t is not difficult to see the impact that Frank Kitson's writing has had on US Counterinsurgency doctrine. Many of the organizational recommendations he gives are moot considering they have long been adopted but his prioritization of intelligence collection and conceptual reframing of the battlefield in the minds of commanders are still just as relevant today. Even after over a decade of counterinsurgency operations, it is not difficult to find officers "longing for the good old days" when men stood against men and pummeled each other on the field of battle. If those days were gone in the 1970s, they are surely gone now.
Many of the specific techniques for which Kitson is criticized, such as mass-incarceration, resettlement, and summary executions, are only tangentially mentioned in the book and usually qualified with a discussion on the establishment of politically-acceptable limits on the use of force at each stage of a conflict. The book was clearly written as a theoretical basis for these types of operations and with the understanding that every individual conflict is different. That being said, pragmatism is an overarching theme and Kitson clearly leaves room to justify types of activities well outside the bounds of what the US Army currently considered morally-acceptable behavior. Kitson leaves much of the translation from theoretical concept to execution in the minds of the reader for this purpose. In short, if you are looking for a less prescriptive and philosophical approach to COIN, this is a good book.