What do you think?
Rate this book
Dochters van Zuid-Afrika
Kronkelpad
As retired physician Lettie Louw looks back upon her life, she recounts her coming of age in WWII-era South Africa in this compelling story of delayed love, loss, and reconciliation.
Lettie Louw is the daughter of the town physician in their South African village. She spends her childhood in the warm African days playing with her friends and being adored by her doting parents. When she becomes a teenager, she experiences her first taste of unrequited romantic love in the form of her best friend’s older brother, De Wet Fourie. When De Wet pursues the beautiful and wealthy Annabelle, Lettie’s dreams are crushed, and she moves to Johannesburg to pursue her studies in medicine.
Life in Johannesburg feels strange to Lettie, and the world around her is in profound upheaval as the Second World War rages. Her feelings for De Wet never waver, and Lettie is heartbroken when he marries another of her childhood friends. Lettie soon meets Marco Romanelli, an Italian immigrant, and they marry and raise two daughters, as the racial and political tensions in South Africa swirl about them.
Lettie never forgets her first love, even as the ravages of time, war, and illness play upon her life and the lives of those she loves. In their later years, Lettie and De Wet are thrown into one another’s company again, and they are given another chance at a life together.
Lettie Louw is the daughter of the town physician in their South African village. She spends her childhood in the warm African days playing with her friends and being adored by her doting parents. When she becomes a teenager, she experiences her first taste of unrequited romantic love in the form of her best friend’s older brother, De Wet Fourie. When De Wet pursues the beautiful and wealthy Annabelle, Lettie’s dreams are crushed, and she moves to Johannesburg to pursue her studies in medicine.
Life in Johannesburg feels strange to Lettie, and the world around her is in profound upheaval as the Second World War rages. Her feelings for De Wet never waver, and Lettie is heartbroken when he marries another of her childhood friends. Lettie soon meets Marco Romanelli, an Italian immigrant, and they marry and raise two daughters, as the racial and political tensions in South Africa swirl about them.
Lettie never forgets her first love, even as the ravages of time, war, and illness play upon her life and the lives of those she loves. In their later years, Lettie and De Wet are thrown into one another’s company again, and they are given another chance at a life together.
512 pages, Paperback
First published August 15, 2011
178 people are currently reading
1693 people want to read
About the author
Irma Joubert
20 books352 followersIrma Joubert is gebore en getoë in die Bosveld (Nylstroom) en het aan UP studeer. Sy begin eers skryf toe sy einde 2004 aftree ná 35 jaar van onderwys. Sy publiseer verskeie artikels en kortverhale in tydskrifte en word in 2005 aangewys as Media24 se “Spesialis Joernalis van die Jaar”. Beide haar Tussen stasies-trilogie en haar Pontenilo-trilogie, asook die eerste boek van haar Oorlogstrilogie, naamlik Immer wes, is in Nederlands vertaal waar dit telkens onder die topverkopers tel. Vier van haar boeke is reeds in Duits vertaal en HarperCollins in Amerika het The girl from the train (Tussen stasies) in 2015 wêreldwyd bekend gestel.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 208 reviews
Read
December 31, 2017THE BLURB:
I won't rate this book, since it is meant for a much different audience.
I was hoping for intense, passionate historical fiction, but got romance with a very light touch of history instead. A feather duster sweep over the essence of the story. There was a lack of passion and atmosphere, for instance, the absence of a real, true-to-character descriptions of the Italian culture. The story had a naive feel to it(like the Mills & Boons romances of a century ago), and nestled comfortably in a contrived pretentious format of yesteryear - about fifty or more years ago. Out of touch. Totally. The research was not good enough.
There are similar kind of books on the market with WWII as background, also with a romance in the works, and written for an audience who prefer to sidestep the gory details, however, all these books still captured the ambiance in their backgrounds beautifully:
The Liberation by Kate Furnivall;
The Chilbury Ladies' Choir by Jennifer Ryan;
The Shell Seekers by Rosamunde Pilcher;
The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah
My litmus test for reality is to see what a character does (in any book) when a finger is hit with a hammer. In this book the answer would have been 'oh dear, that hurts'. So totally out of sync with the real verbal expression by real people. Just too polished.
I am adding my personal gripes with books like these in this
I suspect a much older audience, perhaps people in their seventies and eighties would revel in the Victorian approach applied to a modern plot in this case. Even the Afrikaner characters lacked depth and soul. The bushveld where the Afrikaner family lived is so much more than was depicted in this saga.
This novel provides a lighter literary moment with here and there some atmospheric descriptions, for instance when the Jewish family and Marco hid in the cave against the Nazis. But even then the Jewish character of the family was completely absent. The author simply did not know her characters well enough. Both the Italian as well as Jewish families seriously lacked authenticity. Even the Afrikaners. But yes, once again, it was written for another audience.
For romance readers, this is a perfect choice. It just lost me. I wanted more. I skipped most of the middle of the book and did not reach the end. Too predictable and bleh. It was enough. Sorry.
From the bestselling author of The Girl From the Train, comes another compelling coming of age story of delayed love, loss, and reconciliation in WWII-era South Africa.MY COMMENTS
Lettie has always felt different from and overshadowed by the women around her– this friend is richer, that friend is more beautiful, those friends are closer. Still, she doesn’t let this hold her back. She works hard to apply her mind, trying to compensate for her perceived lack of beauty with diligent academic work and a successful career as a doctor. She learns to treasure her friendships, but she still wonders if any man will ever return her interest.
Marco’s experience in the second world war have robbed him of love and health. When winters in his native Italy prove dangerous to his health even after the war has ended, he moves to South Africa to be with his brother, husband to one of Lettie’s best friends. Marco is Lettie’s first patient, and their relationship grows as she aids him on the road back to restored health.
In the company of beloved characters from The Child of the River, Marco and Lettie find a happiness that neither of them thought possible. With that joy comes pain and loss, but Lettie learns that life—while perhaps a crooked path—is always a journey worth taking.
I won't rate this book, since it is meant for a much different audience.
I was hoping for intense, passionate historical fiction, but got romance with a very light touch of history instead. A feather duster sweep over the essence of the story. There was a lack of passion and atmosphere, for instance, the absence of a real, true-to-character descriptions of the Italian culture. The story had a naive feel to it(like the Mills & Boons romances of a century ago), and nestled comfortably in a contrived pretentious format of yesteryear - about fifty or more years ago. Out of touch. Totally. The research was not good enough.
There are similar kind of books on the market with WWII as background, also with a romance in the works, and written for an audience who prefer to sidestep the gory details, however, all these books still captured the ambiance in their backgrounds beautifully:
The Liberation by Kate Furnivall;
The Chilbury Ladies' Choir by Jennifer Ryan;
The Shell Seekers by Rosamunde Pilcher;
The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah
My litmus test for reality is to see what a character does (in any book) when a finger is hit with a hammer. In this book the answer would have been 'oh dear, that hurts'. So totally out of sync with the real verbal expression by real people. Just too polished.
I am adding my personal gripes with books like these in this
I suspect a much older audience, perhaps people in their seventies and eighties would revel in the Victorian approach applied to a modern plot in this case. Even the Afrikaner characters lacked depth and soul. The bushveld where the Afrikaner family lived is so much more than was depicted in this saga.
This novel provides a lighter literary moment with here and there some atmospheric descriptions, for instance when the Jewish family and Marco hid in the cave against the Nazis. But even then the Jewish character of the family was completely absent. The author simply did not know her characters well enough. Both the Italian as well as Jewish families seriously lacked authenticity. Even the Afrikaners. But yes, once again, it was written for another audience.
For romance readers, this is a perfect choice. It just lost me. I wanted more. I skipped most of the middle of the book and did not reach the end. Too predictable and bleh. It was enough. Sorry.
December 20, 2017
Lettie Low grew up in South Africa feeling inferior to her girlfriends. She didn’t possess their beauty or their slim figures. She had many crushes on boys but was always overlooked and left heartbroken. Being the daughter of the town’s only doctor, she threw herself into her studies and joined his practice after college. She had given up on new relationships until she met a patient from Italy named Marco Romanelli.
Marco Romanelli is plagued with bouts of pneumonia which he acquired during the Nazi occupation of Italy. His brother, Antonio, currently lives in South Africa and believes that a change of climate would help his condition. Marco joins his brother and decides to seek better medical help. Marco crosses paths with Lettie when she takes him as a patient. As she works on improving his health, she quickly realizes that he is also suffering from emotional distress due to the war. These lonely people share many mutual friends and a deep bond starts to develop.
This historical fiction novel is set in both Italy and South Africa. This engaging book explores the lives of two people who experience life’s challenges and detours. Some of the characters from this book can be enjoyed in Irma Joubert’s prior novel “Children Of The River”.
Marco Romanelli is plagued with bouts of pneumonia which he acquired during the Nazi occupation of Italy. His brother, Antonio, currently lives in South Africa and believes that a change of climate would help his condition. Marco joins his brother and decides to seek better medical help. Marco crosses paths with Lettie when she takes him as a patient. As she works on improving his health, she quickly realizes that he is also suffering from emotional distress due to the war. These lonely people share many mutual friends and a deep bond starts to develop.
This historical fiction novel is set in both Italy and South Africa. This engaging book explores the lives of two people who experience life’s challenges and detours. Some of the characters from this book can be enjoyed in Irma Joubert’s prior novel “Children Of The River”.
December 20, 2017
I haven't read a book this amazing in a long time! Beautifully described historically by author Irma Joubert I could feel all the historical research she has put into the delightful details. This was my total reading pleasure. The book really comes full circle from beginning to end. Lettie is a shy and awkward young woman with not a lot of confidence in her appearance. One thing she does have confidence in is her doctoring skills as she works with only the best, her father who teaches her how to become a doctor just like him as she grows up in South Africa. Her profession take her far and she is very skilled in doctoring. She falls for a young man, De Wit but he falls for her best friend. She meets a man,Marco he is a tender and wonderful man and they marry. He is hesitant to have children with her though because of the health problems he has developed. The character are so well developed and the story line was not what I expected. Though there were joys and losses within the book it comes full circle in the end and this is just what this book needs.
Pub Date 07 Nov 2017
Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson--FICTION for a review copy in exchange for my honest review.
Pub Date 07 Nov 2017
Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas Nelson--FICTION for a review copy in exchange for my honest review.
April 10, 2018
This author has a gift for being able to touch the deepest places of your heart though her stories. This is the third book I've read by Joubert and I've felt the same with each one. There are many things to love about this book. The two things that stood out the most were the Italian cultural aspects and the human relationships. I love reading about the Italian culture. The food and history are fascinating. The Italian men are more emotional and affectionate. The visit to Italy was a literary treat, it made me want to visit even more so. The other thing that stood out to me are the relationships. They are so wonderfully drawn out. Whether South Africa, Italy or even America, family and relationships are much the same. Joy, pain, love and loss are all part of life and each are portrayed beautifully throughout this story. This is a long book in more ways than one. I was frustrated in the beginning with all the characters. It took me a while to settle in and enjoy it but it was totally worth it. Don't try to read this in a hurry. Take your time and savor it.
November 9, 2017
BookLookBloggers
MY BLOG: Melissa Martin's Reading List
MY BLOG: Melissa Martin's Reading List
November 5, 2017
About the Book
As retired physician Lettie Louw looks back upon her life, she recounts her coming of age in WWII-era South Africa in this compelling story of delayed love, loss, and reconciliation.
Lettie Louw is the daughter of the town physician in their South African village. She spends her childhood in the warm African days playing with her friends and being adored by her doting parents. When she becomes a teenager, she experiences her first taste of unrequited romantic love in the form of her best friend’s older brother, De Wet Fourie. When De Wet pursues the beautiful and wealthy Annabelle, Lettie’s dreams are crushed, and she moves to Johannesburg to pursue her studies in medicine.
Life in Johannesburg feels strange to Lettie, and the world around her is in profound upheaval as the Second World War rages. Her feelings for De Wet never waver, and Lettie is heartbroken when he marries another of her childhood friends. Lettie soon meets Marco Romanelli, an Italian immigrant, and they marry and raise two daughters, as the racial and political tensions in South Africa swirl about them.
Lettie never forgets her first love, even as the ravages of time, war, and illness play upon her life and the lives of those she loves. In their later years, Lettie and De Wet are thrown into one another’s company again, and they are given another chance at a life together.
My Review
The Crooked Path is yet another beautiful but haunting work of art from South African author Irma Joubert. The Crooked Path begins with an older and retired Lettie who begins to look back at her life and recount her younger years in WWII South Africa. Her first encounter with her first love De Wet who eventually marries one of Lettie's childhood friends and Lettie who meets a young Italian immigrant whom she marries and has a family with. Then years later Lettie and De Wet meet again and reconnect. The Crooked Path is a story about love, loss, faith, and second chances. This is a story, as all of Irma's works, that will stay with you long after you turn the last page. Irma Joubert skillfully and masterfully is able to create characters that leap off the page and into the reader's heart. This is a must read!
As retired physician Lettie Louw looks back upon her life, she recounts her coming of age in WWII-era South Africa in this compelling story of delayed love, loss, and reconciliation.
Lettie Louw is the daughter of the town physician in their South African village. She spends her childhood in the warm African days playing with her friends and being adored by her doting parents. When she becomes a teenager, she experiences her first taste of unrequited romantic love in the form of her best friend’s older brother, De Wet Fourie. When De Wet pursues the beautiful and wealthy Annabelle, Lettie’s dreams are crushed, and she moves to Johannesburg to pursue her studies in medicine.
Life in Johannesburg feels strange to Lettie, and the world around her is in profound upheaval as the Second World War rages. Her feelings for De Wet never waver, and Lettie is heartbroken when he marries another of her childhood friends. Lettie soon meets Marco Romanelli, an Italian immigrant, and they marry and raise two daughters, as the racial and political tensions in South Africa swirl about them.
Lettie never forgets her first love, even as the ravages of time, war, and illness play upon her life and the lives of those she loves. In their later years, Lettie and De Wet are thrown into one another’s company again, and they are given another chance at a life together.
My Review
The Crooked Path is yet another beautiful but haunting work of art from South African author Irma Joubert. The Crooked Path begins with an older and retired Lettie who begins to look back at her life and recount her younger years in WWII South Africa. Her first encounter with her first love De Wet who eventually marries one of Lettie's childhood friends and Lettie who meets a young Italian immigrant whom she marries and has a family with. Then years later Lettie and De Wet meet again and reconnect. The Crooked Path is a story about love, loss, faith, and second chances. This is a story, as all of Irma's works, that will stay with you long after you turn the last page. Irma Joubert skillfully and masterfully is able to create characters that leap off the page and into the reader's heart. This is a must read!
December 20, 2017
Favorite Quotes:
Annabel turned to her. “See, Lettie,” she said, carelessly tossing her hat onto her blanket roll, “that’s how you treat boys . . . men. They’re a bit like goats. If you stroke their egos, they’ll eat out of your hand.”
She was a tall, thin woman with hair piled high on her head and a nose like a quarter pound of cheese.
I love you like I’ve never loved anyone before and never will again.” His words flooded her brain, washed over her body, and entered the chambers of her heart where they were anchored, to be remembered and cherished in years to come.
You understand . . . with a deeper understanding than words can convey.”
Years ago my mom told me life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you’re supposed to be…
My Review:
The Crooked Path bore no similarity to my expectations, and I couldn’t be happier. The premise was entertaining and the writing and storylines were captivating, well-crafted, and smartly paced. The book was highly engaging, eventful, well researched, and encompassed a shattering and traumatic period of history that was told through the inspiring, contrasting, and heartbreaking personal experiences and sacrifices of highly endearing characters on separate continents and of different cultures. The story was poignant, emotive, and thoughtfully written without being overly melodramatic. Sweet story threads, humorous descriptions, amusing observations, and thoughtful insights into the characters’ life-altering transitions were generously woven throughout to balance the tragedy and traumas that befell them. I reveled in the entertaining nuances of the various characters and customs, all of which were unfamiliar and intriguing to me. Ms. Joubert often tucked in amusing and mind-snagging Easter egg details such as the hairdresser “producing a comb from her ample bosom…” and a little later, “delved into her bosom again and produced a pair of scissors.” She was also rather gifted in stinging my eyes and burning my throat with her moving and heartrending narratives. I was captivated and engaged from the very beginning to the pleasantly satisfying end.
Annabel turned to her. “See, Lettie,” she said, carelessly tossing her hat onto her blanket roll, “that’s how you treat boys . . . men. They’re a bit like goats. If you stroke their egos, they’ll eat out of your hand.”
She was a tall, thin woman with hair piled high on her head and a nose like a quarter pound of cheese.
I love you like I’ve never loved anyone before and never will again.” His words flooded her brain, washed over her body, and entered the chambers of her heart where they were anchored, to be remembered and cherished in years to come.
You understand . . . with a deeper understanding than words can convey.”
Years ago my mom told me life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you’re supposed to be…
My Review:
The Crooked Path bore no similarity to my expectations, and I couldn’t be happier. The premise was entertaining and the writing and storylines were captivating, well-crafted, and smartly paced. The book was highly engaging, eventful, well researched, and encompassed a shattering and traumatic period of history that was told through the inspiring, contrasting, and heartbreaking personal experiences and sacrifices of highly endearing characters on separate continents and of different cultures. The story was poignant, emotive, and thoughtfully written without being overly melodramatic. Sweet story threads, humorous descriptions, amusing observations, and thoughtful insights into the characters’ life-altering transitions were generously woven throughout to balance the tragedy and traumas that befell them. I reveled in the entertaining nuances of the various characters and customs, all of which were unfamiliar and intriguing to me. Ms. Joubert often tucked in amusing and mind-snagging Easter egg details such as the hairdresser “producing a comb from her ample bosom…” and a little later, “delved into her bosom again and produced a pair of scissors.” She was also rather gifted in stinging my eyes and burning my throat with her moving and heartrending narratives. I was captivated and engaged from the very beginning to the pleasantly satisfying end.
December 18, 2017
This the third novel by South African Author Irma Joubert translated from Afrikaans into English. As with the first two novels, The Crooked Path spans many years and is full of historical detail.
In particular it was interesting to learn about the origin of contact lenses and the term paparazzi. Main character Lettie is in the medical field and readers learn about the beginnings of penicillin and the spread of polio.
My favorite part of the novel occurred during the first third of the novel. I adored Marco and Rachel's story.
This was a well written novel and I look forward to reading others by the talented Irma Joubert.
My gratitude to publisher Thomas Nelson for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and the opinions expressed are my own.
In particular it was interesting to learn about the origin of contact lenses and the term paparazzi. Main character Lettie is in the medical field and readers learn about the beginnings of penicillin and the spread of polio.
My favorite part of the novel occurred during the first third of the novel. I adored Marco and Rachel's story.
This was a well written novel and I look forward to reading others by the talented Irma Joubert.
My gratitude to publisher Thomas Nelson for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and the opinions expressed are my own.
November 14, 2017
Thank you so much TLC Book Tours and Thomas Nelson publishing for sending me a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review and for having me on this book tour!
A beautiful and inspiring story that left me in tears, I won't soon forget the love between an Italian teacher and his South African doctor nor the crooked path that led them to each other. I rate this story 4 our of 5 stars!
"...life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you're supposed to be."
At first I wasn't so sure I was going to like this book. We start out with Lettie's character learning of her background and seeing her grow up to become a doctor. The writing came across stilted and I didn't really care for Lettie's character. But then we meet Marco. We hear his story. And immediately I am sucked in. Reading about World War II is always hard, but what was unique for me was reading about it through the eyes of characters from Italy and South Africa. What Marco had to go through during those war years, all for love, brought me to tears. Then Marco and Lettie's lives intersect and I fell in love with them and their love. I fell in love with their story and their very own crooked path.
Irma captures the rawness of life in its most unforgiving times. This book isn't a cookie cutter romance or a light hearted coming of age. It is true to what life is, both ups and downs. Heartaches and joy. Loss and new beginnings. Irma writes a story that just is, it isn't wrapped up in a little bow, it is real and has a life of its own. I soaked up this story and felt each and every emotion the characters felt.
I also enjoyed all the historical information through out this book. Whether during the war time, medical illnesses and findings, or in Italy with all the sites and art. There was so much knowledge in this book and I appreciate all that went in to make it accurate.
There were few things I didn't like about this book, but one or two things did stick with me. As I mentioned already Lettie, at first, was slightly unlikeable. I didn't connect to her story. I felt she cared so much about her looks and yet she was so smart and accomplished. To be a female doctor in that time period is amazing and instead of being strong and proud of herself she harped on her looks. Towards the end of the book though I began to like her because I think Marco and her brought out the best in each other. I couldn't not love them. I also thought the ending, while beautiful and truly a sentiment to the idea that we all live a life on a very crooked path, I felt it may have been a bit rushed and a little unfair to a certain someone's memory being in that town. I don't want to give anything away so I won't go further into that.
Overall, I loved this book. I cried and laughed. I fell in love with the characters and all of their kids. I truly walked a crooked path with them and I hope to revisit this story many times in the future.
"It's the wonderful thing about life that every person is unique."
A beautiful and inspiring story that left me in tears, I won't soon forget the love between an Italian teacher and his South African doctor nor the crooked path that led them to each other. I rate this story 4 our of 5 stars!
"...life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you're supposed to be."
At first I wasn't so sure I was going to like this book. We start out with Lettie's character learning of her background and seeing her grow up to become a doctor. The writing came across stilted and I didn't really care for Lettie's character. But then we meet Marco. We hear his story. And immediately I am sucked in. Reading about World War II is always hard, but what was unique for me was reading about it through the eyes of characters from Italy and South Africa. What Marco had to go through during those war years, all for love, brought me to tears. Then Marco and Lettie's lives intersect and I fell in love with them and their love. I fell in love with their story and their very own crooked path.
Irma captures the rawness of life in its most unforgiving times. This book isn't a cookie cutter romance or a light hearted coming of age. It is true to what life is, both ups and downs. Heartaches and joy. Loss and new beginnings. Irma writes a story that just is, it isn't wrapped up in a little bow, it is real and has a life of its own. I soaked up this story and felt each and every emotion the characters felt.
I also enjoyed all the historical information through out this book. Whether during the war time, medical illnesses and findings, or in Italy with all the sites and art. There was so much knowledge in this book and I appreciate all that went in to make it accurate.
There were few things I didn't like about this book, but one or two things did stick with me. As I mentioned already Lettie, at first, was slightly unlikeable. I didn't connect to her story. I felt she cared so much about her looks and yet she was so smart and accomplished. To be a female doctor in that time period is amazing and instead of being strong and proud of herself she harped on her looks. Towards the end of the book though I began to like her because I think Marco and her brought out the best in each other. I couldn't not love them. I also thought the ending, while beautiful and truly a sentiment to the idea that we all live a life on a very crooked path, I felt it may have been a bit rushed and a little unfair to a certain someone's memory being in that town. I don't want to give anything away so I won't go further into that.
Overall, I loved this book. I cried and laughed. I fell in love with the characters and all of their kids. I truly walked a crooked path with them and I hope to revisit this story many times in the future.
"It's the wonderful thing about life that every person is unique."
December 30, 2017
"The Crooked Path" by Irma Joubert is a book I knew nothing about. I don't normally like books that take place around the World Wars, as I'm more of a "happily ever after" type of person and books about the Wars are often too realistic and hard to read emotionally. That being said, I was pleasantly surprised by this book!
From the moment you read the first few pages, you can tell Ms. Joubert is a wordsmith. Her writing style is top notch and flows well, making it easy to read. The setting in this book is unique--South Africa and Italy during the World War II era. I appreciate how Ms. Joubert incorporates a lot from the cultures of the places she writes about. She obviously did a lot of research.
There are a lot of great themes in this book, such as self-esteem, loss, death, chronic illness and the path we travel in life. There is some faith content, but I would have liked more. Overall, the book is a little too sad for me and some of the parts were so well written that I had to disengage so I didn't become depressed. This is not a fluffy read. I appreciate books that deal with such issues and themes, but they are not my favorite to read. Like I said before, I do truly appreciate the writing style and the lessons that are incorporated into this story!
Content: I would give this book a PG rating. There is a girl asking how people get pregnant and if there's a way to not be pregnant. A guy notices a woman's curves. A guy and a girl who are not married sleep under the same blanket, but nothing happens. The word "hellhole" is used. There are harsh conditions described in concentration camps. A married couple is in bed talking without any clothes on. Babies are born out of wedlock. A character wants an abortion. Characters drink alcohol.
Rating: I give this book 3.5 stars.
Genre: Christian Fiction; Historical Fiction; Romance
I want to thank Irma Joubert, Thomas Nelson and the Fiction Guild for the complimentary copy of this book for review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I express in this review are my own. This is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s CFR 16, Part 255.
From the moment you read the first few pages, you can tell Ms. Joubert is a wordsmith. Her writing style is top notch and flows well, making it easy to read. The setting in this book is unique--South Africa and Italy during the World War II era. I appreciate how Ms. Joubert incorporates a lot from the cultures of the places she writes about. She obviously did a lot of research.
There are a lot of great themes in this book, such as self-esteem, loss, death, chronic illness and the path we travel in life. There is some faith content, but I would have liked more. Overall, the book is a little too sad for me and some of the parts were so well written that I had to disengage so I didn't become depressed. This is not a fluffy read. I appreciate books that deal with such issues and themes, but they are not my favorite to read. Like I said before, I do truly appreciate the writing style and the lessons that are incorporated into this story!
Content: I would give this book a PG rating. There is a girl asking how people get pregnant and if there's a way to not be pregnant. A guy notices a woman's curves. A guy and a girl who are not married sleep under the same blanket, but nothing happens. The word "hellhole" is used. There are harsh conditions described in concentration camps. A married couple is in bed talking without any clothes on. Babies are born out of wedlock. A character wants an abortion. Characters drink alcohol.
Rating: I give this book 3.5 stars.
Genre: Christian Fiction; Historical Fiction; Romance
I want to thank Irma Joubert, Thomas Nelson and the Fiction Guild for the complimentary copy of this book for review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I express in this review are my own. This is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s CFR 16, Part 255.
January 1, 2018
I treasured yet another touching story by author Irma Joubert. Her storytelling and characters always leave a mark on my heart--they're not perfect but their lives and journeys are difficult and beautiful. And the rich historical details makes me feel like I'm right there with the characters.
The Girl From the Train is still my favorite, but The Crooked Path--particularly the relationship between Lettie & Marco--was a lovely reading experience.
4.5 stars. I highly recommend this author and her stories to fans of historical fiction with romantic threads.
The Girl From the Train is still my favorite, but The Crooked Path--particularly the relationship between Lettie & Marco--was a lovely reading experience.
4.5 stars. I highly recommend this author and her stories to fans of historical fiction with romantic threads.
April 12, 2018
It was a good book overall. I loved how the book told the entire story of their lives. But on flip side there were so many characters it was hard to keep them all straight in my head. Also at the beginning where it tells you the list of characters it gives the story away telling you the ones that had kids together, that was very disappointing.
December 20, 2017
I’ve been wanting to read one of Irma Joubert’s books for some time now, so when I was given the opportunity to review The Crooked Path, I snapped it up. I’ll admit it took me a couple of chapters to get into the story, because it begins with a lot of narrative that provides a summary of Lettie’s childhood through to attending university during WWII. It may have been partly the fact that this novel is translated to English from the original language (Dutch or Afrikaans—I’m not sure which), but the writing in the opening chapters felt abrupt to me and even detached.
But then, in the third chapter, we meet Marco Romanelli, and although he is introduced in much the same way, I was quickly drawn into his story as a young Italian man in love with a Jewish girl as war breaks out in Europe. It was eye-opening to know just what some people went through to survive the war, and as his story progressed, I began to get an inkling of how his path might eventually cross with Lettie’s, and by then I was hooked.
Lettie’s mother once told her that life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you’re supposed to be. On the other side of the world, as the political unrest heightens in Europe, Marco observes: “Even a crooked path has to lead somewhere.” This book takes us along those crooked paths with Marco, Lettie and Lettie’s friends Klara, Christina, and Annabel over a span of some thirty or forty years, navigating life’s important relationships—friendship, romance, and parenthood—and both the joy and the sadness encountered along the way. And although there are obviously times when the books skips large sections of time, there is continuity in the path the story takes through those years.
I really don’t want to say anything more about the plot—that’s best left to the book itself—but there was a sense in which this story came full circle by the end. I would have liked a bit more of a dénouement, as there wasn’t really any time to enjoy the ending once we got there, but this is an engaging story for those who want to experience life in a different time and place, and be reminded that even when we don’t get what we want, even when life takes unexpected detours, there is beauty to be found on a crooked path.
I received a copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.
But then, in the third chapter, we meet Marco Romanelli, and although he is introduced in much the same way, I was quickly drawn into his story as a young Italian man in love with a Jewish girl as war breaks out in Europe. It was eye-opening to know just what some people went through to survive the war, and as his story progressed, I began to get an inkling of how his path might eventually cross with Lettie’s, and by then I was hooked.
Lettie’s mother once told her that life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you’re supposed to be. On the other side of the world, as the political unrest heightens in Europe, Marco observes: “Even a crooked path has to lead somewhere.” This book takes us along those crooked paths with Marco, Lettie and Lettie’s friends Klara, Christina, and Annabel over a span of some thirty or forty years, navigating life’s important relationships—friendship, romance, and parenthood—and both the joy and the sadness encountered along the way. And although there are obviously times when the books skips large sections of time, there is continuity in the path the story takes through those years.
I really don’t want to say anything more about the plot—that’s best left to the book itself—but there was a sense in which this story came full circle by the end. I would have liked a bit more of a dénouement, as there wasn’t really any time to enjoy the ending once we got there, but this is an engaging story for those who want to experience life in a different time and place, and be reminded that even when we don’t get what we want, even when life takes unexpected detours, there is beauty to be found on a crooked path.
I received a copy of this novel from the publisher. This has not influenced the content of my review, which is my honest and unbiased opinion.
May 7, 2015
Vir my die mooiste (en die hartseerste met tye) boek van die trilogie. Irma Joubert toor met woorde.
February 23, 2018
This book was so amazing. I cried which I never have in all my 16 years! Irma Joubert is now one of my all-time favourite writers!
February 6, 2018
Sometimes life leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you're supposed to be.
A delightful character driven book that begins before World War II. Where hope and promise is all that you cling to. Lettie Louw is surrounded by good friends, she is studious and loyal but does not see love in her future. She practices medicine with her father in South Africa. Her life takes a turn when Marco Romanelli comes to South Africa after the war. He suffers from weakened lungs as he was a prisoner in a Jewish camp. His brother, Antonio, lives in South Africa with his family and suggests that Marco teach at the university and get the care that he needs from Lettie.
Marco and Lettie connection is professional at first however, their attraction to character is deep. Marco's character is one of deep commitment. His story starts with his first love Rachel a Jewish girl whom he professes his love and as the Nazi's take over, he is committed to her family for their safety. Their story is heartbreaking and speaks of deep courage of hope. His character continues to shine as he and Lettie connect. They discover each other, they get each other and make beautiful Amore!
Their story also reflects the plight of polio and the fear that it brought to families in the region. It is a story of love, pain, loss and hope. I was completely enthralled with this one.
A Special Thank You to Thomas Nelson and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
A delightful character driven book that begins before World War II. Where hope and promise is all that you cling to. Lettie Louw is surrounded by good friends, she is studious and loyal but does not see love in her future. She practices medicine with her father in South Africa. Her life takes a turn when Marco Romanelli comes to South Africa after the war. He suffers from weakened lungs as he was a prisoner in a Jewish camp. His brother, Antonio, lives in South Africa with his family and suggests that Marco teach at the university and get the care that he needs from Lettie.
Marco and Lettie connection is professional at first however, their attraction to character is deep. Marco's character is one of deep commitment. His story starts with his first love Rachel a Jewish girl whom he professes his love and as the Nazi's take over, he is committed to her family for their safety. Their story is heartbreaking and speaks of deep courage of hope. His character continues to shine as he and Lettie connect. They discover each other, they get each other and make beautiful Amore!
Their story also reflects the plight of polio and the fear that it brought to families in the region. It is a story of love, pain, loss and hope. I was completely enthralled with this one.
A Special Thank You to Thomas Nelson and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportunity to post an honest review.
October 13, 2017
I absolutely loved, loved this book. Everything from the location of South Africa to the storyline, and the characters. The author found the magic touch striking the right balance with all of these elements. A treasured read!
The story starts out with Marco fleeing with his love and her family. They barely survive to be captured by the Germans. Once freed, Marco is the only one to be alive. He travels to South Africa to be with his brother. In this opening section of the story, I got to meet Marco and start forming a bond with him without the distraction of many other characters. I only say "meet" Marco as I truly got to know him once he met Lettie. He was a true gentleman during the courting stage, a caring husband, great father and brother, and a lover of music.
Now, I need to talk about Lettie. She is also kind and a good friend. Yet, she really blossomed when she met Marco. She was a good wife, mother, alright cook, and had a nice laugh. Marco and Lettie forever. If you are in the look out for an amazing read, you need to check out this book.
The story starts out with Marco fleeing with his love and her family. They barely survive to be captured by the Germans. Once freed, Marco is the only one to be alive. He travels to South Africa to be with his brother. In this opening section of the story, I got to meet Marco and start forming a bond with him without the distraction of many other characters. I only say "meet" Marco as I truly got to know him once he met Lettie. He was a true gentleman during the courting stage, a caring husband, great father and brother, and a lover of music.
Now, I need to talk about Lettie. She is also kind and a good friend. Yet, she really blossomed when she met Marco. She was a good wife, mother, alright cook, and had a nice laugh. Marco and Lettie forever. If you are in the look out for an amazing read, you need to check out this book.
December 20, 2017
“Years ago my mom told me life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you’re supposed to be, she replied.”
-Lettie Romanelli
Irma Joubert’s latest tale once again draws the reader to the complex life of South Africa during WWII. Readers of her previous novel, Child of the River, will find many of the same characters in this book along with many new ones. The story begins in Italy in 1939 and revolves around Marco Romanelli and the Rozenfeld family and their plight to escape the Nazis.
After four years of hiding the Rozenfelds in isolation in a mountainous cave and nearly starving, Marco and the Rozenfelds are captured by the Nazis and shipped to a camp. The depth of their tragedies during these difficult times is heart breaking. After the war finally ends and Marco returns home to his village, a sick and broken young man, his family sends him to South Africa to stay with his brother and recover from the war.
Marco meets Dr. Lettie Louw, who begins to nurse him back to health. Lettie and Marco marry and begin their family, only to have another of life’s difficulties change their course. Read this detailed account of Marco and Lettie’s life as they encounter complexities one can only imagine.
Once again Joubert gives the reader a good look at religious and ethnic prejudices during this very difficult time in history. The author delivers a deep, detailed book for readers of historical fiction, particularly those with an interest in WWII and South Africa.
This copy was received from Thomas Nelson and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. The above thoughts and opinions are wholly my own.
-Lettie Romanelli
Irma Joubert’s latest tale once again draws the reader to the complex life of South Africa during WWII. Readers of her previous novel, Child of the River, will find many of the same characters in this book along with many new ones. The story begins in Italy in 1939 and revolves around Marco Romanelli and the Rozenfeld family and their plight to escape the Nazis.
After four years of hiding the Rozenfelds in isolation in a mountainous cave and nearly starving, Marco and the Rozenfelds are captured by the Nazis and shipped to a camp. The depth of their tragedies during these difficult times is heart breaking. After the war finally ends and Marco returns home to his village, a sick and broken young man, his family sends him to South Africa to stay with his brother and recover from the war.
Marco meets Dr. Lettie Louw, who begins to nurse him back to health. Lettie and Marco marry and begin their family, only to have another of life’s difficulties change their course. Read this detailed account of Marco and Lettie’s life as they encounter complexities one can only imagine.
Once again Joubert gives the reader a good look at religious and ethnic prejudices during this very difficult time in history. The author delivers a deep, detailed book for readers of historical fiction, particularly those with an interest in WWII and South Africa.
This copy was received from Thomas Nelson and Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. The above thoughts and opinions are wholly my own.
April 10, 2018
This author has a wonderful way of drawing you into the characters' lives and making you feel attached to them. It was an emotional journey of love, loss, and new love, friendship and family. I am impressed by how this story intertwines with Child of the River, yet Lettie's story is entirely different from that of Persomi. I want to go back and read both books again.
December 7, 2020
Not quite what I expected... With the second half, anyway. I enjoyed it even if it was sadder than I expected in different ways than I expected.
December 20, 2017
Another day, and this time a book about Italian prisoners of war meeting South African doctors. This book was an interesting read: set in a part of the world that we perhaps don’t think about when it comes to the Second World War, or its aftermath. The result is a book that can be, at times, heartbreaking.
The Crooked Path is mainly about two people: Marco Romanelli and Lettie Louw, two people who grow up on the opposite sides of the world- though characters from Joubert’s other novels also pop up during the story.
Despite the fact that the main part of the action is set in South Africa, though, the book begins, oddly, with Marco’s experiences during the Second World War, including a nasty spell in Auschwitz. Though the story Joubert tells here is sensitively done, it’s also jarring, and completely unrelated to the rest of the novel, so it does make for a confusing start.
The rest of it, though, is great. Bringing to mind Sarah Franklin’s excellent Shelter, the relationship between Marco and Lettie is made all the better because we do spend time getting to know them before they actually meet in real life. As characters, they’re believable, warm and easy to sympathise with- especially Lettie’s anguish when younger that she’ll never meet anybody, or win the heart of the boy she loves, because she believes that she’s too ugly to do so. They have human flaws, but Lettie’s determination coupled with Marco’s sweet nature make them people to root for.
Their romance is well written, too: they’re two likeable characters, and Joubert gives their romance the space to breathe, so that when they finally do get together it’s very sweet. I was also impressed by the amount of time Joubert devoted to building up the world that the characters lived in. It’s bizarre to think that as little as fifty years ago South Africa was almost cut off from the rest of the world, and inventions like the gramophone were considered sophisticated instruments! This focus on history takes a serious turn, too: polio is the main focus of the second half of the novel, which gives you a real sense of how much fear it must have caused the population, and makes the novel seem much more grounded and realistic.
The only thing I found a bit problematic was the ending. Joubert has a tendency to cross vast periods of time at random during the course of the novel, which does leave you floundering and struggling to connect with the characters- especially with the younger ones, like Lettie’s daughters. That in turn creates problems with the characters, as it feels more like you’re catching up with them rather than reading a story about their lives. The final section of the book has a romance that feels shoehorned in and clumsy as a result, and I got the feeling that Joubert was struggling to tie up loose ends with all of her characters- which makes for a slightly disappointing ending to an otherwise lovely book.
All in all, this is a light-hearted, sweet read that touches on some of the post-war years- but it’s real focus is the relationship between Lettie and Marcus. If you want something to curl up with this winter then The Crooked Path is it.
The Crooked Path is mainly about two people: Marco Romanelli and Lettie Louw, two people who grow up on the opposite sides of the world- though characters from Joubert’s other novels also pop up during the story.
Despite the fact that the main part of the action is set in South Africa, though, the book begins, oddly, with Marco’s experiences during the Second World War, including a nasty spell in Auschwitz. Though the story Joubert tells here is sensitively done, it’s also jarring, and completely unrelated to the rest of the novel, so it does make for a confusing start.
The rest of it, though, is great. Bringing to mind Sarah Franklin’s excellent Shelter, the relationship between Marco and Lettie is made all the better because we do spend time getting to know them before they actually meet in real life. As characters, they’re believable, warm and easy to sympathise with- especially Lettie’s anguish when younger that she’ll never meet anybody, or win the heart of the boy she loves, because she believes that she’s too ugly to do so. They have human flaws, but Lettie’s determination coupled with Marco’s sweet nature make them people to root for.
Their romance is well written, too: they’re two likeable characters, and Joubert gives their romance the space to breathe, so that when they finally do get together it’s very sweet. I was also impressed by the amount of time Joubert devoted to building up the world that the characters lived in. It’s bizarre to think that as little as fifty years ago South Africa was almost cut off from the rest of the world, and inventions like the gramophone were considered sophisticated instruments! This focus on history takes a serious turn, too: polio is the main focus of the second half of the novel, which gives you a real sense of how much fear it must have caused the population, and makes the novel seem much more grounded and realistic.
The only thing I found a bit problematic was the ending. Joubert has a tendency to cross vast periods of time at random during the course of the novel, which does leave you floundering and struggling to connect with the characters- especially with the younger ones, like Lettie’s daughters. That in turn creates problems with the characters, as it feels more like you’re catching up with them rather than reading a story about their lives. The final section of the book has a romance that feels shoehorned in and clumsy as a result, and I got the feeling that Joubert was struggling to tie up loose ends with all of her characters- which makes for a slightly disappointing ending to an otherwise lovely book.
All in all, this is a light-hearted, sweet read that touches on some of the post-war years- but it’s real focus is the relationship between Lettie and Marcus. If you want something to curl up with this winter then The Crooked Path is it.
December 20, 2017
This and other reviews can be found at justonemorechapter.com
Thank you to TLC Tours for the opportunity to be part of this blog tour. Irma Joubert is a new author to me. I have seen her books around but have never read anything before and was anxious to read The Crooked Path.
The book opened up with Lettie where we learn of her early years in South Africa, I have to admit I was not drawn in right away, I found her character and the writing a bit stilted and I had a hard time liking her. Then the story jumps to Marco and his experiences with World War II in Italy. I was immediately drawn in and immersed in his story. I haven’t read much of World War II taking place in Italy so this was an eye-opener and an emotional part of this book.
It’s when their lives meet up in South Africa that further invested me in the story and The Crooked Path. The affects of World War II don’t stop at the end of the war and for Marco it lingers and affects the rest of his life. Life isn’t easy in South Africa during this time and the author does a good job of presenting the lifestyle of that era and things people endured, especially Lettie as a female doctor.
The Crooked Path is a story of friendship, love and loss, and so much more, in a setting (both Italy and South Africa) both before and after World War II. Definitely an author I will read more of. She took me to places and events unfamiliar to me in an honest and realistic manner.
Thank you to TLC Tours for the opportunity to be part of this blog tour. Irma Joubert is a new author to me. I have seen her books around but have never read anything before and was anxious to read The Crooked Path.
The book opened up with Lettie where we learn of her early years in South Africa, I have to admit I was not drawn in right away, I found her character and the writing a bit stilted and I had a hard time liking her. Then the story jumps to Marco and his experiences with World War II in Italy. I was immediately drawn in and immersed in his story. I haven’t read much of World War II taking place in Italy so this was an eye-opener and an emotional part of this book.
It’s when their lives meet up in South Africa that further invested me in the story and The Crooked Path. The affects of World War II don’t stop at the end of the war and for Marco it lingers and affects the rest of his life. Life isn’t easy in South Africa during this time and the author does a good job of presenting the lifestyle of that era and things people endured, especially Lettie as a female doctor.
The Crooked Path is a story of friendship, love and loss, and so much more, in a setting (both Italy and South Africa) both before and after World War II. Definitely an author I will read more of. She took me to places and events unfamiliar to me in an honest and realistic manner.
Read
August 25, 2021Wasn't my cup of tea.
November 17, 2018
I was mesmerized, engaged and surprised by this authors’ compelling novel titled, “The Girl From the Train.” I couldn’t wait to read another book by her. This book showed a different look at the persecution of the Jews that took place in Italy during WWII. The author says, “All my historical novels are based on true stories people have told me.” Knowing this makes the story an even more compelling read.
This book was set up differently than most books I’ve read. The author first lists a cast of characters then follows that by a glossary of words. Part one of this book is titled “Stepping out.” I was quickly drawn into this story and felt for the leading lady Lettie from the first line, “What she was looking at, was definitely not what she wanted to see.”
Readers are introduced to Lettie in her younger years. The author shows where Lettie’s drive to succeed came from. It was an effort to overcome insecurities from childhood, and to face the challenge of thriving in a male dominated field. She had to work hard to prosper so in the end she could show her childhood friends she was smart enough be a successful doctor. She wanted to be someone they would look up to and respect.
Then the story shifts to the second part titled “Love and War” where readers are brought to Italy and introduced to Marco Romanelli. I instantly connected with Marco and felt for his situation. Readers see him fall in love with a Jewish girl, Rachel Rosenfield. The author shows how that affects both of their lives and that of their families.
I felt a disconnect here because I was fully engaged in Lettie’s story in the USA then the author makes a switch and introduces another character living in Italy. I liked Marco from the start and was quickly engaged in his story and his life in Italy; but I couldn’t imagine how Lettie’s life and his would intersect but I read on. I’m glad I did.
The author quickly engages readers as they learn about Marco and Rachel’s family, their love and see how their community fights the powerful Nazi regime and survive the best they can. I felt for the people as they tried to be imaginative in how they’d survive the horrors of WWII.
I liked what Lettie’s mom told her. “Life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end, it will always take you where you’re supposed to be.” Marco says to Rachel, “…even a crooked path has to lead somewhere.”
Again, the book takes another shift to Part three titled “Intersection”, where Lettie and Marco meet (after 123 pages into the story). The last part is titled, “Wondering.” Again, I’m not sure if the choppiness from section to section is partly due to the fact that this novel was translated to English from the authors native tongue Dutch. There was a detachment that felt like little bumps in the road. The ending felt forced as the author ties things up in a nice bow. I did enjoy the vacation Lettie and her friends went on as they toured Italy. I wanted to be there with them they had so much fun.
This was a very interesting compelling, heart wrenching, read about the WWII era; rich in history, dealt with survival, love, loss, relationships and hope. I enjoyed it. I look forward to reading more by this author. I found the Author notes interesting. There are thirteen discussion questions to help create engaging discussion at your book club.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins! www.bookfun.org
The Book Club Network blog www.psalm516.blogspot.com
Book Fun Magazine https://tinyurl.com/y9lwbfrs
SVP Promotion
This book was set up differently than most books I’ve read. The author first lists a cast of characters then follows that by a glossary of words. Part one of this book is titled “Stepping out.” I was quickly drawn into this story and felt for the leading lady Lettie from the first line, “What she was looking at, was definitely not what she wanted to see.”
Readers are introduced to Lettie in her younger years. The author shows where Lettie’s drive to succeed came from. It was an effort to overcome insecurities from childhood, and to face the challenge of thriving in a male dominated field. She had to work hard to prosper so in the end she could show her childhood friends she was smart enough be a successful doctor. She wanted to be someone they would look up to and respect.
Then the story shifts to the second part titled “Love and War” where readers are brought to Italy and introduced to Marco Romanelli. I instantly connected with Marco and felt for his situation. Readers see him fall in love with a Jewish girl, Rachel Rosenfield. The author shows how that affects both of their lives and that of their families.
I felt a disconnect here because I was fully engaged in Lettie’s story in the USA then the author makes a switch and introduces another character living in Italy. I liked Marco from the start and was quickly engaged in his story and his life in Italy; but I couldn’t imagine how Lettie’s life and his would intersect but I read on. I’m glad I did.
The author quickly engages readers as they learn about Marco and Rachel’s family, their love and see how their community fights the powerful Nazi regime and survive the best they can. I felt for the people as they tried to be imaginative in how they’d survive the horrors of WWII.
I liked what Lettie’s mom told her. “Life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end, it will always take you where you’re supposed to be.” Marco says to Rachel, “…even a crooked path has to lead somewhere.”
Again, the book takes another shift to Part three titled “Intersection”, where Lettie and Marco meet (after 123 pages into the story). The last part is titled, “Wondering.” Again, I’m not sure if the choppiness from section to section is partly due to the fact that this novel was translated to English from the authors native tongue Dutch. There was a detachment that felt like little bumps in the road. The ending felt forced as the author ties things up in a nice bow. I did enjoy the vacation Lettie and her friends went on as they toured Italy. I wanted to be there with them they had so much fun.
This was a very interesting compelling, heart wrenching, read about the WWII era; rich in history, dealt with survival, love, loss, relationships and hope. I enjoyed it. I look forward to reading more by this author. I found the Author notes interesting. There are thirteen discussion questions to help create engaging discussion at your book club.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising”
Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins! www.bookfun.org
The Book Club Network blog www.psalm516.blogspot.com
Book Fun Magazine https://tinyurl.com/y9lwbfrs
SVP Promotion
December 20, 2017
From a young age, Lettie has felt like she doesn't measure up to those around her. Though she finds some success in her life by becoming a doctor, she is convinced that when it comes to matters of the heart, that romance is always going to pass her by. Marco is a survivor of the horrors of World War II, barely making it through the war with his life intact. When Marco moves to South Africa for the benefits of the temperate climate for his fragile health, he becomes Lettie's first patient after she returns home to the bushveld to join her father's practice. As their lives become ever more entwined, Lettie and Marco discover a joy and love they did not suspect was possible.
Irma Joubert has so succeeded at bringing history to life that at times I felt like I was stepping into the pages of a memoir rather than delving into a fiction book. From page one, I was captivated by the character of Lettie, resonating with her lack of confidence in who God made her to be and yet admiring her determination to continue down the path set before her. And Marco stands out as the very definition of a man, putting his own needs and desires aside to care for others. Walking alongside both Lettie and Marco, both in their individual stories and then once their paths crossed, was an emotional journey indeed, with loss and pain but joy and life at the same time. Joubert writes with a sure hand and with pacing that held my interest from start to finish. I should mention that my wife felt that some of the pacing in the book was odd in the choices that the author made in terms of which parts of their life to speed through and which parts to focus in on. But that wasn't my experience, and so I encourage you to read the book and decide for yourself. I loved seeing once again the characters I grew to care about in Joubert's prior book, The Child of the River, and I was torn between deciding whether I liked this book or that one better. In the end, it doesn't really matter as both are excellent reads!
I strongly recommend "The Crooked Path" and award it a solid 4 out of 5 stars.
Book has been provided courtesy of the Booklook Bloggers review program. Available from your favorite book retailer from Thomas Nelson, a division of HarperCollins.
Irma Joubert has so succeeded at bringing history to life that at times I felt like I was stepping into the pages of a memoir rather than delving into a fiction book. From page one, I was captivated by the character of Lettie, resonating with her lack of confidence in who God made her to be and yet admiring her determination to continue down the path set before her. And Marco stands out as the very definition of a man, putting his own needs and desires aside to care for others. Walking alongside both Lettie and Marco, both in their individual stories and then once their paths crossed, was an emotional journey indeed, with loss and pain but joy and life at the same time. Joubert writes with a sure hand and with pacing that held my interest from start to finish. I should mention that my wife felt that some of the pacing in the book was odd in the choices that the author made in terms of which parts of their life to speed through and which parts to focus in on. But that wasn't my experience, and so I encourage you to read the book and decide for yourself. I loved seeing once again the characters I grew to care about in Joubert's prior book, The Child of the River, and I was torn between deciding whether I liked this book or that one better. In the end, it doesn't really matter as both are excellent reads!
I strongly recommend "The Crooked Path" and award it a solid 4 out of 5 stars.
Book has been provided courtesy of the Booklook Bloggers review program. Available from your favorite book retailer from Thomas Nelson, a division of HarperCollins.
May 3, 2019
The Crooked Path by Irma Joubert
After The Girl from the Train whenever I read a Joubert book I have to remember it’s been translated from Afrikaans to English. So it’s a bit different.
But as the others, this is a fascinating story. All of her books are set around WWII and move through the years.
The Crooked Path begins with childhood friends, boys and girls in the bushveld of South Africa working through attractions and angst. The focus in on Lettie Louw, a misfit of sorts, although close with the others. She’s plain and plump and feels inferior because the others in her group are highly attractive. The story moves to marriages and careers fairly quickly with Lettie becoming a doctor in her father’s practice.
Suddenly there’s another story, one of Marco Romanelli, which has great detail and history of life, family and love in Italy. Life is lovely until Germany becomes a threat.
Years go quickly and, as the book title suggests, there are crooked paths all the friends must traverse and God is with them.
Very good book. But the way it is written is not in typical American form. There is great detail in several time periods, then there is a rush through years with very little detail. Such as two daughters are never said to even have a boyfriend. Then suddenly the book is talking about their husbands. Zero detail. But beyond the writing differences, it is still a marvelous book.
I both listened to and read the book. The narrator was good, but honestly I preferred reading it. Listening was for driving and doing things around the house.
After The Girl from the Train whenever I read a Joubert book I have to remember it’s been translated from Afrikaans to English. So it’s a bit different.
But as the others, this is a fascinating story. All of her books are set around WWII and move through the years.
The Crooked Path begins with childhood friends, boys and girls in the bushveld of South Africa working through attractions and angst. The focus in on Lettie Louw, a misfit of sorts, although close with the others. She’s plain and plump and feels inferior because the others in her group are highly attractive. The story moves to marriages and careers fairly quickly with Lettie becoming a doctor in her father’s practice.
Suddenly there’s another story, one of Marco Romanelli, which has great detail and history of life, family and love in Italy. Life is lovely until Germany becomes a threat.
Years go quickly and, as the book title suggests, there are crooked paths all the friends must traverse and God is with them.
Very good book. But the way it is written is not in typical American form. There is great detail in several time periods, then there is a rush through years with very little detail. Such as two daughters are never said to even have a boyfriend. Then suddenly the book is talking about their husbands. Zero detail. But beyond the writing differences, it is still a marvelous book.
I both listened to and read the book. The narrator was good, but honestly I preferred reading it. Listening was for driving and doing things around the house.
December 20, 2017
I've been in the mood for emotional reads. It didn't take very long to know that The Crooked Path is definitely one of those books. I cried my way through this one.
As you are introduced to Lettie, you really feel her inadequacy, even though she is a very smart woman. Her friends are always making her feel that she isn't up to snuff because she's not as beautiful or wealthy or popular as her other friends. It doesn't help that she has a crush on a guy that would never look at her in the way that she wants him too.
Marco is an Italian Catholic in love with a pretty Jewish girl.
The time period is WWII, so you know that there is going to be heartbreak there even though Marco does his best to protect them from the Nazis. His story is the one that will rip your heart out, toss it on the floor and then stomp all over it.
This man goes through hell, protecting the woman he loves as well as her family, only to lose all and then become deathly sick, which is what leads him to South Africa and lettie.
Through a crooked path, a theme that is recurring throughout this book, Lettie and Marco find one another and they find love. I love the quote “Years ago my mom told me life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you’re supposed to be.”"
There's a lot of truth to that quote, especially as you see the crooked path that Lettie takes, as she helps her town and then her family battle polio.
The only thing that bothered me was Lettie's self esteem and the focus on how she couldn't be beautiful if she wasn't slim.
There is much heartache in this story, but the story comes full circle at the end. I was glad Lettie had a little bit more happiness in her life agai.
This was one of the most beautiful books I've read this year.
As you are introduced to Lettie, you really feel her inadequacy, even though she is a very smart woman. Her friends are always making her feel that she isn't up to snuff because she's not as beautiful or wealthy or popular as her other friends. It doesn't help that she has a crush on a guy that would never look at her in the way that she wants him too.
Marco is an Italian Catholic in love with a pretty Jewish girl.
The time period is WWII, so you know that there is going to be heartbreak there even though Marco does his best to protect them from the Nazis. His story is the one that will rip your heart out, toss it on the floor and then stomp all over it.
This man goes through hell, protecting the woman he loves as well as her family, only to lose all and then become deathly sick, which is what leads him to South Africa and lettie.
Through a crooked path, a theme that is recurring throughout this book, Lettie and Marco find one another and they find love. I love the quote “Years ago my mom told me life sometimes leads you along a strange crooked path, but in the end it will always take you where you’re supposed to be.”"
There's a lot of truth to that quote, especially as you see the crooked path that Lettie takes, as she helps her town and then her family battle polio.
The only thing that bothered me was Lettie's self esteem and the focus on how she couldn't be beautiful if she wasn't slim.
There is much heartache in this story, but the story comes full circle at the end. I was glad Lettie had a little bit more happiness in her life agai.
This was one of the most beautiful books I've read this year.
January 22, 2018
I adored this book! It was super emotional which I figured out from the beginning. It was an emotional roller coaster and I was spot on. My favorite story within the book was Lettie and Marco’s. There love for one another went deeper than any other relationship they had in their lives. It was a beautiful love. They understood one another without having to say a word to each other. It’s hard for me at times when reading a book to go from a time in life, to the next. I get emotionally invested in each relationship or story line so when things change it’s hard. I have to give myself a few days or hours to recover and with Irma Joubert’s books every single one I’ve read I needed some time. They are wonderful books and take you to so many different times and place. The Crooked Path is definitely one. Irma Joubert another five stars for me!! Thank you for this lovely, historical, beautiful, romance!
December 20, 2017
I truly enjoyed this book and the setting of it as well.
Lettie longed for someone she couldn't have, she felt inferior to all of her friends, but worked twice as hard to compensate. She studies hard and becomes a doctor, following in her father's footsteps.
Marco, having spent a majority of the war in the hills, has diminished health and his lungs are not strong. He moves to South Africa for a better climate, where he meets Lettie.
4.5 stars
Lettie longed for someone she couldn't have, she felt inferior to all of her friends, but worked twice as hard to compensate. She studies hard and becomes a doctor, following in her father's footsteps.
Marco, having spent a majority of the war in the hills, has diminished health and his lungs are not strong. He moves to South Africa for a better climate, where he meets Lettie.
4.5 stars
December 20, 2017
I received an advance reader copy in exchange for a fair review.
This book was hauntingly beautiful. Such anguish and such happiness. What a journey!!
This book was hauntingly beautiful. Such anguish and such happiness. What a journey!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 208 reviews