Surprising, and like the best poetry elusive.
I wasn’t a bit sure about it at first. A stirring story maybe. But, er, is it a ‘story’, a narrative moving through time? And who is it about and how many characters? I first counted four, but, ah! was it really two? oh no again, maybe essentially just one person’s mind, experience, emotion? Not much time frame either or movement (a little) so could it be a narrative? a moment in time then, or rather across time, obliterating it? a mood, a poem? Best think Browning or Coleridge not Hunger Games or Game of Thrones.
I read it that way, not as at all the usual kind of narrative or love story.
The writing is beautiful. Take the opening – vivid indeed if read in a conventional way: a ballroom of golden chandeliers, silk drapes, the sound of flutes and violins, ethereal lights, a description very nicely written though perhaps nothing especially outstanding about it. Look a bit deeper and read on – is it not a picture of hidden decadence? And the liberated society, site of democracy and freedom, hurray they’re celebrating it and so should we – but, but, here is the shock, a society that has introduced slavery, a society of aristocrats unwilling to get their hands dirty, happy, taking it for granted, to live on the pain of others. And the curse of non-forgiveness. Is this then how it finishes, this triumphant free’d society?
And what of the central characters, Nikolai, the celebrated liberating hero, the one who’d saved them from the wickedness of the banished witch, and Rose, sweet name sweet girl, beautiful? Ah yes, but his hollow eyes are hard, reflecting back the aristocrats’ empty expressions. And have not dictators from Augustus right on to those with us now, ever been those promising to free us from our chains? It’s a dystopian picture – the fashion in fiction that I do not myself warm to - but not, we see, a matter for uncritical celebration.
And she? Obsessed with him, with what he had done, tied in a faustian knot, her dilemma, her fate. And was she perhaps also …
But no spoilers, you must read it. It won’t take you long. A puzzle, yes, at first, but I suspect that, as for me, it will remain with you. What is this life of ours? Perhaps I read too much into it, but I end feeling that in its way it is, finally, a blow, a hope at least, for better, more open, times.
So - compelling and complex but not for everyone