Lee makes several important points, such as remembering that we are called to disciple the nations, not merely “evangelize.” That we should allow God to use us wherever we are with whatever gifts and resources we may have. She’s right on target with her understanding that our first calling is to be in relationship with God, and all missional action flows out of that relationship. She promotes adoption, volunteering, reaching out across cultural and economic boundaries, good stewardship, being content and grateful rather than materialistic, and other important Biblical principles.
However, when I visited her website and clicked on the “resources” tab, I found three sections entitled “Living Green,” “Living Justly,” and “Racial Reconciliation.” These causes make several appearances in her book.
What worries me is how innocent and scripturally grounded Helen Lee sounds in most of her book, which belies the radical resources she’s directing her readers towards. She makes several ignorant assumptions about poverty, justice, and economics - the same common ones that average Christians (even many conservatives) have been making, and they are lightly scattered through what otherwise would have been a completely satisfactory chapter.
For instance, she condemns consumerism as idolatry (so far so good), but then describes the myriad of choices in the cereal aisle as an example of how Americans are driven by consumerism (do we really NEED all these choices?). In her mind, capitalism appears to equal greed and materialism – a common but dangerous logical fallacy. Perhaps she doesn’t recognize that having all those choices is FAR better than living in a Communist country where you only have ONE choice – and have to stand in a bread line for hours to get it. In rightly opposing the idolatry of consumerism, she incorrectly condemns the choices provided by the free market, and undermines the very foundational freedoms which would allow the third-world nations she worries about to finally lift themselves out of grinding poverty.
She talks about how she was disturbed to hear the “Battle Hymn of the Republic” played along with “God Bless America” at a Fourth of July celebration because it implied that “being a Christian and an American were one and the same.” She defines “the American Dream” as “being good consumers and competitors”. She decries that the church has become “immersed in the culture…of materialism, autonomy, individualism, and competition,” as if all of these qualities were evil in and of themselves (not merely when they become a form of idolatry). Given the fact that Jim Wallis and others in the “social justice” movement make frequent appearances in her book, I’m not surprised at the erroneous scriptural parallels and conclusions she draws.
In an especially disturbing entry, she lists the phrases describing those whom Jesus says will be “blessed” in the Beatitudes: Poor in spirit, mourning, meek…etc. She then says, “This is not the kind of list that resembles the American Dream, which proclaims the right of every American to have ‘life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness’.”
The American Dream is FREEDOM, not materialism, and the inalienable rights mentioned in the Declaration of Independence are declared as things which only God can grant and take away (not the “almighty state”). Only someone ignorant of the history and origin behind those timeless words could equate them with the idolatry of consumerism, and essentially condemn them as unbiblical.
The problem is, the average American Christian is largely ignorant of both history and Biblical economics (as Lee appears to be), and so has very little armor to defend themselves against socialist arguments cloaked as calls to discipleship. Lee’s are so subtly woven that it makes me believe she’s not a socialist – merely a misled Christian mother who wants to be missional, looked for ways to serve, got sucked into Leftist arguments for making the world better, and is now encouraging other mothers to do the same. Her motives and the scriptural admonitions to be salt and light appear to be straight up, but the practical applications she turns to as the solution are downright dangerous.
This becomes even more clear when one visits "The Missional Mom" website for more information and resources. The “Living Green” section is full of links about saving the planet from global warming. Lee appears to be fully on board with the Leftist global warming movement, believing it to be “Biblical stewardship”. She provides links to Al Gore’s debunked propaganda film “An Inconvenient Truth,” the anti-capitalist short film “The Story of Stuff,” the now-radicalized environmentalist organization “World Wildlife Fund,” and dozens of other completely unbiblical resources.
Under the “Racial Reconciliation” tab, you can find books like “Savage Inequalities: Children in America’s Schools” by radical leftist education writer Jonathan Kozol, and “Fire in the Heart: How White Activists Embrace Racial Justice” by Mark R. Warren, which is praised on Amazon by the radical left-wing activist Tim Wise, author of “White Like Me: Reflections on Race from a Privileged Son.” Michael Emerson’s book “Divided by Faith: Evangelical Religion and the Problem of Race in America” is mentioned several times in “The Missional Mom”, but what is not mentioned are the ‘Big Government’ solutions Emerson pushes, encouraging liberal policies and blaming conservatives for standing in the way of “racial progress”.
It’s not difficult to see how Lee’s ideas have been shaped by such influences. An entire chapter in her book is dedicated to racial relations, and while most of it simply encourages families to build cross-cultural relationships, it is built on the underlying theme that most Americans (and whites, especially), are closet racists who just haven’t recognized it yet. Apparently the best way to solve this “problem” is to meet some quota of minorities in your relationships and churches, such as the pastor she praises for raising his church’s percentage of “ethnically diverse” attendees from 2 to 20 percent. If the percentage of minorities warming your pews were truly a direct measurement of how “racist” a church is, then Scandinavian and African tribal churches would be the most racist in the world. But they’re not – because one is not a direct reflection of the other (except in the minds of Leftists who thrive on stoking racial divisiveness, victim mentality and white guilt to garner votes and further the cause of redistribution).
The “Living Justly” tab provides resources which promote “social justice”, which, among Christians, has become the “spiritualized” term for forced wealth redistribution via the government. The redistribution angle is often very subtle, because many Christians don’t discern the socialist undertones to these so called “charitable” enterprises. They just erroneously equate them with Biblical charity.
In Lee’s book, she praises a mother who went to see Bono perform and raise awareness for AIDS in Africa, got involved in his “ONE” campaign against poverty and disease, and met an African woman who was receiving anti-viral medicine through a program that was funded by a foreign aid package that she had lobbied George W. Bush for. The woman is amazed at how her lobbying produced results and now she’s meeting someone she “helped.”
Warm and fuzzy story, until you step back a step and realize that she didn’t really “help” anyone with her OWN money, but with money that had been taken by force from someone under pain of going to jail. That’s not Biblical charity – that’s stealing, and the Bible is very clear about theft. Using the state as an instrument of plunder to launder the money for you doesn’t make it right. Stealing by majority vote doesn’t make it right. Stealing with “good intentions” for a “better world” doesn’t make it right. That’s the subtle deception that the Church desperately needs to recognize. God may have been calling this mother to help in the fight against AIDS, but with her OWN resources or those donated by volunteers – not someone else’s stolen property.
On her website, under the “Living Justly” tab, one of the links is for a children’s book by radical anti-semite and socialist Desmond Tutu. Other recommended books include those by PETA “Animal Liberation” activist Peter Singer, ”Emerging Church” theological revisionist Brian McLaren, and Shane Claiborne, whose book includes a foreword by self-described “Evangelical” Marxist Jim Wallis. Wallis himself is quoted on page 68, which is rather disturbing given his history of socialist radicalism.
I'm afraid the 90% of the book which appears Biblically sound cannot disguise the other poisonous 10%. Christians must be wary of the dangers of “social justice” theology and other erroneous distortions of Biblical stewardship and charity.