Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Great Tamasha: Cricket, corruption and India's unstoppable rise

Rate this book
To understand modern India, one must look at the business of cricket within the country.

When Lalit Modi--an Indian businessman with a criminal record, a history of failed business ventures, and a reputation for audacious deal making--created a Twenty20 cricket league in India in 2008, the odds were stacked against him. International cricket was still controlled from London, where they played the long, slow game of Test cricket by the old rules. Indians had traditionally underperformed in the sport but the game remained a national passion. Adopting the highly commercial American model of sporting tournaments, and throwing scantily clad western cheerleaders into the mix, Modi gave himself three months to succeed. And succeed he did--dazzlingly--before he and his league crashed to earth amid astonishing scandal and corruption.

The emergence of the IPL is a remarkable tale. Cricket is at the heart of the miracle that is modern India. As a business, it represents everything that is most dynamic and entrepreneurial about the country's economic boom, including the industrious and aspiring middle-class consumers who are driving it. The IPL also reveals, perhaps to an unprecedented degree, the corrupt, back-scratching, and nepotistic way in which India is run.

A truly original work by a brilliant journalist, The Great Tamasha* makes the complexity of modern India--its aspiration and optimism straining against tradition and corruption--accessible like no other book has.

*Tamasha: a Hindi world meaning "a spectacle."

272 pages, Hardcover

First published July 15, 2012

16 people are currently reading
355 people want to read

About the author

James Astill

2 books2 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
51 (21%)
4 stars
122 (51%)
3 stars
52 (21%)
2 stars
13 (5%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 40 reviews
Profile Image for Swati Garg.
53 reviews21 followers
October 22, 2014
I had planned on writing a long review for this book since it is about a thing i am really passionate for i.e. indian cricket
But i'll just say two lines:
Read it because you LOVE indian cricket, you'll get a reality check.
Also read it because you HATE Indian Cricket, you'll find reasons to love it.
Profile Image for Abhinav.
272 reviews261 followers
March 11, 2014
So much has been said about this book already in so many reviews - from the NYT & the Observer to the Telegraph & ESPN Cricinfo, to name a few - that I really don't have much to add to what they have written.

All I will say is that anyone who invests his emotions whenever India's national cricket team takes the field should definitely give James Astill's "The Great Tamasha" a read, for it is a wonderful book about the past, present & what probably lies in the future of Indian cricket.
Profile Image for Mac.
199 reviews2 followers
February 17, 2022
As someone who knows almost nothing about India and even less about cricket I still found this an engaging and extremely informative read. Good stuff.
Profile Image for Peter Karsten.
4 reviews1 follower
March 26, 2018
Messy journey through a messy country, guided by cricket.

You need a guide in India. It might as well be cricket.

Very interesting read about a complex continent.
Profile Image for James.
875 reviews15 followers
November 1, 2024
This wasn't quite what I was expecting, and was a cultural history of modern India more than an account of the IPL's formation. Reading it 10 years on has two advantages, one being how much foresight Astill had, and the other being its capture of the mood when the IPL was in its early stages, free of revisionism.

Most of the book is about the social history of cricket in India, from sectarian teams in the earliest competition, to patronage from princes, and the ongoing conflicts and diplomatic issues with Pakistan. It is a thorough account, and the print is very small to keep the page count down which made me frequently feel drowsy, but I felt my knowledge of India and its politics was enhanced as a result of reading it.

Few sections were given over to politics entirely, which instead provided a backdrop to economic and cultural changes, although Astill's own beliefs were made clear. He stated he'd written for The Economist, although this could have been deduced fairly easily from his views on market economics and the left. (India was obviously hamstrung by its early efforts for equality post-independence, did a lot better economically once liberalised, but for unknown reasons India had got more unequal since then which seemed to be considered bad. Positive discrimination had led to an inefficient civil service, but disproportionate ratios of castes or religions in desirable positions was also bad. Make your mind up mate).

His sociopolitical analysis wasn't brilliant, and you could tell he was a journalist of narrative rather than statistics - the obvious answer as to why India produced good spinners was surely that their pitches suit it and reward spinners more reliably, rather than a cultural or genetic difference. This was odd as he'd rightly dismissed the idea of first-class cricket conforming to traditional Indian longform tales, which was shown to be nonsense when ODI and then T20 cricket became the most popular form.

Astill had secured a decent range of interviews including former players, administrators and Lalit Modi, whose early influence on the IPL was significant. The retelling of the ICL/IPL story seemed a bit patchy to me, and prior knowledge would definitely be beneficial, but I think fundamentally the author just didn't care for T20 that much which coloured his coverage of it. To be fair to him, at the time there were lots of scandals, but it has gone from strength to strength, and the same team owners have controlling interests in most leagues around the world. The players he interviewed still saw it as a bit of a joke, but they were top test cricketers at the end of their careers, and it would have been interesting to hear from more run of the mill players, or younger ones. Perhaps the demise of test cricket has been more gradual than foreseen, but T20 now has both popularity and legitimacy.

Less prescient still was Astill's coverage of nationalism and sectarianism, and Narendra Modi's party has increased both, whereas Astill didn't believe it had much strength politically. This is always a difficulty in political proclomations because the context can change very quickly, but it showed the folly of journalists predicting the future and the limits of their wisdom, on top of the central issue for me that one middle class journalist will never get a true feel for ordinary people in a country of 1bn people, when they rarely capture the mood of a much smaller one they've grown up in.

This was still an interesting book for what it revealed about Indian culture, particularly their reverance for money, even if I felt Astill couldn't always join the dots. He described himself as a cricket tragic but I was not entirely convinced, and saw him more as someone who might watch it on TV and enjoys a day out drinking at Lords. A great book could have been written but this wasn't it.
Profile Image for Pranav Jagdish.
56 reviews1 follower
April 26, 2021
This book covers the rise of Indian cricket - from the days when it was merely a colonial obsession to now, when the BCCI practically owns cricket. It isn't a comprehensive review into any specific phase, Astill brushes through all the important points that factor into the rise of Indian cricket. This is the USP of The Great Tamasha, that it never reads like cricket history. It's riveting to read and being a fan of Indian cricket, it felt great to get an overall view of how far the game has come.

The most interesting parts of the book was when Astill describes the prowess of great cricketers of the early 20th century. I never knew anything about Ranjitsinghji, C.K Nayudu or Tiger Pataudi. These are the true icons of cricket, personalities that shaped the future of cricket as a whole. The later chapters describing cricket post 2011 were familiar but I didn't feel like it just covered the main highlights of all the important events that occurred.

That's the strength of this book in my opinion, how Astill somehow finds a way to make the mundane interesting. On the surface, this book only covers the rise of Indian cricket without getting into too much detail. However, there are always interviews and POVs from various cricket celebrities that always spice up a chapter. I'd highly recommend this book to any average cricket fan who doesn't have any idea of our rich cricket history. This book might seem slightly boring for someone totally up to speed but this is great starting point to get into Indian cricket history.
58 reviews
March 13, 2025
This book provides a fascinating overview of the development of Indian cricket, set against the emergence of the IPL. Although a little dated now, it is remarkable how many of the issues still prevail, particularly in terms of the dominance of the BCCI on the game's administration.
Insights into India's culture and society are skillfully woven into the narrative, including (as one would expect from a journalist at the Economist) commentary and analysis of India's growing global economic power.
Astill writes objectively, yet sensitively about the state of the game in India, and is appropriately critical of the links between cricket and nationalism. Overall a fascinating read that is highly recommended.
Profile Image for JasonDeen.
53 reviews
December 27, 2024
I really liked how clearly everything is described here. This book is perfect for those who want to get to know the history of Indian cricket better. Yes, the book cannot contain all the figures and facts but.. Those who want to dig deeper can always request statistics using resources such as 1xbet app India. It is very nice that the book also includes fans who support cricket.
Profile Image for Ujjwal Ashok.
16 reviews1 follower
March 24, 2022
A page turner. Rich in detail & narratives which are masterfully etched together by the author. A book of interest to anyone who desires to understand the rise of India as a cricketing superpower in the modern age.
Profile Image for Mayur Patil.
23 reviews
February 1, 2021
This is the first book, I read about cricket. I really liked the way, Author has discussed lot of things from Indian society which are intertwined with the Cricket. While discussing Cricket, Authors has placed anecdotes from past, excerpts/observations from interviews, stories about Importance of cricket for poor people. Must read for Cricket fan.
1 review1 follower
September 4, 2013
I am not a frequent book reader but I plan to develop this as a habit, because this just helps.
At my work place in author's read session that we have I got introduced to this book. The title was catchy and so was the book's random paragraphs that I mostly read before I really start reading a book. This revolves around Indian Cricket scene.

I should not take away the credit from author to make the book a interesting read. It targets Indian cricket scene starting from late 19th century, how game was introduced to India by the English. Author here brings the events and social changes that Cricket introduced in India. Author touches upon the many segments of society and his personal interview extracts with all levels of cricket lovers in India.

Author also show the limitations that politics have placed into cricket and how it is used for some personal gains by the powerful decision makers.
Events that changed cricket , match fixing, terror attacks on cricket players, cross border tension , Mumbai attacks etc. It is interesting also to know how corruption has deep rooted into the Indian political system.
Sometimes the book makes me feel sorry to see the deserving not getting rewarded for the efforts and harsh reality they have to live with due to corruption and how the rules are modified for benefits of few . But also there are some stories that will make you feel and hope to work hard towards a goal.

As a conclusion Author here is non biased and tries to introduces phases of development Indian cricket have gone. He touches upon social issues cricket have within Cricket Mad country - India. I learnt a lot of facts from the book related to cricket and also non cricket related . It's a read for someone who would to understand modern cricket, why is it the way it is today ( t20 , match fixing, power struggle … ) .


Profile Image for Kaustubh Kirti.
102 reviews12 followers
November 5, 2016
Great book full of real life characters, stories and realities from the on the field and off the field. What is best is the book tries to outline and define the politics and people behind this game . BCCI being one of the most strongest organisations in the entire world sits at the peak of cricket in the world. However the organisation is in rot. Driven by corruption and un wanted interventions in international schedules BCCI decides what will happen next. With such financial strength the organisation had the capability to home grown India into a great cricketing paradise, inventing more into talents. Currently we see only players from middle class or upper class families embroiled themselves in betting scandals bu the aspirations of this countrymen at large remains unfulfilled. However what BCCI has given us Twenty 20, Lalit Modi and a further scoop of scandals.

From behind the scenes the author has tried to sum up the above right from the birth of cricket in late 19th century and how it was picked up by Maharajas and Parsis. He adds the story of India cricketers post independence , effect of 1947 on cricket, Pataudi, Contracter etc. HE tells the story of how post 1990 when BCCI started arm twisting the international cricketing time tables and what we see is just what happened afterwards. Driven by money money the organisation and its people with no interest in the game have blatantly shammed the concept of test cricket in twenty20.

The best part is definately the politics of the game and the downfall and ultimate ouster of Lalit Modi. Great read and especially for someone who follows cricket diehard might relate to some of the matches which the author describes on the way.
192 reviews3 followers
March 28, 2014
It is a brilliant book. Much like the Economist for which James Astill works, it is well researched, provocative and more importantly spot on. I have not read any other book or article which describes the corruption in India better or with an understanding of what its consequences will be. This is remarkable.

Another important thing for me is that he reminded me some of the best times in Indian cricket. Kapil Dev's thrilling 175 against Zimbabwe, the wins against Australia and England and of course, the victory at Lords in the final. Also, for all his mistakes off the field, Azharuddin remains one of India's most stylish batsman ever. His cover drives were stuff of legend. I enjoyed reading those snippets about him.

On the human side, some of his conversations gives you a glimpse of the celebrity which you have only guessed about earlier. I felt this especially with Tiger Pataudi, Vijay Mallya and Vinod Kambli. Another personality he showed so clearly is Arvind Pujara. The only quibble I have with this book is that, Astill has lived in India for four years it is sad that the only people he genuinely empathized were all in Dharavi.
Profile Image for Vinod Peris.
233 reviews9 followers
May 23, 2014
I was traveling to India and wanted to catch up on 25 years of cricket while sitting on a plane. This seemed like the perfect book for this. It started out with some of the early cricketing pioneers of India and it was interesting to see how it gained popularity despite the fact that the British did nothing to encourage it when they ruled India. The book quickly progresses to more modern times and the author has done his homework well in terms of distilling the essence of the key players of the Indian Cricket Team through the second half of the twentieth century. His descriptions of Gavaskar, Vishwanath, Bedi, Chandra, Prasanna and Venkat were precise and brought on a wave of nostalgia as I read through those sections. Finally, the part that I really needed an education was the events leading up to the IPL. The author is clearly not impressed with the quality of the cricket there and expresses his doubts on whether it is beneficial to the cricket game as a whole.

Overall, I would not recommend this book unless you are looking to get educated on the Indian Cricket scene.
Profile Image for Raghavendra.
26 reviews
July 30, 2014
A sports book is usually a good read. A cricket book is always a good read. James Astill doesn't completely disappoint. The chapters on Indian cricket history, the excellent reference section and the sublime encounters in this book make it a good read. The disappointment is in the overly generalized comparison of the current Indian economy with cricket. The rise and fall of the fortunes of the players of the game is tied to the rise and fall of the Indian republic via anecdotes and cherry picked stories. It skirts around a lot of Indian post-independence history and makes cricket a way bigger protagonist than the game really has been.Add a dash of condescension of things Indian in general and IPL and its audience in particular. Makes for awkward reading sometimes.

That said, it is a fine read and quite well written. The reference section is really above par and has led me to a lot of other books. Read this for enjoyment and don't take it seriously.After all, it is only a game.
Profile Image for Umair Mir.
8 reviews1 follower
August 16, 2013

The Great Tamasha ponders over the transition , of the game from elite Britishers ( symbolism ) to the biggest slum of Asia..A mind boggling transition by any standards..It also examines the contribution of Parsis and few Unsung heroes , thrown into the understanding of India..To quote Astill " As i hope to have shown, i know of no better way to make sense of India, in its vastness and complexity , than through its passion for cricket "
In its later part,the author critically analyses and examines the future of cricket in India aligned with its freakonomics, and posing a great threat to the traditional as well as the international form of cricket...One could say a choice between the National pride and Consumerism...
Profile Image for Mayuresh Dubhashi.
8 reviews1 follower
September 23, 2013
Someone needed to shed light on the murkier side of the BCCI and the way it manages cricket in the country. And thankfully this book does exactly that.
It's like the Maximum City for cricket, right from talking to honest, aspiring cricketers to self-declared demi-gods like Niranjan Shah, it talks about them all.
The author really loves his cricket & cricketing history and so one ends up noticing that tinge of sadness about how the sport in being manhandled by those feudal lords who have no clue about it.

Read it for the rise of cricket in India and the very delicate perch at the top on which it sits today.

Profile Image for Umesh Kesavan.
451 reviews178 followers
July 15, 2014
Combines the historical analysis of Ramachandra Guha with the travelogue-style of Rahul Bhattacharya. The chapters on Niranjan Shah and Lalit Modi were revealing. Like any cricket book based in India,there is a generous dose of Bollywood,economics,Hindu nationalism,politics and caste thrown it. A particular sideshow I enjoyed was the chapter on Nargis Fakhri on the sets of Rockstar. The only minus to point out is that the book says nothing new or suggests no solutions to revamp Indian cricket. Otherwise,an enriching read.
Profile Image for Kshitiz.
4 reviews1 follower
August 11, 2014
This book couples the history of Indian cricket with political and economic development in India. It tells how India became the undisputed leader of Cricket Economics. What is ailing Indian Cricket and follies of its administrators and system. There are some hidden nuggets of information (for e.g. development of Pujara as a cricketer) which ordinary observer/follower of cricket would not have privy to. But at the same time, I am a bit surprised by the degree of sarcasm used in the book.
Highly readable book and puts Indian Cricket into right perspective.
Profile Image for Parth.
34 reviews3 followers
September 27, 2015
The book is a nice attempt to view the Indian cricket from unbiased eyes of a foreign correspondent. I came to know many things about the history of the game in India as well as how current state of the game actually is. The author has been bold enough to criticise what he has felt wrong and also good enough to highlight what he found outstanding in Indian cricket. I just completed the book over a weekend and now will see the world cup starting from next week with a slightly different perspective.. All in all, a must read at least once for every cricket enthusiast of India..
Profile Image for Raghu Oddiraju.
49 reviews
August 11, 2013
As the description of the book says, it is about cricket, corruption and how things get done in India.Unfortunately, it may not be suitable to people who are not familiar with the sport even though it is not exactly about the game itself but more about how it is run. For those who are familiar with the sport, it gives a great insight about how among a lot of talented people, only some get a chance to play.
Profile Image for Nilendu Misra.
353 reviews18 followers
February 14, 2014
Economist writers have a way to keep readers with them for 400 pages! I originally borrowed this book from local library to possibly thumb-through in an hour. After the page where he interviews Kapil Dev I got hooked and raced to the end. Imran Khan condoning suicide bombing to Sir Viv Richards, drunk cable-wallahs of Delhi, forgotten geography of ICL -- the book also sub-plots significant political happenings in 80s and 90s. A good read.
Profile Image for Arvind.
12 reviews
June 5, 2014
The book is brilliant, well written and a well researched one at that considering the fact that the author works for the Economist. He describes the history of Indian Cricket from its origins to the current day T20 series, the scandals and corruptions that have time and again brought ill repute to the game. took up this book after reading a review on the NYT. A book one should read to understand what Indian Cricket is all about
Profile Image for Geoff.
994 reviews130 followers
June 15, 2014
Great examination of the history of cricket in India, with a focus on the rise to world cricket administration dominance of (& increased corruption in) the Indian Cricket Board and the development (and corruption) of the Twenty20 Indian Premier League.

it's an excellent book - the only quibble is that the author seems to hate Twenty20 cricket (and greatly prefers the Test match), slings some baseless insults at the shorter game, and never really describes why the test version is better.
62 reviews
October 25, 2014
This is what you'd expect from an editor from the Economist writing about cricket in India: potted history, interviews with cricket administrators and cricket obsessives across the social spectrum, skepticism towards economic regulation. It entertains and informs, though the journalistic tone is a bit too breezy for my tastes. Worth reading if you're interested in the consequences of India's economic development and its impact on global cricket.
Profile Image for A.
118 reviews3 followers
February 3, 2014
The cricket in India. The impact of the game, the social-economic effects and the subsequent corruption/growth. This is what the book tries to go through. With a lot of scope, the could have gone even deeper. Overall a good book especially for the observation and the last chapter where he for sees the BCCI bullying. Not bad. Worth a read.
35 reviews4 followers
September 7, 2014
A wonderful book that the phenomenon of cricket in India - its history, its politics, and its present. Very critical of Indian politics in sports and says the current standing of Indian cricket is only because of the people running the sport. Also highly critical of the IPL - it is a wonderful read for every Indian sport fan.
Profile Image for Akin.
331 reviews18 followers
October 15, 2014
Two and a half stars, really. Solid but unspectacular research, goes long on the anecdote and personal aside, but rather short on analysis. Not terribly well organised. IPL probably warrants a book in itself. Dreadful editing. It could have been...should have been a much better book, but feels like it was put together in a hurry.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 40 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.