This book was a fun read.
Things I like:
- I like that it has a lot of information about Deaf culture, the Deaf community, the history of sign. There is even really great information that is usually not included in ASL books - on accommodations for a Deaf person's hotel or hospital room, how to behave around a guide dog, how to use a TTY, etc. Some of the information was kind of like preaching to the choir (e.g., why health care and police workers should learn ASL) and thus less interesting, but the historical tidbits were entertaining.
- The photos are nice and big. (Although, I think if the decision was bigger photos or more signs, they should have gone with more signs.)
- The included practice activities and the group activities in the back are all GREAT ideas for practice.
- There was good information about Deaf etiquette and cultural norms.
Things I didn't like:
- Some of the topic groupings seemed illogical or could at least have been ordered better. For instance, that "thank you" is introduced in chapter 18 under the category of "Potpourri." Greetings, introductions and polite words should be at the beginning of any language you're learning.
- Some of the signs, according to other books and websites and my own interaction with the Deaf community, do not seem to be the more commonly used version. (Using two hands for "cat," for instance, is considered old-fashioned.)
- The photos appear really dated and the signers have expressionless or very serious faces. It's not often clear from the arrows what the motion should be (though, for the most part, the descriptions of the sign often make up for that). However, it seems there's a newer version of the book with new photos, so maybe those photos are better.
- Some of the signs are described in the text but there are no accompanying pictures.
- There are a lot of signs and a lot of grammatical information (about classifiers, time orientation, facial expression, etc.) but not much practice with whole sentences.
Overall, this book would be a great addition to a curriculum when used with a class textbook and a signing dictionary.