⭐⭐.5
Pre-Read Notes:
Love this publishing house, so it was an easy choice. Besides that, I'm a sucker for a good topographical map, so this cover undid me.
"She has spent the majority of her life without a cell phone, never needing one until ten or so years ago, and even then, she never thought she needed it. But now, seeing her daughter’s belongings without her daughter, she needs it, desperately." p158
Final Review
(thoughts & recs) Some 300 page books, I can read in an afternoon or maybe over two of them. And some 300 page books feel like they take *forever* usually as a matter of form or style. This is one of the latter.
For me, it's an issue of irregular pacing and a thin plot. Together with clarity issues, these problems really affected my enjoyment. For most of the book I needed higher stakes, and then once at least emotional stakes were worth investing in, the book was three quarters of the way done, and I was wondering how the writer had the space to fit in everything the story needed.
Also-- and this is such a weird quibble-- Boland doesn't seem comfortable here with her pronoun use, particularly in paragraphs in which the daughter (Bea) describes thoughts and beliefs belonging to the mom (Christy). I found it both horribly confusing and sometimes a real challenge to figure out who is doing what with the verb in any given sentence.
Don't expect resolution for any aspects of the story here, because it doesn't come. I've never read a book that used so many words to say "This is all you get."
I think this book will be a win for some readers, since most of my complaints are a matter of style. I recommend it to fans of
My Favorite Things:
✔️ "Look, people make shit up all the time. We’re all a bunch of filthy liars. White lies, big lies, anonymous sources, self-checkout, dating profiles, cover letters, orgasms, calories, taxes. We can lie about everything and we do." p9 Don't miss the preface. These are the opening sentences. This section works well as a work-in to a very unique style. "People make shit up all the time, but sooner or later, the storm comes. It always does." p15
✔️ "Bea considered what it would mean to tell Christy about her job, her finances. Their finances. Her mother might wave her off, tell her they’d be burritos in the meantime, it was no big deal. But it was. It was her career. It was her life. Their life. And her mother seemed happy. A bit delusional, sure , but aren’t all happy people deluded?" p47 A lot of casual ableism in this book, but that's not that surprising, given the character details.
✔️ Boland is quite gifted with the long metaphor, like the one you'll find on nuclear fallout on the first 5 pages of Section 2. They aren't always clearly anchored to the story, so their subtext isn't always immediately clear.
Notes Content: financial ruin, fraud, credit cards, bankruptcy, stalking, mother-daughter conflict, gender bias, being lost, missing loved one, political rally, guns,
Thank you to Kathleen Boland, Viking, and NetGalley for an accessible digital arc of SCAVENGERS. All views are mine.