2.5 stars. I really thought this was something I would like, but it really didn't work for me on any level. I was originally going to round this up to 3 stars, but the more I thought about the story after I finished it, the more I found to dislike. I think my biggest issue was just that I didn't care for the writing style. The author did not seem to subscribe to the "show, don't tell," way of storytelling, so there would be moments when, like, Ryan would tell Julia how witty she was, and I'd be like, ".......she is?" because I had seen no evidence of it. I also don't understand why this was called Nerd Girl because... she's not particularly nerdy at all??? I'm trying to think of one scene where she might come off as nerdy, and I'm coming up completely blank. She's supposed to be less beautiful and popular than her twin sister, so maybe that's why? But of course she's still beautiful and lots of people like her and Ryan falls in love with her instantly, so I don't know how that qualifies her as a nerd girl.
I was hoping to at least get sucked in by the romance, but it didn't work for me at all. I kind of like the employer/employee set-up for romances, so I was looking forward to that conflict, but then... it's never actually a conflict at all. Like, he's high up at the place she works, but he heads up a completely different department, and the only reason it's even relevant that they work at the same place is that Ryan's fiancee happens to be Julia's boss. And everything with Ryan's fiancee made me dislike him so much. I think we're supposed to think Ryan's a kind, decent guy, but I found it really hard to get past the fact that he had been dating Catherine for 7 years and was engaged to her, and after one week of knowing Julia, he's willing to throw all that away, and he doesn't even tell Julia he's engaged. Lying about being engaged is not something that's going to make me want to root for the male lead to get the girl, sorry. Plus, him deciding he had to be with Catherine after she found out she had cancer because she would die without his support or something was ridiculous and didn't help my opinion of Ryan either. (Also, surprise cancer storylines are always going to be one of my least favorite things.)
And the relationship between Ryan and Julia also went way too fast for my liking. It really is a love at first sight kind of thing, which I wasn't expecting, and I am almost never into that sort of thing. I mean, he breaks off his engagement after just a week of knowing Julia and making out with her a couple times, and then he and Julia are telling each other they love each other constantly, and they've been together like 2 weeks. I think I also realized that in most of my favorite romances I've read in the past year, the major obstacle to the couple being together is internal conflict rather than external stuff. I mean, one thing I feel like the Amour et Chocolat series by Laura Florand does so well is that with each couple, there's never some 3rd party getting in between the characters; they always have their own, internal issues they're dealing with, and being together helps them deal with those issues, and then eventually they're able to be together for real. And I find that so much more interesting and engaging than stories like this one, where the two characters fall for each other instantly, and the only things keeping them apart are Ryan lying about being engaged, the fact that his ex-fiancee is Julia's boss (which means she has to quit her brand new job), and Ryan's ex-fiancee getting cancer. Like, that's all the conflict. Neither of the characters has to grow on their own or deal with their issues together or anything. And unfortunately that's just not interesting enough for me.