Here is an amazing chronicle of an amazing woman, who fashioned an amazing life amidst hardships and betrayals that would have felled a lesser mortal. Judy Garland is one of the top performers of all time (I rank her far higher than overrated wannabes like F Sinatra and J Cash, for example), and her ability to rise above travail and still sing like some sort of sacred angel have thrilled us for many, many years.
This particular book focuses on the ill-fated CBS television series "The Judy Garland Show," lasting only one tumultuous season in 1963-1964. Having seen several of the original episodes with my mother, and loving them dearly, we were both sorely disappointed when the show was cancelled by a fickle CBS, as it was almost as if Broadway had come to the lowly medium of television, just for a brief while.
The book deftly chronicles the shows themselves, in admirable detail, listing all the songs performed, various takes required, the stellar list of guest stars, the cataclysmic change in personnel, etc. Even more important, if heartbreaking to read at times, is the recounting of all the villains of the piece, those powerful men (always men) who conspired against, sabotaged, extorted from, and undermined the Divine Ms G at every turn.
Freddie Fields, David Begelman, James Aubrey, Hunt Stromberg Jr., and Mel Torme all get righteously roasted as their nefarious deeds against Judy are chronicled in sometimes-painful detail. Truthfully, these and other men acted as financial and career parasites, using Judy and her prestige to their own gain, and causing Judy immeasurable suffering as a result.
But Judy showed them all, by overcoming these obstacles and performing for her fans and audience like nobody, arguably, had ever done before, and how nobody has ever since. There will never be moments like Garland in duets with a kooky young unknown named Barbra Streisand, or belting out "The Battle Hymn of the Republic" in response to the heinous murder of her dear friend, JFK, by the CIA.
And where are those greedy male clowns now? Aubrey, Stromberg, Fields, Begelman? They are pathetic history, whereas Judy Garland will live on and on. The only remaining injustice in the story of "The Judy Garland Show" is that Sid Luft, Garland's estranged husband at the time, owns the rights to program on home media, and so is still extracting financial gain from a woman he treated like dirt. The lesson may be that nobody escapes the machinations of shady characters in show business, but the real trouper will rise above calamity to become the legend they were meant to be. Like Judy.
As for the bloated, self-absorbed tool known as Mel Torme, his inane ego-fueled warbling is, to this day, not allowed in my house, nor will I bear to hear of him in conversation. Hated within the industry even at the time, the vapid fool was known as "Mel Torment" and "The Velvet Schmuck!"