’ll be stranded on an island.
This book reminded me that not everyone is who they display to the world. We all have hidden depth to us no matter how shallow or self-centered we act. This is a very sweet romance with some pretty funny moments especially on the island!
February 3, 2026
3 stars - perfectly okay rom-com, but not among the author's best work. The writing style is quirky and fun, in true Macintosh -style, the main character was likeable, but the chemistry between her and the male protagonist seemed very sudden and I didn't quite see it. Also the misunderstanding felt a little contrived and very obvious, I wished there had been another, more original obstacle.
The idea for the story was fun though - a reality TV casting-person as the main character, and the way the show turned out was great. But other than that the characters, besides the main character, felt a little underdeveloped.
Fun. But not enough of a story to be memorable. I'll still keep reading Macintosh though as the books are perfect as "palate cleansers" in between heavier books, and even her "less perfect" books never annoy me in the way many rom-coms do.
The idea for the story was fun though - a reality TV casting-person as the main character, and the way the show turned out was great. But other than that the characters, besides the main character, felt a little underdeveloped.
Fun. But not enough of a story to be memorable. I'll still keep reading Macintosh though as the books are perfect as "palate cleansers" in between heavier books, and even her "less perfect" books never annoy me in the way many rom-coms do.
January 1, 2026
Portia is an auto buy author for me so when I saw this on NetGalley I couldn’t not read it. As usual I loved this one. I devoured it and when I wasn’t reading it I was wanting to pick it up and thinking of it.
The joy of the book was Portias humour shining through. I loved both MCs and how real the behind the scenes of the tv industry was written. All the characters added to the story with all their quirks. Cleo and Lockies chemistry was sizzling and jumping off the pages.
Portias writing is always such an easy, enjoyable read. Even though you know what will happen it doesn’t detract from a clean romance written superbly. Another top write from this author and worth investing in.
Thank you NetGalley for this book in exchange of my honest opinion.
The joy of the book was Portias humour shining through. I loved both MCs and how real the behind the scenes of the tv industry was written. All the characters added to the story with all their quirks. Cleo and Lockies chemistry was sizzling and jumping off the pages.
Portias writing is always such an easy, enjoyable read. Even though you know what will happen it doesn’t detract from a clean romance written superbly. Another top write from this author and worth investing in.
Thank you NetGalley for this book in exchange of my honest opinion.
January 29, 2026
This is classic Portia shining through-her writing is always easy breezy and her humor is on point. You know there's going to be a happily ever after, but it doesn't take anything away from the fun of getting there. I always recommend Portia to anyone looking for a good rom-com because she is guaranteed to deliver.
The story behind this one is out of the norm for me because I am not much for reality survival type shows but both the MCs. Cleo and Lockie were full of quirks that made them fun to root for and their chemistry was undeniable. I can only imagine going on a survival type game show like Love Island and then something happens that changes everything for them all. Some of the supporting characters are not super smart but I guess that's to be expected on that type of show but it's a fun look behind the curtain.
If you need an escape from this cold winter, grab this Caribbean adventure!
Thanks to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for this eArc in exchange for my review.
The story behind this one is out of the norm for me because I am not much for reality survival type shows but both the MCs. Cleo and Lockie were full of quirks that made them fun to root for and their chemistry was undeniable. I can only imagine going on a survival type game show like Love Island and then something happens that changes everything for them all. Some of the supporting characters are not super smart but I guess that's to be expected on that type of show but it's a fun look behind the curtain.
If you need an escape from this cold winter, grab this Caribbean adventure!
Thanks to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for this eArc in exchange for my review.
January 30, 2026
I can't think of a better way to shake off the January blues than diving into one of Macintosh's romcoms and being transported off to sunnier climes.
We're off to the Caribbean for a spot of fake dating. Or is it?
Light, fluffy and full of hilarity, A Shore Thing is the perfect escapism and I breezed my way through it in several hours.
Erratic characters, witty banter, and forced proximity, with the vibes of Love Island...can't go wrong with that!
We're off to the Caribbean for a spot of fake dating. Or is it?
Light, fluffy and full of hilarity, A Shore Thing is the perfect escapism and I breezed my way through it in several hours.
Erratic characters, witty banter, and forced proximity, with the vibes of Love Island...can't go wrong with that!
Read
January 25, 2026Fun, flirty, and just a bit off the wall.
I wasn’t convinced of a relationship between Cleo and Lockie but then I don’t think they fit with anyone else either.
Being stuck on an island doesn’t give you a load of choices but it was fun to read about their escapades.
Speed dating works out for some but shouldn’t there be expiration dates?
Thanks Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the early read.
I wasn’t convinced of a relationship between Cleo and Lockie but then I don’t think they fit with anyone else either.
Being stuck on an island doesn’t give you a load of choices but it was fun to read about their escapades.
Speed dating works out for some but shouldn’t there be expiration dates?
Thanks Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the early read.
January 28, 2026
OMG, Portia totally did it again! ☺️ This one has got to be in my top 3 of her books EVER! I mean, seriously, who can resist those adorable witty banter moments, the clingy proximity vibes, and that classic falling-for-each-other storyline? It’s got everything I could ever want in a rom-com! 💖✨ Honestly, it’s hands down my favorite read so far in 2026—can’t get enough! 🎉📚
January 28, 2026
If you love reality tv shows like love island and love tropes like forced proximity, hate to love then this book is perfect for you!
It was an amazing rom com and as always with Portia’s books it wasn’t long enough!
Her writing style makes you feel like you are right there watching the story unfold in real life. It had banter, romance and drama…all the things I love!
It was an amazing rom com and as always with Portia’s books it wasn’t long enough!
Her writing style makes you feel like you are right there watching the story unfold in real life. It had banter, romance and drama…all the things I love!
January 24, 2026
I enjoyed the book nice easy flow.
Tropes: 🏝️ Workplace romance 🏝️ Enemies to lovers 🏝️ Fake dating 🏝️ Forced proximity 🏝️ Reality TV show 🏝️ Caribbean island setting
Lights. Camera...Showmance!
Remind me of love island
Tropes: 🏝️ Workplace romance 🏝️ Enemies to lovers 🏝️ Fake dating 🏝️ Forced proximity 🏝️ Reality TV show 🏝️ Caribbean island setting
Lights. Camera...Showmance!
Remind me of love island
January 28, 2026
3.5 ⭐️
This book had a different vibe than all of her other books, and I wasn’t as invested in this relationship as I usually am. On the positive side, she is so good at creating in depth characters in such short books. Forever a fan of Portia. I’ll read anything she writes.
This book had a different vibe than all of her other books, and I wasn’t as invested in this relationship as I usually am. On the positive side, she is so good at creating in depth characters in such short books. Forever a fan of Portia. I’ll read anything she writes.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Genius.
Ive loved this story so so much. I loved the characters and i just didn't want it to end. As with all of Portia's books, she made me feel like i was there on the island with them.
The ending was brilliant and the twist was very cleverly done.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Ive loved this story so so much. I loved the characters and i just didn't want it to end. As with all of Portia's books, she made me feel like i was there on the island with them.
The ending was brilliant and the twist was very cleverly done.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
This was such a fun book. a clean romance set in a world of reality TV. The mcs were great as well as the supporting characters. I love this author and this book didn't disappoint.
January 30, 2026
📚A Shore Thing
✍🏻Portia MacIntosh
Blurb:
The BRAND NEW gorgeously funny romantic comedy from MULTI-MILLION COPY bestseller Portia MacIntosh, perfect for fans of Love Island, Christina Lauren and Tessa Bailey! 🏝️🌞💖 🏝️ Workplace romance 🏝️ Enemies to lovers 🏝️ Fake dating 🏝️ Forced proximity 🏝️ Reality TV show 🏝️ Caribbean island setting
Lights. Camera...Showmance!
From the moment Cleo met Lockie, her infuriatingly charming co-casting producer on hit reality show Welcome to Singledom, he’s been getting under her skin. Their job? Casting singles for the ultimate island romance. Their problem? They can’t agree on anything.
Now, the cameras are ready to roll, and the contestants—well, most of them—are en route. But when the threat of a tropical storm delays half the cast, launch night turns into a total disaster. With no Plan B, Cleo and Lockie are forced to step in as contestants. Just for 24 hours until the real stars arrive.
Simple, right? Except tensions are sky-high and sparks are flying for all the wrong reasons! All they have to do is couple-up and get voted off - but there’s a storm coming, so leaving the island might not be so easy. Cleo’s used to pulling strings behind the scenes, not falling headfirst into the drama.
But when the cameras stop rolling, will their fake fling fade with the credits—or could it be Cleo’s most unexpected plot twist yet?
Escape to paradise with a laugh-out-loud, gorgeous forced proximity with your rival romance from MILLION-COPY bestseller Portia MacIntosh
💖 Praise for Portia 💖
'Smart, funny and always brilliantly entertaining, every book from Portia becomes my new favourite rom com.' Shari Low
'I laughed, I cried - I loved it.’ Holly Martin
'The queen of rom com!' Rebecca Raisin
‘This is one of the easiest 5 stars I have given’ Reader Review
‘Portia Macintosh knows how to add the perfect amount of humor, current pop culture reference, and setting to make every rom-com an absolute joy to read!’ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Reader Review
‘If you're looking for a feel-good read that will make you laugh, swoon, and maybe even shed a tear, "Wish You Weren't Here" is a must-read. Highly recommend!’ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Reader Review
My Thoughts:
This is my first Portia MacIntosh read to date.When a tropical storm derails their reality dating show, casting producers Cleo and Lockie must pose as contestants. The main characters like each other from the start, they just disagree on certain things, and the female lead is often annoyed by the male lead’s ideas. Lockie and Cleo are interesting, relatable, intriguing characters. I enjoyed their romance and the path it took to get to their HEA. Cleo, a casting producer of a reality TV Show.and her co‑casting producer, Lockie..Then a major storm hits. Communication with the outside world goes down, the cameras go dark, and suddenly the show has to go on—at least until help arrives. What follows is a fun, fast-paced story full of tension, forced proximity, and unexpected connection.The banter, the tension, the slow shift from frustration to feelings—it all felt so natural. I also really loved the character development of the other contestants. A shore thing is a book full of warmth, humor and just a totally pure joy to read.
Thanks NetGalley, Boldwood Books and Author Portia MacIntosh for the complimentary copy of "A Shore Thing" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#NetGalley
#BoldwoodBooks
#PortiaMacIntosh
#AShoreThing
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
✍🏻Portia MacIntosh
Blurb:
The BRAND NEW gorgeously funny romantic comedy from MULTI-MILLION COPY bestseller Portia MacIntosh, perfect for fans of Love Island, Christina Lauren and Tessa Bailey! 🏝️🌞💖 🏝️ Workplace romance 🏝️ Enemies to lovers 🏝️ Fake dating 🏝️ Forced proximity 🏝️ Reality TV show 🏝️ Caribbean island setting
Lights. Camera...Showmance!
From the moment Cleo met Lockie, her infuriatingly charming co-casting producer on hit reality show Welcome to Singledom, he’s been getting under her skin. Their job? Casting singles for the ultimate island romance. Their problem? They can’t agree on anything.
Now, the cameras are ready to roll, and the contestants—well, most of them—are en route. But when the threat of a tropical storm delays half the cast, launch night turns into a total disaster. With no Plan B, Cleo and Lockie are forced to step in as contestants. Just for 24 hours until the real stars arrive.
Simple, right? Except tensions are sky-high and sparks are flying for all the wrong reasons! All they have to do is couple-up and get voted off - but there’s a storm coming, so leaving the island might not be so easy. Cleo’s used to pulling strings behind the scenes, not falling headfirst into the drama.
But when the cameras stop rolling, will their fake fling fade with the credits—or could it be Cleo’s most unexpected plot twist yet?
Escape to paradise with a laugh-out-loud, gorgeous forced proximity with your rival romance from MILLION-COPY bestseller Portia MacIntosh
💖 Praise for Portia 💖
'Smart, funny and always brilliantly entertaining, every book from Portia becomes my new favourite rom com.' Shari Low
'I laughed, I cried - I loved it.’ Holly Martin
'The queen of rom com!' Rebecca Raisin
‘This is one of the easiest 5 stars I have given’ Reader Review
‘Portia Macintosh knows how to add the perfect amount of humor, current pop culture reference, and setting to make every rom-com an absolute joy to read!’ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Reader Review
‘If you're looking for a feel-good read that will make you laugh, swoon, and maybe even shed a tear, "Wish You Weren't Here" is a must-read. Highly recommend!’ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Reader Review
My Thoughts:
This is my first Portia MacIntosh read to date.When a tropical storm derails their reality dating show, casting producers Cleo and Lockie must pose as contestants. The main characters like each other from the start, they just disagree on certain things, and the female lead is often annoyed by the male lead’s ideas. Lockie and Cleo are interesting, relatable, intriguing characters. I enjoyed their romance and the path it took to get to their HEA. Cleo, a casting producer of a reality TV Show.and her co‑casting producer, Lockie..Then a major storm hits. Communication with the outside world goes down, the cameras go dark, and suddenly the show has to go on—at least until help arrives. What follows is a fun, fast-paced story full of tension, forced proximity, and unexpected connection.The banter, the tension, the slow shift from frustration to feelings—it all felt so natural. I also really loved the character development of the other contestants. A shore thing is a book full of warmth, humor and just a totally pure joy to read.
Thanks NetGalley, Boldwood Books and Author Portia MacIntosh for the complimentary copy of "A Shore Thing" I am leaving my voluntary review in appreciation.
#NetGalley
#BoldwoodBooks
#PortiaMacIntosh
#AShoreThing
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Book review: Portia MacIntosh’s A Shore Thing.
Boldwood Books, thank you so much along with NetGalley for my gifted ARC in exchange for an honest review.
There’s something deeply comforting about opening a Portia MacIntosh novel. You know you’re going to laugh, you know there will be chaos, and you know you’ll be rooting for people who swear they absolutely do not want to fall in love. A Shore Thing delivers all of that with a sunburned grin and a knowing wink, dropping the reader straight into the glossy, overproduced world of reality dating TV and then gleefully pulling the curtain back.
Cleo is firmly a behind the scenes woman. She’s a fixer, a planner, and someone who prefers control to spontaneity, which makes her pairing with Lockie, a charming, maddening co casting producer, feel like fate having a laugh. Their dynamic starts off prickly and competitive, the kind where every interaction feels like a sparring match neither wants to lose. When a tropical storm delays half the cast of their dating show and they’re forced to step in as contestants themselves, the story leans fully into forced proximity and fake dating in the most delicious way.
What I really enjoyed here was how self aware the book is. It understands reality TV logic perfectly and plays with it rather than pretending it’s something it’s not. The island setting is escapist without being over described, and the showmance setup gives plenty of room for awkward moments, accidental intimacy, and the slow realization that maybe the person you argue with the most is also the one who sees you most clearly.
The humor is classic Portia MacIntosh. It’s conversational, observational, and often sneaks up on you in throwaway lines that land harder than expected. One quote that perfectly captures the tone is, “It turns out pretending to be in love is dangerously easy when you’re already halfway there.” That blend of wit and warmth is exactly why her books are such reliable comfort reads.
Cleo is a strong, capable heroine who feels human rather than polished. She second guesses herself, gets annoyed, and occasionally makes choices driven by emotion instead of logic. Lockie, while flawed, fits the rom com mold of a man who has a lot to learn and isn’t always great at communicating. Their relationship development feels earned through proximity and shared experience rather than grand gestures, which made the romance more satisfying for me.
This isn’t a high drama, twist heavy story, and it doesn’t need to be. The joy here comes from the banter, the setting, and the familiar yet cozy beats of a rom com done well. It’s the kind of book you read quickly, smile through, and then recommend when someone asks for something fun and escapist.
If you love fake dating, enemies to lovers, workplace romance, and reality TV inspired chaos wrapped in a warm, funny package, this book review confidently recommends A Shore Thing. It’s breezy, charming, and exactly the kind of story you want when you need a mental vacation.
Star rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (4 out of 5 stars)
#AShoreThing #PortiaMacIntosh #BookReview #RomanticComedy #NetGalley #BoldwoodBooks #FakeDatingRomance #EnemiesToLovers #RealityTVRomance #RomComReads #2026Books
Boldwood Books, thank you so much along with NetGalley for my gifted ARC in exchange for an honest review.
There’s something deeply comforting about opening a Portia MacIntosh novel. You know you’re going to laugh, you know there will be chaos, and you know you’ll be rooting for people who swear they absolutely do not want to fall in love. A Shore Thing delivers all of that with a sunburned grin and a knowing wink, dropping the reader straight into the glossy, overproduced world of reality dating TV and then gleefully pulling the curtain back.
Cleo is firmly a behind the scenes woman. She’s a fixer, a planner, and someone who prefers control to spontaneity, which makes her pairing with Lockie, a charming, maddening co casting producer, feel like fate having a laugh. Their dynamic starts off prickly and competitive, the kind where every interaction feels like a sparring match neither wants to lose. When a tropical storm delays half the cast of their dating show and they’re forced to step in as contestants themselves, the story leans fully into forced proximity and fake dating in the most delicious way.
What I really enjoyed here was how self aware the book is. It understands reality TV logic perfectly and plays with it rather than pretending it’s something it’s not. The island setting is escapist without being over described, and the showmance setup gives plenty of room for awkward moments, accidental intimacy, and the slow realization that maybe the person you argue with the most is also the one who sees you most clearly.
The humor is classic Portia MacIntosh. It’s conversational, observational, and often sneaks up on you in throwaway lines that land harder than expected. One quote that perfectly captures the tone is, “It turns out pretending to be in love is dangerously easy when you’re already halfway there.” That blend of wit and warmth is exactly why her books are such reliable comfort reads.
Cleo is a strong, capable heroine who feels human rather than polished. She second guesses herself, gets annoyed, and occasionally makes choices driven by emotion instead of logic. Lockie, while flawed, fits the rom com mold of a man who has a lot to learn and isn’t always great at communicating. Their relationship development feels earned through proximity and shared experience rather than grand gestures, which made the romance more satisfying for me.
This isn’t a high drama, twist heavy story, and it doesn’t need to be. The joy here comes from the banter, the setting, and the familiar yet cozy beats of a rom com done well. It’s the kind of book you read quickly, smile through, and then recommend when someone asks for something fun and escapist.
If you love fake dating, enemies to lovers, workplace romance, and reality TV inspired chaos wrapped in a warm, funny package, this book review confidently recommends A Shore Thing. It’s breezy, charming, and exactly the kind of story you want when you need a mental vacation.
Star rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ (4 out of 5 stars)
#AShoreThing #PortiaMacIntosh #BookReview #RomanticComedy #NetGalley #BoldwoodBooks #FakeDatingRomance #EnemiesToLovers #RealityTVRomance #RomComReads #2026Books
January 11, 2026
A Shore Thing was my first book to read from this author, although I'd heard good things about her from fellow readers. I will say, I'm really torn about my review of this book. I generally really enjoy the workplace rivals-to-lovers kind of trope, and the premise of a reality show gone wrong was really interesting. And it's not every day that you get a triple-twist! Although I think that initially the prose was a little heavy with how very in-the-FMC's-head we were, I enjoyed the first 90% of this book. Then, in my view, the wheels fell off.
Because around the 90% mark is when the key conflict happens, but then it resolves itself in a mere handful of pages, and it's a race to the HEA. The race to the end means that the whole situation felt very superficial. That would be problem enough, but it was also wildly infuriating. Because you see, we spent quite a bit of the book very in-the-mind of the FMC, so we're very clear on how little she trusts, and precisely how she *should* handle lies, betrayal, and manipulation of herself and everyone else involved based on what we know about her character. But how she *should* show up in this situation--a strong, sure-of-herself woman who demands accountability for the lies, betrayal and manipulation against herself and all the others--is precisely the opposite of what happens: instaforgiveness. That would be bad enough, but then she goes on to say she should have been more trusting of the person who lied, betrayed, and manipulated her (I was wrong about this small thing, therefore I forgive you for this huge thing??). And to make matters worse, we actually know so little about the MMC (apart from a rather terse suggestion that he's been too married to his work) that I really have no basis to think he deserves either the understanding or the forgiveness, insta- or otherwise. Did he actually learn anything? Is he really sorry? Or just sorry he got caught?
If the story hadn't tripped on the resolution, I would be giving this book 5 stars. And I will definitely be giving this author another try for the sake of the 90% of this one I enjoyed. In my view, A Shore Thing was a good story that just didn't stick the landing.
Thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for an ARC in exchange for my honest assessment of this work.
Because around the 90% mark is when the key conflict happens, but then it resolves itself in a mere handful of pages, and it's a race to the HEA. The race to the end means that the whole situation felt very superficial. That would be problem enough, but it was also wildly infuriating. Because you see, we spent quite a bit of the book very in-the-mind of the FMC, so we're very clear on how little she trusts, and precisely how she *should* handle lies, betrayal, and manipulation of herself and everyone else involved based on what we know about her character. But how she *should* show up in this situation--a strong, sure-of-herself woman who demands accountability for the lies, betrayal and manipulation against herself and all the others--is precisely the opposite of what happens: instaforgiveness. That would be bad enough, but then she goes on to say she should have been more trusting of the person who lied, betrayed, and manipulated her (I was wrong about this small thing, therefore I forgive you for this huge thing??). And to make matters worse, we actually know so little about the MMC (apart from a rather terse suggestion that he's been too married to his work) that I really have no basis to think he deserves either the understanding or the forgiveness, insta- or otherwise. Did he actually learn anything? Is he really sorry? Or just sorry he got caught?
If the story hadn't tripped on the resolution, I would be giving this book 5 stars. And I will definitely be giving this author another try for the sake of the 90% of this one I enjoyed. In my view, A Shore Thing was a good story that just didn't stick the landing.
Thanks to NetGalley and Boldwood Books for an ARC in exchange for my honest assessment of this work.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
3,5/5, maybe. As general fiction/comedy it’s fun, but as a romance, it’s a no from me.
Don't get me wrong, it was a nice read, I didn't actively dislike going back to it every time I had to take a break - it was quite entertaining. I really liked the premise, and the main character (outside of her taste in men and lack of a spine) was cool. The writing was good, and the plot twists, too.
So, what was wrong?
Well, in order for something to work as a romance, you need to convince me that I want the main couple to be together and that there is enough chemistry between them that they would and should end up together long-term.
I did not want them to be together or believe they would make it.
I didn't like the MMC, hadn't from almost the very start and my feelings - unfortunately - only solidified. His actions weren't redeemable and he was no better than the FMC's ex (actually actively worse because he screwed her over on more accounts than the one time at the beginning when they were still in the office portion of the story). The explanations provided from him were so flimsy and not enough that my brain didn't even compute them. I'm still mad he did everything he did.
Besides that, I don't think there was really anything between them outside of maybe some physical chemistry. There's no reason why a woman like Cleo would like him, especially not enough for them to be an actual, for-life couple. It reads like a fling, a few-months-long relationship before you realize the person you're with doesn't match you, has different values and outlook on life, and you're not compatible enough for forever, even if some parts feel good.
At one point, I really wanted there to be a plot-twist, so she'd end up with the other contestant, or - at the finish line - to stay alone. Unfortunately - and I guess that's a spoiler, sorry - she doesn't. There is a 'happy' ending there.
So yeah, I pretty much enjoyed most of it, but I cannot give it more than 3,5 stars, because it is supposed to be a romance, and I did not like that part.
Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for letting me read the ARC!
Don't get me wrong, it was a nice read, I didn't actively dislike going back to it every time I had to take a break - it was quite entertaining. I really liked the premise, and the main character (outside of her taste in men and lack of a spine) was cool. The writing was good, and the plot twists, too.
So, what was wrong?
Well, in order for something to work as a romance, you need to convince me that I want the main couple to be together and that there is enough chemistry between them that they would and should end up together long-term.
I did not want them to be together or believe they would make it.
I didn't like the MMC, hadn't from almost the very start and my feelings - unfortunately - only solidified. His actions weren't redeemable and he was no better than the FMC's ex (actually actively worse because he screwed her over on more accounts than the one time at the beginning when they were still in the office portion of the story). The explanations provided from him were so flimsy and not enough that my brain didn't even compute them. I'm still mad he did everything he did.
Besides that, I don't think there was really anything between them outside of maybe some physical chemistry. There's no reason why a woman like Cleo would like him, especially not enough for them to be an actual, for-life couple. It reads like a fling, a few-months-long relationship before you realize the person you're with doesn't match you, has different values and outlook on life, and you're not compatible enough for forever, even if some parts feel good.
At one point, I really wanted there to be a plot-twist, so she'd end up with the other contestant, or - at the finish line - to stay alone. Unfortunately - and I guess that's a spoiler, sorry - she doesn't. There is a 'happy' ending there.
So yeah, I pretty much enjoyed most of it, but I cannot give it more than 3,5 stars, because it is supposed to be a romance, and I did not like that part.
Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for letting me read the ARC!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Originally reviewed for Chick Lit Central (www.chicklitcentral.com)
This is my favorite Portia MacIntosh read to date! I’m all about a reality TV show-type story, and A Shore Thing offered that up and then some. It felt like it was Survivor meets Love Island, but it offered up even more by giving background information on what happens behind the scenes on a show like Welcome to Singledom.
Cleo wants to take Welcome to Singledom in a direction that would include more “real” contestants; everyday people that the everyday person could relate to and identify with. But Lockie, the new co-casting producer, doesn’t agree. He thinks if it ain’t broke, there’s no reason to change the formula they’ve stuck to since the beginning of the reality show’s inception: bring in the hottest contestants who produce the most drama, creating an exciting environment that will keep a viewer’s attention.
When both Cleo and Lockie are forced to become short-term contestants on the show, both theories are put to the test. Cleo sees herself as a regular, girl-next-door type of gal, while Lockie definitely fits into that “hottie” category. But despite who ends up coming out on top, it doesn’t change the fact that they have to survive the elements on a remote island, with strangers who are all vying to win the show, and the show’s prize money.
I felt like I was part of the reality show chaos. Usually I watch that kind of drama on my tv, but this felt just as exciting and in-depth. From the various contests the contestants have to participate in, to the absolute disconnection from anything in society, it was believable. A Welcome to Singledom show could really exist. While there are plenty of twists and turns that change the outlook Cleo and Lockie have when it comes to their career choices and their time on the island, the formula I have come to enjoy with my reality shows never faltered–it was all there, just as it should be. A Shore Thing was a sure thing, and a five-star experience!
This is my favorite Portia MacIntosh read to date! I’m all about a reality TV show-type story, and A Shore Thing offered that up and then some. It felt like it was Survivor meets Love Island, but it offered up even more by giving background information on what happens behind the scenes on a show like Welcome to Singledom.
Cleo wants to take Welcome to Singledom in a direction that would include more “real” contestants; everyday people that the everyday person could relate to and identify with. But Lockie, the new co-casting producer, doesn’t agree. He thinks if it ain’t broke, there’s no reason to change the formula they’ve stuck to since the beginning of the reality show’s inception: bring in the hottest contestants who produce the most drama, creating an exciting environment that will keep a viewer’s attention.
When both Cleo and Lockie are forced to become short-term contestants on the show, both theories are put to the test. Cleo sees herself as a regular, girl-next-door type of gal, while Lockie definitely fits into that “hottie” category. But despite who ends up coming out on top, it doesn’t change the fact that they have to survive the elements on a remote island, with strangers who are all vying to win the show, and the show’s prize money.
I felt like I was part of the reality show chaos. Usually I watch that kind of drama on my tv, but this felt just as exciting and in-depth. From the various contests the contestants have to participate in, to the absolute disconnection from anything in society, it was believable. A Welcome to Singledom show could really exist. While there are plenty of twists and turns that change the outlook Cleo and Lockie have when it comes to their career choices and their time on the island, the formula I have come to enjoy with my reality shows never faltered–it was all there, just as it should be. A Shore Thing was a sure thing, and a five-star experience!
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
A Shore Thing is a fabulous, funny romantic comedy set on a sun‑soaked Caribbean island. I absolutely loved it. The story was full of sunshine, fun, warmth and charm with great characters. Such a brilliant read with such a clever plot.
The main characters are Cleo, a casting producer and her co‑casting producer, Lockie. Together they produce the reality TV dating show, Welcome to Singledom! Two characters, each with their own strengths, but in their professional life were known to clash more often than not and there always seemed to be an underlying friction.
Unexpected weather shakes things up entirely and sends the whole show off course. But the show has to go on, which meant two contestants were suddenly needed to be found and step in to save the show. The show where couples find love needed a new couple ...
Thank goodness for that unexpected twist as without it, things might never have happened the way they did and I am so glad they did!
Cleo had been carrying so many worries for so long, far more than she ever needed to. Being on the island finally gave her the confidence and the space to let go of some of the weight she was carrying and to open her heart again. Her connection with Lockie reminded her of what is worth letting go, and what is worth fighting for. I loved the gentle, gradual way things unfolded between them.
Amongst the story there was an important message. When life feels heavy, hold on and focus on the good moments because they are the lights that will help you and guide you through the dark.
I am a huge fan of enemies-to-lovers tropes and this was so well written and delivered in every way. I did not want it to end. I raise a coconut to this fantastic 5 star read!
Thank you very much to Boldwood Books, for my advanced copy. This review is based on a NetGalley ARC provided in exchange for an honest and unbiased opinion.
The main characters are Cleo, a casting producer and her co‑casting producer, Lockie. Together they produce the reality TV dating show, Welcome to Singledom! Two characters, each with their own strengths, but in their professional life were known to clash more often than not and there always seemed to be an underlying friction.
Unexpected weather shakes things up entirely and sends the whole show off course. But the show has to go on, which meant two contestants were suddenly needed to be found and step in to save the show. The show where couples find love needed a new couple ...
Thank goodness for that unexpected twist as without it, things might never have happened the way they did and I am so glad they did!
Cleo had been carrying so many worries for so long, far more than she ever needed to. Being on the island finally gave her the confidence and the space to let go of some of the weight she was carrying and to open her heart again. Her connection with Lockie reminded her of what is worth letting go, and what is worth fighting for. I loved the gentle, gradual way things unfolded between them.
Amongst the story there was an important message. When life feels heavy, hold on and focus on the good moments because they are the lights that will help you and guide you through the dark.
I am a huge fan of enemies-to-lovers tropes and this was so well written and delivered in every way. I did not want it to end. I raise a coconut to this fantastic 5 star read!
Thank you very much to Boldwood Books, for my advanced copy. This review is based on a NetGalley ARC provided in exchange for an honest and unbiased opinion.
February 6, 2026
Marketed as Love Island meets Survivor, this book absolutely delivers on that promise. The tropical setting, high-stakes competition, and forced proximity create a compelling backdrop full of tension, strategy, and emotional fireworks. I was completely there for the concept and the messy situations that unfolded as a result of it.
The banter between characters is top notch — sharp, witty, and often the highlight of the book. Fans of Survivor, especially anyone who remembers Ozzy, will immediately recognize the archetype in one of the main male leads. That comparison isn’t subtle, and honestly? It works. I just found myself wanting so much more of the dynamic between Ozzy, Locke, and Chloe. Their interactions had real potential, and I kept waiting for them to be explored more deeply.
Where the book lost me was in the pacing. Several storylines felt rushed, as if they were building toward something meaningful only to be wrapped up abruptly. As a reader, that left me feeling a bit cheated — like emotional investments were made without payoff.
And while I understand the desire to deliver a happily-ever-after, the execution didn’t fully land for me. The resolution felt forced, and in doing so, it slightly undercut the strength of the female lead. It was disappointing because the foundation of her character — and the overall premise — was genuinely interesting and had the potential to land with much more impact.
Overall, A Shore Thing shines in concept and character chemistry, but struggles with pacing and follow-through. It’s an entertaining read, especially for reality TV fans, but one that leaves you wishing it had trusted its own tension just a little bit longer.
If you'd like, I can also:
Make it shorter for Goodreads
Make it spicier/more blunt
Or polish it for Amazon tone specifically
The banter between characters is top notch — sharp, witty, and often the highlight of the book. Fans of Survivor, especially anyone who remembers Ozzy, will immediately recognize the archetype in one of the main male leads. That comparison isn’t subtle, and honestly? It works. I just found myself wanting so much more of the dynamic between Ozzy, Locke, and Chloe. Their interactions had real potential, and I kept waiting for them to be explored more deeply.
Where the book lost me was in the pacing. Several storylines felt rushed, as if they were building toward something meaningful only to be wrapped up abruptly. As a reader, that left me feeling a bit cheated — like emotional investments were made without payoff.
And while I understand the desire to deliver a happily-ever-after, the execution didn’t fully land for me. The resolution felt forced, and in doing so, it slightly undercut the strength of the female lead. It was disappointing because the foundation of her character — and the overall premise — was genuinely interesting and had the potential to land with much more impact.
Overall, A Shore Thing shines in concept and character chemistry, but struggles with pacing and follow-through. It’s an entertaining read, especially for reality TV fans, but one that leaves you wishing it had trusted its own tension just a little bit longer.
If you'd like, I can also:
Make it shorter for Goodreads
Make it spicier/more blunt
Or polish it for Amazon tone specifically
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
Portia MacIntosh is one of those authors I automatically reach for, and A Shore Thing was exactly the kind of fun, feel-good read I was hoping for. I absolutely devoured it—when I wasn’t reading, I was thinking about when I could pick it back up again.
One of the biggest joys of this book is Portia’s humor. It’s light, observant, and woven so naturally into the story that it often sneaks up on you. The behind-the-scenes look at the reality TV world felt surprisingly authentic and added an extra layer of enjoyment. It’s glossy and chaotic on the surface, but the book does a great job of pulling back the curtain and having fun with the absurdity of it all.
Cleo and Lockie were fantastic main characters. Their chemistry crackles from the start, full of banter, tension, and that delicious sense of two people who protest far too much. I loved how their relationship developed through forced proximity and shared experiences rather than big dramatic gestures. The supporting cast was equally entertaining, each character bringing their own quirks and energy to the story.
This is a clean romance, but it never feels bland or boring. Even when you can guess where things are headed, the journey is so enjoyable that it doesn’t matter. Portia’s writing is easy, engaging, and comforting—exactly the kind of book you breeze through with a smile on your face.
Overall, this was such a fun, escapist read. Breezy, charming, and packed with humor, A Shore Thing is another solid win from an author I truly love. Highly recommended if you’re in the mood for a light rom-com with fake dating, workplace tension, and reality TV chaos.
Thank you to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the gifted ARC in exchange for my honest review.
One of the biggest joys of this book is Portia’s humor. It’s light, observant, and woven so naturally into the story that it often sneaks up on you. The behind-the-scenes look at the reality TV world felt surprisingly authentic and added an extra layer of enjoyment. It’s glossy and chaotic on the surface, but the book does a great job of pulling back the curtain and having fun with the absurdity of it all.
Cleo and Lockie were fantastic main characters. Their chemistry crackles from the start, full of banter, tension, and that delicious sense of two people who protest far too much. I loved how their relationship developed through forced proximity and shared experiences rather than big dramatic gestures. The supporting cast was equally entertaining, each character bringing their own quirks and energy to the story.
This is a clean romance, but it never feels bland or boring. Even when you can guess where things are headed, the journey is so enjoyable that it doesn’t matter. Portia’s writing is easy, engaging, and comforting—exactly the kind of book you breeze through with a smile on your face.
Overall, this was such a fun, escapist read. Breezy, charming, and packed with humor, A Shore Thing is another solid win from an author I truly love. Highly recommended if you’re in the mood for a light rom-com with fake dating, workplace tension, and reality TV chaos.
Thank you to Boldwood Books and NetGalley for the gifted ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
2.5 rounded to 3
Unfortunately, this one just wasn’t for me, I could not get myself to like this one despite loving reality TV romances. While the supporting characters were wonderful, I found the MMC to be unlikable. The banter, while good, was mixed with dialogue that at times lacked flow and was difficult to read – though I’m sure that is in no small part from being unaccustomed to the lack of double quotations in the dialogue. The idea of an enemies to lovers plot also felt too rushed to really sink in, leaving it more like an opposites attract than a true enemies to lovers trope.
I agree with other reviewers that the plot was a bit outside the box for me as well. I was excited to read this as a fan of reality TV, but it was hard to understand the world in which producers would be forced to join the show, even just for 24 hours. But perhaps I Just don’t know enough about the behind the scenes. I was also looking for more side plots, as often happens in these types of reality shows, but they were really not present.
This book is definitely best if you’re looking for a rom-com that doesn’t have much heaviness. It is light and fast paced – I was able to finish it in a day – but the lead up to the show also had a bit of a drag. It was easy to push through just because you’re curious as to when it would begin. I was definitely left underwhelmed and looking for more from it, further depths and understanding of the characters and their motivations. I prefer books that allow the readers to really connect with the characters and this one just fell flat. In my opinion, the most well developed part of the book was the setting of the island.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC, all opinions are my own.
Unfortunately, this one just wasn’t for me, I could not get myself to like this one despite loving reality TV romances. While the supporting characters were wonderful, I found the MMC to be unlikable. The banter, while good, was mixed with dialogue that at times lacked flow and was difficult to read – though I’m sure that is in no small part from being unaccustomed to the lack of double quotations in the dialogue. The idea of an enemies to lovers plot also felt too rushed to really sink in, leaving it more like an opposites attract than a true enemies to lovers trope.
I agree with other reviewers that the plot was a bit outside the box for me as well. I was excited to read this as a fan of reality TV, but it was hard to understand the world in which producers would be forced to join the show, even just for 24 hours. But perhaps I Just don’t know enough about the behind the scenes. I was also looking for more side plots, as often happens in these types of reality shows, but they were really not present.
This book is definitely best if you’re looking for a rom-com that doesn’t have much heaviness. It is light and fast paced – I was able to finish it in a day – but the lead up to the show also had a bit of a drag. It was easy to push through just because you’re curious as to when it would begin. I was definitely left underwhelmed and looking for more from it, further depths and understanding of the characters and their motivations. I prefer books that allow the readers to really connect with the characters and this one just fell flat. In my opinion, the most well developed part of the book was the setting of the island.
Thank you to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC, all opinions are my own.
February 7, 2026
This was one of my favorites by PM of her recent books. There were so funny lines, and I laughed out loud multiple times. Then narrator, Karen Cass, is so amazing, I’m so glad she narrates these books.
The premise is that Cleo and Lockie work as co-casting producers for a reality show “Welcome to Singledom” where cast members need to survive on an island while they pair off. The two do not agree on anything with Lockie wanting bring in controversial characters and people who have been on other reality shows, and Cleo is looking for more “real people” who might have more depth than your average social media influencer.
Everything goes a bit off the rails when a storm prevents some of the contestants from getting to the island, so Cleo and Lockie have to step in to make it a total of 8 contestants. The story continues with survival games and splitting into pairs. Lockie has been into Cleo from the beginning of the book, and she is attracted to him, but she keeps resisting him on principle. After a storm hits the island and cuts off all contact with the ship which has the production group, the contestant realize they really are on their own, for a little while at least.
Finally, Cleo and Lockie get together, but then as they are making an attempt to get off the island, Cleo catches Lockie making contact with the shows producers, and realizes that he has been in contact with them and keeping it a secret. The producers have been able to livestream the show without the contestants knowing about it. There is a misunderstanding of sorts, but Lockie has a good explanation, Cleo forgives him, they win the competition, the audience declares them in love, and they quit working on the show. The two end up working on a new TV show together!
The premise is that Cleo and Lockie work as co-casting producers for a reality show “Welcome to Singledom” where cast members need to survive on an island while they pair off. The two do not agree on anything with Lockie wanting bring in controversial characters and people who have been on other reality shows, and Cleo is looking for more “real people” who might have more depth than your average social media influencer.
Everything goes a bit off the rails when a storm prevents some of the contestants from getting to the island, so Cleo and Lockie have to step in to make it a total of 8 contestants. The story continues with survival games and splitting into pairs. Lockie has been into Cleo from the beginning of the book, and she is attracted to him, but she keeps resisting him on principle. After a storm hits the island and cuts off all contact with the ship which has the production group, the contestant realize they really are on their own, for a little while at least.
Finally, Cleo and Lockie get together, but then as they are making an attempt to get off the island, Cleo catches Lockie making contact with the shows producers, and realizes that he has been in contact with them and keeping it a secret. The producers have been able to livestream the show without the contestants knowing about it. There is a misunderstanding of sorts, but Lockie has a good explanation, Cleo forgives him, they win the competition, the audience declares them in love, and they quit working on the show. The two end up working on a new TV show together!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
🏝💘🌩 A Shore Thing by Portia MacIntosh
Genre: Rom Com
Length: 264 pages
Pub Date: Jan. 26, 2026
My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Tropes:
🥥 Enemies-to-lovers
🥥 Destination plot
🥥 Forced Proximity
🥥 Workplace romance
Thank you @NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the e-ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Summary:
Cleo is a single, 31-year old woman who works on/plans the hot reality dating/survival show, Welcome to Singledom. The boss feels the show needs a little refresh and hires Lockie, who has a completely opposite vision for it from Cleo.
When a tropical storm is forecast right before the show taping begins, Cleo and Lockie are forced to go ON the show to fill the slot of contestants who couldn't get there in the bad weather. Now, they're stuck on the island together with four other contestants and have to fake a relationship, but not become liked enough by the public to win the prize money. And then the real storm comes...
Review:
I love reality TV shows, especially those like Love Island, Survivor, and the like. This was a perfect combination of those shows and literally a perfect storm of a plot for the MCs, Cleo and Lockie. The author really knows how to create a hilarious scene, even amidst absolute disaster. I was surprised how much I really enjoyed the four other characters on the show, and I love how each one of them had something great to add to both the story and the group's survival on the island. The enemies-to-lovers trope really shined in this one, and the one-bed+one (read to find out!) was really funny to read. If you love a fun, comedic romance mixed with basic survival instincts, this is a definite winner!
Genre: Rom Com
Length: 264 pages
Pub Date: Jan. 26, 2026
My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Tropes:
🥥 Enemies-to-lovers
🥥 Destination plot
🥥 Forced Proximity
🥥 Workplace romance
Thank you @NetGalley and Boldwood Books for the e-ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.
Summary:
Cleo is a single, 31-year old woman who works on/plans the hot reality dating/survival show, Welcome to Singledom. The boss feels the show needs a little refresh and hires Lockie, who has a completely opposite vision for it from Cleo.
When a tropical storm is forecast right before the show taping begins, Cleo and Lockie are forced to go ON the show to fill the slot of contestants who couldn't get there in the bad weather. Now, they're stuck on the island together with four other contestants and have to fake a relationship, but not become liked enough by the public to win the prize money. And then the real storm comes...
Review:
I love reality TV shows, especially those like Love Island, Survivor, and the like. This was a perfect combination of those shows and literally a perfect storm of a plot for the MCs, Cleo and Lockie. The author really knows how to create a hilarious scene, even amidst absolute disaster. I was surprised how much I really enjoyed the four other characters on the show, and I love how each one of them had something great to add to both the story and the group's survival on the island. The enemies-to-lovers trope really shined in this one, and the one-bed+one (read to find out!) was really funny to read. If you love a fun, comedic romance mixed with basic survival instincts, this is a definite winner!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 158 reviews