The three issues of Sebastian O were an impulse buy on Free Comic Book Day. I knew nothing about the series or Grant Morrison, but the promise of steampunk Oscar Wilde drew me in like nothing else. Unfortunately, the story didn't hold up to expectations.
In a Victorian London infused with clockwork technology, Lord Lavender, the Queen's advisor (fixer? prime minister?), has won. He's jailed or flipped all the members of the notorious Club de Paradis Artificiel. Part Hellfire Club, part scientific community, these scandalous club members were queer inventors and artists who rejected the "dirty natural" reality in favor of the "clean unnatural" lines of artificiality. And they're not taking their defeat lying down. The bulk of the comic is Sebastian O, the club's ringleader, breaking out of Bedlam and wrecking his revenge on Lord Lavender, despite Lavender's assassins and machinations. All while looking quite fashionable, of course.
From the first page, I felt a little off-kilter with this book. The bloody revenge story was a surprise, since the cover art suggested well-mannered triumph with perhaps a dash of boxing. Stuff reminiscent of Dorian Gray and Holmes vs Moriarty. I don't mind a story where queer people take visceral revenge on those who wronged them, but Morrison's was poorly done. The world-building is sloppy and uneven. A gay character is a pedophile. Sebastian is supposed to be our amoral gay hero, but he has his maids disrobe while he bathes, spouts toxic clasist trite, and shows little to no compassion towards the club members he says he cares about. Lavender is evil and insane. Other club members are brutally murdered and silenced. The only well-done characters are a lesbian couple, who provide the sole redeeming bits of humor.
Honestly, the comic feels like it was written, inked, colored, and created for and by straight people. Those creators may be fans of Oscar Wilde, steampunk, and the Victorian era, but fannish predilection isn't enough for a good story homage. I finished the comic with a bad taste in my mouth and feeling not a little insulted. I can't say I recommend Sebastian O to anybody.