I’m rather aware that I had a different reaction to this book than several of the other extant reviews at time of writing. A lot of them note that, as a textbook, it is a rather dry and technical read; some might say challenging. My initial thoughts as I picked this up? ‘Gosh, this takes me right back to undergraduate first year, having all the basics explained in preparation for the real work ahead’. Yeah. It struck me as a ‘starter’ text. To be fair, back when I was a first year undergraduate, like some of these other reviewers, I didn’t read the whole thing either. I dipped in and out of it as needed for required reading for class prep and essay hints. Seeing as how this year I’m doing a reading challenge of all my Bronze Age books, I decided it was about time I owed this book a full, cover-to-cover read through.
So what I would say about the challenge (or not), of this book, is that it really depends on the audience. If you never studied history before, are a casual hobbyist, or similar, you might end up finding this book a bit of a chore – it is longer than the average 300 page paperback, and delves in to plenty of technical and scientific nitty gritty. If, however, like me, you’re past your university days in the same subject, then you might find yourself skimming past all the sections where the author explains to the reader the basics of archaeological methodology and how archaeologists know what they know. The ideal readership is definitely first-year undergraduates and those about to start such a degree. It lays out an essential overview of the history of ancient Egypt, as well as clearly describing the key methods of archaeological investigation.
The one big error I spotted was that the book claims that the 6th Dynasty ended with Queen Netiqret. This is actually a latter distortion and misunderstanding of a male king whose name was Netjerkare Siptah I – a case of the mists of time turning history into fairytale. This is slightly embarrassing for the book considering it was published in 2007 and this error had been known for some years at that point.
7 otu of 10