Rwanda Inc. by Patricia Crisafulli, is an interesting look at Rwanda in the modern world. Most people will remember the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda, where Hutu Génocidaires, with support from Rwandan politicians, clergy and military figures, massacred over one million people in the worst genocide the world has seen since the Holocaust. The international community largely stood by and did nothing, the UN security mission tied its own hands and watched in horror, and the French government actively supported Hutu politicians both at the beginning of the event, and as the perpetrators fled persecution by the victorious RPF forces.
After this event, Paul Kagame and his RPF forces took control of Rwanda, and tried to rebuild and
heal ties between Hutu and Tutsi communities. Kagame was in power for 6 years as an informal leader, while the country began to right itself. He stepped down for a time, but has been in charge for almost 14 years (two terms in Rwanda) as a popularly elected leader. Kagame in that time has been a hotbed for praise and controversy, being accused of making opposition figures disappear, presiding over the Congo Wars, largely a continuation of Rwanda's ethnic struggles in the Congo, and being accused of authoritarian practices - he has yet to announce his intentions after his 2017 term is up at the time of writing this review.
Kagame is also praised highly in international circles and at home. He has presided over a Rwanda that is struggling to rebuild, and has tried to put aside ethnic squabble in exchange for a single cultural identity. He has seen Rwanda's growth rate growing by 7-8% per year for almost a decade - no small feat for a landlocked and small African nation overcoming its war torn past and ethnic tensions. He has tried to forge his own path for Rwanda, shunning World Bank advice much to the chagrin of international investors and Western politicians. He has begun to mend ties with France, not an innocent party at all in the conflicts in Rwanda. This book is a look at the good side of Kagame.
So how does it hold up? Frankly, I was disappointed. I have read many books on authoritarian figures like Park Chung-hee, Lee Kuan Yee, Deng Xiaoping and so on, figures who have not promoted democracy in their respective nations, but have presided over a massive increase in living standards, education, healthcare and international approval. Kagame is often thrown into their mix as a modernizer who will do what it takes to get things done, and improve the lives of the average Rwandans. This is no small task. Rwanda faces many challenges that each of the above figures (in South Korea, Singapore and China, respectively) never had to contend with. All of the other tigers have sea access, were able to count on support from the international community as trading hubs (Singapore), or to improve ties (China), or for Geo-strategic purposes (South Korea). Rwanda has none of these. It is a small landlocked nation with a population of over 10 million people. It has few natural resources, no international port, and is viewed with skepticism or outright hostility by many neo-liberal democracies. Kagame has sought to alter this viewpoint, and the book is largely a manifesto of sorts to his ideals.
Kagame has pushed for an open for business attitude in Rwanda by promoting international investment and encouraging pro-business laws and ideals. At the same time, he is seeking to mend ties with a community that once killed their own neighbours in brutal fashion, while maintaining the security of a state surrounded by East African neighbours with their own agendas, ethnic make-up and conflicts. The book is highly praiseworthy of Kagame, so much so as to resemble a corporate biography (which is its intention). This style did not work for me at all (as my rating can attest). I enjoy reading about Rwanda, the "Singapore of Africa" supposedly, because I enjoy developmentalism as a subject. Rwanda Inc. felt like the perfect read for me, but falls far short of what it should be. The book lacks much in the way of important information on how Kagame is doing things, and instead focuses on his "drive, ambition, courage" etc. This glowing book is difficult to read as it offers little concrete information on the subject at hand, and focuses solely on character traits which are not helpful in the least. It looks at the intentions of Rwanda as stated by the RPF and its leaders, but offer no critical insight, no metrics or information, and indeed, little sources at all, besides other books like Stephen Kinzer's A Thousand Hills, a much more in depth analysis of Kagame and his regime in Rwanda.
As mentioned, I enjoy books on alternative governance styles, and Kagame's fits the build of interest for me. However, this book glosses over his authoritarian tendencies, which may seem controversial, but are much more understandable in the context of Rwanda's many security issues. It seems the authors were intending this book for a specific audience of Westerners unfamiliar with Rwanda besides the genocide. They leave much information on Kagame's role in the Congo conflict (they barely mention it at all). It is inexplicable to me why they would do this. It is a huge part of the story, and needs to be told in order to gain a concrete understanding of Rwanda's struggles, and why many feel it is such a hopeful nation in the global community. Whether one would compliment or condemn (and indeed, this is the struggle faced by the international community, both racked with guilt over their role in the conflict, but ever critical of any system not mirroring their own) Rwanda is a literal ray of light for the world. This is a nation that has gone from devastated to rapid growth in just over 10 years. It is one of the most promising investments in Africa. It's leader is a fascinating person marred by interesting flaws, controversies and possessed with clear strengths and wisdom. Rwanda is a fascinating topic in the modern world.
Frankly, however, I did not enjoy this book. It's glowing portrait glosses over the facts. It is poorly sourced, and offers little useful or practical information. It is a bland CEO-biography style book. It has some interesting moments and insights on Rwanda's success, and it is a hopeful book in tone, which is refreshing. However, it struggles to keep ones interest due to it's lack of personality. This can be safely passed over for more interesting material for most readers, but for those looking for a book on Rwanda that is not so depressing or cynical, and know little of the country in modern times, this is a good introduction point. It has a purpose to serve, but it did not do so for me.