What do you think?
Rate this book
Our Brains, Our Selves
WINNER OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY TRIVEDI SCIENCE BOOK PRIZE
A FINANCIAL TIMES, THE TIMES AND GUARDIAN BEST SCIENCE BOOK OF 2025
What makes us who we are? Is it our background that creates our identities? Or our families, where we lived, how we were brought up and educated, the jobs we’ve held? Yes, all of the above, but more fundamental than any of these is our brain.
This is never more evident than if we lose even a single one of our cognitive abilities. People who develop a brain disorder can find that their identity, their sense of self, can undergo dramatic changes. Through the stories of seven of his patients, acclaimed Oxford University neurologist Masud Husain shows us how our brains create our identity, how that identity can be changed, and sometimes even be restored. Among the people we encounter is a man who ran out of words, a woman who stopped caring what others thought of her and another who, losing her memory, started to believe she was having an affair with the man who was really her husband.
These compelling human dramas reveal how our identities are created by different functions within the brain. They show how modern neuroscience can help to explain the changes in behaviour that occur when our perception, attention, memory, motivation or empathy are altered. By understanding how our brains normally function, neurologists are bringing hope to patients with brain disorders and illuminating the human experience. The resulting journey will ignite new ideas about who we really are and why we act in the ways we do.
A FINANCIAL TIMES, THE TIMES AND GUARDIAN BEST SCIENCE BOOK OF 2025
What makes us who we are? Is it our background that creates our identities? Or our families, where we lived, how we were brought up and educated, the jobs we’ve held? Yes, all of the above, but more fundamental than any of these is our brain.
This is never more evident than if we lose even a single one of our cognitive abilities. People who develop a brain disorder can find that their identity, their sense of self, can undergo dramatic changes. Through the stories of seven of his patients, acclaimed Oxford University neurologist Masud Husain shows us how our brains create our identity, how that identity can be changed, and sometimes even be restored. Among the people we encounter is a man who ran out of words, a woman who stopped caring what others thought of her and another who, losing her memory, started to believe she was having an affair with the man who was really her husband.
These compelling human dramas reveal how our identities are created by different functions within the brain. They show how modern neuroscience can help to explain the changes in behaviour that occur when our perception, attention, memory, motivation or empathy are altered. By understanding how our brains normally function, neurologists are bringing hope to patients with brain disorders and illuminating the human experience. The resulting journey will ignite new ideas about who we really are and why we act in the ways we do.
280 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 13, 2025
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews
May 8, 2025
Husain gives a modern version of Oliver Sacks here, wisely choosing not to update the formula of individual case studies combined with basic medical explanations too much. He is a skilled storyteller, and his subjects come to life. He also covers more common conditions, like Alzheimers, alongside the rarer. He makes a valiant effort to make the book upbeat - we have a few who can resume normal life - despite the somewhat unsettling subject matter. And unlike Sacks, his subjects come from, and are indicative of, modern London, making this feel like a more diverse representation of illness than perhaps we often get. I'm not as sure that the attempts to weave in a sense of time through fleeting references to Syria (incurred by his habit of using a newspaper to help understand how patients percieve the world) worked as well, but I appreciate the attempt. Id you like Sacks, you'll like this, and it would make a handy gift for anyone with a friend diagnosed with dementia or acquired brain injury, for example.
June 3, 2026
Neiroloģijas keisu apraksti (Olivera) Saksa stilā ir viens no maniem mīļākajiem žanriem, un šī grāmata tam ir ļoti foršs papildinājums. Uzsvars uz disfunkciju cilvēcīgo pusi + fonā labi risināta tēma par "es" iekšējo un sociālo veidošanos
February 5, 2026
The author is a neurologist and, following in the footsteps of Sacks, recounts his most interesting clinical cases, placing them in both a neurobiological and historical context. Truly fascinating, and at the same time frightening, of course. Well written and with an eye to making it accessible to non-specialists, without however writing too simplistic or superficial.
L'autore é un neurologo e sulla scia di Sacks, racconta i suoi casi clinici piú interessanti, inquadrandoli sia in un contesto neurobilogico che storico. Veramente molto interessante, e allo stesso tempo spaventoso ovviamente. Ben scritto e con un occhio anche alla facilitá di comprensione da parte dei non adetti, senza peró scivolare nel semplicistico o superficiale.
I received from the Publisher a complimentary digital advanced review copy of the book in exchange for a honest review.
L'autore é un neurologo e sulla scia di Sacks, racconta i suoi casi clinici piú interessanti, inquadrandoli sia in un contesto neurobilogico che storico. Veramente molto interessante, e allo stesso tempo spaventoso ovviamente. Ben scritto e con un occhio anche alla facilitá di comprensione da parte dei non adetti, senza peró scivolare nel semplicistico o superficiale.
I received from the Publisher a complimentary digital advanced review copy of the book in exchange for a honest review.
June 22, 2025
I absolutely loved Our Brains, Our Selves – it felt like a modern-day continuation of the kind of work Oliver Sacks made so compelling (an absolute fave of mine). Masud Husain brings real empathy and clarity to complex neurological conditions, blending vivid patient stories with science in a way that’s both informative and deeply human. From memory loss to delusions and everything in between, each chapter gave me a new appreciation for how fragile and fascinating our brains really are. It’s the kind of book I’ll be recommending to anyone remotely curious about the mind. Insightful and beautifully written.
May 5, 2026
I am a great beater of drums for less obvious book prizes and this deservedly won the Royal Society pop-science Prize last year. Husain is a highly respected Neurologist and Neuroscientist whose book does many things, some of them rather surprising things given the subject matter, extremely well.
The bulk of the book is devoted to chapters each covering a particular patient, Husain's original meeting with them, winkling out the nature of their illness, the history and social context of the illness, potential causes and treatments, and what happened to the patient. It is clear, engrossing on a personal level, complex medical and neurological issues are kept within a layperson's grasp. But the book's British patients are not all white middle class people and their illnesses are seen in the context of their cultural and personal backgrounds. Husain meets their families and friends where we learn what can happen to our social relations when our behaviour changes as a result of neurological conditions (we are not dealing with psychology or psychiatry here) since the book is framed within an individual's need to 'belong' to groups in a social psychology sense. Husain himself came from East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) as a child and discusses his experiences as an immigrant.
Along the way we meet scientists and doctors from previous generations making groundbreaking discoveries, mad King George lll and his doctors, Dr Strangelove, Gabriel García Marquéz, visit the Bedlam madhouse, learn why you don't want to be thought to be possessed by a djinn or have untreated syphalis. And a host of other fascinating titbits.
A generous, humane book which genuinely causes you to ponder what it is to - as the title says - possess a 'self', how this self can be impaired and to what extent this self is simply the function of the grey organ we carry round in our skull or something more metaphysical.
The bulk of the book is devoted to chapters each covering a particular patient, Husain's original meeting with them, winkling out the nature of their illness, the history and social context of the illness, potential causes and treatments, and what happened to the patient. It is clear, engrossing on a personal level, complex medical and neurological issues are kept within a layperson's grasp. But the book's British patients are not all white middle class people and their illnesses are seen in the context of their cultural and personal backgrounds. Husain meets their families and friends where we learn what can happen to our social relations when our behaviour changes as a result of neurological conditions (we are not dealing with psychology or psychiatry here) since the book is framed within an individual's need to 'belong' to groups in a social psychology sense. Husain himself came from East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) as a child and discusses his experiences as an immigrant.
Along the way we meet scientists and doctors from previous generations making groundbreaking discoveries, mad King George lll and his doctors, Dr Strangelove, Gabriel García Marquéz, visit the Bedlam madhouse, learn why you don't want to be thought to be possessed by a djinn or have untreated syphalis. And a host of other fascinating titbits.
A generous, humane book which genuinely causes you to ponder what it is to - as the title says - possess a 'self', how this self can be impaired and to what extent this self is simply the function of the grey organ we carry round in our skull or something more metaphysical.
September 27, 2025
I am forever impressed by how the brain works, and it's fascinating to see what happens when the brain _doesn't_ work.
This book describes seven patients with seven different neurological conditions. I would've loved to see more! The book requires no prior knowledge of the brain/neuroscience. It's written in a very accessible way, with some tidbits of history in there as well. Overall, I really enjoyed this book, and I'd heartily recommend this to anyone who's looking for a solid science read.
This book describes seven patients with seven different neurological conditions. I would've loved to see more! The book requires no prior knowledge of the brain/neuroscience. It's written in a very accessible way, with some tidbits of history in there as well. Overall, I really enjoyed this book, and I'd heartily recommend this to anyone who's looking for a solid science read.
April 13, 2025
This was a relatively straightforward read, and I quite enjoyed the individual stories within each chapter.
Overall it didn’t quite gel for me - a series of individual diagnoses but no more.
Overall it didn’t quite gel for me - a series of individual diagnoses but no more.
May 12, 2025
Engaging, informative, fascinating, great storytelling.
April 27, 2026
Our Brains, Our Selves: What a Neurologist’s Patients Taught Him About the Brain’ by Masud Husain looks at patients with mostly common diseases (e.g. dementia, strokes, Parkinson’s) and through these common neurological disorders – tells us more about the human experience. I loved it and found its case studies great, but also what it reveals about us all.
IDENTITY EMERGES FROM BRAIN SYSTEMS
- At the heart of the book is the idea that our identity arises from the brain. While upbringing, culture, and relationships shape who we become, the brain provides the fundamental biological foundation of the self.
- Rather than being a single unified entity, the “self” is produced by multiple interacting brain systems responsible for memory, motivation, perception, language, and social understanding.
- Through a series of neurological case studies, Husain demonstrates that when one of these systems is disrupted by injury or disease, a person’s behaviour, personality, or sense of identity can change dramatically. These examples challenge the idea of a stable, unchanging self and suggest that identity is a dynamic product of neural processes.
MOTIVATION: THE BRAIN SYSTEMS THAT DRIVE ACTION
- One theme Husain explores is how the brain generates motivation and drive.
- A patient named David develops profound apathy after two small strokes affecting circuits linked to motivation. Although he is not depressed and can still think clearly, he loses the internal drive to initiate action. He stops working, socialising, and even carrying out simple daily activities.
- Husain explains that structures within the basal ganglia, particularly areas like the nucleus accumbens and ventral pallidum, help translate desire into action. When these circuits fail, behaviour loses its internal “push.”
- The case demonstrates that motivation is not simply a matter of willpower or personality; it is rooted in brain function. When doctors targeted the disrupted neural circuits with treatment, David’s motivation partially returned, using drugs similar to those on people with Parkinson’s that working on dopamine systems that drive reward, they show how closely identity is tied to the functioning of specific brain systems.
- On a personal level, I had a close friend who was once the life and soul of a party became a recluse and no longer motivated to meet people and just lived in his place until he recently died of a heart attack – I’ve often wondered what changed him and wondered if he had had a stroke or some form of neurological infarct.
LANGUAGE AND MEANING: HOW THE BRAIN ORGANISES KNOWLEDGE
- Another case examines a patient who speaks fluently but cannot name objects or retrieve specific words. Although his speech appears normal, he struggles to access vocabulary and categories of knowledge.
- Husain links this problem to damage in the left temporal lobe, a region crucial for organising semantic memory—our knowledge of words, concepts, and categories.
- This case illustrates several key points:
- Language relies on networks of meaning rather than isolated words.
- Damage to these networks can disconnect meaning from expression.
- A person may sound fluent while losing important aspects of language identity.
- The story reveals how language is not merely a communication tool but also an important component of how we understand and express who we are.
MEMORY AND THE CONTINUITY OF THE SELF
- Memory plays a central role in maintaining a coherent sense of identity. Husain illustrates this through the story of a woman with severe memory impairment resembling Alzheimer’s disease.
- Because of damage to the hippocampus and related memory systems, she frequently forgets people, events, and relationships. When her memory fails, she sometimes fills in gaps with invented explanations that feel real to her – a phenomenon known as confabulation.
- Husain emphasises that memory is not a perfect recording of the past. Instead, it is constantly reconstructed by the brain. When the systems responsible for storing and retrieving memories break down, the continuity of personal identity also becomes unstable.
- The case shows how memory connects past experiences with the present, helping us maintain a consistent story about who we are.
- Psychologists have long shown that human memory is far more malleable than we tend to believe. Our recollections can be subtly reshaped simply by the way a question is asked. A well known example comes from the experiments of Elizabeth Loftus and John Palmer, who asked students to watch videos of two cars colliding. Afterwards, participants were questioned about the speed of the vehicles—but the verbs used in the questions varied. Those who heard the word “smashed” gave much higher speed estimates than those who heard milder verbs such as “collided,” “bumped,” or “contacted.”
- A week later, the same students were asked whether they remembered seeing broken glass in the footage. None had actually appeared, but the participants who previously heard the verb “smashed” were far more likely to report that broken glass had been present. Their memories had changed, not because of the event itself, but because of how it had been framed to them.
- This kind of distortion has serious real world implications. False memories can be unintentionally created through suggestion, which helps explain why eyewitness testimony is often unreliable. In another study, people viewed an eight second security video and were later asked to identify the gunman from a set of photographs. Every participant chose someone—even though the actual gunman was not in the lineup at all. These findings show how easily normal memory can slip, shift, or fill in gaps.
- Confabulation, which occurs in certain neurological conditions, can be understood as an extreme version of these everyday distortions. People who confabulate are completely convinced by the false memories they produce, and these memories often stem from fragments of real past experiences or things they have recently seen or heard. Research suggests that such patients struggle to distinguish between memories that are relevant to their current reality and those drawn from unrelated or earlier experiences. In essence, they have difficulty identifying the source of a memory—when it happened, where it came from, or whether it belongs to the present moment at all. This “source monitoring” problem blurs the boundaries between genuine recollection and imagined or misplaced information.
PERCEPTION AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF REALITY
- Another theme is that our experience of the world is actively constructed by the brain.
- One patient, Wajid, experiences vivid visual hallucinations such as shadows or faces appearing in his surroundings. Importantly, he recognises that these images are not real.
- Husain uses this case to show that hallucinations can arise from disruptions in visual processing rather than from loss of insight. The story also highlights how different cultures may interpret such experiences in different ways - for example, attributing them to supernatural forces or spirits.
- The case illustrates how perception depends on complex brain processes and how disruptions to those processes can alter a person’s relationship with reality.
ATTENTION AND THE BOUNDARIES OF EXPERIENCE
- Another patient develops spatial neglect following a stroke. Although his vision is intact, he pays attention only to the right side of space and ignores objects or people on his left.
- This condition reveals that perception is not simply about seeing but about attention. The brain must actively select which parts of the environment to process.
- Neglect disorders demonstrate that our subjective experience of the world is shaped by attention networks in the brain. When these networks fail, entire portions of reality can effectively disappear from awareness.
PERSONALITY AND SOCIAL BEHAVIOUR
- Damage to the frontal lobes can dramatically alter personality and social behaviour. Husain describes a woman who becomes impulsive, blunt, and socially inappropriate after frontal lobe damage. She interrupts conversations, speaks without restraint, and struggles to understand how others feel or perceive her comments by others and lacks empathy.
- The frontal lobes are essential for: self-control, empathy, perspective-taking and social judgement.
- Without these regulatory systems, behaviour becomes less inhibited and more impulsive. Although the woman sees herself as newly “liberated,” her relationships deteriorate because the social filters that previously shaped her behaviour have been disrupted.
- This case highlights how personality and moral judgement depend on brain systems that regulate social interaction.
BODY AWARENESS AND THE SENSE OF SELF
- Another patient experiences disturbances in body awareness. She cannot reliably recognise her own limbs unless she looks directly at them.
- This condition reveals the importance of the brain’s body schema—an internal map that allows us to know where our body parts are in space.
- Without this neural representation, even the most basic aspect of identity—our sense of owning and controlling a body - can be disrupted.
SOCIAL IDENTITY AND BELONGING
- Husain also emphasises that identity is not only personal but also social.
- Brain disorders can affect how individuals relate to others, altering friendships, family relationships, and social roles. Stigma surrounding neurological or psychiatric conditions can further reshape a person’s identity, sometimes isolating them from their communities.
- Thus, the self is formed not only within the brain but also within social relationships and cultural interpretations.
THE BOOK’S CENTRAL ARGUMENT
- Across these cases, Husain develops a broader theory of identity.
The self is not a single, unified entity. Instead, it emerges from multiple interacting cognitive systems, including memory, motivation, perception, language, attention, social cognition and body awareness
- When one of these systems fails, aspects of identity may change, but the self rarely disappears entirely. Instead, identity is reshaped.
- Understanding these mechanisms allows clinicians to better support patients and, in some cases, restore disrupted aspects of identity through targeted treatments.
CORE THEMES OF THE BOOK
- Identity is constructed by the brain: Our sense of self emerges from interacting neural systems rather than a single fixed essence.
- Behaviour often has neurological causes: Symptoms such as apathy, hallucinations, neglect, or disinhibition can result from specific brain disruptions rather than purely psychological factors.
- Memory and perception shape our experience of reality: The brain reconstructs memories and actively constructs perception, meaning our sense of reality is continually produced by neural processes.
- Social relationships are central to identity: Brain disorders affect not only internal experience but also how individuals relate to others and participate in society.
- Recovery and adaptation are sometimes possible: When clinicians understand the underlying neural circuit involved, treatments can sometimes restore lost functions or help patients rebuild aspects of their identity.
IDENTITY EMERGES FROM BRAIN SYSTEMS
- At the heart of the book is the idea that our identity arises from the brain. While upbringing, culture, and relationships shape who we become, the brain provides the fundamental biological foundation of the self.
- Rather than being a single unified entity, the “self” is produced by multiple interacting brain systems responsible for memory, motivation, perception, language, and social understanding.
- Through a series of neurological case studies, Husain demonstrates that when one of these systems is disrupted by injury or disease, a person’s behaviour, personality, or sense of identity can change dramatically. These examples challenge the idea of a stable, unchanging self and suggest that identity is a dynamic product of neural processes.
MOTIVATION: THE BRAIN SYSTEMS THAT DRIVE ACTION
- One theme Husain explores is how the brain generates motivation and drive.
- A patient named David develops profound apathy after two small strokes affecting circuits linked to motivation. Although he is not depressed and can still think clearly, he loses the internal drive to initiate action. He stops working, socialising, and even carrying out simple daily activities.
- Husain explains that structures within the basal ganglia, particularly areas like the nucleus accumbens and ventral pallidum, help translate desire into action. When these circuits fail, behaviour loses its internal “push.”
- The case demonstrates that motivation is not simply a matter of willpower or personality; it is rooted in brain function. When doctors targeted the disrupted neural circuits with treatment, David’s motivation partially returned, using drugs similar to those on people with Parkinson’s that working on dopamine systems that drive reward, they show how closely identity is tied to the functioning of specific brain systems.
- On a personal level, I had a close friend who was once the life and soul of a party became a recluse and no longer motivated to meet people and just lived in his place until he recently died of a heart attack – I’ve often wondered what changed him and wondered if he had had a stroke or some form of neurological infarct.
LANGUAGE AND MEANING: HOW THE BRAIN ORGANISES KNOWLEDGE
- Another case examines a patient who speaks fluently but cannot name objects or retrieve specific words. Although his speech appears normal, he struggles to access vocabulary and categories of knowledge.
- Husain links this problem to damage in the left temporal lobe, a region crucial for organising semantic memory—our knowledge of words, concepts, and categories.
- This case illustrates several key points:
- Language relies on networks of meaning rather than isolated words.
- Damage to these networks can disconnect meaning from expression.
- A person may sound fluent while losing important aspects of language identity.
- The story reveals how language is not merely a communication tool but also an important component of how we understand and express who we are.
MEMORY AND THE CONTINUITY OF THE SELF
- Memory plays a central role in maintaining a coherent sense of identity. Husain illustrates this through the story of a woman with severe memory impairment resembling Alzheimer’s disease.
- Because of damage to the hippocampus and related memory systems, she frequently forgets people, events, and relationships. When her memory fails, she sometimes fills in gaps with invented explanations that feel real to her – a phenomenon known as confabulation.
- Husain emphasises that memory is not a perfect recording of the past. Instead, it is constantly reconstructed by the brain. When the systems responsible for storing and retrieving memories break down, the continuity of personal identity also becomes unstable.
- The case shows how memory connects past experiences with the present, helping us maintain a consistent story about who we are.
- Psychologists have long shown that human memory is far more malleable than we tend to believe. Our recollections can be subtly reshaped simply by the way a question is asked. A well known example comes from the experiments of Elizabeth Loftus and John Palmer, who asked students to watch videos of two cars colliding. Afterwards, participants were questioned about the speed of the vehicles—but the verbs used in the questions varied. Those who heard the word “smashed” gave much higher speed estimates than those who heard milder verbs such as “collided,” “bumped,” or “contacted.”
- A week later, the same students were asked whether they remembered seeing broken glass in the footage. None had actually appeared, but the participants who previously heard the verb “smashed” were far more likely to report that broken glass had been present. Their memories had changed, not because of the event itself, but because of how it had been framed to them.
- This kind of distortion has serious real world implications. False memories can be unintentionally created through suggestion, which helps explain why eyewitness testimony is often unreliable. In another study, people viewed an eight second security video and were later asked to identify the gunman from a set of photographs. Every participant chose someone—even though the actual gunman was not in the lineup at all. These findings show how easily normal memory can slip, shift, or fill in gaps.
- Confabulation, which occurs in certain neurological conditions, can be understood as an extreme version of these everyday distortions. People who confabulate are completely convinced by the false memories they produce, and these memories often stem from fragments of real past experiences or things they have recently seen or heard. Research suggests that such patients struggle to distinguish between memories that are relevant to their current reality and those drawn from unrelated or earlier experiences. In essence, they have difficulty identifying the source of a memory—when it happened, where it came from, or whether it belongs to the present moment at all. This “source monitoring” problem blurs the boundaries between genuine recollection and imagined or misplaced information.
PERCEPTION AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF REALITY
- Another theme is that our experience of the world is actively constructed by the brain.
- One patient, Wajid, experiences vivid visual hallucinations such as shadows or faces appearing in his surroundings. Importantly, he recognises that these images are not real.
- Husain uses this case to show that hallucinations can arise from disruptions in visual processing rather than from loss of insight. The story also highlights how different cultures may interpret such experiences in different ways - for example, attributing them to supernatural forces or spirits.
- The case illustrates how perception depends on complex brain processes and how disruptions to those processes can alter a person’s relationship with reality.
ATTENTION AND THE BOUNDARIES OF EXPERIENCE
- Another patient develops spatial neglect following a stroke. Although his vision is intact, he pays attention only to the right side of space and ignores objects or people on his left.
- This condition reveals that perception is not simply about seeing but about attention. The brain must actively select which parts of the environment to process.
- Neglect disorders demonstrate that our subjective experience of the world is shaped by attention networks in the brain. When these networks fail, entire portions of reality can effectively disappear from awareness.
PERSONALITY AND SOCIAL BEHAVIOUR
- Damage to the frontal lobes can dramatically alter personality and social behaviour. Husain describes a woman who becomes impulsive, blunt, and socially inappropriate after frontal lobe damage. She interrupts conversations, speaks without restraint, and struggles to understand how others feel or perceive her comments by others and lacks empathy.
- The frontal lobes are essential for: self-control, empathy, perspective-taking and social judgement.
- Without these regulatory systems, behaviour becomes less inhibited and more impulsive. Although the woman sees herself as newly “liberated,” her relationships deteriorate because the social filters that previously shaped her behaviour have been disrupted.
- This case highlights how personality and moral judgement depend on brain systems that regulate social interaction.
BODY AWARENESS AND THE SENSE OF SELF
- Another patient experiences disturbances in body awareness. She cannot reliably recognise her own limbs unless she looks directly at them.
- This condition reveals the importance of the brain’s body schema—an internal map that allows us to know where our body parts are in space.
- Without this neural representation, even the most basic aspect of identity—our sense of owning and controlling a body - can be disrupted.
SOCIAL IDENTITY AND BELONGING
- Husain also emphasises that identity is not only personal but also social.
- Brain disorders can affect how individuals relate to others, altering friendships, family relationships, and social roles. Stigma surrounding neurological or psychiatric conditions can further reshape a person’s identity, sometimes isolating them from their communities.
- Thus, the self is formed not only within the brain but also within social relationships and cultural interpretations.
THE BOOK’S CENTRAL ARGUMENT
- Across these cases, Husain develops a broader theory of identity.
The self is not a single, unified entity. Instead, it emerges from multiple interacting cognitive systems, including memory, motivation, perception, language, attention, social cognition and body awareness
- When one of these systems fails, aspects of identity may change, but the self rarely disappears entirely. Instead, identity is reshaped.
- Understanding these mechanisms allows clinicians to better support patients and, in some cases, restore disrupted aspects of identity through targeted treatments.
CORE THEMES OF THE BOOK
- Identity is constructed by the brain: Our sense of self emerges from interacting neural systems rather than a single fixed essence.
- Behaviour often has neurological causes: Symptoms such as apathy, hallucinations, neglect, or disinhibition can result from specific brain disruptions rather than purely psychological factors.
- Memory and perception shape our experience of reality: The brain reconstructs memories and actively constructs perception, meaning our sense of reality is continually produced by neural processes.
- Social relationships are central to identity: Brain disorders affect not only internal experience but also how individuals relate to others and participate in society.
- Recovery and adaptation are sometimes possible: When clinicians understand the underlying neural circuit involved, treatments can sometimes restore lost functions or help patients rebuild aspects of their identity.
December 21, 2025
People with Parkinson’s disease have slowness of movement, rigidity and tremor. They lose the swing of their arms when they walk, they may develop poor balance and a stooped posture. However, we now appreciate that there are several neurological conditions which have some of these Parkinsonian features, but which are not Parkinson’s disease.
‘It’s a bizarre thing to explain to someone, but my right arm and leg have been acting kind of strangely.’ ‘In what way?’ She hesitated. ‘I can be reading in bed and suddenly realise that I don’t know where my right hand is, but if I look at it, it will be there. The same can happen with my right leg. I can be sitting on the bus and become unaware where it is. Before I know it, someone has tripped over my foot because it is in the middle of the aisle.’
A compelling read. This work details 7 different cases of neurodegeneration caused by a multiplicity of factors. As I was reading, I could think of at least 3 people I know who suffer one or other of these conditions and relate to what Husain explains are the social consequences of the loss of a specific indentity construct. The author follows in the footsteps of Oliver Sacks in popularising brain conditions and explaining them to the layman. At the same time he has his own style and his many asides on his own daily thoughts on the tube on a park bench in his office make this read very relatable. And very humane.
‘It’s a bizarre thing to explain to someone, but my right arm and leg have been acting kind of strangely.’ ‘In what way?’ She hesitated. ‘I can be reading in bed and suddenly realise that I don’t know where my right hand is, but if I look at it, it will be there. The same can happen with my right leg. I can be sitting on the bus and become unaware where it is. Before I know it, someone has tripped over my foot because it is in the middle of the aisle.’
A compelling read. This work details 7 different cases of neurodegeneration caused by a multiplicity of factors. As I was reading, I could think of at least 3 people I know who suffer one or other of these conditions and relate to what Husain explains are the social consequences of the loss of a specific indentity construct. The author follows in the footsteps of Oliver Sacks in popularising brain conditions and explaining them to the layman. At the same time he has his own style and his many asides on his own daily thoughts on the tube on a park bench in his office make this read very relatable. And very humane.
December 15, 2025
In the same vein as The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat by the great Dr Oliver Sacks, one of my all-time favourite books. Loved the insightful tangents as well as following patients from diagnosis to follow-up. It's surreal to think that something as amorphous, abstract & large as our personality is dependent on a small patch of cells & synapses and that damage to a tiny area can dramatically change who we are.
April 18, 2026
Read it one sitting. What a great read, lively, heartfelt with personal stories, but still explains the brain to a layperson in clear terms.
May 28, 2026
Very much enjoyed the case descriptions
March 30, 2026
A well put-together collection of 7 people’s clinical case stories. It made me appreciate the difficulties neurological conditions can have in people’s social identity, and their sense of self - more so since I felt like I knew more about each person presented here. Took one star out, as some historical references and historical cases were not really to my taste.
April 26, 2025
A book which could have been really great, but lacks depth or breath in the subject matter to be especially worth recommending.
An Oxford University neurologist, Masud Husain's book aims to use seven case studies from his own clinical practice, to demonstrate truisms about the nature of self. If someone is minded to read this book, the conclusion does a really neat job of summing up all the main parts of the whole book. That is not a criticism, though it does speak to the substance within the body of the book. There are examples here of people forgetting the name of things, people experiencing drastic personality changes, and people unable to control their own limbs. Some of them contain interesting facts about neuroscience, though none of them leave a particularly strong impression other than "the brain is very complicated".
Indeed, a lot of this book is impressionistic. Husain tells stories about people rather than analysing situations. It is a good book for offering a range of views on how brain trauma impacts peoples lives, how randomly it can affect people and the frightening effects of what happens. However it did not really offer much actual teaching or knowledge about how the brain works or functions. It lacks a clear delineation of the science behind what is going on, and the social impact of what is happening. In many ways, that is a progressive approach to take, as one of the consequences is that biology and society are very obviously shown to interact to an almost inseparable level.
It is difficult to tell here what may have been editorialised, but the book does come across as slightly confused. At times Husain will go from explaining how a character has forgotten who her partner is, to lengthy explanations on the history of hot chocolate. Similar things happen when Husain takes time to explain the British partition of India or the unsubstantiated lies of the pro-Brexit campaign. It's the kind of thing a reader might suspect as an intrusive editor or overzealous publisher wanting to include, but on the other, this could easily be the author taking the opportunity to try to add substance to what may otherwise comfortably fit within 100 pages.
Overall, this is not a book I would recommend very strongly. I had hoped it would offer a more substantial explanation of neurology and brain trauma, but it ends up being remarkably soft. That said, I'm not sorry to have read it, there is nothing materially wrong with Husain's approach here, and it would be to each reader to decide how effective the book is in what it is trying to accomplish.
An Oxford University neurologist, Masud Husain's book aims to use seven case studies from his own clinical practice, to demonstrate truisms about the nature of self. If someone is minded to read this book, the conclusion does a really neat job of summing up all the main parts of the whole book. That is not a criticism, though it does speak to the substance within the body of the book. There are examples here of people forgetting the name of things, people experiencing drastic personality changes, and people unable to control their own limbs. Some of them contain interesting facts about neuroscience, though none of them leave a particularly strong impression other than "the brain is very complicated".
Indeed, a lot of this book is impressionistic. Husain tells stories about people rather than analysing situations. It is a good book for offering a range of views on how brain trauma impacts peoples lives, how randomly it can affect people and the frightening effects of what happens. However it did not really offer much actual teaching or knowledge about how the brain works or functions. It lacks a clear delineation of the science behind what is going on, and the social impact of what is happening. In many ways, that is a progressive approach to take, as one of the consequences is that biology and society are very obviously shown to interact to an almost inseparable level.
It is difficult to tell here what may have been editorialised, but the book does come across as slightly confused. At times Husain will go from explaining how a character has forgotten who her partner is, to lengthy explanations on the history of hot chocolate. Similar things happen when Husain takes time to explain the British partition of India or the unsubstantiated lies of the pro-Brexit campaign. It's the kind of thing a reader might suspect as an intrusive editor or overzealous publisher wanting to include, but on the other, this could easily be the author taking the opportunity to try to add substance to what may otherwise comfortably fit within 100 pages.
Overall, this is not a book I would recommend very strongly. I had hoped it would offer a more substantial explanation of neurology and brain trauma, but it ends up being remarkably soft. That said, I'm not sorry to have read it, there is nothing materially wrong with Husain's approach here, and it would be to each reader to decide how effective the book is in what it is trying to accomplish.
May 7, 2025
Excellant
Easy yo read and understand the brain through case studies. The writing is absorbing and descriptive wirh a good background of clinical information. An excellant read.
Easy yo read and understand the brain through case studies. The writing is absorbing and descriptive wirh a good background of clinical information. An excellant read.
March 15, 2025
Excellent in many ways. Accessible and very knowledgeable
July 4, 2026
" [...] Twój mózg tworzy ciebie. Nieważne, skąd pochodzisz, jakie jest twoje obecne lub dawne miejsce zamieszkania, jakim językiem mówisz, jaki masz kolor skóry — to mózgowi zawdzięczasz swoją tożsamość [...]"
"Outsiderzy" autorstwa profesora Masuda Husaina, to niezwykle ciekawa książka dotycząca mózgu. Autor — świetny neurolog na podstawie kilku przypadków pokazuje nam choroby mózgu, które również nas mogą spotkać. Najpierw przedstawia nam objawy danej choroby. Później pokazuje nam obserwacje i jak odkrył, na co dany pacjent zachorował. Na koniec dowiadujemy się, jak się czuje dany chory po leczeniu. Świetne jest również to, że Masud Husain cofa się w czasie i przedstawia nam pierwszego pacjenta danej choroby i jego odkrywcę od którego wzięła się jej nazwa. To mi się bardzo podobało. Jestem wdzięczna autorowi, że zamieścił tutaj rysunki mózgów i zaznaczył na nich, która część odpowiada za daną chorobę.
Ta książka uświadomiła mi, jak mało wiemy o mózgu i jego wpływu na życie. Póki działa poprawnie, nie interesujemy się nim. A tak naprawdę powinniśmy o niego dbać. Jest najważniejszym organem w naszym ciele. To od niego zależy między innymi, jak się zachowujemy, czy widzimy swoje kończyny, czy pamiętamy, co było kilkanaście lat temu i sekundę temu.
Poznacie tutaj różnych chorych. Między innymi Annę z Polski, która wraz ze swoimi rodzicami wyemigrowała do Anglii. Jej przypadek mnie mocno poruszył. Doświadczyła rasizmu, który na zawsze zmienił jej życie i mogę śmiało powiedzieć, że miał stu procentowy wpływ na jej chorobę. Jaki miała problem z mózgiem? Bardzo poważny, który utrudniał jej codzienne funkcjonowanie. Zachęcam was do poznania jej historii.
Autor uświadomił mnie również, że chorób mózgu nie można bagatelizować. Jeżeli widzicie, że wasi bliscy od jakiegoś czasu dziwnie się zachowują, np. nie pamiętają tego co robili przed chwilą, nie widzą, któreś ze stron, są nerwowi, przeklinają, gdy normalnie byli jak anioły, wyglądają jak pijani, chociaż nic nie pili, to sygnał dla was, że dzieje się z nimi coś nie tak. W takich przypadkach warto nie bagatelizować objawów, nie zostawiać ich bez opieki, tylko udać się z nimi do neurologa. Dzięki temu poprawi się ich jakość życia i kto wie, może wrócą do dawnych siebie.
Pamiętajcie obserwacja i reakcja, a nie obraza i bierność.
Tę książkę dla własnego dobra, powinien przeczytać każdy człowiek, któremu zależy na zdrowiu swoim i najbliższych.
Mam nadzieję, że autor napisze kolejną książkę, prezentując w niej inne choroby mózgu, o których jeszcze nie słyszeliśmy.
"Outsiderzy" Masuda Husaina, to wciągająca lektura, którą nie tak łatwo odłożyć. Po przeczytaniu, jej treść na długo pozostaje w głowach. Chyba o to chodziło autorowi. Nie dziwię się, że w 2025 roku, ta książka była najlepszą książką naukową i zdobyła nagrodę Trivedi Science Book Prize, przyznaną przez Royal Society.
Czy lubicie czytać książki popularnonaukowe i czy często po nie sięgacie?
"Outsiderzy" autorstwa profesora Masuda Husaina, to niezwykle ciekawa książka dotycząca mózgu. Autor — świetny neurolog na podstawie kilku przypadków pokazuje nam choroby mózgu, które również nas mogą spotkać. Najpierw przedstawia nam objawy danej choroby. Później pokazuje nam obserwacje i jak odkrył, na co dany pacjent zachorował. Na koniec dowiadujemy się, jak się czuje dany chory po leczeniu. Świetne jest również to, że Masud Husain cofa się w czasie i przedstawia nam pierwszego pacjenta danej choroby i jego odkrywcę od którego wzięła się jej nazwa. To mi się bardzo podobało. Jestem wdzięczna autorowi, że zamieścił tutaj rysunki mózgów i zaznaczył na nich, która część odpowiada za daną chorobę.
Ta książka uświadomiła mi, jak mało wiemy o mózgu i jego wpływu na życie. Póki działa poprawnie, nie interesujemy się nim. A tak naprawdę powinniśmy o niego dbać. Jest najważniejszym organem w naszym ciele. To od niego zależy między innymi, jak się zachowujemy, czy widzimy swoje kończyny, czy pamiętamy, co było kilkanaście lat temu i sekundę temu.
Poznacie tutaj różnych chorych. Między innymi Annę z Polski, która wraz ze swoimi rodzicami wyemigrowała do Anglii. Jej przypadek mnie mocno poruszył. Doświadczyła rasizmu, który na zawsze zmienił jej życie i mogę śmiało powiedzieć, że miał stu procentowy wpływ na jej chorobę. Jaki miała problem z mózgiem? Bardzo poważny, który utrudniał jej codzienne funkcjonowanie. Zachęcam was do poznania jej historii.
Autor uświadomił mnie również, że chorób mózgu nie można bagatelizować. Jeżeli widzicie, że wasi bliscy od jakiegoś czasu dziwnie się zachowują, np. nie pamiętają tego co robili przed chwilą, nie widzą, któreś ze stron, są nerwowi, przeklinają, gdy normalnie byli jak anioły, wyglądają jak pijani, chociaż nic nie pili, to sygnał dla was, że dzieje się z nimi coś nie tak. W takich przypadkach warto nie bagatelizować objawów, nie zostawiać ich bez opieki, tylko udać się z nimi do neurologa. Dzięki temu poprawi się ich jakość życia i kto wie, może wrócą do dawnych siebie.
Pamiętajcie obserwacja i reakcja, a nie obraza i bierność.
Tę książkę dla własnego dobra, powinien przeczytać każdy człowiek, któremu zależy na zdrowiu swoim i najbliższych.
Mam nadzieję, że autor napisze kolejną książkę, prezentując w niej inne choroby mózgu, o których jeszcze nie słyszeliśmy.
"Outsiderzy" Masuda Husaina, to wciągająca lektura, którą nie tak łatwo odłożyć. Po przeczytaniu, jej treść na długo pozostaje w głowach. Chyba o to chodziło autorowi. Nie dziwię się, że w 2025 roku, ta książka była najlepszą książką naukową i zdobyła nagrodę Trivedi Science Book Prize, przyznaną przez Royal Society.
Czy lubicie czytać książki popularnonaukowe i czy często po nie sięgacie?
February 21, 2026
A very interesting read on personal ( and social ) identity and how it emerges from the brain. There are 7 cases of patients where each one describes a certain change in the personal self of the patient and their acceptance in their social circle ( social identity ) affected by the neurological condition they have.
There is obviously some neurology stuff, the disorders, their symptoms, causes, their treatments, brain regions where they affect which the reader might not be familiar with but it's not too much to derail the reading flow. Things are explained to the depth they should to a reader new to the `Society of Mind`.
Each case might give you some completely new information and which might seem bizarre at first. The brain is a super complex machinery and the nervous system is an elegantly designed network. You would appreciate the working of the brain and respect it more after reading this book, that's for sure. The things whose functioning we take for granted, they might not be. Everything from perception to a simple movement of your limbs involves a highly sophisticated process and brain processes that you would be surprised to know about.
Conditions such as visual hallucinations, pathological apathy and like these which might be diagnosed quickly ( and falsely ) to madness and insanity at first glance might be a neurological condition. There is not much widespread knowledge of this distinction and a lot of people seemingly declared by the society might be treated if this awareness of this distinction is made in public. A lot of stigma, social exclusion, superstitious assumptions are often associated with these false diagnoses which does not allow for the normal treatment that the patient should get.
There is a discussion on the concept of self ( personal and social identity ) and various prominent philosophers take on this idea which is quite interesting. This book can definitely spark an interest in someone who might be looking for a detailed study of psychology, neurology or in general, our amazing brain.
There is obviously some neurology stuff, the disorders, their symptoms, causes, their treatments, brain regions where they affect which the reader might not be familiar with but it's not too much to derail the reading flow. Things are explained to the depth they should to a reader new to the `Society of Mind`.
Each case might give you some completely new information and which might seem bizarre at first. The brain is a super complex machinery and the nervous system is an elegantly designed network. You would appreciate the working of the brain and respect it more after reading this book, that's for sure. The things whose functioning we take for granted, they might not be. Everything from perception to a simple movement of your limbs involves a highly sophisticated process and brain processes that you would be surprised to know about.
Conditions such as visual hallucinations, pathological apathy and like these which might be diagnosed quickly ( and falsely ) to madness and insanity at first glance might be a neurological condition. There is not much widespread knowledge of this distinction and a lot of people seemingly declared by the society might be treated if this awareness of this distinction is made in public. A lot of stigma, social exclusion, superstitious assumptions are often associated with these false diagnoses which does not allow for the normal treatment that the patient should get.
There is a discussion on the concept of self ( personal and social identity ) and various prominent philosophers take on this idea which is quite interesting. This book can definitely spark an interest in someone who might be looking for a detailed study of psychology, neurology or in general, our amazing brain.
December 8, 2025
I had a bit of a love-hate relationship with Masud Husain in his capacity as narrator. On the one hand, this book is precisely what I was looking for in terms of a greater understanding about the different areas of the brain and how damage to a particular region can affect the way we behave and our sense of identity. On the other hand, he has this bizarre habit of shoehorning in totally irrelevant information about himself that reeks of narcissism. He also has an obsession with the Syrian Civil War, which is brought up in every chapter but has only the most oblique relationship to the topic of the book.
The concept of the book is a clever one, using a series of neurological cases to elucidate the functions of the brain, then progressing to the way brain function affects identify and sociological behaviors.
I found the neurological aspects very interesting, especially learning about the brain and how it is affected by stroke or disease. Husain explains these beautifully and succinctly - it's during these moments that he really shines as an author. The sociological aspects, unfortunately, are less interesting, and you could pretty much summarise the conclusions as 'having issues with brain function can be isolating' - well, duh. It's only in the last chapter that it begins to get some depth, but it certainly isn't woven into the fabric of the book.
I couldn't help but think back to the Emperor of Maladies, written by Siddhartha Mukherjee - who, incidentally, is a narrator I was quite happy to spend time with. His work is the gold standard to which I hold this type of popular medical science book, and by contrast there are a number of shortcomings in Our Brains, Our Selves.
That said, I would still have no qualms recommending this book to anybody interested in learning more about neuroscience.
The concept of the book is a clever one, using a series of neurological cases to elucidate the functions of the brain, then progressing to the way brain function affects identify and sociological behaviors.
I found the neurological aspects very interesting, especially learning about the brain and how it is affected by stroke or disease. Husain explains these beautifully and succinctly - it's during these moments that he really shines as an author. The sociological aspects, unfortunately, are less interesting, and you could pretty much summarise the conclusions as 'having issues with brain function can be isolating' - well, duh. It's only in the last chapter that it begins to get some depth, but it certainly isn't woven into the fabric of the book.
I couldn't help but think back to the Emperor of Maladies, written by Siddhartha Mukherjee - who, incidentally, is a narrator I was quite happy to spend time with. His work is the gold standard to which I hold this type of popular medical science book, and by contrast there are a number of shortcomings in Our Brains, Our Selves.
That said, I would still have no qualms recommending this book to anybody interested in learning more about neuroscience.
January 4, 2026
Our Brains, Our Selves by Masud Husain is an accessible and engaging introduction to neuroscience, guided by a thoughtful and humane narrator. As the reader is introduced to key brain regions—the basal ganglia, temporal, parietal, and frontal lobes—they gradually become part of one’s active vocabulary, their functions vividly illustrated through stories of Dr Husain’s patients.
While describing the process of establishing diagnoses, the author takes brief but illuminating excursions into the history of neurology and offers insights into current medical practices, as well as the limitations of modern treatments and medications.
However, this book is far more than a collection of intriguing clinical case studies. Husain repeatedly returns to a central question: what is the self? He presents identity as a composition of multiple cognitive processes, showing that the loss of a single faculty does not necessarily erase one’s sense of self. Identity, he argues, is not only individual but also social. Group membership—and, conversely, exclusion—often depends on conformity to social markers such as language, behaviour, and humour, which can be lost or difficult to acquire after brain injury.
Dr Husain reflects on the challenges of building and maintaining a social identity through both his patients’ experiences and his own personal story, giving the book emotional depth alongside its scientific rigour.
For anyone curious about the brain, its common disorders, and contemporary treatments, this is an enjoyable and rewarding read. What I appreciated most was the author’s presence throughout the book—his empathy, patience, and respect for even the most challenging patients. Though a work of non-fiction, the book often reads like a novel, thanks to Husain’s skilful storytelling, and it ultimately renewed my respect for the medical profession.
While describing the process of establishing diagnoses, the author takes brief but illuminating excursions into the history of neurology and offers insights into current medical practices, as well as the limitations of modern treatments and medications.
However, this book is far more than a collection of intriguing clinical case studies. Husain repeatedly returns to a central question: what is the self? He presents identity as a composition of multiple cognitive processes, showing that the loss of a single faculty does not necessarily erase one’s sense of self. Identity, he argues, is not only individual but also social. Group membership—and, conversely, exclusion—often depends on conformity to social markers such as language, behaviour, and humour, which can be lost or difficult to acquire after brain injury.
Dr Husain reflects on the challenges of building and maintaining a social identity through both his patients’ experiences and his own personal story, giving the book emotional depth alongside its scientific rigour.
For anyone curious about the brain, its common disorders, and contemporary treatments, this is an enjoyable and rewarding read. What I appreciated most was the author’s presence throughout the book—his empathy, patience, and respect for even the most challenging patients. Though a work of non-fiction, the book often reads like a novel, thanks to Husain’s skilful storytelling, and it ultimately renewed my respect for the medical profession.
July 4, 2026
A deeply personal book in which the author, a neuroscientist, describes his patients' stories and his own biography, mainly of how difficult it was to adapt to life in British society as an immigrant.
While explaining how the brain works, the author also emphasizes that its proper functioning is fundamental to every aspect of our lives. Through seven real-life clinical cases, he illustrates the roles played by different regions of the brain and demonstrates how neurological disorders can affect people's everyday experiences.
Readers also learn that recovery depends not only on the nature of the brain injury itself, but equally on the patient's environment and the people surrounding him. Anna's story is a compelling example. In her youth she suffered a traumatic brain injury when she was brutally assaulted by a group of nationalists. She became terrified of undergoing further medical procedures, even though her deteriorating health severely limited her daily life. Her fear was rooted in painful memories of the attack. Wahid's case is equally revealing. He concealed his visual hallucinations because he feared rejection by his community and worried that people would consider him mentally ill. Through stories like these, the neurologist demonstrates how essential the support and involvement of a patient's family and loved ones can be during treatment. More often than not, they play a crucial role in the patient's recovery.
This is a fascinating book on many levels. Scientifically, it expands the reader's understanding of the brain using clear, accessible language. Sociologically, it highlights important aspects of human relationships and social life. Culturally, it draws attention to the values and characteristics that shape different communities and backgrounds.
Highly recommended.
While explaining how the brain works, the author also emphasizes that its proper functioning is fundamental to every aspect of our lives. Through seven real-life clinical cases, he illustrates the roles played by different regions of the brain and demonstrates how neurological disorders can affect people's everyday experiences.
Readers also learn that recovery depends not only on the nature of the brain injury itself, but equally on the patient's environment and the people surrounding him. Anna's story is a compelling example. In her youth she suffered a traumatic brain injury when she was brutally assaulted by a group of nationalists. She became terrified of undergoing further medical procedures, even though her deteriorating health severely limited her daily life. Her fear was rooted in painful memories of the attack. Wahid's case is equally revealing. He concealed his visual hallucinations because he feared rejection by his community and worried that people would consider him mentally ill. Through stories like these, the neurologist demonstrates how essential the support and involvement of a patient's family and loved ones can be during treatment. More often than not, they play a crucial role in the patient's recovery.
This is a fascinating book on many levels. Scientifically, it expands the reader's understanding of the brain using clear, accessible language. Sociologically, it highlights important aspects of human relationships and social life. Culturally, it draws attention to the values and characteristics that shape different communities and backgrounds.
Highly recommended.
December 23, 2025
How Brain Changes Rewrite Us: A Fascinating, Frightening Tour of Identity, Personality, and Relationships
Masud Husain’s "Our Brains, Our Selves" is an absorbing and sometimes unsettling exploration of how fragile identity becomes when the brain is even slightly altered. The overall conceit of the book is both intriguing and engaging, raising several interesting ideas about what makes us who we are, yet it remains accessible and easy to read for non-specialists.
The book circles a deceptively simple question: what makes us who we are? I find myself returning to it constantly. Our personal traits define us, both in our own eyes and in the eyes of others, yet their origins remain obscure. Our traits also shape how others respond to us and how we find a place within our particular web of relationships; this book shows how alterations in those traits can abruptly endanger those very bonds. The prospect is deeply disquieting. Is it possible to wake up one day as someone fundamentally different? Told through a series of short case studies, each chapter is compelling in its own right; together, they form a thought‑provoking portrait of how precarious our sense of self can be.
Two examples are especially memorable. David, a once-driven young professional transformed into someone eerily apathetic after tiny strokes to his basal ganglia, shows how motivation itself can vanish when a single network fails. Anna, assaulted as a teenager and later plagued by an “alien” hand she cannot fully control, vividly illustrates how even one injured brain region can estrange a person from her own body. Throughout, Husain’s humane storytelling and clear explanations make this frightening material mesmerizing rather than merely clinical.
Masud Husain’s "Our Brains, Our Selves" is an absorbing and sometimes unsettling exploration of how fragile identity becomes when the brain is even slightly altered. The overall conceit of the book is both intriguing and engaging, raising several interesting ideas about what makes us who we are, yet it remains accessible and easy to read for non-specialists.
The book circles a deceptively simple question: what makes us who we are? I find myself returning to it constantly. Our personal traits define us, both in our own eyes and in the eyes of others, yet their origins remain obscure. Our traits also shape how others respond to us and how we find a place within our particular web of relationships; this book shows how alterations in those traits can abruptly endanger those very bonds. The prospect is deeply disquieting. Is it possible to wake up one day as someone fundamentally different? Told through a series of short case studies, each chapter is compelling in its own right; together, they form a thought‑provoking portrait of how precarious our sense of self can be.
Two examples are especially memorable. David, a once-driven young professional transformed into someone eerily apathetic after tiny strokes to his basal ganglia, shows how motivation itself can vanish when a single network fails. Anna, assaulted as a teenager and later plagued by an “alien” hand she cannot fully control, vividly illustrates how even one injured brain region can estrange a person from her own body. Throughout, Husain’s humane storytelling and clear explanations make this frightening material mesmerizing rather than merely clinical.
September 12, 2025
There are knowledge-enhancing stories in this book to learn about how some crucial aspects of the quality of our lives seriously depend on our brains functioning without anomaly. There are seven cases of brain anomalies here that the author took care of and shares his enlightening neuroscience insight. His prose is attention grabbing and easy to understand with proper neuroscience background provided for each case of brain anatomy discussed. It is also pleasant to know that there is cure or alleviation for each of the ailments. The author also adds a bit more charms to this book by some narratives of dramatic trials and tribulations of his patients.
One treasure from this book is to learn that neurologists have several simple physical, neurological, and cognitive test methods to check their patients for any deficiencies that we the general public can also use to test ourselves. Do not miss all these tests.
Funny, when reading about the case of frontal lobe dysfunction in which the afflicted becomes "disinhibited", suddenly the image of D. J. Trump emerges into my mind!?! Some brain doctor should have had his brain scanned and analyzed for the sake of sensibility and democracy! Actually, his entire cabinet should be subject to the analyses!
These cautionary neurological tales serve to remind readers not to wait until the pond dries up to realize its consequences (in may cases, they cannot even realize it!). Learning and practicing healthy foods, healthy lifestyle is the most valuable skill to acquire for sustaining our life quality.
In the end, this book enables readers to see that weird behaviors have their root causes in the brain's health. The only thing I hope some more from this book is that the author provided some more cases. For those who want to digest more on this same mind blowing neuroscience, I highly recommend this book: Human: The Science Behind What Makes Us Unique which also discusses several same brain anomalies as Dr. Husain's book but with much more about brain science as this book is quite thick. This book also adds even some more insights into the earnest importance of our brain: Incognito: The Secret Lives of the Brain. The case of Texas University Shooter in 1966 is so mesmerizingly enlightening. This last book is very much in the sale vein as Dr. Husain's book, only more mind-blowing cases of brain anomalies: Matter of Mind: A Neurologist's View of Brainbehavior Relationships. All these books enable readers to recognize and understand so many weird behaviors, from the fatal to the annoying!
One treasure from this book is to learn that neurologists have several simple physical, neurological, and cognitive test methods to check their patients for any deficiencies that we the general public can also use to test ourselves. Do not miss all these tests.
Funny, when reading about the case of frontal lobe dysfunction in which the afflicted becomes "disinhibited", suddenly the image of D. J. Trump emerges into my mind!?! Some brain doctor should have had his brain scanned and analyzed for the sake of sensibility and democracy! Actually, his entire cabinet should be subject to the analyses!
These cautionary neurological tales serve to remind readers not to wait until the pond dries up to realize its consequences (in may cases, they cannot even realize it!). Learning and practicing healthy foods, healthy lifestyle is the most valuable skill to acquire for sustaining our life quality.
In the end, this book enables readers to see that weird behaviors have their root causes in the brain's health. The only thing I hope some more from this book is that the author provided some more cases. For those who want to digest more on this same mind blowing neuroscience, I highly recommend this book: Human: The Science Behind What Makes Us Unique which also discusses several same brain anomalies as Dr. Husain's book but with much more about brain science as this book is quite thick. This book also adds even some more insights into the earnest importance of our brain: Incognito: The Secret Lives of the Brain. The case of Texas University Shooter in 1966 is so mesmerizingly enlightening. This last book is very much in the sale vein as Dr. Husain's book, only more mind-blowing cases of brain anomalies: Matter of Mind: A Neurologist's View of Brainbehavior Relationships. All these books enable readers to recognize and understand so many weird behaviors, from the fatal to the annoying!
January 16, 2026
Neuroscience and Neurology is one of my special interest when it comes to nonfiction, so I was really looking forward to reading this book.
The concept is quite reminiscent of Oliver Sack‘s books, which I really enjoyed. The central question posed by the Author, a neurologist and neuroscientist at the university of Oxford, is what makes us who we are? Using the story of several of his patients, we get a glimpse of what a possible answer might be. The reader is taken along from the moment he meets the patients, to their relevant background and any symptoms they are experiencing, to making a differential diagnosis and the tests performed to verify his suspicions as well as treatment options, and why they might work or might not work, are explained well and in a way that is easy to understand, even for someone who is no neuroscientist.
It was evident that the author thought of his patients not just as individual people, but also as people who are part of their own social and cultural groups and the significance this holds when making decisions of any kind, which I highly appreciated.
Throughout these different stories the reader also learns of historical events that might be relevant or interesting in the context of the story.
Only critique point I have, is that the writing style felt a bit long-winded, especially in the beginning and the very end.
All in all I really enjoyed reading this book and the insights it gave into neuroscience and how f.e. the loss of function in particular regions of the brain can have profound consequences on our sense of „self“.
Thanks to Netgalley and Canongate Books for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
The concept is quite reminiscent of Oliver Sack‘s books, which I really enjoyed. The central question posed by the Author, a neurologist and neuroscientist at the university of Oxford, is what makes us who we are? Using the story of several of his patients, we get a glimpse of what a possible answer might be. The reader is taken along from the moment he meets the patients, to their relevant background and any symptoms they are experiencing, to making a differential diagnosis and the tests performed to verify his suspicions as well as treatment options, and why they might work or might not work, are explained well and in a way that is easy to understand, even for someone who is no neuroscientist.
It was evident that the author thought of his patients not just as individual people, but also as people who are part of their own social and cultural groups and the significance this holds when making decisions of any kind, which I highly appreciated.
Throughout these different stories the reader also learns of historical events that might be relevant or interesting in the context of the story.
Only critique point I have, is that the writing style felt a bit long-winded, especially in the beginning and the very end.
All in all I really enjoyed reading this book and the insights it gave into neuroscience and how f.e. the loss of function in particular regions of the brain can have profound consequences on our sense of „self“.
Thanks to Netgalley and Canongate Books for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
January 28, 2026
Our Brains, Our Selves is a beautifully written and deeply humane work of narrative science—one that blends clinical insight with storytelling in a way that feels both accessible and profound. Masud Husain draws on seven remarkable patient cases from across his career, each one illuminating a different facet of how the brain shapes who we are, how we behave, and how we understand ourselves.
What makes the book so compelling is the compassion threaded through every chapter. Husain doesn’t simply present neurological puzzles; he introduces us to people—individuals whose lives have been upended by strokes, injuries, or rare disorders that alter memory, language, inhibition, or perception. A man who suddenly loses his words, a woman whose personality shifts dramatically, another who mistakes her own husband for a stranger—each case is presented with clarity, curiosity, and respect.
The result is a narrative that feels as much about humanity as it is about neuroscience. Husain guides readers through complex concepts with elegant simplicity, showing how identity is not a fixed essence but a dynamic interplay of brain systems that can falter, adapt, and sometimes astonishingly recover. The stories are moving, occasionally unsettling, and always thought‑provoking.
This is the kind of book that lingers—one that expands your understanding of the mind while reminding you how delicate and extraordinary it is to be human. A fascinating, insightful read for anyone interested in the mysteries of the brain and the stories that reveal who we truly are.
with thanks to Masud Husain, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
What makes the book so compelling is the compassion threaded through every chapter. Husain doesn’t simply present neurological puzzles; he introduces us to people—individuals whose lives have been upended by strokes, injuries, or rare disorders that alter memory, language, inhibition, or perception. A man who suddenly loses his words, a woman whose personality shifts dramatically, another who mistakes her own husband for a stranger—each case is presented with clarity, curiosity, and respect.
The result is a narrative that feels as much about humanity as it is about neuroscience. Husain guides readers through complex concepts with elegant simplicity, showing how identity is not a fixed essence but a dynamic interplay of brain systems that can falter, adapt, and sometimes astonishingly recover. The stories are moving, occasionally unsettling, and always thought‑provoking.
This is the kind of book that lingers—one that expands your understanding of the mind while reminding you how delicate and extraordinary it is to be human. A fascinating, insightful read for anyone interested in the mysteries of the brain and the stories that reveal who we truly are.
with thanks to Masud Husain, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
April 26, 2026
Husain writes about his patients in a way that reflects his interest, care, and respect as a clinician, and which makes me feel the same way toward the people he is describing and the ways that their lives are impacted by their neurological conditions. I think that he correctly identifies the loss of self as a thread that is common among these patients whose conditions are otherwise generally rather different. I also think that he begins a very interesting discussion on how the experiences of these patients bear on our concept of the self. However, I found the philosophical discussion itself to be underdeveloped; I felt like the claim of the book with respect to the notion of the self was limited to the idea that the self must inherently involve the function of the brain as a whole. The discussion of several philosophies of the self was helpful to frame these cases, and it felt like Husain was arguing that these patients' experiences aligned most closely with Minsky's "Society of Mind" theory. I don't think that Husain necessarily needed to develop a new theory of the self to explain his patients, but I do think that he leaves the discussion with much to be said about how such cases bear on the concept of the self when they are some of the best empirical evidence that we have. I think that this book was well done as a documentation of the phenomena that these patients experienced, but claims to provide philosophical insight that it does not deliver.
July 1, 2026
[ współpraca reklamowa ]
Jako iż to jest reportaż to nie będzie taka standardowa recenzja. Z tej książki wyciągnęłam wiele rzeczy. Poznałam wiele nowych schorzeń. Wiedziałam, że ludzki mózg ma wiel, że tak powiem “do zaoferowania”. Jednak nie sądziłam, że aż tak wiele sytuacji i zachowań człowieka może mieć problemy z np. jedną z dwóch półkul mózgu. Książka była naprawdę świetną lekturą. Większym moim zainteresowaniem cieszyły się rozdziały 1-7. I o nich chciałabym wam o części z nich pokrótce opowiedzieć. Mam nadzieję, że z ciekawości sięgniecie po ten tytuł!
Mały cud: rozdział opowiada o kompletnej zmianie osobowości. Główny bohater doznał udaru, jednak wstępnie było z nim w porządku. Jednak z czasem z osoby towarzyskiej i pełnej zapału stał się człowiekiem nic nie robiącym. Nie cieszącym się z niczego. Nie spodziewałam się, że takie dolegliwości mogą się przytrafiać.
Człowiek, któremu zabrakło słów: opowiada historię mężczyzny, który z biegiem lat zapomniał do czego służą przedmioty i sformułowania, które go otaczają. Wie, że ktoś potrzebował czegoś, jednocześnie nie potrafił wytłumaczyć do czego dany przedmiot służył. Według mnie to był jeden z ciekawszych rozdziałów.
Kobieta bez hamulców: Ten rozdział również był intrygujący. Kobieta ze skromnej osoby nagle zmieniła się w kobietę, która potrafiła wygarnąć wszystko innym, nie hamował się. Można było pomyśleć, że to zwykła pewność siebie. Też z początku o tym pomyślałam! Jednak przez pewien problem z płatem te granice się coraz bardziej zacierały. Krzyczała czy nawet obmacywała ludzi, tłumacząc to pewnością siebie. Była wysysaczem energii, nikt nie potrafił zrozumieć o co chodzi, dopóki nie przyszli z tym do neurologa. Co było ciężkie, osoby takie nie zdawały sobie sprawy z powagi sytuacji. Tłumaczyły to pewnością siebie.
To jest lektura, którą polecam każdemu. Ja przytoczyłam tylko trzy intrygujące historie, jednak każda z nich jest świetna. Wiele się dowiedziała z tej książki. Kocham poznawać nowe fakty. Wiele z tych schorzeń, jest wciąż badana, na część z nich wciąż nie ma leków.
Jako iż to jest reportaż to nie będzie taka standardowa recenzja. Z tej książki wyciągnęłam wiele rzeczy. Poznałam wiele nowych schorzeń. Wiedziałam, że ludzki mózg ma wiel, że tak powiem “do zaoferowania”. Jednak nie sądziłam, że aż tak wiele sytuacji i zachowań człowieka może mieć problemy z np. jedną z dwóch półkul mózgu. Książka była naprawdę świetną lekturą. Większym moim zainteresowaniem cieszyły się rozdziały 1-7. I o nich chciałabym wam o części z nich pokrótce opowiedzieć. Mam nadzieję, że z ciekawości sięgniecie po ten tytuł!
Mały cud: rozdział opowiada o kompletnej zmianie osobowości. Główny bohater doznał udaru, jednak wstępnie było z nim w porządku. Jednak z czasem z osoby towarzyskiej i pełnej zapału stał się człowiekiem nic nie robiącym. Nie cieszącym się z niczego. Nie spodziewałam się, że takie dolegliwości mogą się przytrafiać.
Człowiek, któremu zabrakło słów: opowiada historię mężczyzny, który z biegiem lat zapomniał do czego służą przedmioty i sformułowania, które go otaczają. Wie, że ktoś potrzebował czegoś, jednocześnie nie potrafił wytłumaczyć do czego dany przedmiot służył. Według mnie to był jeden z ciekawszych rozdziałów.
Kobieta bez hamulców: Ten rozdział również był intrygujący. Kobieta ze skromnej osoby nagle zmieniła się w kobietę, która potrafiła wygarnąć wszystko innym, nie hamował się. Można było pomyśleć, że to zwykła pewność siebie. Też z początku o tym pomyślałam! Jednak przez pewien problem z płatem te granice się coraz bardziej zacierały. Krzyczała czy nawet obmacywała ludzi, tłumacząc to pewnością siebie. Była wysysaczem energii, nikt nie potrafił zrozumieć o co chodzi, dopóki nie przyszli z tym do neurologa. Co było ciężkie, osoby takie nie zdawały sobie sprawy z powagi sytuacji. Tłumaczyły to pewnością siebie.
To jest lektura, którą polecam każdemu. Ja przytoczyłam tylko trzy intrygujące historie, jednak każda z nich jest świetna. Wiele się dowiedziała z tej książki. Kocham poznawać nowe fakty. Wiele z tych schorzeń, jest wciąż badana, na część z nich wciąż nie ma leków.
March 25, 2026
Seven case studies of patients seen by Dr Husain (a neurologist) over the course of his career to date. They are chosen to illustrate what happens when parts of our brain start to go wrong, in ways that affect our character. The style is very accessible, non-technical, and with lots of conversational padding around the occasional forays into nitty gritty science.
The patients represented here have acquired brain injury caused by stroke, disease or accident, and each has a different array of symptoms. Few have insight into their own deficiencies, which makes things difficult for their families and friends - and for the doctor.
An interesting insight into the working life of a neurologist, it's a very easy read, but at the same time gives much food for thought.
I was left thinking that very few of the patients discussed in this book would have sought help independently. It was their partners, friends and families that had insisted, and made the appointments happen. Without them, who knows what might have happened to these unfortunate people?
The patients represented here have acquired brain injury caused by stroke, disease or accident, and each has a different array of symptoms. Few have insight into their own deficiencies, which makes things difficult for their families and friends - and for the doctor.
An interesting insight into the working life of a neurologist, it's a very easy read, but at the same time gives much food for thought.
I was left thinking that very few of the patients discussed in this book would have sought help independently. It was their partners, friends and families that had insisted, and made the appointments happen. Without them, who knows what might have happened to these unfortunate people?
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews