What do you think?
Rate this book
Ultra in the West
Ultra in the West is a major work in the field of Second World War literature. Originally published in 1979, it told for the first time Ultra's contribution to the liberation of Europe.
At every point from the Normandy landings to the German surrender eleven months later Ultra in the West offers a unique analysis. It shows, for instance, how Montgomery was able to note the astonishing success of the deception plan which kept men and tanks away from his front in the dangerous early days of the build-up and held them idle round Calais, waiting for an assault the Allied Command never intended to make. Not all decodes were put to such good use. Ultra gave warning of Panzer divisions in the Arnhem area before the air landings of Operation Market Garden. If read correctly they would have warned that the German concentrations opposite the lightly-held Ardennes in November and December 1944 meant attack not defence. As the review in the Economist said, ' . . . his important summary makes a lot of the war look in need of a rewrite.'
' Throws much light on the intelligence background against which ''vital decisions were, or ought to have been taken,'' and shows that this background was markedly different from what has hitherto been supposed. His careful scholarship makes the book a valuable contribution to Ultra history.' R. V. Jones, author of Most Secret War
'A new prime source of undoubted value.' Peter Calvooressi, The Times
'Ultra in the West is a professional's rewriting of military history . . . as a war-time intelligence officer, and more as professional historian, he is at pains to e as accurate and objective as possible, and to provide backing in reference for every statement. He has achieved his aim of demonstrating the great contribution which Ultra made to the campaign . . . It is on these (decoded signals) that Ralph Bennett has drawn, his memory transforming them from dead into live historical material.'
Field Marshall Lord Carver, Times Literary Supplement
At every point from the Normandy landings to the German surrender eleven months later Ultra in the West offers a unique analysis. It shows, for instance, how Montgomery was able to note the astonishing success of the deception plan which kept men and tanks away from his front in the dangerous early days of the build-up and held them idle round Calais, waiting for an assault the Allied Command never intended to make. Not all decodes were put to such good use. Ultra gave warning of Panzer divisions in the Arnhem area before the air landings of Operation Market Garden. If read correctly they would have warned that the German concentrations opposite the lightly-held Ardennes in November and December 1944 meant attack not defence. As the review in the Economist said, ' . . . his important summary makes a lot of the war look in need of a rewrite.'
' Throws much light on the intelligence background against which ''vital decisions were, or ought to have been taken,'' and shows that this background was markedly different from what has hitherto been supposed. His careful scholarship makes the book a valuable contribution to Ultra history.' R. V. Jones, author of Most Secret War
'A new prime source of undoubted value.' Peter Calvooressi, The Times
'Ultra in the West is a professional's rewriting of military history . . . as a war-time intelligence officer, and more as professional historian, he is at pains to e as accurate and objective as possible, and to provide backing in reference for every statement. He has achieved his aim of demonstrating the great contribution which Ultra made to the campaign . . . It is on these (decoded signals) that Ralph Bennett has drawn, his memory transforming them from dead into live historical material.'
Field Marshall Lord Carver, Times Literary Supplement
Mass Market Paperback
First published November 1, 1979
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews
December 30, 2022
This was probably the worst book I have ever read. I imagine if one wanted to torture someone who liked to read, that person would be made to read this book.
There is maybe a very small group of people that could find this writing worthwhile. First, any military commander versed in warfare might appreciate the contents. Second, those fascinated with WWII could also perhaps appreciate the contents.
But these two groups might also agree that an animated map showing troop movements would tell the story much more concisely and effectively than all the verbiage.
Next, I asked myself if there were some way to make this interesting? Maybe add characters (Eisenhower is referenced in passing but only very factually, tangentially, and not even really playing the role of a character) and details of battle to captivate the reader? Sadly this would only belabor the torture and not make the book any more interesting.
There is maybe a very small group of people that could find this writing worthwhile. First, any military commander versed in warfare might appreciate the contents. Second, those fascinated with WWII could also perhaps appreciate the contents.
But these two groups might also agree that an animated map showing troop movements would tell the story much more concisely and effectively than all the verbiage.
Next, I asked myself if there were some way to make this interesting? Maybe add characters (Eisenhower is referenced in passing but only very factually, tangentially, and not even really playing the role of a character) and details of battle to captivate the reader? Sadly this would only belabor the torture and not make the book any more interesting.
August 30, 2013
I am helping develop a board game covering WWII in NW Europe so this book provides a lot of useful information. This is the second time I have read the book.
Displaying 1 - 2 of 2 reviews