So I actually have more questions at the end of this volume than the first one. It's a little bit disappointing, because I had thought this was gearing up to be a favorite series, but this installment was pretty average.
It didn't feel like there was a lot of actual development in their relationship. I'd loved the scene by the river so much and had been expecting more like that, with them bonding in concrete ways over time. There's some of that implied but we go straight into some heavier drama instead, with Arikawa answering Misaki's phone while he's out of the lab, and having a brief and unsettling conversation with the guy who'd given Misaki the necklace.
That leads to an argument with a deeply embarrassed Misaki, then to Arikawa walking home in the rain, then to Misaki visiting a fever-sick Arikawa at home. (Because in manga, every time you walk outside without an umbrella, you come down with a romantically convenient fever. Kinda like Jane Austen I guess.)
I did like the scene with Arikawa trying to return Misaki's necklace, Misaki hyperventilating at the memories connected to it, and the two of them clinging to each other and expressing a little bit of their feelings for each other. Friendship-wise, anyway, without bringing romance into it just yet.
The backstory was kind of disappointing and disjointed, though.
When Misaki's parents died in an accident, he was taken in by his grandfather, a botany professor who was cold and stern and didn't really speak with Misaki much. Kawabata, the mysterious caller, was a research student who started coming by often, to speak with Misaki's grandfather and eventually to tutor Misaki. This led to Misaki having a better relationship with his grandfather, since he developed an interest in botany, too, and was eventually given the key to his grandfather's cherished greenhouse.
Then Misaki's grandfather died suddenly, leaving Misaki alone again...except for Kawabata, who embraced and kissed him and gave him a necklace and promised he'd always be there to take care of him. Misaki's brotherly admiration subsequently flared into romantic interest.
But that didn't lead to an actual relationship.
I get why: there's the age gap, of course, but, for Kawabata, it's more important that he absolutely cannot be in a non-standard relationship. He's already failing to live up to his family's high expectations, and dating a man would ruin things irrevocably for him. So he goes out and starts dating the first girl who shows some interest in him, cruelly introduces her to Misaki, and establishes himself as an overprotective older brother. He constantly harasses Misaki, calling him and keeping tabs on his life - not wanting to sully himself by dating a man, but wanting that man to prioritize him above anyone else.
It's a very selfish, one-sided relationship, and I get why Misaki wanted to escape from it. But the timing of it all seems odd to me...it was something like four years of this? And then why did he suddenly reject Kawabata the night of the subway incident, after all that time? How did he even run into Arikawa there, with his necklace already broken?
Like I said, it feels like a lot of important structural questions weren't answered this time around, and I find that frustrating.
Another question: who was that older student from the first volume? I guess it must have been a translation issue, because to me it had sounded more like a mutual thing - establishing that Misaki is gay - but at the beginning of this volume, Arikawa referred to it as an assault, which changes the circumstances dramatically and also introduces a lot of unnecessary complications to Misaki's story. Why are a bunch of random older men trying to take advantage of him? Just because he has a delicate build and a pretty face?
And I still don't get what the lab professor's connection to Arikawa is, or why he'd mentioned Misaki-sensei if Misaki doesn't have any family left. Maybe another translation gap, where he'd been talking about a responsibility to a deceased friend/colleague, and not someone he would actively be speaking with about the younger Misaki's day-to-day life. But that connection isn't shown or referred to again.
Also a little disappointed in the dramatic and entirely coincidental way Arikawa and Misaki finally started up their relationship, with Kawabata just happening to be in the subway station the day Arikawa left the lab and Misaki chased after him. Unless Kawabata has a tracker on his phone or something, but I think that's beyond the logical scope of this story.
Still have some hope for the third volume, and it's not that this is a bad series. I was just hoping the storyline would be stronger and less full of pretty basic tropes.
Plus, the magical-seeming dreams still aren't explained. Even if they did meet once, or a few times, as kids, that's not really enough to explain any of this - especially since it doesn't seem like Arikawa learned Misaki's name in the playground sandbox, either.