These two volumes have been researched and written by Robin Cross, who is a well-respected historian and author. Each book covers the major events and personalities in a pictorial overview of the two World Wars. The authoritative text is illustrated by dramatic photographs which detail the battles, the people, the strategies, and the machinery of the two most devastating military catastrophes of our century.
This is a very strange book. It claims to tell the story of the war through photographs, and I was looking forward to some really stunning, moving pictures showing the events of the war. However, the photos are not particularly brilliant or interesting, and are certainly nothing I haven't seen before. The focus on this book is primarily the narrative which takes up most of the page space. However the words are lacking description and detail, and there is a real lack of chronology and connection of events. The pictures also didn't seem to correspond with the words which I found irritating. This book would have been far better if it ran in a more chronological manner and used some inspiring pictures to tell the story, using fewer words by way of simply explaining the images. Books on the World War really need some level of detail to make them have the impact required and that just wasn't the case here.
World War II in photographs, first published in 1998, attempts to give a pictorial summary of the worlds greatest conflict in only 96 pages, through the use of just over 150 illustrations. This it cannot really do, added to which the photos selected are some of the most common hackneyed pics used over the years. As such, I'm not sure what it really adds to the subject apart from filling shelf space in the local bargain bookstore. On the positive side, nicely printed with sensible captions to the photos.
The reason it took me almost a year to finally go and finish this book was that it just didn't catch me. Guess I was expecting a bit more of the human side of WW2 and the book leaned to the statistical and strategical side. It's got a lot of information about what type of weapons and vehicles were used, points for combat deployment and casualty numbers. It was just way too descriptive for me.