3.5 stars.
I really do adore the author's writing, her ability to transport us to other places (or "time," as in Welcome to Paradise), and her keen attention to detail while never making it feel instructional or pandering. I'd read and greatly enjoyed all in her previous Escape to New Zealand series so it was an absolute "duh" to get this one tout de suite.
There are two main characters, Ally, a Canadian-American, and Nate, the (new) All Blacks (national rugby team) captain, and two lesser characters (more than supporting but not as main as Ally + Nate), Kristen, a recently divorced American (and younger sister to Just This Once's Hannah) and Liam, a Maori rugby player, teammate and good friend of Nate. This story takes place in Wellington, so it was fun to learn a bit more about NZ and its cities.
At Kristen's behest, Ally moves to NZ with her for a year for an adventure (for Ally) and for Kristen to heal after the painful dissolution of her marriage (her husband was a jerk and cheated on her). Ally is an outdoorsy woman, loving adrenaline sports and works as a rock climbing instructor: she works for a misogynistic blowhard, which is hard on her but she plugs away. Ally does not have really any disposable income -- she is living month-to-month, and that's refreshing -- so many romances have characters who seem to have not a financial worry in the world. Just like the rest of us, eh? Ha ha. Ally is forthright and maybe a bit brash for the depicted Kiwi polite, restrained culture -- to me, she felt like a breath of fresh air, and I loved how she didn't play coy or cute -- she is who she is and she feels how she feels. The only time(s) she faltered were when she didn't stay true to herself. Good girl -- she is what I wish for young women.
While rock climbing, Ally and Kristen first come across Nate and Liam, and so the story goes. Nate seems like a good enough guy but he's not looking for anything serious (code for easy sex), except Ally gets under his skin (in a good way). Because Kristen has had one disappointing and failed relationship after another, she has decided to not date and instead work on herself, figuring out what she is bringing, or looking for, or attracting, so she can break that cycle. Liam is taken with Kristen, of course for her statuesque beauty, but probably more for her quiet determination. He recognizes something of himself in her steely resolve to "fix" herself, and he responds positively to it.
There are strong Pride and Prejudice influences at play here -- Devon is Wickham with Ally the unsuspecting Elizabeth (and later, a touch of Lydia), Nate is Darcy with Kristen the ethereal and good Jane and Liam the pure and also good Mr. Bingley (but not naive like Mr. Bingley); the story line itself is even similar in that Jane and Mr. Bingley are strong supporting characters in P+P and we root for them without ever getting as "inside" their characters as we do Elizabeth and Darcy. There are also strong similarities to the first in the Escape to New Zealand series, Just This Once, with Nate this time drawing a parallel to Hannah and her devotion to anything but a relationship and how it could fulfill her personally. Nate is taken with rugby to the exclusion of being willing to have a serious relationship with anyone, including himself. And, just as it did Hannah, it hurts him. It hurts those who love him. (It's also fun the way the author peppers the titles from her previous books throughout, but not as titles -- as expressions.)
While I understand why the two story lines (Nate and Ally's and Kristen and Liam's) were told in one book (as they are concurrent in time) I would have wished for them to be separate. I would have liked to spend a lot more time with both Kristen and Liam, together and individually, especially inside Kristen's head and how she is doing with her self-work. It felt as if we got a better handle on Liam and how he had healed himself, which was terrific to read, but I wanted as much from Kristen. I also would have loved to spend more time in their relationship because it was so gentle, so tender, so frail-seeming, and I'm not just talking about their sex life (although that was so different to read because most of the sex lives of the couples in the Escape to New Zealand series seem to have rougher, more gymnastic couplings) but about their hesitant interactions with one another. They are both rather careful with the other.
Also, Nate just wasn't my favorite. He wasn't a bad guy but his priorities were messed up, and I got exasperated / bored with him. I loved that the author painted such a full picture of him that we understand why he is the way he is (that as a young teen he was sent away from home to attend school and to focus on rugby, because he was gifted at it), why rugby is his focus. During those formative years he wasn't around his parents to see how adults live and love together, the way they can be focused on outside pursuits but still make time for their significant other and how that SO can actually enhance those outside pursuits. So he's a bit stunted. But I still resented how he took advantage of Ally's emotional largesse and kinda led her on -- unknowingly, unintentionally, but led her on all the same. Early on, even when he hadn't admitted it to himself (thought he was after a quick lay), he was pursuing her in a relationship sense -- to have sex with her he wouldn't go on a big hike with her. He wouldn't pursue her at the rock climbing gym where she works, wouldn't accompany her to the ladder-diving off the quay near Te Papa (museum in Wellington), wouldn't have let it go on so long.
**SPOILERS**
I do also wish we'd spent more time at the end with Nate and Ally as they figured out how to have a loving, committed relationship, and how they did that while Nate was still pursuing his rugby and Ally pursued her education. By the end, it appeared that in that elapsed time (fourteen months) Nate had grown and changed *a lot*, and I would've really enjoyed being present for that. Really enjoyed it. Also, it would've been a treat to spend more time with Kristen and Liam as they planned their traditional Maori wedding. Just because.
**END OF SPOILERS**
Anyway, the writing continues to be quite good with characters you can get behind, invest in, root for, even if occasionally you aren't in love with them. I'll read anything by Rosalind James because she's a romance writer for smart readers.