From a Pulitzer Prize winner comes the story of an unforgettable moment in American the historic meeting between General Robert E. Lee and General Ulysses S. Grant that ended the Civil War. MacKinlay Kantor captures all the emotions and the details of those few the aristocratic Lee’s feeling of resignation; Grant’s crippling headaches; and Lee’s request?which Grant generously allowed?to permit his soldiers to keep their horses so they could plant crops for food.
Benjamin McKinlay Kantor, was an American journalist, novelist and screenwriter. He wrote more than 30 novels, several set during the American Civil War, and was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction in 1956 for his 1955 novel Andersonville
Kantor was born in Webster City, Iowa, in 1904. His mother, a journalist, encouraged Kantor to develop his writing style. Kantor started writing seriously as a teen-ager when he worked as a reporter with his mother at the local newspaper in Webster City.
Kantor's first novel was published when he was 24.
During World War II, Kantor reported from London as a war correspondent for a Los Angeles newspaper. After flying on several bombing missions, he asked for and received training to operate the bomber's turret machine guns (this was illegal, as he was not in service). Nevertheless he was decorated with the Medal of Freedom by Gen. Carl Spaatz, then the U.S. Army Air Corp commander. He also saw combat during the Korean War as a correspondent.
In addition to journalism and novels, Kantor wrote the screenplay for Gun Crazy (aka Deadly Is the Female) (1950), a noted film noir. It was based on his short story by the same name, published February 3, 1940 in a "slick" magazine, The Saturday Evening Post. In 1992, it was revealed that he had allowed his name to be used on a screenplay written by Dalton Trumbo, one of the Hollywood Ten, who had been blacklisted as a result of his refusal to testify before the House Un-American Committee (HUAC) hearings. Kantor passed his payment on to Trumbo to help him survive.
Several of his novels were adapted for films. He established his own publishing house, and published several of his works in the 1930s and 1940s.
Kantor died of a heart attack in 1977, at the age of 73, at his home in Sarasota, Florida.
It was okay they talked a lot about there horses 🐎 and how they were amazing war prizes to acquire. War started from 1861 and ended 1865 in that time the death toll estimated for the North 360,000 to 390,000 and the South with 258,000 to 300,000. General Grant was only 42 years old.
The army of the Shenandoah was critical during the crucial period leading up to Lee surrender at Appomattox, because it denied the confederate army critical food supplies in the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia. At the time it operated under the command of major general, Philip Sheridan, but immediately after the surrender, Command shifted to Brigadier General A.T.A Torbert. April 7, 1865 General Lee’s response to Ulysses S. letter. I do not quite agree with you that the Confederate cause is lost, or that there is nothing to be gained by our fighting on. But I agree with you and your wish to stop the needless killing of brave men. What terms will you give me if I agree to surrender?
Before surrender was considered, one suggestion offered was the South regiment dissolved completely, here, and now, and try to slip off through the woods in order to avoid capture by the Yankees. As many as 2/3 of the Confederate troops, it was hoped, might in this way, avoid the act of surrender. Eventually, they could reassemble at some agreed place, and once more take the field against their enemies. But generally said no. He saw that if his men followed, this course, they would be classified as Guerrillas, as armed marauders. They would have to rob and steal in order to live. Far better, General Lee was beginning to think about his men to proceed to their homes and again assume the care of their families. This war was started by rich men and politicians, poor southerners who owned no slaves made up the bulk of Confederate military and General Lee just wanted them to have a chance to survive and have some semblance of a life they more than deserved.
General Grant on writing the letter to General Lee for the surrender of the army of the northern Virginia in the following terms:
(1) each officer must individually give a parole that he would not take up arms against the government of the United States until he was properly exchanged.
(2) each company or regimental commander was likewise to sign a parole for the men under his command.
(3) all guns, Cannon, and other public property possessed by the Rebels must be turned over to the Federals.
Momentarily general grant stopped writing. His glance was not resting, not on the proud Hurtt face of his defeated enemy, but on the beautiful sword at general Lee’s side. It was a gorgeous piece of cutlery, with ornamented hilt. If the sword had been drawn from its scabbard, all eyes might have seen that the gleaming steel blade was beautifully chased with designs and inscriptions. Union officers in the room, thought that this must be the fable sword of fantastic workmanship which was presented to Lee by his native state of Virginia. This was not quite the case; it was a ceremonial weapon, which Lee called his “Maryland sword.” Today the short can be seen at the Confederate Museum in Richmond, Virginia.
During the four year conflict of the Civil War, a lot of military personnel once considered brothers were split onto two different sides. One of Ulysses’ old mess-mates was a Captain named Cadmus Wilcox who Grant had chosen as a Groomsmen for his wedding. Who would have thought years later this same friend/brother in arms would be on the other side in his gray uniform of the Confederacy his heart like lead in his breast.
It is sometimes believed that the Civil War ended immediately when general Robert E Lee surrendered the army of northern Virginia to general Ulysses S Grant at Appomattox Virginia on April 9, 1865. But while this surrender was key, the war trickled on for several weeks after this. After Lee’s surrender, which occurred just a week before Abraham Lincoln was assassinated, General Joseph E Johnson surrendered almost 90,000 troops of the army of Tennessee to Union general William T Sherman near Durham, North Carolina.
A Cherokee leader, Stan Watie, became the last Confederate to surrender in the Civil War. Stand Watie (also known as Isaac S. Watie) holds the distinction of being the last Confederate general to surrender his command, nearly two months after Robert E. Lee met with Ulysses S. Grant at Appomattox.
(Lead me to want me to learn more about the Cherokee leader, Stan Watie on the internet)
The Surrender at Doaksville:
While the main Confederate armies in the East and West surrendered in April and May 1865, the conflict in the Trans-Mississippi Department (west of the Mississippi River) lasted longer due to the vast distances and lack of communication.
Date: June 23, 1865. Location: Doaksville, Choctaw Nation (near present-day Fort Towson, Oklahoma). Command: Watie surrendered the First Indian Brigade, which consisted of Cherokee, Creek, Seminole, and Osage battalions.
Rank: He was the only Native American to achieve the rank of Brigadier General in the Confederate States Army. Tactics: He was famous for his guerrilla warfare tactics, leading successful raids on Union supply trains and steamboats, which kept Union forces in the Indian Territory on the defensive for much of the war.
It is worth noting that while Watie was the last general to surrender, he wasn't the very last Confederate entity to stop fighting. The CSS Shenandoah, a Confederate commerce raider, continued to capture Union merchant ships in the Pacific until its captain learned the war was over in August 1865. The ship finally surrendered to British authorities in Liverpool in November 1865.
This book is a piece of U.S. History I never knew or learned from school. The Civil War shaped our country in ways people don’t even realize for decades. One of which I learned from a documentary was the The 14th Amendment (1868): Specifically, the Due Process and Equal Protection clauses, which state no state shall "deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law". Santa Clara County v. Southern Pacific Railroad (1886): This landmark case established the precedent that corporations are considered persons under the 14th Amendment, allowing them to use it to protect their rights from state infringement. Historical Context: While designed to secure rights for freed slaves, this amendment became a powerful tool for corporations to fight against state governments.
I’ve had to read the above multiple times for years always reminding myself that “Hey Corporations, are people to and they’re allowed to make mistakes 🤮”. They will not be deprived of LIFE, LIBERTY, or PROPERTY without due process of the law.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This is another offering in the Landmark series, which does an admirable job of describing the events at the close (sort of) of the Civil War, arguably the most devastating period in American history. There was a major battle just prior to the meeting between the two generals to discuss terms of surrender, but the book primarily focuses on their meeting and the logistics of arranging a truce sufficient to come to acceptable terms to avoid further slaughter.
Most people (if they know the significance at all) don't know that the end of the Civil War came, not at a "courthouse" at all, but in the parlor of a private residence, in Appomattox Court House, a village, was not just an actual courthouse, but rather an entire town. In one of America's most ironic twists of fate, as the book notes, Robert E. Lee formally surrendered to General Ulysses S. Grant at the home of one Wilmer McLean (1814-1882) - the man who owned the property where the Civil War had essentially begun, four years earlier.
McLean, a wholesale grocer from Virginia, owned a property near Manassas, Virginia, where the First Battle of Bull Run occurred, in 1861, at his Yorkshire Plantation. Seemingly traumatized by the events at the outbreak of the war, like so many others - artillery was actually fired at his house, which at the time was being used as Confederate Brigadier General Beauregard's headquarters - McLean fled 90 miles south, to the small village of Appomattox Court House. It came as something of a shock when, in April, 1865, officials came knocking at his door, asking if his house could serve as the setting for a meeting between generals Lee and Grant, to discuss terms of surrender. McLean was reported to have said of the momentous occasion: "the war began in my front yard and ended in my front parlor."
One of the more humorous (although certainly not at the time) episodes, albeit unintentionally, as the book notes, and as the photos attest, were the actions of some of the personnel in attendance, who began acting like enterprising souvenir hunters. Immediately following the formal signing of the surrender, they began to purchase (and others to "liberate," as the book states) from the owner items associated with the event, such as the table on which Grant had drafted the surrender document, for a reported $20 in gold, and a larger, marble-top table where Lee had signed it, which was purchased by Major General Ord for $40. Others just shoved money into McLean's hands as they made off with his property, despite his protests, which fell on deaf ears.
The aforementioned small table, used by Grant, was purchased by Philip Sheridan - who, in turn, asked one George Armstrong Custer to transport it astride his horse; of course, he did, as he had already garnered a reputation for outlandish stunts - carting off a table on horseback was no mean feat for the soon-to-be-infamous Custer, who would meet his end at the Battle of the Little Bighorn. The table was later presented to Custer's wife, and is now on display at the National Museum of American History, in the Smithsonian collection. The book includes photographs of several of the other items, including the two chairs the generals sat in, which are likewise on display, as is Lee's impressive custom-made ceremonial sword.
McLean's house, later called the "Surrender House," did not fare well, after the war's end. McLean defaulted on the loan, so the bank seized and then sold it at public auction, in November, 1869. The house changed hands several times, before someone got the idea of making it a tourist attraction: but not in far-flung Appomattox Court House. It was even proposed that the house be moved to Chicago as an attraction at the 1893 World's Fair, but this plan never came to fruition. Later, an even more ambitious plan saw the house dismantled and packed for shipping, with the intent of moving it to Washington, DC. However, due to a lack of funding, it sat in pieces for more than a half-century. It was rescued in 1940 by the Congress, with the creation of the Appomattox Court House National Historical Monument, and plans were made to reconstruct it, but measures were interrupted by WWII. Finally, reconstruction began, and in 1949, more than 80 years after the event, the McLean house was opened to the public. The dedication ceremony took place in 1950.
I won't recap all the events, but the book does a good job of hitting the highlights, and what was involved in the planning and execution of the fateful meeting between the two generals, who couldn't have been more different. This volume is more expansive than some of the others in this series, at least the version I read, and has the added benefit of numerous color photographs, drawings and documents. A major feature seems to be the generals' horses, who apparently became almost as famous as the men themselves! Perhaps the most famous was Lee's gorgeous gray American Saddlebred, Traveller, but Grant had his share of famous mounts, also, which included the son of the fastest racehorse in the country.
One thing which just about drove me crazy with this volume, however, - petty, i know, but inexcusable in a later addition which was ostensibly a revision of an earlier volume - were all of the grammatical mistakes in this volume, to the degree that the editor needs a new line of work! Misspellings, conflated words, misused terms - this one has it all, which is very surprising, considering that I haven't noticed a single error in any of the others I have read in this series. We all make them every once in a while, but the number in this book were at the point of distraction. Still a good read, however, and a capable introduction to one of the most momentous events in US history.
This book told about the surrender of General Lee to General Grant at Apppmattox which brought about the end of the Civil War. I was suprised at the correspondence that took place during the days beofre the surrender. General Grant sent a message stating that the rebels were beaten and the he wanted to allow General Lee to surrender honorably so the killing would stop on both sides. There was no need for more soldiers to die. General Lee intially was concerned about the surrender, would it apply to all armies of the south or just to the Army of Northern Virginia? What are the terms? Messages passed back and forth between the two generals, sometimes delayed as troops moved about. Eventually the two generals agreed on terms and a meeting place. General Lee was the first to arrive. He was accompanied by his aide and orderly, as well as General Grant's secretary and a union orderly. Gerneal Grant arrived about a half hour later. After greeting each other and some discussion, terms were written out by General Grant himelf. His secreatry read it and made a correction or two and the the paper was given to General Lee. While reading over it General Lee noticed that a word was missing and he corrected the error. The order of surrender was signed. I love the respect that the two generals displayed for each other and for their brave men. Reaching an honorable peace was more important than punishing or humiliating the loser. Saving lives on both sides was more important than completely demolishing the opposition. I enjoyed learning some things that I didn't know about the surrender. The poor farmed who ended up having a bidding war for items in his house by the military personnel present that day.
The McLean's family land was where the first of the civil war began. Moving away 150 miles away to avoid the battles, the family ended up at Appomattox where Grant and Lee signed a peace agreement that ended the civil war.
A short account filled with actual photos and accounts of the last few days of the war. If you are a history buff, you will appreciate the those photos and insights to the war that are not in the average history books. Grant and Lee were respected leaders and during the peace process, had the utmost respect for each other. Desiring for healing and the country to move forward united. This is a great source for anyone desiring to know the history and the men behind the history.
A Special Thank you to Quarto Publishing and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
I gave this short book (143 pages) four stars (Goodreads rating is 3.5). It is about the surrender of General Lee to General Grant at Appomattox. Even though I have been to Appomattox Court House where the surrender was signed, this book had some interesting information that I did not remember.
The book was written by MacKinley Kantor, who also wrote the Civil War novel Andersonville.
Interesting fact: The last Confederate to surrender in the Civil War was Stand Watie, a Cherokee Indian.
I have been to Appomatix. I have just read Shelby Footes account of Lee's surrender. This is a very enjoyable narrative of the surrender and portraits the emotional setting for Lee and Grant.
Jacob rates this book 4 stars, Mom says 3 stars, and Ellie 2 stars. Good details of things behind the scenes of the war, what people were feeling, etc. but it didn't have the best flow to it.
This is a history book with lots of made-up dialogue but that is why it was interesting to children. The best chapter was the last: "What Traveler Thought."