What do you think?
Rate this book


200 pages, Hardcover
First published April 2, 2014
In Eating Dangerously the authors offer a look at the risks inherent in our food supplies. However, having just finished The Norm Chronicles (a wholly enjoyable read on assessing risk), I'm skeptical of the concerns presented here.
For example, cantaloupe was responsible for the 2011 Lysteria outbreak that killed 33 people (a story the authors were involved in covering and which makes several appearances throughout the book). Not to minimize those deaths or the suffering of the families involved, but I have to wonder: how many people ate cantaloupe in the U.S. during that time-frame in 2011? 330? 330,000? 3.3 million? I don't know, but I'm guessing my chances of getting sick, much less dying, from eating cantaloupe are pretty small yet the authors portray that humble melon sitting on your kitchen table as a time bomb just waiting to go off and put you and your family in the hospital, facing death or permanent kidney failure and a life time of dialysis.
The same with raw spinach, sprouts, shellfish and all the other food items that are presented here. Feta cheese? Really, we should stop eating feta cheese right now because it's made with unpasteurized milk? They make it sound like putting a loaded gun to my head and pulling the trigger
In fairness to Booth and Brown, these are not their claims -- they are simply reporting the concerns pointed out to them by the food safety experts they talked to. However, there was no attempt to put these claims or the risks presented into the broader picture of overall food consumption in this country.
It was peanut butter that killed her.By providing an inside look at the food production process, the authors highlight the many places where food can be infected or “dirtied”. They also show that sometimes a lack of responsibility on the manufacturers’ part is not simply accidental, but on purpose. I felt a very accusatory tone from the text, mostly at the government and the food producers and manufacturers; the somewhat biased writing (most likely intended to make readers angry at the big guys) put me off a little, but I think that’s just personal taste. I also grew less sympathetic as I kept reading because there were just so many disastrous cases that lead to severe illness or death.