Despite a number of very famous authors being included here, I didn’t like as many of them as I was expecting to. Like, Rudyard Kipling’s The Phantom Rickshaw was downright boring (and kinda misogynistic? It was one of those instances where it’s like “is this really just the POV character being a dick, or does the author actually think this way”) in my opinion. And my initial reaction upon finishing Ligeia by Edgar Allan Poe was “well that was dumb” haha. (Although to be fair, after reading about the story more online, it seems that some people believe it was written as satire, so maybe that’s why it was so bad?)
There were some stories I liked though of course. My favorites were probably Teig O’Kane and the Corpse (labeled as “traditional”), The Body-Snatcher by Robert Louis Stevenson, The Old Nurse’s Story by Elizabeth Gaskell, and August Heat by WF Harvey. The rest of the stories ranged from forgettable to mid to decently good. So yeah, a pretty wide range of quality in my opinion haha.