The Mussoorie Murders

by Divyaroop Bhatnagar

Mussoorie, 1909. The ghastly murder of Margaret Maynard Liddell in a hotel room locked from the inside shocks the public. Its ripples reach Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Rudyard Kipling, who can only guess the identity of the killer but never prove it. Around sixty years later, a wealthy heiress is found similarly murdered in the queen of the hills.
The needle of suspicion points to an old housekeeper, an estranged brother, an aloof husband, and a fraud godman and his acolyte, for each of them has a motive to kill her. Avijit Sikdar, an Oxford-returned detective and a fan of Doyle and Kipling’s writings, gets a whiff of the case and begins his hunt for the elusive killer while trying to piece together the connection between the two crimes. Join Sikdar and Kipling on this thrilling and page-turning adventure across two timelines as they untangle the mystery of the murder in a locked room.

Genres: Mystery, Thriller, Audiobook, Indian Literature, Murder Mystery, Crime

295 pages, Paperback

Published September 11, 2023

About the author

Divyaroop (Debu) Bhatnagar was born and brought up in Kanpur. As a child, his family would go up to Mussoorie every summer for their school vacations and the love for the place and the mountains have stayed with him for a lifetime.

Debu loves reading, travelling and pretends to play Golf and Bridge. He has fancied his hand at writing since he was a young man and in a benevolent alternate universe he may well have been a writer to start with instead of the quintessential corporate honcho that he became.

Debu has finally decided to slow down and find time for all the things he loves, Writing (at last!), long drives in the Himalayas and solving the world’s problems with likeminded friends. He has two grown up daughters and two lovely granddaughters and lives in Gurgaon with his wife, Devi.

Reviews

[Supratim · Rating 4 out of 5]

Interesting!

This novel features two locked-room murder mysteries running in parallel though set apart in time by 60 years.

The book is very easy to read and can be finished in one sitting.

Full review to come soon!

[Kavya Bhat · Rating 4 out of 5]

Atmospheric & Clever Locked-Room Mystery :

The Mussoorie Murders is a gripping blend of historical crime fiction and classic mystery that unfolds across two eras — a real 1909 locked-room murder and a fictional 1973 murder in the misty hills of Mussoorie. Both cases are eerily similar, and unraveling their connection becomes the heart of this narrative.

[Lalitha Ramanathan · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Mussoorie Murders by Divyaroop Bhatnagar is a riveting read, reminiscent of Agatha Christie’s whodunnits. The book touches on two murders committed years apart, the first in 1909, and the second in 1973. This gripping narrative traverses between these two periods.

The death of Margaret Maynard Liddell in 1909 had baffled many. More than sixty years later, Anahita Bilimoria’s murder is similar. Both crimes were committed in the picturesque hill station of Mussoorie, under nearly identical circumstances. The victims were women; heiresses, unlucky in love, who visited Mussoorie to heal their broken hearts through spirituality. They were found murdered in locked rooms, bolted from the inside, baffling the police and family members alike. Are the resemblances only coincidental, or have buried secrets resurfaced? The Oxford-returned Avijit Sikdar in an Indian Hercule Poirot avatar, attempts to get to the bottom of the mystery.

The scenic beauty of Mussoorie comes alive through the author’s words, as he captures the old-world charm of the buildings, the local cuisine, and the grandeur of the hotels. The plot abounds with red herrings and suspicious characters; an inheritance, an estranged family, a cheating spouse, a fraudulent Godman, and greedy siblings. Avijit deciphers the clues and ties up both cases neatly, in a satisfying conclusion.

The writing is elegant and flows easily. A times the two timelines can get a tad confusing, given the similarity of the circumstances and the location. It may take the reader a split-second to recalibrate between the two. What makes this book stand out is the blending of fact and fiction, using real-life narratives and anecdotes from the doyens of literature- Rudyard Kipling, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, and Agatha Christie.

I'm eager to watch the onscreen adaptation of this compelling read. I look forward to reading more of Avijit’s adventures in the future!

[Riju Ganguly · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book, a retro mystery set in the seventies of last century, harking back to events farther back, turned out to be a very good one. It reminded me of the frisson generated by classical works penned by the Great authors.
Best part of this work was its ability to solve a historical locked-room mystery while paying homage to Dame Christie. The writing also had a distinctly Sharadindu-like flavour, making the book even more endearing.
Hopefully the author would charm us with more cases of Abhijit Sikdar.
Recommended.

[Mitra Samal · Rating 5 out of 5]

Great story telling. Gives you chills and is an absolute page turner. The story of the unsolved Mussoorie murder in 1909 (inspired by a true event) and creating a parallel to it sixty years later makes it deeply engaging. Both the timelines where experts work to solve a murder mystery of the murder in a locked room will just blow your mind.

The writing style is captivating and builds the story in a fashion that makes it gripping right from the start to the end.

[Surbhi Amba · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Mussoorie Murders is a murder-mystery thriller that spans two interconnected timelines and combines historical intrigue with classic detective fiction elements

Plot Summary:
The story begins in 1909 in Mussoorie, when Margaret is found brutally murdered in a hotel room locked from the inside, baffling the residents and authorities. The mystery attracts the attention of literary heavyweights Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Rudyard Kipling, who try (but ultimately fail) to uncover the truth behind this locked-room murder.

Fast forward about 60 years, and another woman, a wealthy heiress named Anahita Bilimoria, is discovered dead in eerily similar circumstances in Mussoorie. The investigation into her death points suspicion at several individuals: an old housekeeper, an estranged brother, an aloof husband, and even a fraudulent godman with a follower.

At the center of the modern investigation is Avijit Sikdar, an Oxford-educated detective with a deep love for mystery classics, especially the works of Doyle and Kipling. As he digs deeper, Sikdar begins to notice links between the two murders and works to unravel the connections across the decades.

The dual timelines - early 20th century and the 1970s (or mid-20th century) - alternate throughout the book, gradually revealing clues, suspects, and motives, and building toward a resolution in which the mysteries of both killings are untangled.

What I Liked:
* Locked-room mystery
* Historical fiction meets detective noir
* Atmospheric setting
* Homage to classic mystery writers

In Short:
The Mussoorie Murders is a layered, atmospheric detective thriller that blends historical true crime inspiration with fictional sleuthing, weaving two eras of baffling murders together through careful plotting, rich setting, and a classic locked-room puzzle that keeps readers guessing until the end.

[Abhijit Chakraborty · Rating 4 out of 5]

Book Title: The Mussoorie Murders
Author: Divyaroop Bhatnagar
Publisher: Om Books International
Format: Paperback
Language: English
Genre: Murder Mystery
Pages: 295
Book Rating: 4/5

"The Mussoorie Murders" by Divyaroop Bhatnagar is a thrilling murder mystery that captivates readers from the very beginning. The novel's unique premise, featuring two interconnected murders separated by six decades, sets the stage for an intriguing and well-crafted story. Bhatnagar skillfully combines fact and fiction, drawing in iconic literary figures like Conan Doyle and Kipling, which adds a delightful layer of authenticity and charm to the narrative. “Conan Doyle never forgot about the Mussoorie murder.”

As the plot unfolds, the locked-room mysteries within the book will leave readers both baffled and engaged. Bhatnagar's meticulous attention to detail and cleverly hidden clues keep you on the edge of your seat, allowing you to become a detective alongside the characters as you attempt to unravel the complex mystery.

Overall, "The Mussoorie Murders" is a must-read for fans of murder mysteries and classic literature. Divyaroop Bhatnagar's storytelling prowess shines through, and his love for the setting of Mussoorie is palpable, making it a character in itself. This book is a literary gem that pays homage to the great mystery writers while forging its path in the genre, leaving readers eagerly anticipating more from this versatile author.

[Akshay Patil · Rating 4 out of 5]

The brilliance of "The Mussoorie Murders" lies in its clever fusion of fact and fiction, resulting in a narrative that's not only entertaining but also deeply thought-provoking. The intricate blend of real-life elements and imaginative storytelling creates a captivating reading experience.

The story's central mysteries, involving well-to-do yet isolated heiresses, and the baffling locked-room murders within bedrooms, serve as a foundation for an intriguing plot. The author masterfully weaves these enigmatic elements into the narrative, leaving both the police and readers perplexed about how such crimes could occur. The multitude of twists and turns ensures that guessing the identity of the murderer is far from easy, adding layers of suspense and complexity to the story.

"The Mussoorie Murders" is a testament to the author's ability to craft a narrative that keeps you engrossed, challenges your deductive skills, and provides an enthralling reading experience. This is a book that beautifully blurs the lines between fact and fiction, making it a must-read for anyone who appreciates a mystery that's as entertaining as it is thought-provoking.

[Vandana Doss · Rating 4 out of 5]

INTRIGUING, fascinating, absorbing and exciting! That, in a nutshell, describes Divyaroop Bhatnagar's latest work, "The Mussoorie Murders".

The story begins with a touch of a "somnolent summer's afternoon", which is rather beguiling, for, as one turns the pages, the plot traverses through a heady combination of romance, cheerfulness, desolation, melancholy, greed, conspiracy, deception and even the occult among the wealthy and upper crust of society. It encapsulates sensational dramatic episodes with enigmatic characters and exciting events intended to appeal to the emotions of murder mystery aficionados.

Divyaroop Bhatnagar describes with warm, often vivid appreciation, a rich cast of blue-blooded aristocratic characters from Bombay to Poona to Lucknow to Dehradun to Mussoorie from the early 1900s to the 1970s. What is striking about the narrative is how the author skillfully navigates back and forth between the British era and India of the 1970s, reminiscent of the flashbacks that often occur in Hindi cinema.

Divyaroop writes with an easy, readable lightness of touch. A thoroughly enjoyable book of suspense that carries throughout the story to the very end.

- KVN Doss

[Pranav · Rating 3 out of 5]

I really enjoyed the book. The setting of Mussourie was beautiful. At first, the switch between the two periods was a bit jarring, but I got into it as the story got going. There were a couple of things that pulled me out of the story, though. First, the character of the husband felt like a copy of Watson instead of developing naturally. Second, there were so many connections to the British that it felt like a British story with few Indian characters, not the other way around.

Most mysteries I’ve read start with the crime, but this one started with the world and character development. I liked the change, but it did feel like the build-up went on a bit too long for me.

[Anirudh Kukreja · Rating 3 out of 5]

I have some mixed reviews about this one:
1. The storyline was interesting and I loved how both the crimes, separated by over half a century, manage to come together.
2. The characters are extremely loveable
3. The pace is really good and the novel gets over before it starts to get on your nerves. Managed to finish this in 3-4 hours straight.
4. It's not a whodunnit: within the first half of the novel, the culprit is extremely obvious.
5. As I mentioned, I loved both the story and the pace; however, the style of writing is extremely juvenile.

[Anjum Attar · Rating 5 out of 5]

The book was gripping, difficult to put down. Unique plots and storytelling.

[Priya · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was such a fun read. Plot twists and unexpected happenings with a good dose of Mussoorie, mystery and nostalgia! Well written and well plotted out. 😊

[Vidya Bhayani · Rating 5 out of 5]

The intricate web of clues and red herrings woven into "The Mussoorie Murders" is a true test for any detective enthusiast. As a reader, you find yourself entangled in a suspenseful puzzle, challenged to decipher the subtle hints and misdirections alongside the characters. The author's skill in crafting this complex narrative keeps you on your toes, making each revelation and unexpected turn a thrilling discovery.

What adds an extra layer of intrigue is the speculative connection to Agatha Christie's iconic debut, "The Mysterious Affair at Styles." The thought that the events at Mussoorie might have inspired one of the greatest mystery writers of all time is a fascinating notion. It sparks a literary curiosity and prompts readers to draw parallels between the fictional world of "The Mussoorie Murders" and the origins of Christie's classic.
“What is more speculative is whether Agatha Christie was inspired by the events at Mussoorie for writing her first book, The Mysterious Affair at Styles.”
It's a clever inclusion by the author that not only deepens the mystery within the book but also adds a meta-layer for those familiar with Christie's work, inviting them to ponder the interconnectedness of literary inspiration.

[Urmi Chakravorty · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Mussoorie Murders, Divyaroop Bhatnagar's debut novel published by Om Books International, proves to be an interesting read, particularly for readers like me who nurse a penchant for whodunits. It also marks his first foray into the domain of crime fiction. At 208 pages and twenty-two chapters, this book can be reasonably wrapped up within two or three reading sessions.

As the title suggests, the setting is the picturesque hill town of Mussoorie. Here, I applaud the writer for coining a title which spontaneously evokes curiosity and intrigue. Mussoorie is a popular destination - I have personally visited it twice and loved both the times. But natural beauty and touristy delight are not what grab eyeballs in this book. The writer has consciously added an eerie element to this Himalayan haven. There occur two episodes of death here, in an uncannily similar set-up, involving similar victims and circumstances. Only, they are dated sixty years apart.

Margaret Maynard Liddell and Anahita Bilimoria die of poisoning in their sleep within rooms which are locked and secured from inside. There are no indications of a forced entry and no tell-tale signs left behind by the murderer. Both the ladies belong to the upper echelons of society, cultivate refined tastes, and have delicate temperaments. Unfortunately, both have been unlucky in love and find themselves lonely and listless. They fall prey to unholy spiritual influences, act in a reckless, unbecoming manner, which, together, catalyse their emotional bankruptcy and eventually, their death. These two plots run parallel in the book in alternating chapters.

Bhatnagar has meticulously drawn up the family connections and back story of both the protagonists. Margaret’s childhood and family in England in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, her journey to Bombay and Lucknow in India, and her subsequent personal misfortune have been essayed in great detail. The old world charm of the Indian cities, their landmarks, the names and routes of ships and trains, the colonial milieu, and the pahaadi ambience of Mussoorie have been reproduced with complete honesty. The same goes for Anahita’s story set in Bombay in the 1970s. The charming, close-knit Parsi community, along with its distinct social set-up, has been portrayed with warmth and candour.

Apart from the two leading ladies, Margaret and Anahita, a number of secondary and tertiary characters criss-cross the plot. Immediate and extended family, friends, domestic helps, attendants, emotional and spiritual anchors, the police and the investigating brigade – they all have a role to play. Bhatnagar has achieved this onerous task of fleshing out so many characters of two parallel plots, without losing track or leaving behind loose ends.

Both the plots have been given equal importance, though I personally felt Anahita’s story enjoyed greater clarity because of the more recent setting and better investigative procedures. The detrimental effect of believing in fake godmen and dubious séance sessions has been highlighted – an unfortunate social trend that continues even today. The writer has peppered the developments with a fair amount of foreshadowing, thus tempting the reader to map the clues and draw his own conclusions – a distinct pre-requisite for a successful thriller. The narrative uses a simple, conversational language that can engage youngsters and adults alike.

Divyaroop Bhatnagar has attempted a rather unique and ambitious technique of introducing iconic literary figures in his novel like Rudyard Kipling, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie, and Sherlock Holmes, and embedding them in the matrix of the plots – a surprise fusion, for sure! For a more immediate and discernible investigation, we have the brilliant Oxford-returned, unobtrusive Avijit Sikdar, our modern-day answer to Hercule Poirot and Holmes.

My only pointer to Bhatnagar’s book would be the constant to and fro movement between timelines in each chapter. In a crime thriller, we tend to dwell upon each new development or discovery for a while, allow our little grey cells to deliberate and deduce, and then move on to the next set of events. Here, we had to shuttle between 1909 and 1973 in consecutive chapters, keeping track of characters, names, places, clues and the like. And given the similarities, I felt a little confused at times. Shifting gear after two or three chapters may have been a feasible alternative in a case like this.

The Mussoorie Murders is an absorbing read with several nail-biting moments that is bound to engage the reader right till the denouement. With the weather turning nippy now, this book is certainly recommended along with a cosy duvet and several cups of milk tea, with the latter making multiple appearances in both the plots!

[Sameer Gudhate · Rating 4 out of 5]

There are books you read with a cup of tea in hand, letting the warmth seep into your palms while the pages gently turn. And then there are books that snatch the cup right out of your grasp, sending it crashing to the floor because—what just happened? The Mussoorie Murders by Divyaroop Bhatnagar did exactly that to me. I opened it expecting a quiet weekend read. Instead, I found myself wide awake past midnight, staring at the ceiling, replaying clues like a detective who refused to clock out.

Divyaroop Bhatnagar—fondly known as Debu to readers who’ve been following his work—carves a space for himself in the landscape of Indian detective fiction that feels both nostalgic and refreshingly new. He writes with the confidence of someone who has walked through Mussoorie’s misty lanes at dawn and listened to the wind tell secrets. His story spans two eras, 1909 and 1973, yet he holds the threads with steady hands, weaving them into a tapestry that glows with old-world charm and contemporary sharpness.

At its heart, the novel is a chilling locked-room mystery that begins in 1909 with the brutal murder of Margaret Maynard Liddell inside a hotel room bolted from the inside—an impossible crime that rattles the British administration and piques the curiosity of literary giants Rudyard Kipling and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Fast forward sixty-something years, and Mussoorie witnesses another eerily similar murder—the death of heiress Anahita Bilimoria, found lifeless under circumstances that mimic Margaret’s fate. Two women. Two rooms locked from within. Two eras haunted by silence. And one persistent detective: Avijit Sikdar, a mathematics professor turned Oxford-bred sleuth whose love for classic mysteries is as crucial as his ability to see beyond the obvious.

This premise alone is delicious. But what delighted me most was the texture of the writing. Bhatnagar doesn’t simply describe Mussoorie—he resurrects it. I could almost taste the cold fog curling around lamp posts, hear the crunch of pine needles underfoot, see the way twilight glowed against slate rooftops. Mussoorie shifts from being a holiday postcard to a living accomplice—quiet, patient, holding its breath. If Ruskin Bond gave us the Mussoorie of gentle rains and childhood nostalgia, Bhatnagar gives us the Mussoorie where shadows cling a little too long and every locked window feels like a withheld confession.

The narrative alternates between the two timeframes, but instead of disorienting the reader, it adds dimension—like peeling wallpaper in an old mansion revealing the stories beneath. The pacing is crisp, every chapter bearing just enough weight without overstaying its welcome. The suspense builds not with loud shocks but with subtle tightening, like the quiet click of a lock in the dark.

Avijit Sikdar is a character I won’t forget soon. There is something deeply human about him—not a flamboyant Sherlock, not a brooding Byomkesh, but an intellectual who wrestles with logic and instinct in equal measure. His admiration for Doyle and Kipling doesn’t feel like fan service; it becomes an emotional compass. And the supporting characters, from the enigmatic housekeeper to the aloof husband to the charlatan godman, each carry the smell of possibility—guilt, grief, or truth.

There are moments in the book that made me pause—particularly the quiet reflections on the loneliness hidden beneath wealth and the idea that secrets do not die, they merely wait. It reminded me of something my father once said: “Time doesn’t erase—it only rearranges.” These two murders sixty years apart feel like echoes refusing to fade.

If I had to gently critique anything, it would be that a couple of secondary characters could have been explored a shade deeper; some emotional beats left me wanting more—not out of dissatisfaction, but because I was invested. The ending, though immensely satisfying, arrives like a sudden gust of wind: stunning, but I wished I had a few more seconds to brace myself.

But the strengths? They shine. The atmosphere. The layered structure. The elegant prose. The blending of fact and fiction so seamlessly that the boundary dissolves. The homage to the golden age of murder mysteries without becoming derivative. Bhatnagar writes like someone lighting a candle in a dark room—slowly, deliberately, illuminating just enough to keep you moving forward.

When I closed the book, I realized something: mysteries aren’t about catching killers. They’re about understanding what drives people to the edges of themselves. And this novel does that beautifully.

If you love atmospheric thrillers, historical mysteries, literary crossovers, or simply the feeling of being deliciously unsettled—The Mussoorie Murders deserves a spot on your shelf, somewhere close to Doyle, Christie, and maybe a cup of hot cocoa for emotional support.

And maybe, just maybe, after reading it, you’ll think twice before checking into a room with the windows locked from the inside.

Go find this book. Sink into it. Let the mist swallow you whole.

[Swapna Peri ( Book Reviews Cafe ) · Rating 5 out of 5]

## **Introduction**

*The Mussoorie Murders* by Divyaroop Bhatnagar captured my attention from the start with its blend of historical intrigue and literary flair. The novel is set against the picturesque backdrop of the Mussoorie hill station, where two mysterious deaths—spanning over six decades—unravel in a locked-room mystery format. The combination of fact and fiction, along with nods to iconic literary figures like Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Rudyard Kipling, adds an extra layer of sophistication to the narrative, making this a standout read in the mystery genre.

## **Plot Overview**

The story centres around two murders: the first in 1909 when Margaret Maynard Liddell is found dead in a locked hotel room, and the second in 1973 when Anahita Bilimoria, another heiress, meets a similar fate. Both women, tragically unlucky in love, seek refuge in Mussoorie, only to face eerily identical deaths. These unsolved cases become the obsession of Avijit Sikdar, an Oxford-educated detective with a passion for classic literature, who sets out to uncover the connection between the two crimes.

## **Themes and Structure**

What really stands out in *The Mussoorie Murders* is how Author Bhatnagar masterfully intertwines two timelines—1909 and 1973—to create suspense. The parallel plotlines keep the reader engaged, gradually revealing hidden clues and building toward a climactic conclusion. The themes of isolation, secrecy, and betrayal are seamlessly woven into the narrative, highlighting the personal struggles of the two women and the lengths people go to hide their darkest secrets.

## **Characterization**

Avijit Sikdar, the central character, is a fascinating detective with a love for literary greats, which influences his approach to solving the mystery. His intellectual curiosity and determination make him an engaging protagonist. The supporting characters, including the two victims, are well-developed, with their backstories contributing depth to the unfolding drama. Bhatnagar’s skill lies in making each character feel integral to the plot, no matter how brief their role.

## **Atmosphere and Setting**

Mussoorie itself is almost a character in the novel, with its misty hills, quiet hotels, and secluded charm providing the perfect setting for the crimes. Bhatnagar’s vivid descriptions of the hill station create a moody, atmospheric backdrop that enhances the tension of the story. I felt fully immersed in the setting, as though I was walking the same streets as the characters, searching for answers to the mystery. Ruskin Bond's Mussoorie is different from Divyaroop Bhatnagar's Mussoorie!

## **Writing Style and Influence**

Bhatnagar’s writing has elegance, paying homage to the classic mystery genre while adding a modern twist. His incorporation of historical figures like Conan Doyle and Kipling adds authenticity and depth to the story, particularly for fans of classic literature. The novel's structure is tight, with every chapter adding a new layer of intrigue, making it difficult to put the book down until the final reveal.

## **Conclusion**

In conclusion, *The Mussoorie Murders* is a must-read for anyone who enjoys a well-crafted, intricate mystery with a literary bent. Bhatnagar’s skillful storytelling, attention to detail, and engaging characters make this a highly satisfying read. The novel not only pays tribute to the golden age of detective fiction but also stands on its own as a modern, sophisticated mystery. This is one book I’ll be recommending to fellow mystery enthusiasts for its compelling plot and unforgettable atmosphere.

[Kitabi Keeda · Rating 4 out of 5]

📍A gripping murder mystery, filled with clever twists & turns that will keep you guessing!

•• INSIGHT: The book revolves around two mysterious murders that take place in an eerily similar fashion in the hill station of Mussoorie, some sixty-four years apart. As history repeats itself, Professor Avijit Sikdar, a renowned Oxford-returned sleuth must race against time to solve the puzzle of the recent murder, while also trying to find out whether the two crimes are somehow linked. Will he succeed, or will the riddles remain unsolved forever?

•• REVIEW: Anahita Bilimoria, a Parsi heiress settled in Bombay circa 1973, takes a trip to Mussoorie & meets the same fate as Margaret Maynard Liddell did in the queen of hills in 1909. The story spans across two timelines, alternating between the events of 1909 & 1973. The author has done a splendid job of crafting this whodunnit, drawing inspiration from the greats of detective fiction, Arthur Conan Doyle as well as Agatha Christie, even giving them brief cameos in the book. The book has been inspired by the true murder case of British Spiritualist, Lady Garnett-Orme, in the Savoy Hotel in Mussoorie, in the 1910s. Riveting suspense & a strong climax made the book a memorable read.

•• STRENGTH: 1. Narration, pacing & characterization were extremely well-done.
2. Great suspense & thrill was maintained throughout, never allowing a dull moment.
3. Climax was duly satisfying.
4. The cameos made by Doyle, Christie & Rudyard Kipling in the story, as well as the inspiration of the book being a true crime, add fascination & intrigue for literature lovers.

•• WEAKNESS: 1. The only minor weakness was that I could personally guess the intricacies of the crime & the killer some 40 pages before the detective officially unfolded his findings, though the writer did manage to make me second-guess quite a few times with his deft red-herrings. Did not take away from the charm of the story at all!

•• TARGET READERS : Suitable for readers with a keen interest in cosy murder mysteries, true crime stories & detective fiction

•• GENRE: Mystery/Thriller

•• RATING: 4.4/5

[Asad · Rating 4 out of 5]

"The Mussoorie Murders" brilliantly marries historical crime fiction with the allure of locked-room mysteries, offering a riveting narrative that seamlessly weaves fact and fiction. The novel skillfully unfolds two murders – the true, unsolved case of Margaret Maynard Liddell in the early 20th century, juxtaposed with the fictitious 1973 murder of Parsi heiress Anahita Bilimoria. This dual timeline, guided by the modern Sherlock Holmes, Avijit Sikdar, sets the stage for a captivating exploration of crime, suspects, and an enigmatic antagonist.

The author's commendable storytelling prowess keeps readers on the edge, skillfully introducing red herrings that add layers of complexity to the investigation. The alternating chapters between the two murders provide a nuanced understanding of the common elements, including seances and the mysterious Godman, Vishwa Jyoti, and his accomplice, Marjorie.

The narrative is a delightful dance between the historical and the fictitious, offering a rich setting in Mussoorie that enhances the atmospheric allure of the story. Avijit Sikdar, as the investigator, channels the spirit of Sherlock Holmes, adding a familiar yet fresh perspective to the unfolding mystery. The incorporation of literary giants like Arthur Conan Doyle, Agatha Christie, and Rudyard Kipling as minor characters adds an extra layer of intrigue for readers familiar with their works.

The book ticks all the boxes of a compelling crime fiction, delivering a satisfying and logical resolution to both mysteries. However, a minor flaw is noted regarding chapter headings lacking dates, causing occasional confusion in the timeline transitions. Despite this, "The Mussoorie Murders" stands as an excellent example of crime fiction set in an Indian context, offering a thrilling read that ties up all knots seamlessly. Highly recommended for those who appreciate the fusion of history, suspense, and the timeless charm of classic detective tales.

[Mukta · Rating 5 out of 5]

I'm a sucker for murder mysteries and courtroom dramas, so when I came across Divyaroop Bhatnagar's Mussoorie Murders, it didn’t take long for me to curl up and get lost in its pages. Mr. Bhatnagar is a master storyteller, weaving together two interbraiding storylines separated by decades. As I read, it felt like a movie playing on a screen in my head.
Mr. Bhatnagar's ability to make readers fall for both strong-minded damsels in the novel is impressive. As you watch them be led into trouble, you want to warn them, tell them to be careful - watch out, but it's to no avail. A girl will do what a girl will do. But the clever writer quickly shifts the scene, leaving you to follow the intriguing life of the other girl you've also become attached to. When the murders happen, Mr. Bhatnagar executes them so deftly that you accept them and move on, eager to see what happens next.
The author brilliantly adds glamour to the plot by including characters like Kipling and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. I hadn't realized until now that they were contemporaries. Much of the discourse in the book happens over food or drinks, in eating places, bars, or at dinner tables. Reading about the sumptuous meals makes you feel like part of the feasting experience. Next time I visit Mussoorie, I will surely check out the watering holes and eateries introduced in this wonderful novel. I so wish they exist.
After finishing the book, several marvelous characters remain vivid in my mind. I will surely be thinking about them for some time to come. One memorable example is a butler dressed in a hotel uniform—bow tie and all—who, before picking up the guests' luggage and speaking in fluent, educated English while leading them to their rooms, bends down to touch their feet. This brief, delightful interlude is both flabbergasting and charming.
Thank you, Divyaroop, for this wonderful treat. I eagerly await your next book.

[ANMOL JAUHER · Rating 4 out of 5]

Entering the world of "The Mussoorie Murders" by Divyaroop Bhatnagar felt like embarking on a captivating journey through two timelines, trying to untangle these perplexing locked-room mysteries that spanned a good 60 years. Bhatnagar's storytelling prowess kept me glued, decoding clues and navigating through unexpected twists.

The notion that Agatha Christie might have drawn inspiration from the Mussoorie events for her debut novel, "The Mysterious Affair at Styles," added this intriguing layer to the narrative. It was as if I was invited to explore the fascinating connections between real-life incidents and the magic of literature.

Bhatnagar skillfully wove together common threads in the two murder tales – the wealthy yet isolated heiresses, those confounding locked-room scenarios. The narrative resembled a rollercoaster ride, with suspenseful turns, unexpected twists, and clever misdirections, making me constantly question the identity of the elusive murderer.

Imagine this: amid seances, spirits, and a modern-day godman with followers, we meet an Indian detective with a Poirot vibe, piecing together the 1973 murder. The links between the two eras formed this intricate puzzle, making the entire reading experience satisfyingly rich.

And what made this book stand out? The playful inclusion of legendary authors like Rudyard Kipling and Arthur Conan Doyle in solving the first murder. There was even this intriguing hint that Conan Doyle might have shared the Mussoorie story with Agatha Christie, adding an extra layer of literary mystery.

As someone who loves Agatha Christie, I tip my hat to Divyaroop Bhatnagar for crafting such an engaging murder mystery. I can't wait for more from this author in the mystery genre – pretty sure they've earned a spot among my all-time favorites!

[Shweta · Rating 5 out of 5]

"The Mussoorie Murders" takes place in the charming town of Mussoorie in 1909. The mystery sets in with the horrifying murder of Margaret Maynard Liddell in a closed hotel room. This crime shocks the public and draws the interest of well-known writers Rudyard Kipling and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

The story then picks up sixty years later, when a rich heiress is discovered murdered in a similar manner. A distant husband, an old housekeeper, an alienated sibling, and even a dishonest godman and his disciple are on the list of suspects. They all have some or the other motivation for killing the heiress and so Avijit Sikdar, a detective who returned from Oxford and an admirer of Doyle and Kipling, finds himself in this challenging puzzle to put the pieces together.

The book's skillful merging of two timelines is one of its finest features. Readers are taken on an exciting adventure as Sikdar investigates the case further, finding clues and drawing connections between the two crimes.

The intriguing exchanges between Rudyard Kipling and Arthur Conan Doyle highlight the author's historical research and understanding of the time. I have thoroughly enjoyed the rich and fine vocabulary author has employed which makes this story such a pleasurable read.

The characters and story telling in "The Mussoorie Murders" are diverse and well-developed, which gives the plot more depth. With his captivating methods of gradually but expertly revealing the enigma surrounding the murder, Avijit Sikdar in particular emerges as an attractive detective and quickly wins over readers.

It's been a very long time since I've read a historical thriller that was this enjoyable, additionally the author's careful plotting keeps the storyline tight and compelling. This captivating mystery is definitely the one that will keep you turning the pages.

[Pinki Pandit · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book weaves a captivating tale that spans decades, linking the ghastly murder of Margaret Maynard Liddell in 1909 to a chillingly similar crime sixty years later in the picturesque Mussoorie. Author intricately entwines the worlds of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Rudyard Kipling as their speculations fuel the suspense, creating a literary dance between fiction and reality.

Avijit Sikdar, the Oxford-returned detective, emerges as a compelling protagonist with his affinity for the literary works of Doyle and Kipling. As he delves into the enigma of a locked room murder, the narrative unfolds with a mesmerizing blend of historical context and modern intrigue. The suspects - an old housekeeper, an estranged brother, an aloof husband, and a dubious godman and his acolyte - add layers of complexity to the plot, each harboring motives that keep readers guessing until the final pages.

The storytelling prowess of the author shines through as Sikdar and Kipling embark on a thrilling adventure, seamlessly navigating two timelines. The atmospheric setting of Mussoorie adds to the mystique, enhancing the overall immersive experience. The meticulous attention to detail, coupled with the interplay of literary elements, elevates the plot beyond a typical murder mystery.

Readers will find themselves engrossed in the intricate puzzle, eager to unravel the secrets hidden within the locked room. The novel masterfully pays homage to the detective legacy of Doyle and the literary charm of Kipling, creating a page-turning fusion of history, suspense, and timeless storytelling. This is a must-read for mystery enthusiasts who appreciate a narrative that transcends eras and leaves a lingering sense of intrigue.

[Komal Singh · Rating 4 out of 5]

"The Mussoorie Murders" is a literary gem that immerses readers in the rich tapestry of historical crime fiction and locked-room mysteries. The dual narrative, seamlessly blending true and fictional murders, serves as a testament to the author's storytelling finesse. The opening with the unsolved case of Margaret Maynard Liddell, followed by the 1973 murder of Parsi heiress Anahita Bilimoria, sets the stage for a gripping exploration of suspense, suspects, and a mysterious antagonist.

Avijit Sikdar, the modern Sherlock Holmes, leads the charge in unraveling these perplexing crimes, navigating the intricate web of seances, Godmen, and enigmatic characters. The alternating chapters between timelines offer a compelling juxtaposition, enhancing the complexity and depth of the narrative.

The novel flawlessly captures the essence of good crime fiction – a detective with sharp instincts, a well-crafted crime, a gallery of suspects, a formidable antagonist, and a captivating setting in Mussoorie. The author skillfully keeps readers guessing with well-placed red herrings, creating an engaging and dynamic reading experience.

Despite its brilliance, a minor drawback surfaces with the absence of dates in chapter headings, occasionally causing confusion during timeline shifts. Nevertheless, the meticulous resolution of both mysteries at the story's conclusion adds a satisfying touch to the narrative.

In summary, "The Mussoorie Murders" stands as an outstanding example of crime fiction, delivering a thrilling and intellectually satisfying read. Despite a minor navigational hiccup, the book's ability to tie up all loose ends contributes to its status as a must-read for enthusiasts of mysteries, history, and classic detective tales.

[Aman · Rating 4 out of 5]

"The Mussoorie Murders" weaves an intricate tapestry of historical crime fiction, blending the reality of an unsolved 20th-century murder with the suspense of a fictitious 1973 crime. The dual timelines provide a captivating backdrop as readers navigate through the labyrinth of mysteries, guided by the modern-day detective, Avijit Sikdar.

Sikdar, a character reminiscent of classic sleuths, injects familiarity into the narrative while uncovering the enigma of seances, the mysterious Godman Vishwa Jyoti, and his accomplice Marjorie. The novel excels in delivering the quintessence of crime fiction – a compelling investigator, a meticulously crafted crime, a diverse array of suspects, a formidable antagonist, and a vivid setting that leaps off the pages.

The absence of dates in chapter headings may momentarily challenge readers shifting between timelines, but the story's resolution expertly ties up all loose ends. The logical and satisfying conclusion to both mysteries leaves a lingering sense of fulfillment.

What sets this book apart is its ability to offer a cultural immersion within an Indian context. The atmospheric portrayal of Mussoorie adds an extra layer of richness to the narrative, creating a unique reading experience that transcends traditional crime fiction. The novel's success lies not only in its suspenseful plot but also in its nuanced exploration of societal and cultural dynamics.

"The Mussoorie Murders" stands as a triumph in the genre, providing a fresh and compelling take on historical crime fiction. With its intricate plotting, engaging characters, and a cultural tapestry that resonates, the book is a recommended read for those seeking a mystery that transcends timelines and offers a truly unique literary experience.

[Viraj · Rating 4 out of 5]

"The Mussoorie Murders" weaves an intricate tapestry of historical crime fiction, blending the reality of an unsolved 20th-century murder with the suspense of a fictitious 1973 crime. The dual timelines provide a captivating backdrop as readers navigate through the labyrinth of mysteries, guided by the modern-day detective, Avijit Sikdar.

Sikdar, a character reminiscent of classic sleuths, injects familiarity into the narrative while uncovering the enigma of seances, the mysterious Godman Vishwa Jyoti, and his accomplice Marjorie. The novel excels in delivering the quintessence of crime fiction – a compelling investigator, a meticulously crafted crime, a diverse array of suspects, a formidable antagonist, and a vivid setting that leaps off the pages.

The absence of dates in chapter headings may momentarily challenge readers shifting between timelines, but the story's resolution expertly ties up all loose ends. The logical and satisfying conclusion to both mysteries leaves a lingering sense of fulfillment.

What sets this book apart is its ability to offer a cultural immersion within an Indian context. The atmospheric portrayal of Mussoorie adds an extra layer of richness to the narrative, creating a unique reading experience that transcends traditional crime fiction. The novel's success lies not only in its suspenseful plot but also in its nuanced exploration of societal and cultural dynamics.

"The Mussoorie Murders" stands as a triumph in the genre, providing a fresh and compelling take on historical crime fiction. With its intricate plotting, engaging characters, and a cultural tapestry that resonates, the book is a recommended read for those seeking a mystery that transcends timelines and offers a truly unique literary experience.

[Ishika Hirani · Rating 4 out of 5]

The Mussoorie Murders by Divyaroop Bhatnagar is a thrilling murder mystery that takes readers on a Heart throbbing Expedition of unveiling the secrets behind Two Murder cases that take place on different time cycles but have some connections linked to them. Margaret Maynard, A British Lady Brutally Murdered in a locked room of Mussoorie in the year 1909 links its story with another woman Anahita who is found similarly murdered in the hills of Mussoorie almost 60 years later. To solve the mystery of the first case, Sir Arthur conan Doyle and Rudyard Kipling come together and put Their best efforts to reveal the culprit of the murder. 

On the other hand, Anahita's murder raises the suspicion and the doubts of the case are laid upon several persons who could be potential killers of her. The book gets more interesting when an Oxford returned Investigator, Avijit Sikdar holds the command and unfolds the mystery behind the connection between both murders and fixes the pieces of this tangling Case. Bhatnagar's Intriguing writing style and the plot development makes this book an Enthralling read.

Overall, The Mussoorie Murders is a well penned Suspense thriller book that allows readers to delve deeper into the realm of Secrets, Adventure, Mystery and Thrill. The plot of the locked room murder makes the book a lot more interesting and the inclusion of famous personalities like Arthur Conan Doyle and Rudyard Kipling leaves an impactful mark on the mind of readers. The characters are very well developed and you can easily imagine the whole background of the book. In conclusion, I will highly recommend this captivating book to all the readers. This book will surely keep you hooked till the end.

[Fiction freakk · Rating 3 out of 5]

I was genuinely drawn into the misty charm of Mussoorie—the mist, the colonial-era hotels, the secluded hill-station ambiance are evocatively painted and feel like a character in the novel itself. 🌲🏔️ The dual timeline—a true crime from 1909 entwined with a fictional murder in 1973—builds a suspenseful, locked-room mystery that kept me guessing. The story differentiates itself by starting with character and world development rather than dumping a crime scene on page one—a refreshing shift.

“The combination of fact and fiction, along with nods to iconic literary figures…adds an extra layer…”

Yet, the pacing feels uneven. The build-up occasionally drags, and the frequent timeline-switching became jarring—sometimes it's hard to recalibrate between 1909 and 1973.

Character-wise, Avijit Sikdar has a certain intellectual charm—he reads like a modern Hercule Poirot, with literary cameos from Kipling, Doyle, and Christie lending the narrative extra flair. But I never truly connected with him. The husband character, in particular, felt too much like a Watson pastiche—helpful, but underdeveloped and lacking organic depth.


The Verdict 💔🗝️

The Mussoorie Murders is a moody, atmospheric lock-room mystery with literary elegance and a gorgeous setting. It shines in its rich historical backdrop and clever blending of true crime with fiction. Yet, its slow start, occasionally jarring structure, and underdeveloped key characters hold it back from greatness.

If you're into atmospheric mysteries, foggy hill stations, and a classic detective vibe, this is worth a read—just be patient with its pacing and structural quirks.

[Gayathri (books_and_lits) · Rating 4 out of 5]

The story grows slowly on the readers and by the time one finishes it,when all those fragments get woven into a single picture,they can’t help but marvel at the writer’s work!

To take an inspiration from one of the earlier,never resolved crimes felt like a refreshing thought.The writer also attempts at solving it with impeccable logic!

I really felt like Sherlock Holmes when I nearly solved the “fictional murder”(before the twist got revealed by the writer!) in the book,which happens almost in a similar way to the crime committed sixty years ago(the unresolved one till date!)

As the story progresses alternating between the current crime & old crime,it was a bit difficult to retain the names of the characters,who belongs to which crime,for sometime.But by the time I finished the book,I felt the flow very justified!

Because of this read I now know many fictional detectives other than Sherlock Holmes😅I have not come across Hercule Poirot,Miss Marple,Father Brown or Lord Peter Wimsey before and to know all of these great,famous minds and their creators was very much exciting and intriguing🤩😱Should solve at least one case each with these genius minds in the future🤞🏻Added many to TBR already😅🤩

In the recent days,I had been introduced to Officer Simone Singh by Devashish Sardana,Detective Aarya Sarkar by Ranjana Joshi and now Detective Avijit Sikdar has joined the team too🤩😍After this book,I am genuinely looking forward to accompany his adventures just like Mr.Watson!

I really loved all the connections between Sir Arthur Conan Doyle,Rudyard Kipling,Agatha Christie and these murders❤️‍🔥

[Ishan · Rating 4 out of 5]

“The Mussoorie Murders” by Divyaroop Bhatnagar offers a captivating and unique blend of murder mystery and historical fiction, enriched by the involvement of iconic authors like Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Rudyard Kipling. The story revolves around two murders that occurred sixty years apart, both within the confines of the same hotel in the picturesque hills of Mussoorie. This ingenious combination of fiction and real-life historical figures adds a delightful and authentic layer to the narrative, making it a compelling read for both mystery enthusiasts and those interested in the lives of these famous authors.

Bhatnagar’s skillful storytelling allows the reader to traverse two different time periods, each with its own set of complexities and clues. The locked-room mysteries that unfold in this scenic backdrop keep you engaged and guessing throughout the book. The author masterfully weaves the stories of these two murders together, creating a sense of continuity and intrigue that is both satisfying and thought-provoking.

For anyone who appreciates the works of Conan Doyle, Kipling, and the art of solving intricate mysteries, “The Mussoorie Murders” is a literary gem. It pays homage to these iconic authors and their influence on the mystery genre while crafting a story that stands on its own. This book is a captivating journey through time, seamlessly merging history, mystery, and the beauty of Mussoorie, making it a must-read for those looking for a truly unique and engaging reading experience.