An informative look at how life in the Wild West was, but, not quite what I was expecting from the title. "The Writer's Guide to Everyday Life in the Wild West" doesn't really have much in the way of "writer's guide" or "everyday life."
The section under "Gunfighters and Outlaws," for example, in Chapter 17, is a one paragraph summary of the existence of train robberies and shoot-outs, and then a long list of various gun violence related factoids - such as "1867 - Jesse James kills three people while robbing a bank in Richmond, Virginia." I mean, these are stock characters in westerns! Pretty much every western character can fit under "gunfighters and outlaws," and its one of the least elaborated subjects.
Things are described in some detail, too, but were somehow lacking to me. I did not feel any want for factual information, but still had some trouble understanding, for example, what a house looked like despite an explanation of its basic size, shape, and materials. Pictures would have been helpful. A few id exist, but they were rare and in black and white. I would have been able to internalize some of the guns, clothing, and buildings used if I could actually see them. As it stands, I feel like I have learned to describe something when I don't actually know what it looks like.
It lacks the "snapshot" of everyday life that I was expecting, but that may not be possible given the six-decade period of time covered, and the sheer volume of information presented. While I have a general idea of what would go into the day (or life) of a wide variety of frontier-types, I lack a vision of how, exactly, a single day might go for these people. I think this could have been solved with some creative writing on the part of the author. Perhaps, occasionally, the monotony of explaining and describing the facets of life in the wild west could be broken up with a fictitious portrayal of someone actually doing it. It's one thing to read a few essays on food, cattle, and digging a well. It'd be quite helpful to read the occasional short story of some rancher going about his daily chores.
I take some issue with the information presented. It's a small annoyance, but... well, here's an example: in the chapter on clothing, the section on women's underwear is about as long as the section on... hats. I mean, c'mon.
Nonetheless, the author clearly did her research. While not maybe a "guide" to "everyday life," imo, it's still by far the best resource I've seen for somebody who wants to write a western, or just learn more about the genre/time period in general. This thing is packed to the brim with facts and trivia, that's both well-organized and easy to understand (if a bit boring to read at times). It gets the most interesting in Part Three; my favorite chapters are 15 (Language) and 17 (Crime and Punishment).
So yeah, check it out if you're really interested in learning about this stuff. This is a book you oughta buy, though - it's the kind of thing that needs to be referenced every once in a while, not memorized in one fell swoop. Don't buy it if you're just looking for a quick fun read, or even if you're hoping to scratch that western itch. It almost does, but not quite. That's ok, though... that's not really the point of a book like this.