The title of “I’ll Call Every Monday” refers to the day of the week that insurance agents go around to collect the premiums and the day of the week that Irene Schoefield asked insurance agent Nicky Weaver to come over and collect from her, the day of the week that her husband went to New York City and left her all alone in that big house on the hill. Irene, of course, had “a set of hips that drove the temperature in the room up to about a hundred and twenty.” “I’ll Call Every Monday” is Orrie Hitt’s take on James Cain’s “Double Indemnity.” Why do we need to read a remake of that classic? Well, for one thing, this book is not a remake of “Double Indemnity” and, for the most part, has little to do with that earlier novel. In fact, for much of the book, the reader keeps waiting for the whole “Double Indemnity” theme to play out to its logical conclusion, but there are so many other things going on here. And, don’t assume you know how its all going to play out.
This is the first novel Hitt ever published and it is the first of two novels he wrote starring Nicky Weaver, the second being “Ladies’ Man.” Here, Weaver is a bit of a sleazeball, getting it on with a married woman, corrupting a young woman and breaking her heart, falsifying insurance policies, borrowing from collections. But, he is still a bit of a chump, still wants to do the right thing and still is moral enough that, when he sees that Irene’s husband has been selling photograph sets of her in her birthday suit at local bars, he hauls off and slugs the bastard.
Hitt specialized in writing about the working class and, here, the insurance agent Weaver, although a white collar salesman, is just another chump trying to make a living, bitching about all the stupid people he deals with and all the people who should be paying up their premiums, but always find excuses not to. Most of them are dopes, he explains, cause they think they are being cute, but they don’t know from nothing. Weaver, at one point, explains that, to sell insurance all you have to do is talk fast, so fast that the client has not way to keep up with you. In some ways, he is not a bad guy and, in fact, when another agent is up to his eyeballs in debt because he’s been taking care of his mistress instead of paying his bills, Weaver lends him money to get it together.
In typical Hitt fashion, the story is sleazy rather than noirish, but its good and it’s a fast read. There are some hilarious lines here that Hitt just slips in such as when Weaver rescues three suits from the cleaners. “They looked like they had been finished off with a carpet beater and a mop.”