I didn’t find this book plausible and it really wasn’t my cup of tea. Though it may work for other people, so, as with all reviews, take this with a grain of salt.
But, for me, so many things happened that I didn’t think would ever happen in real life. I won’t go into all of them bc I feel this review gets long enough as is.
I finished the book in order to see who did it because no explanations I came up with made sense. And the ultimate explanation was a “bad guy” who was an annoying obstacle the whole book, who didn’t have clues leading to him throughout the book (besides him being unhelpful) and who didn’t have what I considered a plausible reason to frame the mc, so I still didn’t feel the explanation made sense.
In particular, the women characters felt really two-dimensional, like set pieces, doing what was required of the plot, rather than doing things that made sense for them as people or as women to do. Like, maybe I’m wrong, but it felt to me like no women read the manuscript prior to it getting published, or if they did, they were too close of friends or family to tell the author that his characters were behaving oddly.
For instance, and spoilers here, the particularly level-headed LDS college-aged girl, seems very unlikely to choose to be alone in a private bedroom with a man, specifically a seemingly homeless man who she just met doing laundry at a random hotel far away from home and family. Not unless he was like, the local bishop and had another local member with him. Nothing against homeless people, or guys, but I personally, and the majority of women I know, would not choose to do that, for safety sake. And then she keeps this guy’s email address and keeps checking her email frequently, desperate for updates from this guy she met once. And gets super involved on his behalf with another random guy she just met. Like, fake homeless guy made a big impression, but it’s the kinda thing you go wow, that was crazy, and move on from, to me.
So anyway, apologies to the author and anyone who enjoyed the book, but I really think this book needed more time in the oven before it was fully baked, ya know?