Very good account of the life of Bruce Edwards: a kind, humble man, who loved sports, and whose heart was laid bare on golf courses across America, shouldering the bag of his muse, mentor and friend: PGA champion golfer Tom Watson. "Caddy for Life: The Bruce Edwards Story" offers up an opportunity to meet and to get to know a beloved soul, who touched many people's lives through his friendly manner, humility, and generous spirit.
The oldest of four children from a wealthy East Coast family, Edwards eschewed what was expected of him from a very early age, and struck his own path. He found his calling on the golf course, and the PGA tour, not as a player, but as a caddy. Though the book doesn't address it enough, Edwards found it more gratifying being part of the action of the sport, rather than being the action itself. In other words, Edwards was a pure sports fan whose love of the game was enough to fill him with joy. He didn't need to play it, Edwards just wanted to be a part of it.
As fate would have it, Edwards ran into PGA hopeful Tom Watson early in his career, offered to caddy for him, and never ever looked back. The team of Watson and Edwards was a force to be reckoned with in the world of golf, win or lose. When Watson was losing, he never complained, and always stayed strong, sustained by Bruce Edwards' unshakable positive attitude. When Watson won, there was no happier person other than his loyal caddy Bruce Edwards.
As author John Feinstein so candidly expressed in "Caddy for Life: The Bruce Edwards Story," golf is a a highly unpredictable sport. Sure, there can be players that have won this or that tournament, like an Arnold Palmer, Jack Nicklaus, or a Tom Watson. Yet what those same players do TODAY can be a whole different story. Weather, course design, attitude, concentration, and choice all play a role in deciding who wins and who loses. Tom Watson won a number of Masters, British Opens, and one U.S. Open, yet he lost a lot as well.
For the uninitiated, golf can be an agonizingly slow and dull sport, especially compared to the pace of American football and basketball. Thankfully, John Feinstein takes you through golf tournament after golf tournament walking through each tee off, chip, birdie, bogey, drive, and putt as if it were a fast-paced boxing match, insuring the drama involved with each play. This is the book's strength, but it is also its weakness.
Although "Caddy for Life: The Bruce Edwards Story" was written with the full cooperation of Bruce Edwards, his friends and his family, John Feinstein misses the hole in terms of depth and detail of who Bruce Edwards really was. For example, as mentioned earlier, much is made of Edwards as a sports enthusiast, yet little is made of Edwards as sports participant. Did he enjoy playing sports, especially golf? If so, how did it inform Edwards as a caddy? Also, what was Edwards' life on the road really like? Where there wild times?
Instead, John Feinstein spends the bulk of his book telling Bruce Edwards' story through Tom Watson's career history, from tour to tournament to tour. Many golf games are chronicled in a play-by-play fashion, with Edwards's fate completely intertwined with how Tom Watson played golf that day. Yes, its true that when Watson did well in tournaments, so did Edwards in terms of their relationship, and in terms of money...so the outcome of each game was indeed important to the both of them. Yet after a while, the game (and the book for that matter) becomes repetitive. More to the point, a person's life story can not fully explored by game alone.
Bruce Edwards did indeed live a full and rich life, with many interesting highs and lows. Sadly, his life was cut short by the horrible ALS disease, which crippled him during the last year of his life. John Feinstein does go into great detail about ALS, and Edwards' struggle with it. Edwards' immense suffering was only matched by his unyielding strength, and courage...which kept him on the golf course by Watson's side long after the disease had taken over his body.
Perhaps it was the intention to publish the book while Bruce Edwards was still alive, I am not sure. Yet good intensions aside, "Caddy for Life: The Bruce Edwards Story" has a gaping hole in it. The story ends in November 2003, with I think might be Tom Watson's final tournament with Bruce Edwards as his caddy. I'm still not sure. You see, the book ends there, and leaves out everything that happened afterward...namely, the last five months of Bruce Watson's life before he died in April 2004. How can you call a book "Caddy for Life: The Bruce Edwards Story" and NOT finish the story with what happened in the last five months of Bruce Edwards's life??? Very disappointing, especially after taking the time to learn about such a good man, and the interesting life he had.
Aside from the abrupt and incomplete ending, I really enjoyed "Caddy for Life: The Bruce Edwards Story" much more than I thought I would. It gave me insight into a life and a world I knew nothing about, and held my interest more often than it did not. Better still, John Feinstein instilled the book with heart, as expressed by the many, many people who admired Bruce Edwards, and loved him.