2/5
The premise of Off Script by Sarah Zane immediately grabbed me: indie author Sadie Hawthorne scraps the happy ending of her trilogy, only to have her characters appear in real life, follow her to a bookish convention, and demand she set their stories right. It’s a fun, meta concept, and I loved seeing Sadie interact with Inez and form new friendships with fellow convention-goers. The plot twist at the ball was clever, and I was happy that everyone - side characters included - got the happy endings promised in the author’s bio.
That said, the execution didn’t quite land for me. Sadie often felt passive, with other characters driving the plot forward while she reacted from the sidelines. The big twist that saved them from Damien, for example, was entirely conceived and carried out by her friend - Sadie wasn’t even aware of it until it was over. It left me wishing other characters had been the protagonist, since they showed more agency. I also think the book could have leaned more into Sadie’s sexuality; her being demisexual, for instance, could have explained why Damien’s seduction powers failed on her, which would’ve been a satisfying integration of character and plot.
The representation itself - both bisexual and demisexual - is wonderful to see, and I applaud the author for including it. Still, the character work didn’t feel consistent. Damien, for example, went from lamenting his absent husband in one scene to openly lusting after a woman in the next with little nuance. And while the narrative focuses heavily on character emotions and inner thoughts, this often came at the expense of pacing. Pages linger on small details, like a character musing about a couch, while bigger elements of the worldbuilding - such as the rules of the magic system - felt underexplained.
The result is a story that sometimes reads more like a lightly edited self-insert fanfic than a polished novel. That said, there are plenty of readers who might appreciate the slower, introspective style and “found family” vibe more than I did. Personally, I prefer a more plot-driven fantasy, and this one dragged for me.
At its heart, Off Script is a feel-good fantasy with clever ideas, representation, and a lot of promise from the author. I just wish it had been more tightly structured and better balanced between action and reflection.