The Plot:
In this second book in the School for Spies series, Max Segredo and his fellow orphans are living at the Merry Sunshine orphanage, which just so happens to be a training school for spies! (In fact, the acronym for the organization running the orphanage is S.P.I.E.S., which stands for Systematic Protection, Intelligence, and Espionage Services.) Max has recently discovered that his father, Simon Segredo, is actually alive and had been working for LOTUS, the enemy organization of S.P.I.E.S. In some ways, Simon has acted as a double agent, by fighting against Max but also helping him in dire moments. In this second installment of the story, Max learns that Simon may have been responsible for Max’s mom’s death.
As the story opens, S.P.I.E.S. is being investigated by a representative from the Ministry of Health, which leads to a number of tense scenes in which the teachers attempt to hide the true nature of the school and make it seem like a safe, normal place for children. (That explosion? That was for Chemistry class! That epic chase during our field trip? They’re filming a movie in town!)
In the middle of all the action, Max is also dealing with a very subtle preteen-friendly love triangle (no kissing, etc.). The new girl, Vespa, is beautiful and flirtatious, but Max already has a complicated, almost-relationship with Cinnabar, and this leads to tension in the orphanage.
In the middle of the investigation, S.P.I.E.S. is also competing against LOTUS to steal a mind-control device. A billionaire named Mr. Elbow is willing to pay very well for this device, which will help the school make enough money to stay open. After Max has used a disguise to break into a building to successfully steal the device, he and most of the rest of S.P.I.E.S. (along with Mr. Elbow) are taken captive by LOTUS. The story ends with the revelation that Vespa is a traitor from LOTUS and Max’s two friends (including his sort-of-crush) realizing that they are the ones who will have to save him!
The Characters:
Thicker than Water boasts a large, diverse cast of characters, but they feel a bit stereotypical. Because there are so many characters, the use of the stereotypes almost seems like a device to help the reader to keep track of everyone. Many of the characters come off as cartoonish and one-note, but this works well enough with the story’s larger-than-life, unrealistic plot. Max deals with some degree of inner struggle and conflicting motivations, which makes him slightly more interesting than the other characters. There is little intrigue and suspense regarding characters, as the plot twist regarding Vespa being untrustworthy was obvious from the beginning.
Overall Evaluation:
Pre-teens/Young teens will enjoy reading about Max’s adventures in espionage, and the gentle hints of romance along with the cliffhanger ending will give readers something to look forward to in future books in the series. Though the story is completely unrealistic and unbelievable, it’s also fun and entertaining, and will provide young readers with a nice escape from reality.