I garbed this book on a free rack at the library when I was 13, impressed by the pulp-style art on the cover. Giant Eye-ball aliens? Hell yeah! And then... it sat in my closet for 13 years. So now I cracked it out and after finishing this novel, I feel the immense need to cleanse my palette with something more tolerable, like Twilight.
Actually, the two can be comparable in some respects; for that there are many unique aliens and ideas in the book that keep you reading. Also, like Twilight, "unique" doesn't mean it's going to end up being worth your time.
Lets take for example the aliens that are a plot point in the book. Smith takes careful time describing the physiology, culture, and mannerisms of almost everything he mentions. I appreciate that, I love history's. But in and of that... what he writes makes very little sense or seems so forced...
Apes with talking wrist watches control the star-ship's cafeteria. The tall fuzzy crab alien is tri-symmetrical. The talking Dolphin is in charge of sentient squid abort the star ship. Orca's run the night-shift. It all seemed nonsensical.
I know, I know. "It's sci fi, it's going to be out there!" Yes. It is Fi, but it's lacking Sci, and why. WHY is a space ship being crewed by gorillas on unicycles (that is actually in there, never explained, How is it that everything can talk, and when did lower primates gain the intellect to be in a leadership position over man? Why do Orca's run the night shift versus the dolphins? Some of the many questions to be asked, and never answered.
1 out of 5. I like the alien designs but the book is lacking anything that would make it worth searching for.