What do you think?
Rate this book
To Win Her Heart
Having completed his sentence for the unintentional crime that derailed his youthful plans for fame and fortune, Levi Grant looks to start over in the town of Spencer, Texas. Spencer needs a blacksmith, a trade he learned at his father's knee, and he needs a place where no one knows his past. But small towns leave little room for secrets...
Eden Spencer has sworn off men, choosing instead to devote her time to the lending library she runs. When a mountain-sized stranger walks through her door and asks to borrow a book, she steels herself against the attraction he provokes. His halting speech and hesitant manner leave her doubting his intelligence. Yet as the mysteries of the town's new blacksmith unfold, Eden discovers hidden depths in him that tempt her heart.
Levi's renewed commitment to his faith leads Eden to believe she's finally found a man of honor and integrity, a man worthy of her love. But when the truth about his prodigal past comes to light, can this tarnished hero find a way to win back the librarian's affections?
Eden Spencer has sworn off men, choosing instead to devote her time to the lending library she runs. When a mountain-sized stranger walks through her door and asks to borrow a book, she steels herself against the attraction he provokes. His halting speech and hesitant manner leave her doubting his intelligence. Yet as the mysteries of the town's new blacksmith unfold, Eden discovers hidden depths in him that tempt her heart.
Levi's renewed commitment to his faith leads Eden to believe she's finally found a man of honor and integrity, a man worthy of her love. But when the truth about his prodigal past comes to light, can this tarnished hero find a way to win back the librarian's affections?
352 pages, Paperback
First published May 1, 2011
346 people are currently reading
8954 people want to read
About the author
Karen Witemeyer
69 books4,306 followersFor those who love to smile as they read, bestselling author Karen Witemeyer offers warmhearted historical romance with a flair for humor, feisty heroines, and swoon-worthy Texas heroes. Voted #1 Readers' Favorite Christian Historical Author in 2023 by Family Fiction Magazine, Karen is a multiple award-winning author and a firm believer in the power of happy endings. She is an avid cross-stitcher, tea drinker, and family board game player who makes her home in Abilene, TX with her heroic husband who vanquishes laundry dragons and dirty dish villains whenever she's on deadline.
Karen also loves to reward her readers. Every month she gives away two inspirational historical novels to someone from her newsletter list and offers substantial bonus content on her website. To learn more about Karen and her books, or to join her subscriber list, please visit www.karenwitemeyer.com.
Karen also loves to reward her readers. Every month she gives away two inspirational historical novels to someone from her newsletter list and offers substantial bonus content on her website. To learn more about Karen and her books, or to join her subscriber list, please visit www.karenwitemeyer.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 808 reviews
January 11, 2015
Two things in particular make this book stand out over a lot of Christian fiction I've read recently:
1) Since both the main characters have already given their lives to Christ before the story begins, there isn't all that pre-conversion angsty-ness that is present in so many other books in this genre.
2) Something other than the problem of evil is the spiritual problem the characters have to deal with.
I don't mean to be dismissive of either a person coming to Christ or of understanding (or trying to understand) why evil is in the world, but there are so many other issues a person can face that can also make for telling a good story, but that are often neglected in this genre. I'll leave you to (preferably) read the book or (if you must know beforehand) read some of the other reviews to find out what exactly the characters have to overcome in this book.
A couple other pluses:
--Though Levi and Eden are attracted to each other physically pretty much from the beginning, they also get to know each other's minds through writing long letters to each other. (It was also cute how they hand-delivered them, since they lived so close to each other.)
--That Levi told Eden (and later her father) himself about his past, and that it was not the climax of the story.
I'll definitely be trying some of Mrs. Witemeyer's other books in the future.
1) Since both the main characters have already given their lives to Christ before the story begins, there isn't all that pre-conversion angsty-ness that is present in so many other books in this genre.
2) Something other than the problem of evil is the spiritual problem the characters have to deal with.
I don't mean to be dismissive of either a person coming to Christ or of understanding (or trying to understand) why evil is in the world, but there are so many other issues a person can face that can also make for telling a good story, but that are often neglected in this genre. I'll leave you to (preferably) read the book or (if you must know beforehand) read some of the other reviews to find out what exactly the characters have to overcome in this book.
A couple other pluses:
--Though Levi and Eden are attracted to each other physically pretty much from the beginning, they also get to know each other's minds through writing long letters to each other. (It was also cute how they hand-delivered them, since they lived so close to each other.)
--That Levi told Eden (and later her father) himself about his past, and that it was not the climax of the story.
I'll definitely be trying some of Mrs. Witemeyer's other books in the future.
April 27, 2020
Current mood during the confinement? Serious overdose of sweet Christian prairie/western romances. I've binge-watched When Calls the Heart, Christy, the Janette Oke Love Comes Softly movies, beta-read Melissa Jagears' new book (oohhhh it's so good y'all, I can't wait to post my review!), and then, this wonderful little gem called to me from the depths of my too-long list of unread books on my Kindle.
It was exactly what I needed when I needed it. It's thick romantic syrup at its best, much too obvious and predictable most of the time, but who cares? The romance is perfect, and that's what I wanted.
I think the general agreement on this book is that everyone loves Levi. I don't know how you couldn't love Levi. A "mountain-sized" blacksmith whose strength and power are constantly alluded to, and whose heart is as big as the sky? A highly intelligent mind hidden behind a speech impediment? Dark secrets of the past? GIVE ME MORE. I adored Levi, obviously. He was wonderful, and his personality just radiated off the pages.
I could see the direction this novel was taking from page 1, most plot points are predictable and those that aren't necessarily don't come as a big surprise either, but that's ok, because I picked this up wanting only my syrupy romance dose, and I was well-served.
Eden and Levi bond over books and flowers. Yes friends, BOOKS AND FLOWERS. LITERATURE AND FLORA. WRITTEN WORDS AND BOUQUETS. (I think you get the point, but I am still SO HAPPY that this romance featured two of my favourite things!!!).
Eden has every bookworm's dream job; she runs a library from her own beautifully-decorated-with-flower-accents-everywhere home, and makes pressed flower art in her spare time (while at work). And has the charming, handsome and heart-melting blacksmith come visit her every day. And then they have intense bookish discussion via letters which they secretly pass to each other via the books. WHERE DO I SIGN UP?????
Not to sound overly superficial, but I didn't care much for the rest of the plot. I appreciated the message, although it was a little heavy on the preachiness and Bible-quoting, and I liked the overall story, but there were several major plot points that I just skimmed, because I wasn't that interested in brawls, not when there was an impeding proposal which had been interrupted!!
Anyways. To each book their time and place. I was all in for the romance, and I got it. My palpitating heart can now calm itself down and turn to more sensible reading (and by that I mean plunge back into two other wonderful novels I've been reading, Laura Frantz's The Lacemaker and Rebecca May's Roses & Shadows).
It was exactly what I needed when I needed it. It's thick romantic syrup at its best, much too obvious and predictable most of the time, but who cares? The romance is perfect, and that's what I wanted.
I think the general agreement on this book is that everyone loves Levi. I don't know how you couldn't love Levi. A "mountain-sized" blacksmith whose strength and power are constantly alluded to, and whose heart is as big as the sky? A highly intelligent mind hidden behind a speech impediment? Dark secrets of the past? GIVE ME MORE. I adored Levi, obviously. He was wonderful, and his personality just radiated off the pages.
I could see the direction this novel was taking from page 1, most plot points are predictable and those that aren't necessarily don't come as a big surprise either, but that's ok, because I picked this up wanting only my syrupy romance dose, and I was well-served.
Eden and Levi bond over books and flowers. Yes friends, BOOKS AND FLOWERS. LITERATURE AND FLORA. WRITTEN WORDS AND BOUQUETS. (I think you get the point, but I am still SO HAPPY that this romance featured two of my favourite things!!!).
Eden has every bookworm's dream job; she runs a library from her own beautifully-decorated-with-flower-accents-everywhere home, and makes pressed flower art in her spare time (while at work). And has the charming, handsome and heart-melting blacksmith come visit her every day. And then they have intense bookish discussion via letters which they secretly pass to each other via the books. WHERE DO I SIGN UP?????
Not to sound overly superficial, but I didn't care much for the rest of the plot. I appreciated the message, although it was a little heavy on the preachiness and Bible-quoting, and I liked the overall story, but there were several major plot points that I just skimmed, because I wasn't that interested in brawls, not when there was an impeding proposal which had been interrupted!!
Anyways. To each book their time and place. I was all in for the romance, and I got it. My palpitating heart can now calm itself down and turn to more sensible reading (and by that I mean plunge back into two other wonderful novels I've been reading, Laura Frantz's The Lacemaker and Rebecca May's Roses & Shadows).
August 27, 2019
Someone should have warned me that this is a CLEAN Christian book.
Meaning - lots of talk of the Lord and so forth, and no sex. The hottest scene was a kiss and the girl seeing the guy shirtless.
NOT my usual cuppa!
However. It was still good writing and I would give it 3.5 rounded to 3 bc the heroine is ANNOYING! She got better later, but she is so annoying so often! She's judgmental and uppity and full of herself. And when she hurt Levi I wanted to hurt her too, bc she just didn't deserve him!
So that's why the rounded down, and 3.5 in the first place. Not bc it's a clean, Christian book.
Tho... I will NOT be reading another one of this genre if I can help it.
Meaning - lots of talk of the Lord and so forth, and no sex. The hottest scene was a kiss and the girl seeing the guy shirtless.
NOT my usual cuppa!
However. It was still good writing and I would give it 3.5 rounded to 3 bc the heroine is ANNOYING! She got better later, but she is so annoying so often! She's judgmental and uppity and full of herself. And when she hurt Levi I wanted to hurt her too, bc she just didn't deserve him!
So that's why the rounded down, and 3.5 in the first place. Not bc it's a clean, Christian book.
Tho... I will NOT be reading another one of this genre if I can help it.
May 6, 2017
One of my favorites by Karen Witemeyer and a great one to re-read! Levi is in my top 5 fictional heroes I'm crushing on. He totally carries the story for me, there are so many layers to him even though he appears simple. Eden is delightful and we have a love for books and flower-pressing in common. Their blossoming friendship is lovely and the special moments they share are so romantic!
August 19, 2021
Rating 4.5
First read by Karen Witemeyer and it will not be the last. She is such a great writer, making my emotions feel like it is on a roller-coaster - I felt compassion, smiled, laughed, got angry and even had that "aaahhh" feeling.
The story started out slow, but kept on building until the climax at the end where I couldn't stop to see what will happen!
I loved that the Christian theme about love and forgiveness was so strong!
I identified a lot with Eden. Eden had to learn to not be critical and judgmental but to look at the person, who that person is and to get to know the person and not to make assumptions and judgement calls based on first impressions. She had to learn to trust God with her heart and not to build shields around her heart due to her fear of getting hurt again. I got frustrated with the way she handled the situation with Levi's past, but this made her more human and the change in her attitude was a testimony of what God can do if you trust Him and let Him change you. It was great to see how she grew in throughout the story. Love without conditions was such a strong theme through Eden.
Levi I just loved. The verse in 2 Cor 5:17, that says that we are a new creation in God and that the old is gone, was just a strong theme through his life. I loved how the author showed that it is not always easy to accept, especially when other people make it difficult because they don't want to accept that the past is just that, the past. I admired Levi even more after the scene with Eden's father, and what a great respectable, insightful man Eden's father is! He was such a great example of forgiveness and looking at a person's character and judging someone for who he/she is now and not focusing on mistakes of the past.
I loved Chloe and Duncan. Chloe was just a fun, lovable character!
Eden and Levi - I enjoyed seeing how their relationship grew and was glad it was not just easy and love at first sight. I specifically loved the parts where it is evident that their love and attraction for each other grew as they get to know each other more.
Sheriff Pratt... I did not like Sheriff Pratt and wanted to hit him over the head with something more than once! He was just an wolf hiding in sheep's clothing. I love how the "dark is always revealed in the light".
If you like to read books which is fun, humorous but which has a deeper story and where you have enjoyable characters with struggles and growth throughout the plot, you should give this book a go.
So now just to decide which Witemeyer book to read next...
First read by Karen Witemeyer and it will not be the last. She is such a great writer, making my emotions feel like it is on a roller-coaster - I felt compassion, smiled, laughed, got angry and even had that "aaahhh" feeling.
The story started out slow, but kept on building until the climax at the end where I couldn't stop to see what will happen!
I loved that the Christian theme about love and forgiveness was so strong!
I identified a lot with Eden. Eden had to learn to not be critical and judgmental but to look at the person, who that person is and to get to know the person and not to make assumptions and judgement calls based on first impressions. She had to learn to trust God with her heart and not to build shields around her heart due to her fear of getting hurt again. I got frustrated with the way she handled the situation with Levi's past, but this made her more human and the change in her attitude was a testimony of what God can do if you trust Him and let Him change you. It was great to see how she grew in throughout the story. Love without conditions was such a strong theme through Eden.
Levi I just loved. The verse in 2 Cor 5:17, that says that we are a new creation in God and that the old is gone, was just a strong theme through his life. I loved how the author showed that it is not always easy to accept, especially when other people make it difficult because they don't want to accept that the past is just that, the past. I admired Levi even more after the scene with Eden's father, and what a great respectable, insightful man Eden's father is! He was such a great example of forgiveness and looking at a person's character and judging someone for who he/she is now and not focusing on mistakes of the past.
I loved Chloe and Duncan. Chloe was just a fun, lovable character!
Eden and Levi - I enjoyed seeing how their relationship grew and was glad it was not just easy and love at first sight. I specifically loved the parts where it is evident that their love and attraction for each other grew as they get to know each other more.
Sheriff Pratt... I did not like Sheriff Pratt and wanted to hit him over the head with something more than once! He was just an wolf hiding in sheep's clothing. I love how the "dark is always revealed in the light".
If you like to read books which is fun, humorous but which has a deeper story and where you have enjoyable characters with struggles and growth throughout the plot, you should give this book a go.
So now just to decide which Witemeyer book to read next...
October 17, 2022
Spencer, Texas 1887
Sweet romance. Loved both main characters (Levi and Eden) and incorporation of messages from the Bible into the story line.
Sweet romance. Loved both main characters (Levi and Eden) and incorporation of messages from the Bible into the story line.
May 23, 2011
I've found a new author to add to my must-read list. Karen Witemeyer's novels brim over with romance, humor, and well-developed characters, and I chewed through all three in a very short time.
The characters were so richly developed. I loved Levi's restraint - from how he creatively works around his speech impediment to how he resists the urge to violence. I also loved watching Eden grow from a woman who sees herself as charitable to a woman who actually is charitable. The side characters are delightful as well.
Even if you're not a fan of the Texas frontier - and I'm not - the beautiful writing and fascinating characters will draw you in. I strongly recommend To Win Her Heart and can't wait for Karen Witemeyer's next novel!
The characters were so richly developed. I loved Levi's restraint - from how he creatively works around his speech impediment to how he resists the urge to violence. I also loved watching Eden grow from a woman who sees herself as charitable to a woman who actually is charitable. The side characters are delightful as well.
Even if you're not a fan of the Texas frontier - and I'm not - the beautiful writing and fascinating characters will draw you in. I strongly recommend To Win Her Heart and can't wait for Karen Witemeyer's next novel!
March 31, 2016
How many ways can I say I love this book?! The characters seemed to be real people, and the storyline was so wonderful. The hero and heroine...ah, I loved it from page 1. This is one of my favorite books so far this year!
I read this non-stop as much as possible, reading on my phone in line for lunch, etc. The librarian and the blacksmith...such an unusual combo. Five stars.
I read this non-stop as much as possible, reading on my phone in line for lunch, etc. The librarian and the blacksmith...such an unusual combo. Five stars.
March 29, 2017
I loved every minute of this book!
April 27, 2011
Karen Witemeyer has done it again!
Not since Julie Lessman have I given the first three books by an author five stars in succession. “To Win Her Heart” has definitely earned my accolades.
I could go on for a complete review on the characters alone. They are crafted and honed until they stand from the page in full three-dimension. Levi is not only an exceptional hero, but he stands as one of the most touching characters I have ever read. He is strapping in his masculinity, but his hearts is what moved me.
But what I loved the most is the uniqueness of the plot. Instead of sticking with the basic romance formula, the author mixed it up and in fact the ending was a complete surprise for me. I wasn’t sure how tension would be maintained, oh but believe me, it was! The ending was a bittersweet conclusion and having seen the characters grow through the story, I nearly cried. (In a good way).
From beginning to end I was completely enthralled with the story, I wish I could go on for another 200 words, this book deserves it. It’s a complex plot that goes beyond mere heart-pounding romance and layers characters that move the heart, emotions that tug at heartstrings and a faith that inspires.
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the publishers through CFBA for my copy to review.
Not since Julie Lessman have I given the first three books by an author five stars in succession. “To Win Her Heart” has definitely earned my accolades.
I could go on for a complete review on the characters alone. They are crafted and honed until they stand from the page in full three-dimension. Levi is not only an exceptional hero, but he stands as one of the most touching characters I have ever read. He is strapping in his masculinity, but his hearts is what moved me.
But what I loved the most is the uniqueness of the plot. Instead of sticking with the basic romance formula, the author mixed it up and in fact the ending was a complete surprise for me. I wasn’t sure how tension would be maintained, oh but believe me, it was! The ending was a bittersweet conclusion and having seen the characters grow through the story, I nearly cried. (In a good way).
From beginning to end I was completely enthralled with the story, I wish I could go on for another 200 words, this book deserves it. It’s a complex plot that goes beyond mere heart-pounding romance and layers characters that move the heart, emotions that tug at heartstrings and a faith that inspires.
This review is my honest opinion. Thanks to the publishers through CFBA for my copy to review.
December 27, 2022
Heartwarming, endearing, and romantic. To Win Her Heart was a winsome, historical read with lovable yet relatable characters, a sweet romance that stole my heart, and beautiful character transformations rooted in faith and active relationship with God. This book was the perfect read and I savored every page. I absolutely adored this book!
July 29, 2021
I’m changing my four star rating to a five star. It’s been a few weeks since I’ve read this, and the book is still lingering in my mind. It was a bookishly fun read with wonderful faith elements. I think it would make a great reread or comfort read.
September 10, 2019
3.85 stars
Second chances.
Don't judge a man by his past, but looked at what he becomes today.
Second chances.
Don't judge a man by his past, but looked at what he becomes today.
August 1, 2015
Wow! I loved this novel! I love, love, love any sort of book where the hero or heroine is hindered with some sort of physical issue. (See Silent Revenge) Levi's speech impediment really tugged on my heartstrings. I enjoyed both him and Eden, separately and together. At times I felt Eden was slightly cliché, but she's human, after all.
I loved the suspense, too! I thought we were nearing the end of the story around the 65% mark, but it just kept going. And I'm glad it did. This is a quick and easy read. Perfect for the beach.
I only had two qualms with this story:
1) The character of Chloe felt unnatural and forced. I felt like she was thrown in there for the heck of having another conversion. She wasn't as gritty as she maybe should have been and everything happened too easily when it came to her story lines.
2) Some of the syntax was too heavy. Long, complicated words were thrown in here and there and they caught me off-guard. While I was able to swallow them, they just didn't fit and disconnected me from the story for a bit because I was too busy trying to figure out what a certain word meant.
I loved the suspense, too! I thought we were nearing the end of the story around the 65% mark, but it just kept going. And I'm glad it did. This is a quick and easy read. Perfect for the beach.
I only had two qualms with this story:
1) The character of Chloe felt unnatural and forced. I felt like she was thrown in there for the heck of having another conversion. She wasn't as gritty as she maybe should have been and everything happened too easily when it came to her story lines.
2) Some of the syntax was too heavy. Long, complicated words were thrown in here and there and they caught me off-guard. While I was able to swallow them, they just didn't fit and disconnected me from the story for a bit because I was too busy trying to figure out what a certain word meant.
October 22, 2022
I loved it! Levi was such an amazing character. I liked Eden too, she had spunk about her and I appreciated that. There was so much depth and wisdom to this story. I loved the forgiveness and grace that was shown throughout. I experienced the emotions the characters did and was ready to wallop the Sheriff myself! I listened to the majority of the story and really enjoyed the narrator. She did an amazing job!
This is my first Karen Witemeyer but not my last.
Rating: PG - some physical violence
Language: clean read
Recommend: yes
This is my first Karen Witemeyer but not my last.
Rating: PG - some physical violence
Language: clean read
Recommend: yes
June 20, 2015
Note:::This book is currently free on all e-reader platforms.
{About the Book}
Do They Have a Fighting Chance at Love?
After completing his sentence for the unintentional crime that derailed his youthful plans for fame and fortune, Levi Grant looks to start over in the town of Spencer, Texas. Spencer needs a blacksmith, a trade he learned at his father's knee, and he needs a place where no one knows his past.
Eden Spencer has sworn off men, choosing instead to devote her time to the lending library she runs in the town her father founded. When a mountain-sized stranger walks through her door and asks to borrow a book, she's reluctant to trust him. Yet as the mysteries of the town's new blacksmith unfold, Eden discovers hidden depths in him that tempt her heart.
Eden believes she's finally found a man of honor and integrity. But when the truth about Levi's prodigal past comes to light, can this tarnished hero find a way to win back the librarian's affections?
{My Review}
This was my fourth Karen Witemeyer book and I have yet to be disappointed. Karen Witemeyer is an author who no matter what she writes and releases I will buy it. To Win Her Heart is Levi and Eden's story and oh boy was it good. It was so good I was up until 2 am to finish it because I had to know what happened. In no way could leave myself hanging until the morning.
To Win Her Heart is set in Spencer, Texas in the late 1800's. Levi is new to town, he has just been released from prison,and has been offered the Blacksmith position in town. But not until a Miss Eden Spencer interviews him to make sure he's right for the job. Levi begins to settle in, but doesn't communicate with his words much, as he is ashamed of his stutter and tries his best to hide it. Soon enough he finds himself spending every afternoon in the lending library that Eden runs. They begin exchanging letters and Eden finds herself falling in love with the "mountain-sized" Levi. The only thing is that Levi has been hiding his past from her and he's afraid if he tells her what her reaction would be.
Oh boy, this book was so amazing and exactly what I was in the mood for. If your looking for Historical Romance with swoon worthy heroes, then you must read Karen's books!
{About the Book}
Do They Have a Fighting Chance at Love?
After completing his sentence for the unintentional crime that derailed his youthful plans for fame and fortune, Levi Grant looks to start over in the town of Spencer, Texas. Spencer needs a blacksmith, a trade he learned at his father's knee, and he needs a place where no one knows his past.
Eden Spencer has sworn off men, choosing instead to devote her time to the lending library she runs in the town her father founded. When a mountain-sized stranger walks through her door and asks to borrow a book, she's reluctant to trust him. Yet as the mysteries of the town's new blacksmith unfold, Eden discovers hidden depths in him that tempt her heart.
Eden believes she's finally found a man of honor and integrity. But when the truth about Levi's prodigal past comes to light, can this tarnished hero find a way to win back the librarian's affections?
{My Review}
This was my fourth Karen Witemeyer book and I have yet to be disappointed. Karen Witemeyer is an author who no matter what she writes and releases I will buy it. To Win Her Heart is Levi and Eden's story and oh boy was it good. It was so good I was up until 2 am to finish it because I had to know what happened. In no way could leave myself hanging until the morning.
To Win Her Heart is set in Spencer, Texas in the late 1800's. Levi is new to town, he has just been released from prison,and has been offered the Blacksmith position in town. But not until a Miss Eden Spencer interviews him to make sure he's right for the job. Levi begins to settle in, but doesn't communicate with his words much, as he is ashamed of his stutter and tries his best to hide it. Soon enough he finds himself spending every afternoon in the lending library that Eden runs. They begin exchanging letters and Eden finds herself falling in love with the "mountain-sized" Levi. The only thing is that Levi has been hiding his past from her and he's afraid if he tells her what her reaction would be.
Oh boy, this book was so amazing and exactly what I was in the mood for. If your looking for Historical Romance with swoon worthy heroes, then you must read Karen's books!
August 4, 2023
Aww, what a sweet story!
Characters:
Levi was a darling, and I couldn't help but love him and the way he avoided 's' at all cost...it was adorably cute! He was so sweet and so convicted it was just beautiful!
Eden was a dear as well, and her arc was just as good!
Duncan was a nice character, as was Chloe!
Oh, and I loved Eden's dad...lol....
Themes:
We don't earn forgiveness. That everyone deserves forgiveness and that we are not defined by our past or even where we were raised.
Romance:
A few kisses. Thoughts of wanting more, but they were never explored. A few mentions of the marriage bed or desire coursing... not my favorites but still very closed door.
Language:
N/A
Overall:
This was a super cute read...part of me felt like the last 15% or so only happened because the author wanted something to happen...I felt it could have been weaved a touch sooner or a little better, buytt that's just me. Overall, the story was beautiful and very sweet and I enjoyed it.
Characters:
Levi was a darling, and I couldn't help but love him and the way he avoided 's' at all cost...it was adorably cute! He was so sweet and so convicted it was just beautiful!
Eden was a dear as well, and her arc was just as good!
Duncan was a nice character, as was Chloe!
Oh, and I loved Eden's dad...lol....
Themes:
We don't earn forgiveness. That everyone deserves forgiveness and that we are not defined by our past or even where we were raised.
Romance:
A few kisses. Thoughts of wanting more, but they were never explored. A few mentions of the marriage bed or desire coursing... not my favorites but still very closed door.
Language:
N/A
Overall:
This was a super cute read...part of me felt like the last 15% or so only happened because the author wanted something to happen...I felt it could have been weaved a touch sooner or a little better, buytt that's just me. Overall, the story was beautiful and very sweet and I enjoyed it.
January 8, 2012
Levi killed a man. He spent two years in prison and wants nothing more than to begin a new life.
The opportunity comes in the post of blacksmith for the small town of Spencer.
And in Eden, the small-town librarian, aka Miss Spencer.
Who can’t bear violence. Even against cockroaches.
But she collects flowers and reads to children and writes to Levi about his favorite author, Jules Verne.
He can’t help himself, really. From falling in love.
If only he could find the words to explain his past. Through a crippling lisp that renders even her name impossible.
Wonderful! Karen Whitemeyer’s books get better and better. Levi’s constant struggle for words—to avoid the sound “s”—and his greater struggle with his past and society’s barriers make him a compelling character. To Win Her Heart is quite often quite impossible to put down.
The opportunity comes in the post of blacksmith for the small town of Spencer.
And in Eden, the small-town librarian, aka Miss Spencer.
Who can’t bear violence. Even against cockroaches.
But she collects flowers and reads to children and writes to Levi about his favorite author, Jules Verne.
He can’t help himself, really. From falling in love.
If only he could find the words to explain his past. Through a crippling lisp that renders even her name impossible.
Wonderful! Karen Whitemeyer’s books get better and better. Levi’s constant struggle for words—to avoid the sound “s”—and his greater struggle with his past and society’s barriers make him a compelling character. To Win Her Heart is quite often quite impossible to put down.
January 21, 2019
This was a well written historical Christian romance novel. Like all of Karen Witemeyer's books that I have read so far, this one had great characters and both protagonists learned important things during their relationship. I really enjoyed this book, which is now on my favorites list, and I'm glad I was encouraged to read this by a fellow Goodreads group member.
December 29, 2017
Maybe I'm biased by the blacksmith (my hubby's a blacksmith) but I just loved this hero. I literally walked around from chore to chore holding it in my hand so I could read it as I walked.
June 29, 2018
5 it won my heart Stars!
May 31, 2022
I'm trying to put into words why I liked this book so much. I reread it and I rarely reread a book...I mean the number of books I've reread include The Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter, Redeeming Love, you get the picture.
This book isn't as famous or as amazing as those books, but then again...there is an amazing comfort in the story of a man who commits the worst crime and finds God's grace. Redemption. Finding mercy where we don't deserve it.
Plus, the romance itself is so sweet, just what I needed after a whirlwind vacation where I didn't relax at all--had to see all the sights.
So, if you need comfort and a smile, this is a book to read, and reread.
This book isn't as famous or as amazing as those books, but then again...there is an amazing comfort in the story of a man who commits the worst crime and finds God's grace. Redemption. Finding mercy where we don't deserve it.
Plus, the romance itself is so sweet, just what I needed after a whirlwind vacation where I didn't relax at all--had to see all the sights.
So, if you need comfort and a smile, this is a book to read, and reread.
July 9, 2021
Such a sweet story! It’s another winner from Mrs. Karen Witemeyer. The cover is darling, but the characters within the book are even more charming. The plot was entertaining. I always enjoy a good library story! It was really neat to see the opening of minds and the growth and healing of hearts. There was some heartache involved, which pressed against my emotions. This, as usual, made me happy. I love a good, emotional story.
Content: alcohol, saloons, gambling, prostitutes, derogatory term
Content: alcohol, saloons, gambling, prostitutes, derogatory term
June 2, 2025
*updated 3/12/22: I just read this whole thing again in one day! I loved it just as much -- one of my absolute favorites!
**updated 3/15/24: I couldn't sleep last night, so I read the whole thing in two sittings. Loved it just as much again! Btw, I have a hard remembering this title, even though I love it so much. I think it should have been called Eden's Garden to make it more memorable.
I absolutely loved the characters, which is the most important thing to me about stories. I loved how Eden Spencer changed from being a “rock-thrower” worried about her reputation to a truly loving and compassionate woman. I loved Levi's change from a guilty ex-fighter to a compassionate and controlled man of strong convictions. I loved Chloe's change from a distrusting girl to a confident woman. I even loved Duncan's optimism and gentlemanly treatment of Chloe.
The quality of writing is top-notch, as all of Karen Witemeyer's books are that I've read. The humor isn't as pronounced, but there are still a few instances in this one. I really loved the details of Levi's speech problem and how she showed his hesitation about using “s” sounds and yet his intelligence in choosing other words without that sound.
There are so many spiritual truths to be gleaned from this story, which I absolutely adored! Forgiveness, compassion, standing up for what's right, thinking of others, and I'm sure there are more.
I would recommend this book for anyone who loves historical fiction and wants a strong thread of faith. The only people who may not appreciate this book are those who don't want to read of the real struggle to put the past behind you and resist temptation.
*updated 3/12/22: I bought this book for myself since I loved it so much!
**updated 3/15/24: I couldn't sleep last night, so I read the whole thing in two sittings. Loved it just as much again! Btw, I have a hard remembering this title, even though I love it so much. I think it should have been called Eden's Garden to make it more memorable.
I absolutely loved the characters, which is the most important thing to me about stories. I loved how Eden Spencer changed from being a “rock-thrower” worried about her reputation to a truly loving and compassionate woman. I loved Levi's change from a guilty ex-fighter to a compassionate and controlled man of strong convictions. I loved Chloe's change from a distrusting girl to a confident woman. I even loved Duncan's optimism and gentlemanly treatment of Chloe.
The quality of writing is top-notch, as all of Karen Witemeyer's books are that I've read. The humor isn't as pronounced, but there are still a few instances in this one. I really loved the details of Levi's speech problem and how she showed his hesitation about using “s” sounds and yet his intelligence in choosing other words without that sound.
There are so many spiritual truths to be gleaned from this story, which I absolutely adored! Forgiveness, compassion, standing up for what's right, thinking of others, and I'm sure there are more.
I would recommend this book for anyone who loves historical fiction and wants a strong thread of faith. The only people who may not appreciate this book are those who don't want to read of the real struggle to put the past behind you and resist temptation.
*updated 3/12/22: I bought this book for myself since I loved it so much!
July 24, 2012
4.5
Well, another great book by Karen Witemeyer. I really enjoyed this one, right from the start. While I’m not a huge believer of the whole reformed criminal, I definitely believed in Levi and fell for his charming character. He is this oversized giant, but a teddy bear on the inside. The story starts with him leaving prison behind and him trying to start a new life for himself as a blacksmith. As soon as he arrives in town he meets Eden Spencer, the town librarian. She judges him at first and is surprised to find there is much more to him then what meets the eye. I thought both Eden and Levi were really likable. Eden has a good heart and really wants to be a better person. She helps those around her and is really good about giving people a chance. Levi was a great leading man; I liked his story and his silent strength. I thought they had good chemistry together and some sweet moments.
The Christian elements in this one were well done. While there was some preaching, it seemed more a part of the characters then flat out preaching. The story was the main focus, which I liked. Overall, a fun read.
Content: Clean.
Well, another great book by Karen Witemeyer. I really enjoyed this one, right from the start. While I’m not a huge believer of the whole reformed criminal, I definitely believed in Levi and fell for his charming character. He is this oversized giant, but a teddy bear on the inside. The story starts with him leaving prison behind and him trying to start a new life for himself as a blacksmith. As soon as he arrives in town he meets Eden Spencer, the town librarian. She judges him at first and is surprised to find there is much more to him then what meets the eye. I thought both Eden and Levi were really likable. Eden has a good heart and really wants to be a better person. She helps those around her and is really good about giving people a chance. Levi was a great leading man; I liked his story and his silent strength. I thought they had good chemistry together and some sweet moments.
The Christian elements in this one were well done. While there was some preaching, it seemed more a part of the characters then flat out preaching. The story was the main focus, which I liked. Overall, a fun read.
Content: Clean.
March 31, 2021
This was such a cute book! The plot was unique and really kept my attention. It was a quick, light read and a really sweet story. If you like Karen Witemeyer’s style of writing you will love this one!
June 17, 2021
Great read, as I have learned to expect from this author. The story and plot were great and engaging, but Levi was a totally awesome character....fresh out of prison and determined to do right no matter what. Loved this book
July 16, 2021
Every new Witemeyer book that I read instantly becomes my favorite! Levi and Eden's story is one I'll definitely be reading again and again.
3 years later and I still love it!
3 years later and I still love it!
March 8, 2012
http://ceceliadowdy.blogspot.com/2011...
Spinster Eden Spencer runs her own library out of her home. She's wealthy and since she's been painfully jilted in the past, she doesn't have any romantic relationships. Instead, she finds solace amoung her book stacks. She also loves reading stories to children every week and she loves flowers.
However, Eden's non-romantic life changes when tall, strong, and handsome Levi Grant comes to town, hired as the new blacksmith. Levi has some ghosts in his past, he's just gotten out of prison, and he used to be a prize fighter. It's a life he's left behind and he finds himself smitten with Eden and her library. Born with a shaming lisp, Levi takes his time with his speech, choosing to use words that do not have the S sound. Eden mistakenly assumes Levi is dim-witted since he speaks so slowly. Can these two overcome their differences and learn to love one another?
This book dealt with the issue of helping those with unfortunate pasts. In one part, Levi rescues a prostitute's daughter, Chloe. Levi brings Chloe to Eden since she doesn't have anyplace to live. Eden hesitates, not wanting to mar her repuation by hiring a prostitute's daughter to do her housework. Levi convinces her to do the right thing and, as a result, she's ostracized in the town. The town exhibited very un-Christian behavior in spite of their regular church attendance, which is sadly, very realistic behavior for a lot of Christians.
I enjoyed this novel and felt that the blacksmith/librarian romance added a fresh twist to this romance novel.
Spinster Eden Spencer runs her own library out of her home. She's wealthy and since she's been painfully jilted in the past, she doesn't have any romantic relationships. Instead, she finds solace amoung her book stacks. She also loves reading stories to children every week and she loves flowers.
However, Eden's non-romantic life changes when tall, strong, and handsome Levi Grant comes to town, hired as the new blacksmith. Levi has some ghosts in his past, he's just gotten out of prison, and he used to be a prize fighter. It's a life he's left behind and he finds himself smitten with Eden and her library. Born with a shaming lisp, Levi takes his time with his speech, choosing to use words that do not have the S sound. Eden mistakenly assumes Levi is dim-witted since he speaks so slowly. Can these two overcome their differences and learn to love one another?
This book dealt with the issue of helping those with unfortunate pasts. In one part, Levi rescues a prostitute's daughter, Chloe. Levi brings Chloe to Eden since she doesn't have anyplace to live. Eden hesitates, not wanting to mar her repuation by hiring a prostitute's daughter to do her housework. Levi convinces her to do the right thing and, as a result, she's ostracized in the town. The town exhibited very un-Christian behavior in spite of their regular church attendance, which is sadly, very realistic behavior for a lot of Christians.
I enjoyed this novel and felt that the blacksmith/librarian romance added a fresh twist to this romance novel.
November 24, 2015
Aw… what a tender love story. What a beautiful tale of redemption. What a powerful testimony of Christ’s love and His surpassing forgiveness. I can’t begin to describe this book to you the way I really want to. To Win Her Heart is truly a novel that brings you to tears.
Eden and Levi’s relationship is ultimately amazing. They test true love, and they find that they do, in the end, have it for each other. But first they have to go through trials of doubting, distrust, self-righteous judgment, and fear of inadequacy to find that treasure. They have to examine their heart, and then compare their judgments, desires, dreams, and hopes to God’s Word and see if they are indeed doing the right thing.
Levi is endearing. He’s a strong, manly, and powerful guy, but he is embarrassed of his lisp, and struggles to live life without anybody knowing of it—and thus, is vulnerable. Eden is attracted to him, and even begins to open up to him in a tender, blossoming romance. But she is determined about a great many things, and hates violence. Levi was once a very violent man…
Add in a young girl working at the saloon, and a charming Irish lad. Plus a cold-hearted sheriff who tries to force himself into Eden’s life, and is full of plans of revenge when she chooses the mysterious Levi instead… a man with a bad past.
And then you have it, a touching, Christ filled, historical romance. I couldn’t have asked for better.
Eden and Levi’s relationship is ultimately amazing. They test true love, and they find that they do, in the end, have it for each other. But first they have to go through trials of doubting, distrust, self-righteous judgment, and fear of inadequacy to find that treasure. They have to examine their heart, and then compare their judgments, desires, dreams, and hopes to God’s Word and see if they are indeed doing the right thing.
Levi is endearing. He’s a strong, manly, and powerful guy, but he is embarrassed of his lisp, and struggles to live life without anybody knowing of it—and thus, is vulnerable. Eden is attracted to him, and even begins to open up to him in a tender, blossoming romance. But she is determined about a great many things, and hates violence. Levi was once a very violent man…
Add in a young girl working at the saloon, and a charming Irish lad. Plus a cold-hearted sheriff who tries to force himself into Eden’s life, and is full of plans of revenge when she chooses the mysterious Levi instead… a man with a bad past.
And then you have it, a touching, Christ filled, historical romance. I couldn’t have asked for better.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 808 reviews