The Way We Were Hunters is a book set in the middle of a war between humans and fallen, creatures that look like human but possess superhuman abilities and a cruelty beyond measure. Amid the chaos and adversity of life in a bunker, we follow our main characters: Lena, once a marksman, now a laundress trying to climb her way back to a respectful position, and Mikhail, an acclaimed, no-nonsense captain admired by everyone. Due to a number of reasons, both end up tangled in a sort of secret romance, which is put in jeopardy as they confront the fallen. As she discovers that the enemy is closer than she'd assumed, Lena will have to choose between following what's right and what her heart truly desires.
When I found this book, I never expected it to be what it ended up being. It was an action-packed novel, and much to my surprise, it had actually chilling, gruesome details that fully gave the ambience of a land scarred by conflict and violence. The plot was very interesting and not like any other war-themed fantasy book I've read before, so the overall reading experience was super entertaining. The pace made it all the easier for me to read non-stop every time I picked it up as well.
My favourite character was Mikhail. Out of the cast, he was the best fleshed out. His story had twists and turns and a good portion of mystery. And he was undoubtedly hot, just like I like my fictional men. I would've loved to know more about his past and how he became captain— maybe a novella about him would be nice?
Now, there were some issues with this book that prevented me from giving it 5 stars. One, and probably the most important, was Lena. At the beginning, she was a boring main character. Had the plot been any less interesting, she wouldn't have been able to carry the story forward on her own. We didn't know anything about her besides her little "accident" with the training instructor, which is supposed to give us the idea that she doesn't care for rules, but we are told this, not shown. She never really does anything that proves her apparently rebellious personality. She has a tragic past, but it isn't relevant at all. Her character does not show any interesting traits (apart from every single man in this book calling her pretty or beautiful or praising her only for her looks) until she starts her affair with Misha: It's because of her feelings for him that she gets to have a "mission", but I would have liked it for her to earn her place there and show her real abilities. By the end of the book, she is rewarded for something she didn't really do— although she wanted to be recognised for her own efforts, it seemed like she never got to prove her worth fairly. I genuinely believed she could, though, but it seemed like the author just wouldn't let her be the hero of her own story. The only moment where I really liked her as a protagonist was towards the end, but then she wasn't really doing anything of importance— and this version of her felt more authentic to me than any other.
Then there was Ardarion. God, what an insufferable character. He was the depiction of bad boy in the way he talked (especially to Lena) and behaved, but nothing about him made him a memorable one. Yet, for some reason I still cannot understand, and despite being described as a macabre being, we are supposed to feel pity for him and root for his crush (which also came from nowhere???). Why in the world he had such fascination for Lena is beyond my comprehension.
But back to what actually matters: the ending was surprisingly satisfying, though I felt a little sad we couldn't get to see more of Lena and Misha together (contrary to my expectations, I did like them as a couple!). I would love to have a sequel to know exactly what happened to them, as the book doesn't give readers enough closure. Apparently, this is a duology, so I'll be patiently waiting for the next part, whenever it comes.
Thanks to BookSirens for sending me a copy of this book to review. All thoughts written are my own.