This book attempts to clarify the immense gap now opening up between Christians and the culture of the world we live in. The author explores the kinds of views, attitudes and topics of discussion that fill the mental atmosphere around us, using them to define current secularist thinking and pinpoint preconceptions that are antithetical to the Christian mind.
This book is hard to review since I found so much to criticize. I have decided to critique this work by suggesting new titles that this could be published under:
Misogynist Laments Lack of Women in Kitchen
Old Man Misses Victorian Era
Modernist Mind Reacts Against Postmodern Culture
Professor McRanty Hates Everything That Seems to be Happening
Solutionless Criticisms Against Post-Christian Culture
The Hasty Generalizer Oversimplifies Everything
An Unnuanced Exploration of Philosophical Undercurrents That the Author Appears Unware Of
I Don't Have to Cite Sources Since C.S. Lewis Was My Teacher
Based on This Magazine Article I Have on My Desk, Media is Intentionally Trying to Destroy Christianity
Unwed Mothers Ruin Everything
People Won't Think Like Me Which is Inconceivable
You get the idea. This isn't to say there aren't nuggets of wisdom or interesting thoughts--there are. However the book feels like a run-on blog entry. The value this piece does have for those trying it understand post-Christian culture is how even an educated modern mind sees postmodern culture.
When Blamires wrote this book in 1998, he already foresaw that its message will be rejected by future readers. "Developments of this kind threaten to bring in an age of lunacy. Moreover, it will be an age of appalling totalitarianism. For I foresee that in another decade or so, it may well be that I should be prosecuted for making the statements I have made in this book." (p95)
So it is no wonder that this important book is ignored by many today. However I'd highly recommend the earnest Christian to read it, and I've no doubt the book will shed clear light on why the moral landscape turned out the way it is today.
I'm generally a cheerful optimist and jump at the chance to encourage, but I do use my one-star reviews for books that need to be set on fire and flung into a canal and/or back into the 1700s.
Spot the difference:
'... to treat any of these as if they were less than a child of God is to deny the validity of one's spiritual existence.' ~ Archbishop Desmond Tutu
vs ...
'... thus we can assert with assurance, that a woman's rights over her own body are non-existent.' ~ Harry Blamires
'The post-Christian mind dare not face facts.' ~ Harry Blamires
'We are in a post-Christian world, a world of self-deceiving psychobabblers from whose minds the moral laws of a whole civilisation have been swept away.' ~ Harry Blamires
'... the way the adolescent who keeps a feverish eye on the pop charts can develop into the classical music enthusiast when taste matures and childish things are put away.' ~ Harry Blamires
... ... so yes, it is a painful read. If you want to misuse scripture to excuse your miserable git-ishness and abundant misogyny, you probably can, but you'll have to squint a bit when you get to the parts about what God's like, or what Jesus actually said - which is probably why there's almost no external citations or biblical references made. Bit awkward.
I'd go further than the person who gave it a very eloquent two-star review; misogyny, generalisation, rants upon rants, it reeks of an academic building justifications for never having to step outside of their university gates. The dreaded 'them' are everywhere in this book. The unwashed, unshaven, frankly incorrect 'them' who are to blame for everything and should be dishonoured at every turn ... apparently. Just as ... Jesus ... did? No, perhaps not.
'I am writing a book about correcting slovenly thinking.' ~ Harry Blamires
... I think Mr Blamires may really have been writing a book about being judgemental. And it has been published and distributed by SPCK.
This one was easier than the Christian Mind, both linguistically and sentence-wise. The author is writing more American style. I kinda miss his British style, hmmm. As for the subjects that he discusses, they're very relevant to the problems/issue humanity and the Christian mind is facing today.