ACTUAL RATING: 2.5
I had high expectations for THE CUT OF WOMEN’S CLOTHES, in large part because the male counterpart by the author is my go-to reference book for male fashions. Unfortunately, this book completely failed to live up to potential.
Despite the book being chalk full of technical information, patterns, pictures, and first hand accounts, the book’s coverage of female fashion is incredibly lopsided. If it isn’t involved in the actual dress, it’s not covered. The construction of hats, gloves, stockings, and other important accessories are largely ignored, even in eras where they are just as important as the gowns themselves. Considering CUT OF MEN’S CLOTHES managed to include all that info for the men of same time periods, its omission here is quite conspicuous. Also, if the period’s style isn’t from England or France, forgot about it entirely, because the book doesn’t bother covering them.
The book improves significantly after the introduction of Victorian fashion, largely because the author spends much more time explaining the why’s and how’s of women’s fashion trends, rather than briefly describing their construction and moving on. It’s also fun to read snippets of Lady Duff Gordon’s self-aggrandizing fashion histories, regardless of context. The improvement is not enough to save the book in my eyes, but it adds a half-star to my original 2-star disappointment.