Published in 2005, I remember how surprised I was finding this volume at my local Deseret Book as I thought Ron Carter wrapped up the story quite nicely in Vol. 8. Was a ninth volume really necessary?
As I write this in the year 2015, after revisiting the series, (ten years later) I got my answer.
No, it wasn't.
Nineteen years have passed since we last saw the Dunson family. Matthew, Kathleen, Billy and Bridgette are empty nesters. Matthew's son, John, is all grown up and guess who he married? Laura Stroud, Eli's little daughter. Eli (now age 55) is enjoying his retirement in the wilderness of Ohio. Adam and Caleb are married and their mother, Margaret, is still alive and kicking.
Therein lies the problem with the plot of this book: everyone who participated in the events of the Revolutionary War, bringing the reader along for the exciting ride, is now too old to participate in the War of 1812 and the author seems to be doing his best to leave his fictional characters out as much as possible.
He tries to include Caleb, John and even Adam in some of the skirmishes, plot complications and navel battles but the War of 1812 is just a footnote to the more famous war of independence.
Eli, the token Indian, acts as ambassador but it's clear his "Batman" days of spying on the enemy and undertaking dangerous missions with Billy as "Robin" are over.
Then Ron Carter commits an unforgiveable sin: he kills off a major character in chapter 22 and hardly anyone blinked. There was no send off, no closure, no reactions from any family and friends.
Then we get chapter 24, the only significant story of interest to Americans concerning the War of 1812 as this is where our beloved national anthem originated. It is a poignant and touching story yet...
Ron Carter could not have made such important events more boring.