I really wanted to like this book because a fast paced space opera mil-scifi is right up my street, and there’s a massive series of books to follow up. Unfortunately, I found a lot of things frustrating about this read.
One major issue for me is how a lot of unrealistic backstory is totally glossed over. I’m ok with suspension of disbelief, but throw us a bone, a little bit of detail as justification every so often. Here I felt I just had to suck it up. (A counterpoint is that in a 7-10+ book series, if you count the follow ups, there’s a chance that there’s more background at some point, if you have the patience). I get that this is more aimed at a YA audience, but even so.
Another bug bear for me is when characters faced with a problem don’t see A Really Obviously Solution that’s standing - literally in this case - right in front of them. Then later, it’s revealed as some kind of genius last minute answer to their woes.
Finally, and this is what brings it from a 3/5 down to a 2 for me, the ending. Or lack thereof. I’m all for ending a book on a cliff hanger, but this was more than that: this was taking the entire ending and moving it to book 2. (A tip: if you want the ending without needing to buy the next book, it’s in the free sample on kindle).
I really, really wanted to like this book and series, it’s fun and an interesting world. I think it would make a great TV series or movie. But there’s not enough attention to detail for me in this one. If you like fast paced, YA style space opera, give it a try, but if you like the more intellectual end of the spectrum this probably is not for you.
Update: I tried to read book 2, had to abandon. Hodor. 0/5