Little Critter, about whom Mercer Mayer has been writing stories since 1975, goes green in this 2011 addition to the I Can Read! series. Ready to plant his garden, he heads to the local garden store, where he and his parents purchase seeds and baby plants and rent a plow. At home, Little Critter and his sister find out that gardening is hard work, but that having patience and caring for the garden ultimately yield a wonderful result.
It's become somewhat trendy in recent years to include a title about going green in every popular children's series. We've had them from Arthur, Gilbert, Sesame Street, The Boxcar Children, and Sid the Science Kid. During the past five years, Fancy Nancy, Dora the Explorer, Robin Hill School, Nancy Drew and the Clue Crew, Just Grace, Spongebob Squarepants, Mallory McDonald, and Rainbow Magic have also published titles in the genre Novelist K-8 and other sources now identify as "eco-fiction." (I tried to find out the original source of this term, but only made it back as far as this book.)
Certainly, it makes sense that every popular series would want to involve its characters in as many holidays and childhood experiences as possible, but the key to making that work, in my opinion, is to write a book that really stands out and does something different than what other books have done. And though this story has a lot of those time-tested and truly loved qualities that have come to be associated with Little Critter in the last 35 years, the content of the story doesn't really introduce anything new.
That's not to say this book isn't well done. I read through it several times before sitting down to write this review, and each time, I was impressed by something new. Since this book is at the "My First" level of the I Can Read ladder, and is intended for an adult to share with a child who is starting to learn to read, there is a lot happening in the illustrations that really supplements the text, which helps new readers contextualize new words, but also enhances the story for kids not yet reading on their own.
One really wonderful thing about the illustrations in this book is the fact that almost all of them include print in some way. Having signs, labels, and notes visible in each illustration helps promote print awareness and encourages new readers to realize there are words everywhere, and that learning to read them is an exciting and important process.
I also like the way Little Critter's personality - filled with mischief, impatience, and the occasional bout of frustration or anger - comes across through his facial expressions and interactions with members of his family. Fans of Little Critter's other books will recognize these qualities and they will enjoy the story more because of them.
Another strength of this book is the way it introduces new garden-related concepts, such as the "weed, water, and wait" process of growing the plants, the compost heap for making "good garden dirt," and buying "good bugs that eat bad bugs." I also enjoyed seeing the family dog try to protect the garden from hungry, unsuspecting deer.
Overall, while I found it difficult to connect with this book, I can understand its merits and its potential appeal to its intended audience. I only wish the story had included a fresher approach to the oft-used subject matter.