If you’re looking for a rich, full-bodied text ripe with descriptive imagery leaving a residue of the imagined, look elsewhere. The text of Under Her Spell is simplistic, at best, and while the potential is there within the book’s theme to summon up an epic love story (complete with a quest) the storyline falls short.
The writer’s style is maddeningly schizophrenic; the character’s erratic, fragmented speech bouncing from old English endearments to disjointed modern colloquialisms. The writing technique is unvarying and one-dimensional, dominated by short, choppy sentences and void of any expression of complex thoughts and ideas seemingly indicated in the topic of forbidden, taboo love between women in a world dominated my magical beings.
Pushing past sexual boundaries in experimentation involving mild BDSM and magically-enhanced eroticism, the prerequisite boudoir scenes are, admittedly, a turn-on… That is, until one of the two main characters speaks. The phrase, “Well, DUH” can never be found to enhance lovemaking. It could be argued that the simple speech was tailored to the reader, enabling her self-identification with the lovers, Athene and Tera, I but prefer erotica that makes my heart pound and my breath quicken over identifying with someone I’d pretend I didn’t know when our paths crossed.
Interesting subtle themes of sexual fluidity, particularly in the character, Hephastae, who’s gender has its own ebb and flow, the language of water, and the sensuous vibration of magic give the book a pleasingly “Through the Looking Glass” feel, and though the technical aspects writing are poor, the lush, imaginative world Under Her Spell is set in is, by all counts, delicious. My hope is that in her next novel, the writer, Maggie Morton, set the bar a little higher for herself and create some structure within the framework of her impressive imagination; the potential is there for luminous writing and for her to write something truly breathtaking.
A digital copy of this book was provided by the publisher for purposes of review.